Guardian Weekly

Ask a silly question

I SIT IN THE DOCTOR’S OFFICE.

He asks: “So, when did you know?” I say: “Always.” Because I’ve heard that simplicity gets results. It is one phrase that has spanned my lifetime. No matter what setting, country or occasion, it remains un defeatable. Like a cockroach that refuses to disappear, it doesn’t care which part of my life I am in; it will always emerge: “So, when did you know?”

People always ask me this, or, if I am not around, they will ask my mother, or a friend, or even a teacher I haven’t seen in years – “So, when did Travis … you know?” The “you” and “know” will come with verbalised italics. If an emoji could appear out of thin air, it would be the eyes darting to the side of the room accompanied by a vague hand gesture, as if to say: so, when was it clear Travis would become a cross-dressing deviant who is straying from God’s path?

Of course, humans are naturally curious, but I find British ways of communicating to be crowded with social pleasantries and forced “politeness” – an investment in never rocking the boat or being seen as out of line. Asking any form of direct question at a British dinner table can cause waves of disapproving murmurs for months. Yet, present that same dinner table with someone who is visibly gender non conforming, wearing a dress, with a bit of a five o’clock shadow coming through, and all of those manners disappear. “So, when did you know?” becomes their version of weather talk or asking what you do for a living. People want to know, often within the first handshake or moment you sit down, whether you were always like this, what your parents think, the defining moment you knew, and when you first tried on the red lipstick and dress from your mother’s closet (even if, in

You’re reading a preview, subscribe to read more.

More from Guardian Weekly

Guardian Weekly1 min read
Chess
Magnus Carlsen, no longer the world champion but still ranked the global No 1, will meet the controversial rising talent Hans Niemann, 21, across the board next Friday for the first time since the 2022 Sinquefield Cup, when their fateful third-round
Guardian Weekly3 min read
Michael Rosen
My father used to tell us a story from when he supervised students training to be teachers. He was sitting in a school staff room when a teacher came in, collapsed into a chair, and said: “Well, I’ve taught it to them. Whether they know it or not is
Guardian Weekly4 min readWorld
Olga Rudenko
At 35, I’m younger than many things – such as the internet or Apple computers. And yet I’m older than my country’s independence. For most people, the independence of their birth state is so ironclad they rarely get to really think about it. Others wo

Related Books & Audiobooks