Pipe Dreams: Find the Chicago Area's Best Plumbers

Plumbing is seldom exciting. It works fine for years, faithfully filling, flowing, and flushing. But when you get a clog or a pipe leaks water through your ceiling, the excitement may become more than you can stand. Even if you’re stressed, don’t panic and dial a number you remember from a radio jingle—big ad budgets don’t indicate great service. Instead, take a few minutes to find a plumber who will get the job done right for a fair price.

Nonprofit Chicago Consumers’ Checkbook’s surveys of local consumers turned up some excellent plumbing outfits in the area. Some companies evaluated by Checkbook were rated “superior” overall by at least 90 percent of their surveyed customers. Fortunately, many of the service providers that rate best for the quality of their work also are among the lowest in price.

But, as you’d expect, Checkbook also found there are many plumbing outfits out there that will soak you: For these, more than half of their surveyed customers rated them poorly overall, with reviews that frequently include words like “overcharged,” “unprofessional,” “incompetent,” “rude,” “messy,” “no-show,” and “dishonest.”

Here are some tips for hiring a plumber. For detailed advice, including ratings of local plumbing outfits for quality and price, visit Checkbook.org/PatchCHI/plumbers. Until March 25, Checkbook is giving readers free access to its ratings of area plumbers.

After you have identified high-quality, reliable companies, you need to consider price. To rate companies for the prices they offer, Checkbook’s undercover shoppers called the companies and requested price quotes for specific plumbing jobs. Prices varied dramatically for the same work. For example, to supply and install an InsinkErator Pro Series 750 garbage disposer, prices ranged from $335 to $753. And to supply and install a Bradford-White RG250T6N

50-gallon gas water heater, prices ranged from $890 to $1,689.

If you have a large remodeling job—a new kitchen or bathroom, for instance—getting several bids is especially critical. Not only is a large amount of money at stake, but the percentage variation in prices on such major jobs is larger than the variation on smaller installation jobs. Checkbook’s undercover shoppers recently obtained bids for a complete remodel of a large master bath and received price quotes ranging from $26,000 to $61,000.

The message is clear: Even for small jobs, it’s worth your time to shop around.

Unfortunately, although it’s fairly straightforward to get price quotes for plumbing installation or remodeling work, it’s often difficult to get accurate pricing for repairs in advance. Your best bet is to call a few companies—start with those that rate highly at Checkbook.org for quality and price. Then—

• Provide an exact description of your problem.
• Ask each company how it computes its labor rates (minimum charge and what it includes, price per hour after the minimum, etc.).
• Try to get an estimate of how long it usually takes to do your job.
• When the plumber arrives, review the labor rates you were provided. This will eliminate misunderstandings and may enhance timekeeping accuracy.

• Clear the area. You don’t want to pay a plumber $150 an hour to clean out junk from underneath your sink.
• Don’t let conversations with the plumber interfere with the work. While it is important to understand what the plumber is doing, there is a reasonable limit. Remember that the plumber is on the clock until he or she writes up the ticket.

For remodeling jobs, get a contract that includes:

• A fixed price for all work.
• Exactly what you want done, including makes and model numbers of all fixtures. Plus who breaks up the floor, cuts holes in the wall, patches floor and walls, hangs the sink, performs the carpentry, hauls away debris.
• Location of fixtures and where pipes will run. Sometimes a few inches can make a big difference in the difficulty of a plumbing job. If you have not spelled out what you want (ideally in a sketch or plan), you may meet a lot of resistance when you want your sink installed just a little to the left to make room for a wastebasket.
• That the contractor will secure required permits and inspections.
• When work is to begin and approximately how long it is to take.
• Warranty. For remodeling work, materials and workmanship should be warrantied for at least one year.
• Arbitration clause. While this request might put off some companies, a company accustomed to doing sizable jobs will see it as a possible cost-saver for both parties, should a dispute arise.
• Payment schedule. Companies that let you withhold a substantial portion of the price of an installation job until completion indicate that they are confident they can satisfy you. And you also get leverage to prod the company to do the job right if you are dissatisfied.

_____________________

Chicago Consumers’ Checkbook magazine and Checkbook.org is a nonprofit organization with a mission to help consumers get the best service and lowest prices. We are supported by consumers and take no money from the service providers we evaluate. You can access Checkbook’s ratings of plumbers free of charge until March 25 at Checkbook.org/PatchCHI/plumbers.