Personhood credentials: Artificial intelligence and the value of privacy-preserving tools to distinguish who is real online
Authors:
Steven Adler,
Zoë Hitzig,
Shrey Jain,
Catherine Brewer,
Wayne Chang,
Renée DiResta,
Eddy Lazzarin,
Sean McGregor,
Wendy Seltzer,
Divya Siddarth,
Nouran Soliman,
Tobin South,
Connor Spelliscy,
Manu Sporny,
Varya Srivastava,
John Bailey,
Brian Christian,
Andrew Critch,
Ronnie Falcon,
Heather Flanagan,
Kim Hamilton Duffy,
Eric Ho,
Claire R. Leibowicz,
Srikanth Nadhamuni,
Alan Z. Rozenshtein
, et al. (7 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
Anonymity is an important principle online. However, malicious actors have long used misleading identities to conduct fraud, spread disinformation, and carry out other deceptive schemes. With the advent of increasingly capable AI, bad actors can amplify the potential scale and effectiveness of their operations, intensifying the challenge of balancing anonymity and trustworthiness online. In this p…
▽ More
Anonymity is an important principle online. However, malicious actors have long used misleading identities to conduct fraud, spread disinformation, and carry out other deceptive schemes. With the advent of increasingly capable AI, bad actors can amplify the potential scale and effectiveness of their operations, intensifying the challenge of balancing anonymity and trustworthiness online. In this paper, we analyze the value of a new tool to address this challenge: "personhood credentials" (PHCs), digital credentials that empower users to demonstrate that they are real people -- not AIs -- to online services, without disclosing any personal information. Such credentials can be issued by a range of trusted institutions -- governments or otherwise. A PHC system, according to our definition, could be local or global, and does not need to be biometrics-based. Two trends in AI contribute to the urgency of the challenge: AI's increasing indistinguishability from people online (i.e., lifelike content and avatars, agentic activity), and AI's increasing scalability (i.e., cost-effectiveness, accessibility). Drawing on a long history of research into anonymous credentials and "proof-of-personhood" systems, personhood credentials give people a way to signal their trustworthiness on online platforms, and offer service providers new tools for reducing misuse by bad actors. In contrast, existing countermeasures to automated deception -- such as CAPTCHAs -- are inadequate against sophisticated AI, while stringent identity verification solutions are insufficiently private for many use-cases. After surveying the benefits of personhood credentials, we also examine deployment risks and design challenges. We conclude with actionable next steps for policymakers, technologists, and standards bodies to consider in consultation with the public.
△ Less
Submitted 26 August, 2024; v1 submitted 14 August, 2024;
originally announced August 2024.
Contextual Confidence and Generative AI
Authors:
Shrey Jain,
Zoë Hitzig,
Pamela Mishkin
Abstract:
Generative AI models perturb the foundations of effective human communication. They present new challenges to contextual confidence, disrupting participants' ability to identify the authentic context of communication and their ability to protect communication from reuse and recombination outside its intended context. In this paper, we describe strategies--tools, technologies and policies--that aim…
▽ More
Generative AI models perturb the foundations of effective human communication. They present new challenges to contextual confidence, disrupting participants' ability to identify the authentic context of communication and their ability to protect communication from reuse and recombination outside its intended context. In this paper, we describe strategies--tools, technologies and policies--that aim to stabilize communication in the face of these challenges. The strategies we discuss fall into two broad categories. Containment strategies aim to reassert context in environments where it is currently threatened--a reaction to the context-free expectations and norms established by the internet. Mobilization strategies, by contrast, view the rise of generative AI as an opportunity to proactively set new and higher expectations around privacy and authenticity in mediated communication.
△ Less
Submitted 24 January, 2024; v1 submitted 2 November, 2023;
originally announced November 2023.