What do you think?
Rate this book
Scrum: The Art of Doing Twice the Work in Half the Time
In the future, historians may look back on human progress and draw a sharp line designating “before Scrum” and “after Scrum.” Scrum is that ground-breaking. It already drives most of the world’s top technology companies. And now it’s starting to spread to every domain where leaders wrestle with complex projects.
If you’ve ever been startled by how fast the world is changing, Scrum is one of the reasons why. Productivity gains of as much as 1200% have been recorded, and there’s no more lucid – or compelling – explainer of Scrum and its bright promise than Jeff Sutherland, the man who put together the first Scrum team more than twenty years ago.
The thorny problem Jeff began tackling back then boils down to this: people are spectacularly bad at doing things with agility and efficiency. Best laid plans go up in smoke. Teams often work at cross purposes to each other. And when the pressure rises, unhappiness soars. Drawing on his experience as a West Point-educated fighter pilot, biometrics expert, early innovator of ATM technology, and V.P. of engineering or CTO at eleven different technology companies, Jeff began challenging those dysfunctional realities, looking for solutions that would have global impact.
In this book you’ll journey to Scrum’s front lines where Jeff’s system of deep accountability, team interaction, and constant iterative improvement is, among other feats, bringing the FBI into the 21st century, perfecting the design of an affordable 140 mile per hour/100 mile per gallon car, helping NPR report fast-moving action in the Middle East, changing the way pharmacists interact with patients, reducing poverty in the Third World, and even helping people plan their weddings and accomplish weekend chores.
Woven with insights from martial arts, judicial decision making, advanced aerial combat, robotics, and many other disciplines, Scrum is consistently riveting. But the most important reason to read this book is that it may just help you achieve what others consider unachievable – whether it be inventing a trailblazing technology, devising a new system of education, pioneering a way to feed the hungry, or, closer to home, a building a foundation for your family to thrive and prosper.
If you’ve ever been startled by how fast the world is changing, Scrum is one of the reasons why. Productivity gains of as much as 1200% have been recorded, and there’s no more lucid – or compelling – explainer of Scrum and its bright promise than Jeff Sutherland, the man who put together the first Scrum team more than twenty years ago.
The thorny problem Jeff began tackling back then boils down to this: people are spectacularly bad at doing things with agility and efficiency. Best laid plans go up in smoke. Teams often work at cross purposes to each other. And when the pressure rises, unhappiness soars. Drawing on his experience as a West Point-educated fighter pilot, biometrics expert, early innovator of ATM technology, and V.P. of engineering or CTO at eleven different technology companies, Jeff began challenging those dysfunctional realities, looking for solutions that would have global impact.
In this book you’ll journey to Scrum’s front lines where Jeff’s system of deep accountability, team interaction, and constant iterative improvement is, among other feats, bringing the FBI into the 21st century, perfecting the design of an affordable 140 mile per hour/100 mile per gallon car, helping NPR report fast-moving action in the Middle East, changing the way pharmacists interact with patients, reducing poverty in the Third World, and even helping people plan their weddings and accomplish weekend chores.
Woven with insights from martial arts, judicial decision making, advanced aerial combat, robotics, and many other disciplines, Scrum is consistently riveting. But the most important reason to read this book is that it may just help you achieve what others consider unachievable – whether it be inventing a trailblazing technology, devising a new system of education, pioneering a way to feed the hungry, or, closer to home, a building a foundation for your family to thrive and prosper.
237 pages, Hardcover
First published January 1, 2014
About the author
Jeff Sutherland
27 books442 followersSutherland is a Graduate of the United States Military Academy, a Top Gun of his USAF RF-4C Aircraft Commander class[citation needed]. He flew more than one hundred missions over North Vietnam[citation needed]. After 11 years in the military, he became a doctor at the University of Colorado School of Medicine[citation needed]. Here he got involved in data collection and IT systems development.
Dr. Jeff Sutherland is one of the inventors of the Scrum software development process. Together with Ken Schwaber, he created Scrum as a formal process at OOPSLA'95. Sutherland helped to write the Agile Manifesto in 2001. He is the writer of The Scrum Guide.
by https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jeff_Su...
It's professional profile on LinkedIn is :
linkedin.com/in/jeffsutherland
Dr. Jeff Sutherland is one of the inventors of the Scrum software development process. Together with Ken Schwaber, he created Scrum as a formal process at OOPSLA'95. Sutherland helped to write the Agile Manifesto in 2001. He is the writer of The Scrum Guide.
by https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jeff_Su...
