Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

The Rumor Game

Rate this book
A determined reporter and a reluctant FBI agent face off against fascist elements in World War II-era Boston.

Reporter Anne Lemire writes the Rumor Clinic, a newspaper column that disproves the many harmful rumors floating around town, some of them spread by Axis spies and others just gossip mixed with fear and ignorance. Tired of chasing silly rumors about Rosie Riveters' safety on the job, she wants to write about something bigger.

Special Agent Devon Mulvey, one of the few Catholics at the FBI, spends his weekdays preventing industrial sabotage and his Sundays spying on clerics with suspect loyalties—and he spends his evenings wooing the many lonely women whose husbands are off at war.

When Anne’s story about Nazi propaganda intersects with Devon’s investigation into the death of a factory worker, the two are led down a dangerous trail of espionage, organized crime, and domestic fascism—one that implicates their own tangled pasts and threatens to engulf the city in violence.

With vibrant historical atmosphere and a riveting mystery that illuminates still-timely issues about disinformation and power, Thomas Mullen delivers another powerful thriller.

368 pages, Hardcover

First published February 27, 2024

Loading interface...
Loading interface...

About the author

Thomas Mullen

24 books812 followers
Thomas Mullen is the author of Darktown, an NPR Best Book of the Year, which has been shortlisted for the Los Angeles Times Book Prize, the Southern Book Prize, the Indies Choice Book Award, has been nominated for two Crime Writers Assocation Dagger Awards, and is being developed for television by Sony Pictures with executive producer Jamie Foxx; The Last Town on Earth, which was named Best Debut Novel of 2006 by USA Today and was awarded the James Fenimore Cooper Prize for excellence in historical fiction; The Many Deaths of the Firefly Brothers; and The Revisionists. He lives in Atlanta with his wife and sons.

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
116 (16%)
4 stars
303 (44%)
3 stars
224 (32%)
2 stars
34 (4%)
1 star
7 (1%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 250 reviews
Profile Image for Liz.
2,445 reviews3,316 followers
January 13, 2024
The Rumor Game combined a well done historical fiction with a murder mystery. Taking place during 1942 in Boston, it covers the existence of pro-fascist sentiments in the city during that time as well as the Mob starting to take control of the unions.
Devon Mulvey is an FBI agent, tasked with investigating sabotage in the local war industrial companies, any crime that might involve an anti-USA aspect and even Catholic clerics against the war effort. He’s also got a bit of a “zipper problem” as we used to say. Meanwhile, Anne Lemire is a young reporter whose newspaper column is the Rumor Clinic, which disproves harmful rumors - everything from WAACs getting abortions to Nazis poisoning the lobsters off the coastline to sailors developing green skin after Pearl Harbor. Both main characters were well defined. Each has something to prove- Mulrey the odd Irishman in the WASPish FBI; Ann being both a woman and Jewish in a male, Christian dominated field.
I was impressed by Mullen’s ability to firmly place the reader in the time and place - the Boston neighborhood boundaries and the complete clannish aspects of the city, the anti-Jewish sentiment, the day to day restrictions because of the war. For a murder mystery, I felt I got a good grip on the political issues of the day. He’s done his research and most of the political issues addressed here are based on historical facts. Even Anne is loosely based on a real life reporter.
The story moves at a brisk pace. Neither main character knows who to trust, including each other. There are lots of moving parts and I was engrossed from beginning to end.
I was a fan of Mullen’s Darktown series and this book just proves that he has the ability to consistently create a well done mystery in a variety of historical times and places.
My thanks to Netgalley and St. Martin’s Press for an advance copy of this book.
Profile Image for Tracey.
624 reviews44 followers
December 10, 2023
This is an entertaining, well-written, historical fiction crime thriller, which is based on actual persons and events. It has an intelligent, strong and capable female protagonist, a flawed but likable male protagonist, mystery, intrigue, suspense, twists and turns, and a satisfying conclusion. The author's notes are interesting and informative, and are truly appreciated. Many thanks to St. Martin's Press, Minotaur Books, NetGalley, and Mr. Thomas Mullen, who provided me with an advance reader copy of this novel. This is my honest opinion.
Profile Image for Matt.
4,157 reviews12.9k followers
January 5, 2024
First and foremost, a large thank you to NetGalley, Thomas Mullen, St. Martin’s Press, and Minotaur Books for providing me with a copy of this publication, which allows me to provide you with an unbiased review.

A fan of Thomas Mullen, I was eager to pick up this book to read another piece of historical fiction. Mullen weaves a wonderful story and keeps the reader in tune with all that is going on. While I love historical fiction, some authors use little to no creative freedom when they write. Mullen makes sure to develop things as he would like them to be, allowing a better story and stronger developments.

It’s June 1943 and tensions are high across the United States, with distrust enveloping many. Friends are now foes and those who are unrecognised had better not come into town, for fear of major ramifications. As tensions rise, there is a great deal of harm that could occur, should stories not be clear or decisions spun in a certain manner.

Reporter Anne Lemire has her hands full trying to dispel many of the rumours that have been circulating around town. Some are Axis propaganda to divide Americans, while others are locally fabricated to stir the pot. Anne must get to the bottom of them before the tinderbox is lit and things become explosive. Anne is tired of the banality of it all and hopes to find a bigger scoop that is well worth her while and abilities.

Special Agent Devon Mulvey has made a name for himself within the FBI, not all good. He spends his days trying to root out the traitors and weekends finding clerics who are fanning the flames for their own benefit. Nothing is quite as Devon would like. Special Agent Mulvey has a way with the women and does all he can to score with them, while their husbands are out fighting or working.

After Anne begins chasing a story about Nazi propaganda, she comes face to face with Special Agent Mulvey, who has been working on an investigation into the murder of a n immigrant worker. Together, they are pulled into the depths of the propaganda machine, where espionage is the least of their concerns. They must find a way to discover the truth, together. As they struggle, there are aspects of themselves that are key to the larger investigation. Mullen does well with this piece and keeps the action high.

