-
Notifications
You must be signed in to change notification settings - Fork 169
New issue
Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.
By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.
Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account
Non-functioning keyboard #71
Comments
I don't think it's related to HID version, most likely QMK is nkro and doesn't support boot mode? Try building QMK without NKRO_ENABLE and check if it works. |
Tried disabling NKRO and it didn't really help. I have another keyboard, also running QMK (nothing is similar between this one and the one I have issues with other than QMK, they have different controllers, architectures etc), with NKRO enabled, and it works fine. This one is also HID v1.11. I'm not saying the HID version is necessarily the fault here, but it's the only real difference I can see between all these boards. |
Maybe the keyboard is also a mouse, and moving the mouse out of the boot protocol mode also reconfigures the keyboard. Can you provide its usb hid report? It might provide some more info. |
I've also disabled mousekeys on it, even bootmagic and mediakeys was removed to test. |
If you have Linux, try using "usbhid-dump" and paste the output. Package would be usbutils. |
Here you go:
|
Looks normal, report matches the "usual" format (modifiers, reserved, 6 keys). It could be something simple, but it's very hard to debug remotely. I'll be trying to implement the hid report mode for keyboards soon, perhaps that will fix it. |
@p3lim can you please also try test_fw.zip and let me know if this fixes anything? |
No change. |
With the latest commits and back at the office after easter break the Lenovo keyboard (3rd in the original post) no longer works as well. |
A little more testing, it seems that the keyboard port doesn't work at all with the latest commits. Putting the Lenovo keyboard in the mouse slot and it works fine. |
Can you try rebuilding with enforce_ports to 1 in user config? Any difference? |
Same issue with |
Oh that was just me being (kind of) stupid; I have both of the host ports connected to monitors, both of which are USB-C docks, and the computer in one of them had gone to sleep, which turned the USB hub in the monitor off, thus one of the picos were not powered. That is kind of a fault with the design though, ports not working unless both hosts are connected and powered. |
It is a crappy trade-off to make it simple, affordable and galvanically isolated. If one side powered both, then some keyboards/mice would not work because the cumulative power draw would be too large. If you provided an external PS, then we all would use whatever we had on hand to connect 230V on one side, and an expensive laptop on the other side. Not all chargers are good like this: https://www.righto.com/2012/05/apple-iphone-charger-teardown-quality.html I could redesign the board to provide external power if somebody really wants to do this :) |
@p3lim any change with the latest experimental beta https://github.com/hrvach/deskhop/releases/tag/v0.60 ? |
Still no |
@hrvach I'm sorry for this stupid comment, but v0.60 is the same commit as v0.52, right? 🙈 |
Changes not committed yet, under (heavy) construction but lack devices to test... |
cc: @jalmeroth @p3lim apologies to bug you, I'd appreciate some help with testing something else if you have a moment? |
I have a custom keyboard running the QMK firmware, and it's not recognized by my deskhop.
I tested with 3 other keyboard that worked fine:
All of these reports multiple HID interfaces when connected directly to my host, e.g:
The only real difference I see between them are the USB HID version they report, all 3 of the keyboards that work report USB HID v1.11, while my QMK-based keyboard report v1.01.
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: