24 goals and a penalty shootout! There was no shock result, but a constant stream of goals to keep us entertained.
That's where we end tonight, but join us tomorrow for another replay as League Two leaders Stockport host National League Aldershot (19:45 GMT).
Thanks for your company and hopefully you can join us again then.
Revised FA Cup ties
#bbcfacup
Now that Stevenage have come through the shoot-out to beat Port Vale having been 2-0 and 3-2 down, we know the make-up of the ties involving tonight's winners.
Second round:
Blackpool v Forest Green (19 December)
Third round (all 6 January):
Maidstone v Stevenage
Newport v Eastleigh
Norwich v Bristol Rovers
Southampton v Walsall
'Defensive frailties let Vale down'
AET: Port Vale 3-3 Stevenage (Stevenage win 4-3 on pens)
Phil Bowers
Journalist, BBC Radio Stoke
This is a difficult one to take for Port Vale.
They looked so commanding for so long but ultimately their defensive frailties let them down at key moments.
They exit at the second round stage, having looked nailed for a trip to Maidstone.
STEVENAGE BEAT PORT VALE ON PENALTIES
FT: Port Vale 3-3 Stevenage (Stevenage win 4-3 on penalties)
Well what a remarkable night at Vale Park.
2-0 up with 10 minutes to go the tie was done.
But Stevenage came back to force extra time and then did it again to take the tie to penalties.
And those last gasp efforts have ultimately been rewarded.
Can you believe that?
MISSED PENALTY PORT VALE
Port Vale 3-4 Stevenage
Port Vale's Ryan Loft sees his penalty saved.
Stevenage are through.
MISSED PENALTY STEVENAGE
Port Vale 3-4 Stevenage
OVER THE BAR!
James Wilding's target practice was way off.
Stevenage's first penalty miss means we could be going onto sudden death.
GOAL PORT VALE
Port Vale 3-4 Stevenage
Tom Sang with a low drive to beat the keeper.
Stevenage can win it.
GOAL STEVENAGE
Port Vale 2-4 Stevenage
Nathan Thompson beats Connor Ripley through the Port Vale keeper's legs.
GOAL PORT VALE
Port Vale 2-3 Stevenage
Jason Lowe smashes the ball into the top corner.
You do not save those!
GOAL STEVENAGE
Port Vale 1-3 Stevenage
Harvey White stutters the run up but drives the ball home.
Stevenage are now in the driving seat.
MISSED PENALTY PORT VALE
Port Vale 1-2 Stevenage
Ben Garrity is normally reliable but it is beaten away by Taye Ashby-Hammond.
GOAL STEVENAGE
Port Vale 1-2 Stevenage
Kane Hemmings beats Port Vale's Connor Ripley after waiting for the keeper to move.
GOAL PORT VALE
Port Vale 1-1 Stevenage
Funso Ojo buries the ball into the bottom corner with his right foot.
GOAL STEVENAGE
Port Vale 0-1 Stevenage
Jamie Reid crisply fires the ball away to the goalkeeper's left.
PENALTY SHOOT-OUT
Stevenage to take first in the shoot out.
PENALTY SHOOT-OUT
Port Vale 3-3 Stevenage
It'll be penalties to settle it at Vale Park.
How this tie changed after 80 minutes.
Vale were cruising after Ben Garritt's double but first Kyle Hemmings in normal time and then Nathan Thompson have take the tie all the way.
'You can't believe where this game is taking you'
Port Vale 3-3 Stevenage
Phil Bowers
Journalist, BBC Radio Stoke
You cannot quite believe where this game is taking you.
GOAL: Port Vale 3-3 Stevenage
Nathan Thompson (120 mins)
AND THEY'VE DONE IT AGAIN !!
Kyle Hemmings with a low ball in and Nathan Thompson is there to pull Stevenage level once again.
What a cup tie.
Post update
Port Vale 3-2 Stevenage
Into stoppage time at the end of extra-time now.
Stevenage looking for another late leveller, this time to force penalties.
GOAL: Port Vale 3-2 Stevenage
Ryan Loft (114 mins)
But this time Vale have scored!
And it's Ryan Loft with his first goal for the club.
He's found all alone in the penalty area and cooly finishes past Taye Ashby-Hammond.
Live Reporting
Adam Lanigan, Alex Winter and Alex Seftel
All times stated are UK
Rex FeaturesCopyright: Rex Features
Latest PostSee you for Stockport tomorrow
#bbcfacup
How about that for an evening of FA Cup football?