The novels of Thomas Mullen that I have read kept me hooked until the final pages. While I had moments of pace slowing, I found myself quite intrigued with how Mullen set things out. With strong narrative flow and keen characters to fill in all the spaces, Mullen keeps the reader wondering until the very end. Using a known historical period as a background, the story comes alive and keeps the reader guessing. Mullen has mastered the art of development and wastes no time here.

Plot points are well received throughout the piece, keeping the reader on their toes. There is so much going on at some points that the reader must stop to collect themselves. While World War 2 stories tend not to pull me in, I found myself hooked and eager to learn more. For that I must thank Thomas Mullen.

Kudos, Mr. Mullen, for keeping things on point and well-developed throughout.

Love/hate the review? An ever-growing collection of others appears at:
http://pecheyponderings.wordpress.com/
Profile Image for Sue.
1,346 reviews605 followers
March 1, 2024
The Rumor Game by Thomas Mullen is an historical fiction novel set in the neighborhoods of Boston during the first year of the United States’s entry into World War II. Most men of fighting age are gone from the streets now, signed up and either in training or already on their way to one of the fronts of this new war. Otherwise, they may be working in necessary industries that produce military equipment or weapons. Then they may be in the police or the FBI.

The first primary character in this novel, they provide alternating narratives, is Anne Lemire, a young woman from Dorchester who works for a Boston newspaper on a column debunking the many rumors related to the war that are running wild. Her goal is to be a serious writer and her concern is the growing number of attacks on Jewish people happening in her neighborhood and others in Boston, seemingly without any police intervention. The other is Devon Mulvey, an FBI agent with Dorchester roots, whose family moved out of the city when he was young. He now lives and works in the city himself. He is caught between the tedium of some necessary paperwork, questions of problems at a munitions company and investigations he would like to take on. Then a murder occurs that seems to bring many worlds together.

This is a picture of that part of the home front that opposes war: both the hoodlums/bigots and the organized fascists trying to prevent or stop US intervention in “Europe’s” war. Within this large picture are the small parts of confusing contradictions where sometimes it’s hard to know who the good guys are.

This is a very interesting reading experience and covers a time I’ve never read or heard about though I have lived in the Boston area my entire life. I wish my parents were around for me to ask about that time. Mullen provides a list of resources on the pre-war and wartime era for reference and also provides historical parallels for some of the characters and incidents.

Recommended.

Thanks to Minotaur Books and NetGalley for an eARC of this book. This review is my own.
Profile Image for Char.
1,799 reviews1,709 followers
January 27, 2024
In THE RUMOR GAME an FBI agent and a rumor killing reporter try to solve a local mystery involving the mafia, unions, and lots of anti-Semites. All of which is taking place in the city of Boston in 1943.

Being from Massachusetts, I am almost always interested in stories taking place in my state. Thomas Mullen reeled me in as a reader some years ago with his stories about the black police force in Atlanta. I was interested to see how Boston was portrayed.

The answer is-not good. Boston has a very long history and a lot of it is not great as far as racism is concerned. Boston had problems with just about every immigrant group. Even though I'm from the western part of the state, I am sometimes ashamed thinking about the things that went on in that city. Plus, and maybe I'm just ignorant, but I never knew about the anti-Semitism until now. People were blaming the Jews back then for roping us into the war. Attacks on Jewish people rose like crazy during that time? Sound familiar? It should. If we don't learn our history we are doomed to repeat it. There are a lot of parallels to today in this story and that makes me afraid.

The writing here is excellent, because...hey, it's Thomas Mullen. The plot meandered a bit, but that introduced us to more compelling characters, and exposed us to more of what was going on in the city. The pacing was fair and the mystery a good one, but somehow this narrative did not connect all the way with me. I didn't care all that much for any of the characters-there was no defined good guy-versus bad guy showdown, and it seems to me that there really were no good guys at all. Maybe that's the case in real life too?

I listened to the audio version of this tale, brilliantly narrated by Megan Tusing. I had previously never heard of her, and now I've listened to two of her audios in one month. She's an excellent narrator and she brought this tale to life.

Overall, I enjoyed this book, just not as much as I expected. It's full of twists and turns, has several memorable characters and it takes a look at an ugly history, which in turn, give us a look at what is going on today, and what might sprout from it. In this way, it's also a disturbing tale.

Recommended, especially to fans of historical fiction!

*Thank you to the publisher, the author and NetGalley for the e-ARC in exchange for my honest feedback. This is it!*
February 23, 2024
Set in Boston just as America enters WWII. There are two main characters: Anne Lemire, a journalist who writes a weekly column called the Rumor Clinic for the Star--her job is to chase down stupid stories and disprove them. And Devon Mulvey, a young FBI agent whose job currently is to provide security for a war munitions plant. He and his partner Lou are called to the scene of the murder of one of the plant's employees. Could it have been because he was Jewish? There seems to be an awful lot of anti-semitism in that mostly Irish area of Boston as America is drawn into the war in Europe.

This story opened my eyes to the level of racial hatred which existed even here in America during that historic period. The plot which combines mystery and a bit of romance allows the author to deliver an important message. One can't help but draw certain parallels to modern times and the racism that still exists unfortunately.

I received an arc of this novel through the St Martin Press Influencer Group via Net Galley. Many thanks for the opportunity. My review is voluntary and the opinions expressed are my own.
Profile Image for Louise.
849 reviews151 followers
April 9, 2024
(rounded up from 4.5)

Thomas Mullen has a way of writing that pulls you into a story quickly. I loved his Blind Spots and I loved The Rumor Game too, which was a very different kind of story.

The Rumor Game takes place over a short period of time in the wartime summer of 1943 in Boston - and specifically in Boston’s Dorchester neighborhood. The main female character is Anne Lemire, who writes a column for the fictional newspaper, The Boston Star, in which she debunks various rumors, some of which sound ridiculous but were believed by a large number of people. And then there are the hurtful rumors, mainly focusing on the Jews of Boston, accusing them of all sorts of things - blaming them for the US being in the war at all, and then profiting from it, for example. The publisher’s blurb didn’t prepare me for how much the story centered on antisemitism. This was a major subplot of the story and it resonated with me, especially given the recent rise in antisemitism that we are experiencing in 2024. In addition to that, Mullen explores how much isolationism and fascist sympathy there still was in that area (and in other parts of the US, of course, but this book looks mainly at Boston). I didn’t realize that there was still so much isolationist sentiment in 1943. I found that fascinating and disturbing.

