Town Unveils Historical Marker Commemorating Famous Bonanza Stand

OYSTER BAY, NY — A local family has been making Italian ices in Oyster Bay for more than 120 years, and now Bonanza's history has been commemorated.

Town Supervisor Joseph Saladino, Councilwoman Michele Johnson, and Town Clerk Rich LaMarca unveiled the historical marker in a ceremony at the Bonanza Stand of Oyster Bay.

The beloved Italian Ice and hot dog stand that's been operated by the Bonanza family for more than 120 years is an iconic local institution.

“The Bonanza Stand is more than just Oyster Bay’s oldest family business; it is a shining example of the American Dream,” said Saladino. “Founded by Italian immigrants John and Emma Bonanza in 1897, this stand began as a modest cart and has grown into a beloved institution that embodies the values of hard work, perseverance, and dedication.”

Saladino told Patch he prefers Bonanza's hot dog with mustard and sauerkraut, and the cherry ice.

“Today, we honor the past, celebrate the present, and look forward to a future filled with more delicious memories,” Saladino concluded. “Here's to the next 120 years of the Bonanza Stand!”

In recognition of Bonanza's significant historical and cultural impact, officials unveiled a special historical marker. This marker will serve as a permanent tribute to the Bonanza Family and the joy they have brought to generations of Oyster Bay residents.

Philip Bonanza Jr., representing the fourth generation of the family to run the business, shared his reflections during the ceremony. “Our family’s journey began with a simple cart and a dream. To see the Bonanza Stand become such a cherished part of this community is incredibly humbling. We’re proud to continue this legacy and grateful for the support that has made it possible.”

How can you choose?

Here are the Italian ice flavors made on the premises and promoted on the Bonanza Stand's website: Blue Raspberry, Cannoli, Cherry, Chocolate, Cotton Candy, Lemon, Orange, Orange Cream Delight, Peach, Banana Cream, Bubble Gum, Cappuccino, Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough, Coconut, Green Mint Chip, Lime, Mango, Peanut Butter, Pina Colander, Pineapple, Rainbow, Raspberry, Strawberry, Vanilla Chocolate chip, Pistachio, Cookies and Creme, Margarita, Peanut Butter and Jelly, Pink Lemonade, Pumpkin (In Season), Reese’s, Snickers, Watermelon, Sugar Free Cherry.