24 goals and a penalty shootout! There was no shock result, but a constant stream of goals to keep us entertained.
That's where we end tonight, but join us tomorrow for another replay as League Two leaders Stockport host National League Aldershot (19:45 GMT).
Thanks for your company and hopefully you can join us again then.
Revised FA Cup ties
#bbcfacup
Now that Stevenage have come through the shoot-out to beat Port Vale having been 2-0 and 3-2 down, we know the make-up of the ties involving tonight's winners.
Second round:
Blackpool v Forest Green (19 December)
Third round (all 6 January):
Maidstone v Stevenage
Newport v Eastleigh
Norwich v Bristol Rovers
Southampton v Walsall
'Defensive frailties let Vale down'
AET: Port Vale 3-3 Stevenage (Stevenage win 4-3 on pens)
Phil Bowers
Journalist, BBC Radio Stoke
This is a difficult one to take for Port Vale.
They looked so commanding for so long but ultimately their defensive frailties let them down at key moments.
They exit at the second round stage, having looked nailed for a trip to Maidstone.
STEVENAGE BEAT PORT VALE ON PENALTIES
FT: Port Vale 3-3 Stevenage (Stevenage win 4-3 on penalties)
Well what a remarkable night at Vale Park.
2-0 up with 10 minutes to go the tie was done.
But Stevenage came back to force extra time and then did it again to take the tie to penalties.
And those last gasp efforts have ultimately been rewarded.
Can you believe that?
MISSED PENALTY PORT VALE
Port Vale 3-4 Stevenage
Port Vale's Ryan Loft sees his penalty saved.
Stevenage are through.
MISSED PENALTY STEVENAGE
Port Vale 3-4 Stevenage
OVER THE BAR!
James Wilding's target practice was way off.
Stevenage's first penalty miss means we could be going onto sudden death.
GOAL PORT VALE
Port Vale 3-4 Stevenage
Tom Sang with a low drive to beat the keeper.
Stevenage can win it.
GOAL STEVENAGE
Port Vale 2-4 Stevenage
Nathan Thompson beats Connor Ripley through the Port Vale keeper's legs.
GOAL PORT VALE
Port Vale 2-3 Stevenage
Jason Lowe smashes the ball into the top corner.
You do not save those!
GOAL STEVENAGE
Port Vale 1-3 Stevenage
Harvey White stutters the run up but drives the ball home.
Stevenage are now in the driving seat.
MISSED PENALTY PORT VALE
Port Vale 1-2 Stevenage
Ben Garrity is normally reliable but it is beaten away by Taye Ashby-Hammond.
GOAL STEVENAGE
Port Vale 1-2 Stevenage
Kane Hemmings beats Port Vale's Connor Ripley after waiting for the keeper to move.
GOAL PORT VALE
Port Vale 1-1 Stevenage
Funso Ojo buries the ball into the bottom corner with his right foot.
GOAL STEVENAGE
Port Vale 0-1 Stevenage
Jamie Reid crisply fires the ball away to the goalkeeper's left.
PENALTY SHOOT-OUT
Stevenage to take first in the shoot out.
PENALTY SHOOT-OUT
Port Vale 3-3 Stevenage
It'll be penalties to settle it at Vale Park.
How this tie changed after 80 minutes.
Vale were cruising after Ben Garritt's double but first Kyle Hemmings in normal time and then Nathan Thompson have take the tie all the way.
'You can't believe where this game is taking you'
Port Vale 3-3 Stevenage
Phil Bowers
Journalist, BBC Radio Stoke
You cannot quite believe where this game is taking you.
GOAL: Port Vale 3-3 Stevenage
Nathan Thompson (120 mins)
AND THEY'VE DONE IT AGAIN !!
Kyle Hemmings with a low ball in and Nathan Thompson is there to pull Stevenage level once again.
What a cup tie.
Post update
Port Vale 3-2 Stevenage
Into stoppage time at the end of extra-time now.
Stevenage looking for another late leveller, this time to force penalties.
GOAL: Port Vale 3-2 Stevenage
Ryan Loft (114 mins)
But this time Vale have scored!
And it's Ryan Loft with his first goal for the club.
He's found all alone in the penalty area and cooly finishes past Taye Ashby-Hammond.
Has that finally won the tie?