Big-Batch Ranchero Sauce

Big-Batch Ranchero Sauce
David Malosh for The New York Times. Food stylist: Maggie Ruggiero. Prop stylist: Sophia Pappas.
Total Time
1¼ hours, plus cooling
Rating
4(755)
Notes
Read community notes

There is no other aroma coming from the kitchen — not truffle, not freshly peeled orange, not a chocolate cake baking — that will stop you in your tracks and make you inhale as deeply as this ranchero sauce simmering away. Here’s a large batch to use in many ways: Poach eggs in it for brunch, simmer shrimp in it for taco filling, or spoon it over shredded chicken with avocado slices inside a flour tortilla for lunch for the kiddos. Put it in tightly sealed Mason jars and bring it to friends as a host gift.

Featured in: I’m Done With Brunch, but I’ll Always Crave Big-Batch Ranchero

  • or to save this recipe.

  • Subscriber benefit: give recipes to anyone
    As a subscriber, you have 10 gift recipes to give each month. Anyone can view them - even nonsubscribers. Learn more.
  • Print Options


Advertisement


Ingredients

Yield:3 quarts (a ton; that’s the point)
  • pounds/about 100 ounces canned whole, peeled plum tomatoes and their juices (or one restaurant-style No. 10 can)
  • 1bunch cilantro, leaves and stems washed and roughly chopped
  • 1cup peeled garlic cloves
  • 4serrano chiles, stems and seeds removed then roughly chopped
  • 2guajillo chiles, stems detached
  • 1tablespoon achiote paste
  • Kosher salt, to taste
Ingredient Substitution Guide

Preparation

  1. Step 1

    Combine everything in a large pot or rondeau, and simmer over gentle heat for 1 hour, stirring occasionally to prevent any scorching on the bottom. Add a little water if it becomes any thicker than ketchup. Allow to cool before puréeing.

  2. Step 2

    Working in a blender in batches, purée until smooth. Check the salt seasoning. Let cool.

  3. Step 3

    Transfer to quart or pint containers, and stock your freezer, or put the sauce in something more attractive — rubber-sealed jars with hinged lids? — to make gifts of the stuff. Ranchero sauce keeps well in the refrigerator for up to 2 weeks, or in the freezer for up to 1 year. (It may separate a little, in which case you can simply reheat and give a new buzz in a blender to reunify.)

Ratings

4 out of 5
755 user ratings
Your rating

or to rate this recipe.

Have you cooked this?

or to mark this recipe as cooked.

Private Notes

Leave a Private Note on this recipe and see it here.

Cooking Notes

Lets say you are a home cook and want a smaller batch and don't have annatto paste available. Here's a passible home sized batch that is still enough for a couple of brunches: 16 oz can peeled plum tomatoes and their juices 1/4 bunch cilantro, leaves and stems washed and roughly chopped 1 bulb garlic peeled 1 serrano chiles, stems and seeds removed then roughly chopped 1/2 a guajillo chile, stems detached 1 teaspoon cumin 1 teaspoon coriander 1 teaspoon dried oregano 1 teaspoon paprika

She’s offering a great recipe in a time when sharing is more important than ever. Make a big batch. Make it the way she writes it. With love. And share it. There is not enough love , sharing or ranchero sauce in the world!

are the guajillos dried? if so, you only remove the stems and not seeds?

The recipe calls for 7 regular cans of tomatoes. A more sensible quantity for home cooking would be 3 cans of tomatoes, with some tomato puree added to make up for the missing 1/2 can (or use 3.5 cans), and halve the remaining ingredients.

From masterclass.com/articles/how-to-cook-with-guajillo-chiles "Guajillo chiles are the dried form of the mirasol chile." The heat level is mild: 2500-5000 Scoville units. So leaving the seeds in is fine. (By contrast, the serranos used in this recipe are 10-20,000 units.)

I am a home cook (of 2- my wife and myself), and I will make this As Is, because it will freeze nicely. I do this with other sauces. And the author states that it can be scaled down (easy math), which doesn't require bellowing about the amount nor making something completely different. As for the achiote, I'll buy at the friendly store that carries it. Now, I just need my tomato plants to play nicely (and that fat groundhog...sigh), and this ex-cook will inhaling Ranchero sauce. Thanks!

The restaurant-style #10 can she mentions is equivalent to just over four 28 oz cans, while the specification by weight is more like 3.75, so 4 of them should work just fine. I may make this this week, and have a quart for us, a quart for my parents, and a quart to freeze and send home with our best friend at the end of her upcoming visit. It sounds nice to have something to share that way.

Don’t bail out on the achiote paste! We can get the stuff even in Northern Montana in the Mexican section of Albertsons. If you really can’t find it then go online it’s inexpensive and the flavor profile is critical for this sauce. The guajillos are dried flat chile pods about 6 inches long. They have a red fruity raspberry-ish flavor. Pull out the stem, shake away the loose little seeds then use scissors to cross cut (perpendicular to the longitudinal axis) into thin strips so they disperse.

A quick version of huevos rancheros that I learned from a Mexican woman in Texas is to saute some onion, pablano or green pepper, and garlic. Stir some eggs with tomato paste, cumin, chili powder, s&p and cook with the vegetables. Then sprinkle on the cheese and wrap into tortillas.

Your eyes have not been deceiving you! They are only ever called "Guajillo" when they are dried. They are called "mirasol" when fresh, so of course no need to specify "dried."

In Mexico we never use cumin for sauces.

Maybe a little oregano? Dried, preferably the Mexican variety, added early — and not very much, I would guess. That said, you might try an experiment with a smaller batch and see if you still hate the cilantro if it's cooked this long. Harold McGee has written about how the aldehydes that people hate in cilantro convert into other substances when it's pureed; I feel like the same process takes place when it's heated for a long time.

No parsley. Leave out cilantro if you don't like.

Achiote paste usually includes annatto, oregano, cumin, clove, cinnamon, black pepper, allspice, garlic, and salt.

All guajillos are dried. Like pasilla or chipotle.

If you have a good New Mexico red chile power, just toast it a bit with minced garlic and add chicken broth and that’s your ranchero sauce. Tomato, cilantro etc just distract

Has anyone canned this? I'm thinking pints in a water bath with 1/4 tsp citric acid added, 30 minutes. I'm also using fresh tomatoes. I have found 3 c of chopped seeded fresh romas rough equals a 28 oz can.

Sub for achiote pasts. Use 4 envelopes of Sazon Goya powder

I make this sauce several times a year. One batch gets jarred just for gifts. EXCELLENT!

We enjoyed this so much I (figuratively) tossed out the enchilada sauce recipe I have used for more than 40 years. I feared it might be too spicy but the chiles impart a subtle smokiness that elevates the sauce. I’ll keep some in the freezer at all times.

Delicious! I found that it needed at least 1 teaspoon of salt, to cut the bitterness. The first quart was gone in 24 hours (tacos, poached eggs, etc.), and the other two went to my kids, so I will be making more soon!

I made this as written - got the big can of tomatoes and the achiote paste from Amazon. It's absolutely delicious. Ate it on most everything - kids loved it too. Gave away a few jars, and have just run out of my stash - so making another batch again this week.

I used 3 28 oz cans of plum tomatoes (84 oz) and one 14 oz can of diced tomatoes (98 oz total) and used a little water to rinse the cans. I did not have achiote paste but used 4 packets of sazon with achiote in place of that. I also added 1 large chopped onion, and for peppers, used 2 cubanelle peppers, 2 pasilla peppers and 2 very large jalapeno peppers (all fresh). I poached eggs in it for huevos rancheros and my family were licking their plates clean. Once made, an easy weeknight dinner.

I made this almost exactly as written but I had only achiote powder rather than paste. It was extremely simple to make and we enjoyed it so much over black bean burritos, topped with a bit of cheese and run under the broiler. I froze it in small ziplock bags for future quick deliciousness. I wish I could get my hands on the paste to see how it compares.

Great recipe! No Guajillos at the store, but Anchos did the job nicely. I added in a bit of allspice, cocoa powder and cinnamon for a little more earthy flavor, simmered longer than the hour recommended. Only thing I would do differently next time is to get out the blender as the submersible blender left some fibers from the cilantro to be picked out. Froze a few quarts for when the family comes for dinner and smaller containers for just the two of us. Good on basically everything.

Use an online recipe converter. It takes a few tries to figure it out, but it works perfectly for smaller batches. Copy, paste and enter.

I made this in half! Wow so good and I’m excited to use it a bunch of different ways and take to friends! Very good

This is disgusting, and the cilantro is the biggest reason why. Do yourself a favor and leave the cilantro out or replace with a combination of fresh parsely, oregano and/or lime juice. Also, I'd spice it up to another level with New Mexico hot chiles, either fresh Sandia variety green or dried Sandia red pods.

As a cilantro lover, I thought it added a lovely freshness! But I would think folks who don't like it, wouldn't follow this recipe.

Amazing! And so easy! My bf is Puerto Rican, so we always have these ingredients, including a big jar of Goya achiote paste. LOL! I only used 3 28-ounce cans of tomatoes, but followed the remainder of the instructions precisely. With more tomatoes, I don't think it would've been spicy enough for me. Hand blender worked great! I gave away a quart and served mine with shrimp, asparagus and mushrooms on top of orzo. Yum! Can't wait to get creative with poached eggs and/or tacos! Highly recommend.

It’s 9:30am… started this pot at 8:30… and damn does the house smell good. Made exactly as written- Amazon delivered the ginormous can of tomatoes and the achiote paste. Can’t wait to try this… on everything!

Private notes are only visible to you.

Advertisement

or to save this recipe.