Spicy Grilled Shrimp
Spicy Shrimp Boil With Lemon Butter
- Total Time
- 20 minutes
- Rating
- Notes
- Read community notes
Advertisement
Ingredients
- 1large onion, halved
- 1head garlic, sliced in half crosswise to expose the cloves
- ¼cup Old Bay seasoning
- 1tablespoon whole black peppercorns
- 1teaspoon fine sea salt, plus more as needed
- ½teaspoon cayenne
- 6tablespoons unsalted butter (¾ stick)
- 1lemon, halved
- 1tablespoon minced shallot (optional)
- 1tablespoon Tabasco or Crystal hot sauce, plus more as needed
- 2pounds large shell-on shrimp
- Crusty bread, for serving
Preparation
- Step 1
Bring 6 cups water with the onion, garlic, Old Bay, peppercorns, salt and cayenne to a boil in a large pot. Cover and simmer for 10 minutes to allow the flavors to develop.
- Step 2
Meanwhile in a small pot, melt the butter. Squeeze the juice from half a lemon into the pot. Stir in shallot, if using, and season butter to taste with hot sauce and salt. Set aside for serving.
- Step 3
Squeeze juice from the other half the lemon into the large pot, then toss in squeezed lemon half. Stir in 1 tablespoon hot sauce and shrimp. Bring just to a simmer (not a boil), then lower the heat so the mixture continues to simmer for 1 to 2 minutes, until shrimp are bright pink and cooked through.
- Step 4
Use tongs or a slotted spoon to transfer shrimp to a large serving bowl or platter. Taste shrimp broth and add more salt and hot sauce if necessary.
- Step 5
Strain shrimp broth into serving bowls. Divide melted butter into small bowls, one per guest.
- Step 6
To serve, give each guest a bowl of spicy shrimp broth and a small bowl filled with seasoned butter for dipping. Guests should peel shrimp and dunk in broth, butter or both. Serve with bread on the side and plenty of napkins, and a bowl for the shrimp shells.
Similar Recipes
Spicy Shrimp Salad With Mint
Lemony Shrimp and Bean Stew
Spicy Shrimp Sauté
Garlic Shrimp With Peas
Spicy Shrimp Patties
Shrimp Cocktail
Hot-Sauce Shrimp
One-Pot Chicken and Rice With Caramelized Lemon
Garlicky Shrimp Tacos
Hot Honey Shrimp
Coconut-Lime Shrimp
Spicy Fried Shrimp With Green Chutney
Shrimp Scampi With Orzo
Ginger-Garlic Shrimp With Coconut Milk
Spicy Shrimp With Blistered Cucumbers, Corn and Tomato
Sheet-Pan Shrimp Boil
Smoky Shrimp Saganaki
Quick Shrimp and Asparagus Stir-Fry
Cajun Shrimp Boil
Private Notes
Cooking Notes
You could, but leaving the shells on deepens the flavor. When I want a less messy dish for guests, I peel the shrimp, put the shells in a cheesecloth bundle tied to keep shells in, and add to the sauce/broth base. It is almost as good as leaving the shells on the shrimp. For this recipe I would add the cheesecloth sack in step 1, then continue as described.
I got the Key West Pinks, in shell, previously frozen at Whole Foods (thank you for the suggestion Joe) and made the recipe just as instructed. We loved it. The broth gave the shrimp a fabulous flavor without being overwhelming. The broth was too strong to drink straight out of the bowl but I tried because it was so yummy. We dipped bread in it and next time I might save it for cooking rice or something else the next day.
It is best to leave the shells on for a peel-as-you-eat experience. The shells impart an extra level of flavor to the shrimp that is lost if the shrimp are pre-peeled. An alternative approach might be to peel the shrimp and boil down a stock made with the shells and aromatics and then poach the shrimp quickly in the stock. But you'll miss the fun and camaraderie of peeling, dunking and eating.
Great recipe! Tasty and fast. Used on Alaska fresh caught spot shrimp and was delicious. Skipped butter altogether which my waistline doesn’t need and did not miss it at all. Just dipped shrimp in filtered broth -heaven! Highly recommend for time crunch recipe.
I combined this with Samin's boil recipe; I added potatoes, corn, mushrooms, celery and sausage. The flavor of the broth was very yummy! I am using the broth to keep making rice and noodles.
I was searching NYTCooking for a shrimp recipe with garlic and butter. I chose this one because I didn't have to peel the shrimp in advance! I used frozed, deveined shrimp from the grocery store (thawed before cooking). The broth gives the shrimp a lovely taste. And the lemon butter was to die for. We'll do this again!!
This was undersalted for my palate as written.
How do you deal with big, raw, in the shell shrimp? Do you thaw first? Throw into oil, wine?
The cooking instructions on the bag of frozen shrimp I used said to thaw before cooking. I put them in a large bowl of cold water, changed it twice, and they were thawed by the time I was ready for them.
This.was.amazing! Cooked exactly as indicated - family raved! Simple to prepare and didn't take long. This is a keeper!
I love this recipe. It is actually quite simple. The broth is too spicy for dipping, but the butter is divine. Don't add the hot sauce or salt to it. There is so much flavor in the broth and therefore the shrimp. The shrimp is delicious with the Kendall Jackson Vintner's Reserve rosé. Serve with asparagus for a more complete meal. Set out the butter early to soften.
I had everything except the shrimp. All I had shrimp-wise was wild caught shrimp pieces (Imperfect Foods delivery). I halved the other ingredients to match the 1 pound of shrimp pieces. I am sure the flavor suffered because there were no shrimp shells. But as a stay-at-home use up what I had this was terrific. Sliced sourdough bread, toasted. I feel this is a keeper recipe.
whoa good but i suggest you do what the people said
Peel the shrimp. Put the shells into cheese cloth & tie. Put into step 1. Remove when straining broth into bowels in step 5. Can also serve with mayo for those who don't care for butter. Follow step 2 but do not cook mayo.
If adding veg would you recommend to cook before or after the shrimp??
Shrimp cooks in 3 minutes. Time the vegetables to finish at the same time.
I got the Key West Pinks, in shell, previously frozen at Whole Foods (thank you for the suggestion Joe) and made the recipe just as instructed. We loved it. The broth gave the shrimp a fabulous flavor without being overwhelming. The broth was too strong to drink straight out of the bowl but I tried because it was so yummy. We dipped bread in it and next time I might save it for cooking rice or something else the next day.
I would make this, but only using wild caught Key West Pinks from Florida (the state where you'll find this dish all over). I've been finding them frozen (which is fine) at Whole Foods in our Minneapolis store, 21-25's, a perfect size! Probably one of the best tasting shrimps you will eat.
Is there another sauce one can make besides the lemon butter? Something a bit healthier, perhaps? Thanks!
Alison: 2 lbs shrimp will easily feed 6 people and 1 T butter per serving is not excessive provided the rest of the meal is balanced accordingly. Plus, you don't need to consume the entire cup of sauce the recipe allots. So go for it!
Cocktail sauce. Mix ketchup with horseradish and Tabasco to taste.
This has so much seasoning it would be impossible to taste the lovely, mild shrimp flavor.
Try it! The shrimp are only in the broth for three minutes, just enough to impart a lovely taste to complement the flavor of the shrimp.
Advertisement