The other main character is Devon Mulvey, an FBI agent who is working to prevent sabotage of the local wartime industrial efforts. He is one of the very few Irish Catholic FBI agents. Lemire, on the other hand, is the product of the marriage of a French Canadian Catholic man and an Eastern European Jewish woman, the latter identity not being revealed until Anne was in her teens. Because of that identity becoming known, her family was then shunned in parts of Dorchester. Her younger brother Sammy has been beaten up by local thugs because of his identity - and he’s not the only one.

All of this was eye-opening to me. My husband grew up in another similarly ethnic part of Boston, but his mother grew up in Dorchester and reading this story made me wish so much that she was still alive so I could talk to her about her experiences at that time!

There’s a murder of a Jewish munitions worker that Devon winds up investigating and of course his path and Anne’s path cross. There are mob ties, racism (including discrimination in hiring at the munitions plant) and plots to create chaos in the city.

I moved back and forth between the audiobook and the ebook for this title, which was very convenient. The audiobook was beautifully narrated by Megan Tusing. She did a great job with both the female and male voices and the various accents.

Thank you to Minotaur Books and NetGalley for the opportunity to read an advance reader copy of this book and to Macmillan Audio and NetGalley for the opportunity to listen to an advance copy of this audiobook. All opinions are my own.
Profile Image for Dona.
834 reviews121 followers
February 28, 2024
Thank you to the author Thomas Mullen, publishers Minotaur Books, and NetGalley for an advance digital copy of THE RUMOR GAME. All views are mine.

Some mistruths were born of ignorance, almost innocent in their lack of understanding about the world. Some were initially harmless, more mistakes than outright lies, until they were repeated often enough to convince a critical mass of people, in which case they became dangerous. Then there were the deliberate mistruths that all but dripped with venom, sharpened like fangs ready to sink into gullible flesh. Loc.30

THE RUMOR GAME by Thomas Mullen quite surprised me, but once I adapted to concept of a *spy* game from a more harmless, or at least domestic sort, I began to appreciate what I was reading. Stylistically speaking, this book is quite good and interesting. Beyond that, this book gives a detailed perspective of immigrant life in the US at the time of WWII. Fascinating insights on domestic spy activity and the immense pressure people faced from the government due to ideological suspicion. I recommend this one for readers of WWII fiction or US historical fiction or domestic spy stories.

𝐶ℎ𝑎𝑠𝑖𝑛𝑔 𝑎 𝑠𝑡𝑜𝑟𝑦 . 𝑊ℎ𝑒𝑟𝑒 𝑖𝑡 𝑤𝑜𝑢𝑙𝑑 𝑙𝑒𝑎𝑑, 𝑠ℎ𝑒 𝑐𝑜𝑢𝑙𝑑𝑛’𝑡 𝑏𝑒 𝑠𝑢𝑟𝑒. 𝐵𝑢𝑡 𝑠ℎ𝑒 𝑤𝑎𝑛𝑡𝑒𝑑 𝑡𝑜 𝑘𝑛𝑜𝑤 𝑤ℎ𝑜 𝑤𝑎𝑠 𝑝𝑟𝑖𝑛𝑡𝑖𝑛𝑔 𝑡ℎ𝑜𝑠𝑒 𝑎𝑤𝑓𝑢𝑙 𝑙𝑒𝑎𝑓𝑙𝑒𝑡𝑠 𝑎𝑛𝑑 𝑤𝑜𝑟𝑘𝑖𝑛𝑔 𝑠𝑜 ℎ𝑎𝑟𝑑 𝑡��� 𝑠𝑡𝑖𝑟 𝑢𝑝 ℎ𝑎𝑡𝑟𝑒𝑑 𝑖𝑛 ℎ𝑒𝑟 𝑐𝑖𝑡𝑦. 𝑊ℎ𝑎𝑡 𝑠ℎ𝑒’𝑑 𝑑𝑜 𝑛𝑒𝑥𝑡 𝑤𝑜𝑢𝑙𝑑 𝑑𝑒𝑝𝑒𝑛𝑑 𝑜𝑛 𝑤ℎ𝑎𝑡 𝑠ℎ𝑒 𝑙𝑒𝑎𝑟𝑛𝑒𝑑. 𝑇ℎ𝑖𝑠 𝑤𝑎𝑠 ℎ𝑒𝑟 𝑏𝑒𝑠𝑡 𝑝𝑙𝑎𝑛. 𝐴𝑡 𝑙𝑒𝑎𝑠𝑡 𝑖𝑡 𝑤𝑎𝑠 𝑓𝑢𝑛. Loc.1269

Three (or more) things I loved:

1. Many WWII novels take place in Europe, or maybe the Pacific islands. I like that this book takes place in domestic, suburban US, and shows the affects fascism and tge war efforts on different kinds of Americans.

2. Some really great insights about the limitations women experience when meeting the social demands and commands of the many institutions holding authority over them.

3. I like the inclusion of union subplot. I don't come across it much and I think it's important history.

4. I adore that Mullen delivers dialogue in summary. It allows for an interesting distant and thus transparency on the narrative that is very entertaining.

Three (or less) things I didn't love:

This section isn't only for criticisms. It's merely for items that I felt something for other than "love" or some interpretation thereof.

1. This book is so over written at the outset, a common issue: Loc.636

2. One of the main reasons I chose this book is the title, which it turns out is an ill fit.

3. I didn't enjoy repeated use of the word
"n---o"; I found it unnecessary and thus inappropriate.

4. Characters are a bit impenetrable. This could a style issue, actually.

Rating: 🪖🪖🪖 / 5 war stories
Recommend? Maybe, for fans of WWII
Finished: Feb 24 '24
Format: Digital arc, Kindle
Read this book if you like:
⏳️ historical fiction
🪖 WWII stories
👩‍✈️ women's rights and feminism
🚔 law enforcement procedurals
Profile Image for Erin Clemence.
1,277 reviews375 followers
November 9, 2023
Special thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for a free, electronic ARC of this novel received in exchange for an honest review.

Expected publication date: Feb. 27, 2024

Thomas Mullen’s, “The Rumor Game” is a high-intensity, World War two novel full of action, conspiracy and racial tension.

Anne Lemire writes a small column in the local paper, where she disproves rumours circulating about the war. She wants more for herself but knows that, as a female, her chances are not the same as they would be if she were a male. However, she starts to notice that the antisemitic tensions around her are increasing, and, as a half-Jew woman, Anne hopes that she can investigate where others can’t, hopefully bringing to light the violence that police officers seem to be ignoring.

Devon Mulvey is one of the few Irish Catholics in the FBI and he spends his time infiltrating Catholic churches and their representatives, to filter out those who are using their power to spread hate speech and propaganda. When a story Anne is writing coincides with one of Devon’s investigations, the two begin a dangerous journey into the dark underbelly of the Boston criminal element, in a time where fear, intimidation and racism is running rampant.


Mullen is a new author for me, although he has been around long enough to win several awards and have at least one of his novels propositioned for a Hollywood version. His talent is evident, observable in his well-developed characters and seamless flow, and his plot is creative and unique. “The Rumor Game” has something for every reader; family loyalty, rebellion, police investigation, corruption, race wars and hatred and even some romance. Every page is tense, thrilling and pulse-pounding.

Anne and Devon both share narrating responsibilities, which helps connect the two characters to each other and the reader. Anne is a firecracker, adamant to bring attention to the way Jews are being treated even if it means sacrificing everything she loves. Devon is an outcast in his own right, looked down on by his colleagues for being Irish, and looked down on from his family for being a cop. These two make the perfect pair to cheer for, as both are relatable and likable.

“Rumor Game” shines a light on Boston’s history with racial tensions that are not as distant as one would like to hope for. A clever and sharp work of historical fiction, Mullen’s new novel kept me engaged and entertained. He has found a new lifetime fan!
Profile Image for Paula.
806 reviews203 followers
March 17, 2024
This is not worthy of the author of the outstanding Darktown trilogy,and Blind Spots.
It's boring,predictable, has cardboard characters,laying it on (everything) too heavy. No nuances.
Mediocre writing,plot feels like YA.
Such a disappointment.
Profile Image for Kasa Cotugno.
2,525 reviews539 followers
November 13, 2023
The Rumor Game, set in WWII era Boston, has a murder to solve, several complicated characters, and a feisty heroine who reminds me somewhat of Rosalind Russell in the gender flipped version of Front Page. There is also an FBI agent who has much to hide from his employers. While the crime was somewhat intriguing, what I really liked about this was its lack of conventionality, its focus on the times and the anti-semitism rampant in Boston at the time. Definitely a different kind of novel from the usual of the genre.
Profile Image for Girish.
1,015 reviews236 followers
December 31, 2023
Thank you Netgalley and Little Brown Book group for the ARC of the book.

This historical fiction set in 1942 US while the war was escalating in Germany cleverly tries to detail out the various biases at play.

Anne Lemire runs a column called “Rumor clinic” where she tracks down the source of rumors and exposes false propaganda and misinformation that might impact the war effort. As a Jewish family in a charged neighborhood she starts putting together a piece on anti-Semitic hate crimes and police corruption.

On the other hand Devon, an Irish FBI agent from an established family is tracking a murder of German jew at the ammunitions factory. There is a missing crate of rifles and a lot of big wigs trying to block the investigation.

When their paths cross with a bit of shared history, the story exposes multiple layers of bias in the society. There is one subtext of Jews vs Christians, one of Reds vs capitals and another of blacks and immigrants. There is organized misinformation and hate mongering with an objective to prevent war.

Based on true events in Boston, the book is written like a taut thriller. The only complaint is the ease of tracking complex plots by just asking or staking out. Maybe the character arcs of the protagonists was still partially developed.

Still a very engaging read. Also my last read of 2023.

The book will hit the stands in Feb 2024.
Profile Image for eyes.2c.
2,860 reviews91 followers
February 26, 2024
Dangerous rumors!

Fascinating story built around the Nazi groups, fascist groups, and other anti Jewish groups in Boston during World War II, including the Christian Front organization.
Told through the eyes of Jewish journalist Anne Lemire and FBI agent Devon Mulvey.
“ Anne wrote for the Rumor Clinic, the weekly Star column she’d managed to create for herself after weeks of persistent calls and a few connections. The idea behind the Rumor Clinic was to identify and disprove the many harmful rumors floating around town, some of them spread by deliberate Axis propaganda to weaken resolve and others just random bits of hearsay mixed with fear, ignorance, and bigotry.”
Incidents are building, fuelled by rumour, and subsequent resentment from blue collar workers about Jews and African Americans supposedly taking their jobs in a munitions factory (untrue.) This, together with the anti semitism of certain Catholic priests, the same sentiments amongst many of Boston police force, and the increased mugging of young Jewish people walking home, weaves a dark tale.
Anne wants to expose fascists and corrupt organizations. Dangerous! Devon is investigating a sudden death. Their paths connect.
Feelings of helplessness, the entanglement of family relationships, of trying to bring untruths to the public awareness—a public that mostly didn’t want to know, pervade.
Challenging and enlightening. Disproving falsehoods and exposing rumors is not easy.

A St. Martin’s Press ARC via NetGalley.
Many thanks to the author and publisher.
Please note: Quotes taken from an advanced reading copy maybe subject to change
(Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.)
Profile Image for Marcia reading past dark.
196 reviews215 followers
February 26, 2024
The Rumor Game, by Thomas Mullen, set in Boston in 1942, is an exciting murder mystery within a historical fiction novel. The main characters are strong and their roles and descriptions are well written. Devon Mulvey, an Irishman, is a hard-nosed FBI agent called in to investigate anti-war crimes. His sideline is chasing skirts. Anne Lemire is a young reporter, whose newspaper column “The Rumor Clinic,” investigates high interest rumors circulating in the city.

This story covers a number social issues of the era: Growing mob activity, antisemitism, abortion, the role of women, and troubles within the Catholic church, all of which were rampant in Boston at the time. This is an action-packed and fast moving read.
Profile Image for J Kromrie.
1,281 reviews23 followers
August 1, 2023
Thanks to the publisher and Netgalley for this eARC.

I felt both pleased and honored to receive a copy of Thomas Mullen's The Rumor Game in return for a review, as I have followed this author's novels for years. Perhaps somewhat predictably, on my part, as I am such a fan of police procedurals as well as novels that remind us that the sins of the past must be reexamined to keep us from repeating them, Mullen's Darktown series is my favorite (he could have written dozens in this captivating series, I would still like up to buy a copy at every release date.

However, even with my adoration of mysteries and crime novels, Mr. Mullen's sheer genius when it comes to delicately opening our hearts and our minds, as when we read his novels they are the closest thing to true-life accounts that fiction can ever be. We fall in love a little with Mullen's characters, and it is the same with the wonderfully brash female reporter in this novel, who pushes herself to be heroic, although she worries deeply when she sees her own personality traits and dedication reflected in her little brother.

I have loved Thomas Mullen's creations for ages, it is as though he gives us a special window to witness past historical events or formative times, you feel like an invisible family member of the main characters in Mullen's novels. He is a very special author who, due to his skill in weaving a magical historical time that we feel so much a part of, his novels will always hold a place in my heart.

In the Rumor Game, Mullen's turns his very talented attention to the sins and nonsensical hatred, cruelty, judgement and prejudice surrounding World War II. Unfortunately, although we would prefer to imagine that the inequality of this time was restricted to Germany and Hitler's vile legacy, much to our shame, the United States and US citizens (as in EVERY shamefully prejudicial and hate-filled time) hated those who appeared or seemed to be "other" or "different" at least on the surface.

A beautiful novel and as usual, this talent author (without overtly doing so) reminds us of our countries past sins, while crafting an extremely captivating story, guaranteed to pull you in, you are so close to "there" when you read Mullen's novels, and this wonderful offering, about a few individualized who were quietly heroic, almost - is a gift that Mullen's deserves to feel proud to give us.


Until next time (my I do go ON, although this author deserves kudos for DAYS). Well, just set aside this clumsy "love letter to this author's talent" and as soon as it is on the shelves pick up a copy of The Rumor Game!
20 reviews2 followers
August 19, 2023
This is the first ever Thomas Mullen book I have read. Due to the subject matter, which I was not aware of at the time Net Galley offered me an ARC, I felt closer to the subject matter.
Anne Lemire, originally believing she was catholic and raised that way living in one of the Irish strongholds of Boston during WW2, graduates a prestigious New England University to become a reporter at a local paper known as “The Star”. Her Column entitled “The Rumor Clinic” was to debunk myths about anything occurring during the WW2 era in Boston. She later learns she really is Jewish and is subjected to all prejudices of Boston especially from the Irish immigrants and their descendants. One of her stories deals with a group that wants us not to enter the war and conspires to prove it was the Jews who wanted us to enter WWII.
Of course, she falls for a second or third generation Irish guy, Devon Mulvey, Harvard educated, but more liberal than the rest of thehis family.
This story could have happened in any city of America at the time and even now. Often revealing how the United States despite what it stands for was very unwelcoming to immigrants-whether Irish or Jewish, white, or African American, Vietnamese, Pakistani etc..
The author’s comments at end are very prescient. Thank You to Net Galley for providing this most enjoyable read for a fair and caring review.
Profile Image for Monica Hills.
1,069 reviews35 followers
August 22, 2023
The Rumor Game is set in Boston during WWII and explores what was going on with Americans as many were divided about the U.S. becoming involved with the war. This novel is told from two different points of view. One is that of an FBI agent and the other of an idealistic young journalist who wants to stop the antisemitic and other hateful rumors targeting marginalized groups. The story revolved around Anne and Devon trying to discover what was really going on in Boston as pamphlets and then ultimately a murder begins to show some serious crime is happening and the local cops are doing nothing about it.

This book had some good moments but ultimately wasn't for me. I did like Anne, who was a strong female character but Devon, the FBI agent was a little off putting to me. I wanted more connection between these two characters. This book was well written and did move along but it felt like more of a true crime novel than a thriller. The author did include an author's note which told what events were true and what was not. I always appreciate this in a historical fiction book. Overall not a bad book but for those who love crime novels.

Thank you to St. Martin's Publishing Group for this ARC.
Profile Image for Debbie.
383 reviews86 followers
February 9, 2024
Set in Boston, right after the bombing of Pearl Harbor and when the U.S. enters WWII, this dark historical fiction mystery highlights a time in our country of isolationists and warmongers. There is fighting between groups of Fascists and Communists, and everyone is out to further their own agenda. The mob wants control over the docks, the factories, and the unions. Union members are threatened and beat up for voting the wrong way, while the local police turn a blind eye to mob activities.

Anne, a plucky journalist with a tenacious attitude writes a column called the Rumor Clinic for a local paper in Boston. She hunts down and reports on the truth of rumors, propaganda, and injustice. While tracking down these rumors Anne runs across gangsters, dirty cops, shifty businesses, and devious plots.

Devon is the local lothario and a Special Agent with the FBI. He is investigating the murder of a factory worker and reports of Irish boys attacking old men, women, girls, and other young boys. During his inquiries he comes across crates of guns that are missing from a munitions factory and much more. Discouraged by the police, Devon must take some deadly risks to find answers.

Anne and Devon grew up in the same neighborhood and when they are reunited they form a mutual attraction and work together to solve the mystery of unexplained events occurring around them, with hopes of not arousing too much curiosity or negative attention.

This is a story filled with hate, prejudice, and bigotry, and the fight to report and overcome human evil. The context of the storyline felt shadowy and sinister. However, even though it was interesting at times and well written, I wasn't drawn in and the narrative did not hold my concentration or interest. Hopefully, this novel will appeal to other readers more.

My sincere thanks to NetGalley and St. Martin's Press/Minotaur Books for giving me the opportunity to read a digital ARC of this novel. All opinions expressed are my own.

Profile Image for Elizabeth McFarland .
446 reviews53 followers
March 22, 2024
This was an enjoyable and well written historical mystery set in Boston during WWII. The story centers around Anna, a journalist working to disprove rumors and Nazi propaganda, and Devon, an FBI agent investigating a murder.

The setting and time period were very well written and made me feel like I was really there. It was like having a snapshot of 1940s America. I liked reading about what life would have been like for the people not actively serving during the war in this country. It's a perspective I don't often come across in books. Thomas Mullins does an excellent job bringing the American atmosphere of the time to life.

Anna is a strong-willed character that was easy to root for, and Devon, while not as serious, was equally likable. The mystery itself was gripping and kept me interested all the way through.

I received a complimentary copy of this book. Opinions expressed in this review are my own.
Profile Image for Staci.
2,021 reviews599 followers
February 16, 2024
Early 1940s Boston

Lots of historical detail in this novel about WWII, racial tension and corruption stateside. The mystery kept my interest and had many twists and turns. FBI Agent Devon Mulvey and reporter Anne Lemire worked to uncover the truth. Both were willing to take risks to do the right thing. While I didn't love either main character, I had a lot of respect for how they handled their chosen vocations.

Great job by the narrator (Megan Tusing).

Some foul language and sexual content.

My gratitude to publisher Macmillan Audio for a complimentary NetGalley copy of this audiobook. I was not required to post a review and all opinions expressed are my own.
Profile Image for Carole Barker.
345 reviews20 followers
February 27, 2024
Anti-semitism and isolationist groups are causing major problems in WWII era Boston in this intriguing thriller.

Anne Lemire is a college-educated, forward thinking young woman working for a Boston newspaper. She has managed to carve out a niche for herself, rising above the usual “women’s interest” topics to write a column called the Rumor Clinic. In it, she chases down war-related rumors that seem silly or downright harmful to disprove them. She has just exposed a story that WAACs are getting pregnant and receiving abortions at a military training area down in Georgia….turns out that a disgruntled would-be suitor was just making up a nasty story to get back at the girl who didn’t return his affections, but had Anne not nipped that rumor in the bud, many families might have been reluctant to let their daughters join the war effort. While she’s pleased that she straightened that out, she knows that she is capable of more meaningful work. One story that is not being taken seriously by either the press or the police is the recent rash of attacks against Jewish people in her neighborhood. Anne herself, though raised to believe she was Catholic, had discovered upon her father’s death that she was, in fact, Jewish. Her family at that time was treated unfairly by their neighbors and ended up moving, so she is quite aware of the negative view that many hold of Jewish people. When her younger brother is attacked for a second time, Anne feels she has no choice but to investigate. Her path will soon cross that of Devon Mulvey, a Special Agent with the FBI who has been tasked with keeping an eye on defense contractors in the area to prevent sabotage and espionage, as well as monitoring priests at local area churches who may hold anti-war views. The former task is not much of a challenge for Mulvey, but the latter makes him a bit uncomfortable. He and his family are Catholic, so spying on priests (some of whom he has known as a parishioner) is pulling at his loyalties. He is one of the few Catholics hired by the FBI, whose college-educated recruits have historically been Protestant, and is aware that many of his co-workers don’t entirely trust him because of his background. The local police, whose ranks include a great many Irish Catholics like Mulvey and in fact have more than a few of his relatives in their ranks, don’t think much of Mulvey for eschewing the police force in favor of the FBI. Like Anne, though for different reasons, Mulvey has a foot in two camps but is accepted by neither. Mulvey avoided being drafted for the war because of his job and is looked down on by many in his circle for not “doing his duty”…and feels guilty about it himself. The fact that he finds himself bedding more than a few women whose husbands are away fighting just adds to his self recrimination. When a Jewish man who worked at a munitions factory is found dead, Anne and Mulvey, who knew one another in their early years, meet and find that their investigations coincide. They also become immersed in possible saboteurs, organized crime and local fascists….any of whom could be involved in the factory worker’s death, and all of whom want to stop them from continuing their investigations. By any means necessary.
I found The Rumor Game to be an excellent read on two levels, both as a mystery and as a historical novel. As someone with roots in the Boston area and its Irish Catholic community, I was readily drawn into the locale portrayed here. It is a city whose problems with race relations have long been known, and in this novel those issues are much at play. The two main characters of Anne and Mulvey are interesting in their complexity, their education setting them apart from many in their own families and communities, and both also are atypical for their gender in some of their choices. Anne is not married and working a career not generally thought of as appropriate for women, while Mulvey has not enlisted in the military despite having no physical impediments. Mulvey’s family has members who do not accept Jewish people as equals and are emphatically against the US entering the war in Europe, and both of those positions run counter to Mulvey’s job. Of the two, I thought the character of Anne was more thoroughly portrayed, but as a pair they were well matched. Neither fully trusted the other, but felt a mutual attraction nonetheless. The mystery of who killed the factory worker and who is behind the attacks against members of Anne’s community is well-paced and presents a variety of possible villains and motives for the crimes. Some unexpected twists and moral ambiguities are sprinkled throughout, and I had fun trying to guess the conclusion. Readers of Mr. Mullen’s previous works will likely enjoy this outing, as might readers of Dennis Lehane, Nelson DeMille and Joseph Kanon. Many thanks to NetGalley and St. Martin’s Press/Minotaur Books for allowing me access to an advanced reader’s copy of The Rumor Game in exchange for my honest review.
Profile Image for Marcia reading past dark.
196 reviews215 followers
February 26, 2024
The Rumor Game, by Thomas Mullen, set in Boston in 1942, is an exciting murder mystery within a historical fiction novel. The main characters are strong and their roles and descriptions are well written. Devon Mulvey, an Irishman, is a hard-nosed FBI agent called in to investigate anti-war crimes. His sideline is chasing skirts. Anne Lemire is a young reporter, whose newspaper column “The Rumor Clinic,” investigates high interest rumors circulating in the city.

This story covers a number social issues of the era: Growing mob activity, antisemitism, abortion, the role of women, and troubles within the Catholic church, all of which were rampant in Boston at the time. This is an action-packed and fast moving read.
Profile Image for Monica.
5 reviews1 follower
March 28, 2024
Thank you to GoodReads for an advanced copy of The Rumor Game by Thomas Mullen. I was honoured to receive it.

I thoroughly enjoyed this book. It was a well written crime thriller.

The author has delicately opened my eyes to a new level of racial hatred.

At the beginning, he introduced us to two main characters, an intelligent female and a flawed, but likeable male.

The Rumor Game was engaging, fast paced and provided several twists throughout the book, however the ending left things unresolved between the two main characters, Anne and Devon.
A sequel would definitely solve this! I encourage Thomas Mullen to write one and I look forward to reading it when he does!
Profile Image for Jackie.
137 reviews45 followers
February 17, 2024
Thank you to publisher Minotaur Books for providing me with an ARC via NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.

In 1942 Boston, World War II has left its mark. Most of the men are off fighting, rationing is in full swing, and as the war rages on, anti-Semitism at home rages with it. Due to his job with the FBI, Agent Devon Mulvey hasn't been sent off to fight, instead remaining at home surrounded by his large Irish Catholic family. It was always Devon's father's ambition to see his son join the FBI, but despite all that, Devon still doesn't seem quite fulfilled.

Anne Lemire isn't feeling very fulfilled herself. One of the few female reporters for the Star, she writes a column called The Rumor Clinic, dispelling wartime misinformation. However, while Anne wants to explore the nasty anti-Semitic rumors that are swirling, her male boss would much prefer if she wrote silly fluff pieces - so, she'll just have to write her own stories behind his back, if she really wants to get the truth out there.

When Devon and his partner are called to investigate the murder of a Jewish factory worker, they discover that the dead man has a drawing of a swastika in his pocket, hinting he may have been targeted due to his religion. Devon's investigation leads him to Anne, his old childhood acquaintance, and the story she's been investigating about anti-Jewish propaganda. Realizing there may be a link between their investigations, the two of them work together to find out the truth. The truth, however, just might come at a grave personal cost...

I found this World War II thriller to be very well-researched, without being too info-dumpy, and it tackled a lot of themes that are - sadly - still incredibly relevant to modern society. There is an author's note at the end explaining some of Thomas Mullen's inspiration for the work.

I liked Anne as a main character, and though she was - like many good intrepid mystery-thriller heroines - a bit reckless at times, I admired her determination, courage, and commitment to truth. As for Devon, I did not get on with him quite as much. In his very first scene, we learn that Devon is...let's say, a bit of a Lothario, and though he does question some of his life choices later on in the narrative, I got off on the wrong foot with him. I just couldn't get over how icky some of his internal monologue made me feel at the beginning.

I did think there were some good reveals and twists in this book, and if the premise sounds interesting to you, I would encourage you to read it. My 3-star rating is due both to not getting on with one of the main characters, as I mentioned, and my entirely subjective reading preferences.
Profile Image for Judy Collins.
2,976 reviews430 followers
February 19, 2024
Master storyteller Thomas Mullen returns following Blind Spots and his Darktown trilogy (loved)— Darktown, Lightning Men, and Midnight Atlanta with his latest,THE RUMOR GAME— A riveting crime novel set in Boston during WWII—A perfect blending of crime, mystery, and American history.

Some of Mullen's previous books are set in Atlanta, where he currently resides, tackling racial injustices. THE RUMOR GAME is set in Boston, where he has family roots, with another riveting novel based on several pro-Nazi, anti-Semitic organizations that existed in the US after the country entered WWII.

Many members were arrested in 1940 by the FBI for hoarding weapons (some stolen from the National Guard Armory) and plotting to assassinate Jewish politicians. (Facist and Communist groups). Also, the distribution of anti-Semitic hate sheets contributes to hostile and violent environments.

The novel features and alternates between two main characters: Anne and Devon.

Anne Lemire, Jewish and raised Catholic, is an anti-fascist activist and reporter who writes for the Rumor Clinic but is tired of writing unimportant stories and wants to dig deeper into more in-depth topics. Her job currently is chasing down harmful war rumors.

She learned over the years through her reporting that there were different kinds of mistruths. Some are born of ignorance and lack of understanding of the world. Some were harmless, more mistakes than lies, until they were repeated often enough to convince a critical mass of people, in which case they became dangerous. Some lies were well-camouflaged, and some were obvious. The good news for her was that with each falsehood, there was the reward of chasing down and disproving. She loved her job.

Agent Devon Mulvey, Catholic, a handsome, philandering FBI agent who is quite the charmer and sleeps with married women whose husbands are at war. (he thinks confessing will make it ok). He is a bit of an outcast. He is to prevent industrial sabotage and spy on clerics with suspect loyalties. He is investigating a case of stolen munitions that ended in murder.

Anne's teenage brother, Sammy, is beaten up by an Irish gang targeting the city's Jews, and the national security concerns surrounding the fatal stabbing of Abraham Wolff, an employee of Northeast Munitions, bring Devon onto the case along with the Boston Police Department.

Devon finds himself at odds with the whole BPD, including his cousin, another officer.

The two intersect with the joint cases. They have known one another from childhood and are not sure they can trust one another, but they wind up in a romance complicated by their family involvements.

From Nazi flyers to counterfeit rations stamps, hoarding/stealing weapons, and corruption.

THE RUMOR GAME is meticulously researched, and the novel gives off a noir vibe with the time era and the smashing front cover, which draws you in. I loved Anne's character - tenacious and resourceful.

Masterfully written, the novel covers highly charged topics of prejudice, hatred, violence, and murder. The author has done his homework as usual with an extensive Author's Note, the inspiration behind the novel, and essential resources for further reading—an ideal book club pick.

This is the 6th book I have read by the author, and I thoroughly enjoy his writing and tackling important controversial topics of our history and how they collide with our present day. I highly recommend the author and all his books!

Mullen's inspiration (for Harold & Anne's project) ignited from a story from Arnold Beichman, 1943 "Christian Front Hoodlums Terrorize Boston Jews" in NY's PM Magazine.

He mentions some aspects of Anne's character were inspired by the Journalist Frances Sweeney, an Irish American writer who dedicated her life to exposing Fascists both before and during the war and who wrote a short-lived column debunking war rumors for the Boston Herald —until it was shut down via pressure from the Office of War Information which claimed the column did more harm than good. These stories and more will have you going down a rabbit hole to learn more!

AUDIOBOOK: I was fortunate to read the e-book and listen to the audiobook narrated by the talented and favorite Megan Tusing for an outstanding performance and listening experience. She made the characters come alive with emotion and suspense.

Thank you, St. Martins's Press, Minotaur Books, Macmillan Audio, and NetGalley, for a gifted ARC and ALC for an honest opinion. #SMPInfluencers #CoverCrush

Blog review posted @
JudithDCollins.com
@JudithDCollins | #JDCMustReadBooks
Pub Date: Feb 27, 2024
My Rating: 5 Stars
Feb 2024 Must-Read Books
Feb Newsletter
Profile Image for Annarella.
13.6k reviews150 followers
March 3, 2024
An excellent historical thriller that kept me on the edge and turning pages. Well researched, vivid historical backgrouns, solid plot, fleshed out characters
A fast paced and action packed story I recommend.
Recommended.
Many thanks to the publisher for this ARC, all opinions are mine
Profile Image for Bridget Dean.
17 reviews
February 13, 2024
This was an interesting tale of murder and mystery. I enjoyed the story, but I feel that those who are offended easily should beware this is full of racial epithets and racist slang for many different people groups. It was very cringey at points because of the words. I understand that this is how people spoke in years past, and the author was trying to be historically accurate, but it was a tad jarring at times and slightly detracted from what was a good story overall. Thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for the advanced screening copy!
Profile Image for Sarah Lord.
59 reviews16 followers
February 3, 2024
WWII historical fiction with a mystery element.

Dual POV - one side being told from a journalist who disproves rumors going around (some silly, minor issues and some big issues about war/community crime). The other side is told by an FBI agent who gets finds himself in several sticky situations in his family life, relationships, and work life.

There’s several mysteries in this book that keep you interested in the story, however I would say it is a slower paced read.

I did really enjoy the story line and how well it depicted various aspects of how the war effected communities and families.

If you enjoy historical fiction, I think this would definitely be up your alley.

Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for an advanced copy in exchange for an honest review!
August 14, 2023
Thomas Mullen delivers a riveting and atmospheric historical crime thriller with "The Rumor Game." Set against the backdrop of World War II-era Boston, this novel masterfully captures the tension and unease of a city divided by wartime suspicions and fascist elements. With compelling characters, intricate plotting, and a richly detailed historical setting, Mullen crafts a story that keeps readers on the edge of their seats from beginning to end.

In June 1943, as the war rages on, reporter Anne Lemire finds herself at the heart of a web of rumors, misinformation, and fear that grips the city. Writing the Rumor Clinic column, Anne works tirelessly to debunk harmful rumors circulating in the community—some spawned by Axis forces, others by mere gossip and ignorance. However, Anne's hunger for a more significant story pushes her to uncover the truth behind Nazi propaganda disseminated by local businesses, leading her to a dangerous path of espionage and conspiracy.

Special Agent Devon Mulvey of the FBI, a devout Catholic navigating his own complexities, is tasked with preventing wartime sabotage and investigating suspicious activities. When Anne's investigation into Nazi propaganda intersects with Devon's probe into the death of an immigrant factory worker, the two are drawn into a web of organized crime, domestic fascism, and espionage. As they navigate this treacherous landscape, their personal histories become intertwined, and the boundaries between friend and foe blur.

Mullen's meticulous attention to historical detail immerses readers in the wartime atmosphere of Boston, creating a palpable sense of time and place. The characters, from the determined and sharp-witted Anne to the complex and conflicted Devon, come alive on the pages, their struggles and motivations driving the narrative forward.

"The Rumor Game" masterfully weaves a narrative that explores the intersections of fear, loyalty, and deception. Mullen skillfully navigates the complex threads of espionage and intrigue, leading to revelations that challenge the characters' perceptions and reveal deeper layers of conspiracy. The novel's pacing is relentless, propelling readers through a maze of twists and turns that culminate in a thrilling and satisfying conclusion.

In "The Rumor Game," Thomas Mullen delivers an engrossing historical crime thriller that captures the essence of a city in turmoil and the individuals determined to uncover the truth, no matter the cost. With its gripping narrative, multidimensional characters, and evocative historical backdrop, this novel is a must-read for fans of historical fiction, espionage, and suspenseful storytelling.
Profile Image for Debra.
291 reviews1 follower
December 17, 2023
Thank you to Minotaur for my advanced electronic copy via NetGalley.

During World War II, reporter Anne Lemire does her bit for the war effort by tracking down harmful rumors and disproving them in her Boston newspaper column. While she sees the value in disproving rumors that could damage morale on the home front, she keeps angling to write about something bigger that will help bring down the fascist elements at home as well as abroad. So when her story about Nazi propaganda brings her in league with Special Agent Devon Mulvey of the FBI who is investigating a murder case, she finally gets her chance. The trail they follow involves espionage, domestic infighting between cultural groups, and the mob, and even pulls in secrets they would rather stayed hidden.

From the first line I was sucked into this hard-boiled, honest look at World War II-era Boston and its different ethnic groups and hard underbelly. The prejudice, hate, fear that fuel disinformation from the powerful and powerless alike are eerily similar to today. These are fully human protagonists who are operating in a very real world of intrigue and grit, and of hopes and dreams and heroism. I was highly invested in both Ann and Devon's stories, aching to see if they would solve anything and if life would get better. In the end I found it to be thought-provoking and evoking of just the right atmosphere to deliver a powerful message.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 250 reviews

Can't find what you're looking for?

Get help and learn more about the design.