It's professional profile on LinkedIn is :
linkedin.com/in/jeffsutherland
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 1,922 reviews
January 21, 2018
Once I got over the extremely self-aggrandizing tone of the author, I found some of the points quite useful. Basically this is a way of operationalizing the 80/20 rule. Here are the things I took away from it:
1. Good team size. 4-6 is optimal, 20 is way too many.
2. Multitasking is a myth - people who think they’re good at it, actually are the worst. The truth is people are serial processing, not parallel, and it takes the brain longer to switch gears so all you’re doing is slowing yourself down.
3. Prioritize based on how much the action will affect your goal (whether that goal is $ or something else)
4. Don’t be a D*ck: Managers need to have zero tolerance for incivility, disrespect, or abuse in the workplace – it actually sucks energy and makes everyone ineffective
5. Don’t waste your time looking for Evil People, look instead for Evil Systems
6. Construct your to do list as follows: To Do, Doing and Done
7. Don’t create Master Plans. Create Micro plans which you can do in time-limited sprints and then iterate.
Things I found a bit weird
- Given that what we’re essentially talking about are “human systems” and anything human, by definition, is messy and non-standard, I find it hard to believe that this method applies to EVERY BUSINESS EVER. This is what the author seems to suggest (and modestly, he also suggests that if it didn’t work for a business they weren’t doing it right). Hmmm…
- The author also fails to mention any examples of where scrum failed even when applied “properly” – I would have liked a few real world examples to have been less “awesome” and go through what the iteration and tweaking process looks like while a company or organization is veering off the path
- The author also fails to talk about the negative aspects of scrum – destabilizing to have plans change so often, difficult to redeploy assets to the right place. It would have made for a much more fair read to get the negative along with the positive so that leaders can make a fully informed decision when they choose to adopt scrum.
1. Good team size. 4-6 is optimal, 20 is way too many.
2. Multitasking is a myth - people who think they’re good at it, actually are the worst. The truth is people are serial processing, not parallel, and it takes the brain longer to switch gears so all you’re doing is slowing yourself down.
3. Prioritize based on how much the action will affect your goal (whether that goal is $ or something else)
4. Don’t be a D*ck: Managers need to have zero tolerance for incivility, disrespect, or abuse in the workplace – it actually sucks energy and makes everyone ineffective
5. Don’t waste your time looking for Evil People, look instead for Evil Systems
6. Construct your to do list as follows: To Do, Doing and Done
7. Don’t create Master Plans. Create Micro plans which you can do in time-limited sprints and then iterate.
Things I found a bit weird
- Given that what we’re essentially talking about are “human systems” and anything human, by definition, is messy and non-standard, I find it hard to believe that this method applies to EVERY BUSINESS EVER. This is what the author seems to suggest (and modestly, he also suggests that if it didn’t work for a business they weren’t doing it right). Hmmm…
- The author also fails to mention any examples of where scrum failed even when applied “properly” – I would have liked a few real world examples to have been less “awesome” and go through what the iteration and tweaking process looks like while a company or organization is veering off the path
- The author also fails to talk about the negative aspects of scrum – destabilizing to have plans change so often, difficult to redeploy assets to the right place. It would have made for a much more fair read to get the negative along with the positive so that leaders can make a fully informed decision when they choose to adopt scrum.
April 1, 2015
I was trying to decide what to give this book as a rating. It wasn't what I was hoping for. I really don't want to hear how smart the creator is or how much better what he is doing is compared to other methodologies - what I want to hear is the nuts and bolts of how to make this idea work and what separates it from the rest of the herd. Frankly, nothing presented showed me any of what I was looking for. So it was going to be either a 3 (more or less neutral) or just pass by not giving any rating at all. Until... the first review I see is a five - by the author. Now THAT made an impression on me. Note how I mentioned how smart the creator of scrum is trying to convince me he is? I am unimpressed by his creation at least as presented in this book (everything he is using can be found elsewhere - there is nothing new under the sun apparently), and then I am a bit put off by his hubris. I can only hope that a 1 can help the author find some humility because he seems to need some. And the rest of you passing out the free 5's... wow.
June 23, 2014
After Ken Schwaber and I wrote "Software in 30 Days" I felt we didn't have enough stories about Scrum outside of software development. This book is for the general business reader in any domain. It also tells the personal story of how my 11 years as a fighter pilot and another 11 years as a medical school professor affected the development of Scrum and the writing of the Agile Manifesto.
January 5, 2015
If you are interested in the historical context of scrum and want to read "around and about" it, this looks like a good book for you. But if you want to learn scrum this is not the book for you.
November 7, 2021
No heroics. If you need a hero to get things done, you have a problem. Heroic effort should be viewed as a failure of planning.
While this is a good (and entertaining) book, I’m not quite sure who to recommend it to. I got this as study material after I had booked a Scrum course. But it was actually more a companion book. Our coach told us on the first day that we don’t need to read it to bolster our chances of passing the assessment. I would go a little further and recommend not to read it shortly before the assessment because it occasionally contains contradictory information to the current Scrum Guide. But that’s not a knock on the book. It has been published in 2014, and Scrum, being so much about adapting, has itself adapted since then.
Is this book outdated then? No, not at all. You see, this isn’t a textbook. It is a firsthand account of how Scrum came to be. Or more precisely, about the ideas and the philosophy behind Scrum and how they drove the development of it. It is told by one of its inventors, using real life examples of when and how Scrum helped to get projects over the line. A broad range of them, from the FBI’s work on a program that was supposed to prevent another 9/11 to a friend of the author using Scrum to organize his wedding.
Sutherland tells the story of his baby in an entertaining, often funny, and sometimes a little self-congratulatory voice. He clearly doesn’t think much of traditional project management and makes his contempt for Waterfall known at various points in the book. He’s a captivating storyteller, though.
On the first day of the course our coach asked us why we were here. I said something like, “You know, I’ve been working on a couple of projects and they turned out fine, but I don’t really know what I’m doing. It’s time I start filling my toolbox.” He started laughing. “Dennis, to that I can only tell you this: Forget about the tools. This is the course of common sense.”
And this is where this book wildly succeeds. There are many moments where you think, Of course. Why are we not doing this? It’s so much easier that way.
So, who to recommend this to? I can’t answer that. I will answer the “when”, though. Read this before you start your Scrum course. I promise, it will make you excited about the whole thing.
And remember, it’s not just in business that time is important. Time makes up your life, so wasting it is actually a slow form of suicide.
March 27, 2015
Although there are kernels of wisdom and good advice on how to be productive, I found it difficult and tedious to wade through the author's biographical background and the data supporting his theory. This would have made a really good magazine article; a book wasn't necessary.
July 13, 2014
I had high expectations for this book, but it left me feeling kinda blah about it.
Maybe I have business self-help book overload, I just wasn't blown away by this.
The majority of the book got skimmed as I wasn't sucked into reading each word and looking for the gold nuggets, the magic bullet.
Maybe I have business self-help book overload, I just wasn't blown away by this.
The majority of the book got skimmed as I wasn't sucked into reading each word and looking for the gold nuggets, the magic bullet.
November 7, 2019
This is the original book on Scrum-way of project management.
It was amazing.
All the components of the scrum framework are deeply rooted in well-established productivity principles e.g. feedback loop, focusing on one thing, the one thing has to bring the most value, accountability, etc.
It was amazing.
All the components of the scrum framework are deeply rooted in well-established productivity principles e.g. feedback loop, focusing on one thing, the one thing has to bring the most value, accountability, etc.
January 15, 2015
The book is basic for someone who already studies and practices Agile Methodologies for a long time. But the book deserves five stars because goes on the Why of Scrum, Why Scrum works and how it is adapted to the new realities of work in the 21st century.
Some of the interesting topics: The origins of Scrum, Team principles, Waste management, The importance of priorities and time management and how this fits with 'estimation' and how to begin implementing Scrum in your team or org.
So it's strongly recommended to beginner and intermediate users of Scrum. The book already have a Portuguese translation.
Some of the interesting topics: The origins of Scrum, Team principles, Waste management, The importance of priorities and time management and how this fits with 'estimation' and how to begin implementing Scrum in your team or org.
So it's strongly recommended to beginner and intermediate users of Scrum. The book already have a Portuguese translation.
April 10, 2017
Я вирішив прочитати цю книгу, щоб точно розібратися в методології, по якій вже кілька років працюю. До того усі знання були часткові і не цілісні.
Книга написана людиною, яка створила дану методологію, вона базується на японській філософії «кайдзен». Речі які я виніс цікаві для себе:
- в спрінт не докидаються таски коли він вже почався
- скрам команда в більшості саморганізована, продакт-оунер грає роль більше напряляючу
- метологія розкриває себе в малих командах, в які працюють люди які розуміють, що в співпраці їхня сила
- власне одна із задач скраму посилити співпрацю
- виявляється основна задача скрам-мастера — забирати перешкоди в роботі команди, робити так, щоб команда працювала ефективно, без простоїв
- ретроспективи мають не меті робити людей щасливими, а не поливати один одного гівном(!)
- скрам-методологію можна успішно використовувати, як в НГО так і навчанні
Книга написана людиною, яка створила дану методологію, вона базується на японській філософії «кайдзен». Речі які я виніс цікаві для себе:
- в спрінт не докидаються таски коли він вже почався
- скрам команда в більшості саморганізована, продакт-оунер грає роль більше напряляючу
- метологія розкриває себе в малих командах, в які працюють люди які розуміють, що в співпраці їхня сила
- власне одна із задач скраму посилити співпрацю
- виявляється основна задача скрам-мастера — забирати перешкоди в роботі команди, робити так, щоб команда працювала ефективно, без простоїв
- ретроспективи мають не меті робити людей щасливими, а не поливати один одного гівном(!)
- скрам-методологію можна успішно використовувати, як в НГО так і навчанні
October 15, 2014
This isn't a guide to Scrum per-se. Which is probably good, since there are lots of guides to scrum at the practices at varying levels of details. What this book does is talk help you understand the value of scrum through stories. There is an appendix of scrum practices at the end. The book is full of war stories (both literally and figuratively), and Sutherland is clearly proud of how he, his family, and organizations he has worked with, have applied scrum. Reading this book will help energize you to use Scrum to help your team succeed. This is not the only book on Scum you need. But if you want motivation to explore more about Scrum, or if you have been practicing Scrum for a while and are looking for inspiration, give this book a read.
January 18, 2022
"it's so bad i want to give you a zero. but i can't so i give you... a one."
was it that i didn't meet a named woman until page 153ish of a 230 page book? maybe.
was it that it a repeated refrain was "find the smartest guy in the room" (as though the word "people" is not available to you?) possible!
was it the fact that certain roles were always referred to as male roles! could be!
but probably most of all, it was that i walked away knowing a lot about Jeff Sutherland and his passions and work experience, and left with only one, maybe two takeaways for my real life job.
BAH.
was it that i didn't meet a named woman until page 153ish of a 230 page book? maybe.
was it that it a repeated refrain was "find the smartest guy in the room" (as though the word "people" is not available to you?) possible!
was it the fact that certain roles were always referred to as male roles! could be!
but probably most of all, it was that i walked away knowing a lot about Jeff Sutherland and his passions and work experience, and left with only one, maybe two takeaways for my real life job.
BAH.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
October 7, 2017
This is one of the worst book I've read lately. It is packed full of my personal most hated characteristic: self-righteousness. It is also poorly translated, and it presents the Scrum as the best thing that happened since the decalog... I hate this narration, and I am sick of reading how Jeff single handedly invented Scrum, MVP and probably entire IT industry. Seriously, I can't recall any occurrence of Ken Schwaber in the entire book. Seriously, after reading this book I would be convinced that he invented it all by himself (IT industry included).
I have been a Scrum Master for 5 years now, and when I see a book that presents the Scrum not only as THE silver bullet, but also as the one and only truth (bow down blasphemers!) I want to put this bullet into my own head. Did I also mentioned the poor translations already? One more "zespół wskroś funkcjonalny" and I will throw up my last month's breakfast. There was even wrong form of Alfred Nobel's name ("z Nagrody Nobela").
Ok, emotions aside - there are three reasons why this book is rated by me as two stars (barely), and not one:
- I save one star for the books I am not able to finish (it was a close miss)
- This book mentioned eduScrum
- If you have absolutely no idea at all, what Scrum is, you may try it
Otherwise I recommend that you stay away and do something more productive instead. Count the grains of salt in your kitchen, check how long you can run in circles, or check how many times Gandalf nods his head in the Gandalf Europop Nod video on famous video portal.
I have been a Scrum Master for 5 years now, and when I see a book that presents the Scrum not only as THE silver bullet, but also as the one and only truth (bow down blasphemers!) I want to put this bullet into my own head. Did I also mentioned the poor translations already? One more "zespół wskroś funkcjonalny" and I will throw up my last month's breakfast. There was even wrong form of Alfred Nobel's name ("z Nagrody Nobela").
Ok, emotions aside - there are three reasons why this book is rated by me as two stars (barely), and not one:
- I save one star for the books I am not able to finish (it was a close miss)
- This book mentioned eduScrum
- If you have absolutely no idea at all, what Scrum is, you may try it
Otherwise I recommend that you stay away and do something more productive instead. Count the grains of salt in your kitchen, check how long you can run in circles, or check how many times Gandalf nods his head in the Gandalf Europop Nod video on famous video portal.
December 27, 2021
While most of the principles of Scrum are definitely sensible, especially its emphasis on whole-project-capable teams working collaboratively in an egalitarian manner, encouragement of work-life balance, or planning of work based on actual performance, I could not stop feeling like this is a New Age white-collar Taylorism, engraving moralistic neoliberal social norms into the minds of common workers.
The book itself is pretty well written - for a popular "science" management book, with some cool stories and examples, although with a lot of simplistic orientalisation of management practices in Japan and martial arts (well, it is a product of the 90s) that are largely taken out of the context.
Sutherland is a very interesting person and Scum was created for software development, where it makes a lot of sense. But a lot of the premises it is based on -and the motivational language it veils them into - are painful to read. For a lot of people, work is just working and that is just okay - not everyone strives to change the world every day, especially if they go into a field where an emphasis on social value is really just self-deceit.
The discouragement of overtime and work-life balance sounds great (or one could see them as convenient for firms as they are trying to avoid having to pay for overtime), but the whole concept of Scrum is created to drain every single second of employee's energy for ticking a box that has been created to demonstrate activity. Sure, many or probably most of the teams will work on projects/tasks/'stories' that make sense and are substantive, but the whole concept of "velocity" turns a thinking and living organism into a high-performing cock within a machine.
On the other hand, the whole ideology of its short-termness and avoidance of multitasking discourages complex and exploratory thinking, developing skills within a team that do not fit into the immediate need for the next release at the end of the current sprint. When you aggregate this thinking and the whole 'lean' ideology, you get the present-day global economy, with its extreme fragility of supply chains, slow productivity growth, and lack of long-term investment. I definitely do not blame Scrum for it, but it is a clear symptom of a larger crisis we live in.
From my own experiences with scrum, the benefits it provides can outweigh its costs, if one manages to somehow avoid death by a thousand meetings.
The book itself is pretty well written - for a popular "science" management book, with some cool stories and examples, although with a lot of simplistic orientalisation of management practices in Japan and martial arts (well, it is a product of the 90s) that are largely taken out of the context.
Sutherland is a very interesting person and Scum was created for software development, where it makes a lot of sense. But a lot of the premises it is based on -and the motivational language it veils them into - are painful to read. For a lot of people, work is just working and that is just okay - not everyone strives to change the world every day, especially if they go into a field where an emphasis on social value is really just self-deceit.
The discouragement of overtime and work-life balance sounds great (or one could see them as convenient for firms as they are trying to avoid having to pay for overtime), but the whole concept of Scrum is created to drain every single second of employee's energy for ticking a box that has been created to demonstrate activity. Sure, many or probably most of the teams will work on projects/tasks/'stories' that make sense and are substantive, but the whole concept of "velocity" turns a thinking and living organism into a high-performing cock within a machine.
On the other hand, the whole ideology of its short-termness and avoidance of multitasking discourages complex and exploratory thinking, developing skills within a team that do not fit into the immediate need for the next release at the end of the current sprint. When you aggregate this thinking and the whole 'lean' ideology, you get the present-day global economy, with its extreme fragility of supply chains, slow productivity growth, and lack of long-term investment. I definitely do not blame Scrum for it, but it is a clear symptom of a larger crisis we live in.
From my own experiences with scrum, the benefits it provides can outweigh its costs, if one manages to somehow avoid death by a thousand meetings.
May 24, 2017
This is not a Scrum how-to book. Rather, the story of its making and its philosophy. The concepts are highly adaptable to not just software, business, but everyday life as well. He talks of how to increase productivity of teams by improving communication, eliminating waste, and continuous improvement. I especially liked the idea is that team happiness is the greatest predictor of success. I enjoyed the conversational style and the positive, inclusive attitude.
August 30, 2017
A must read for people and teams who cares about their productivity. Key takeaways for me:
1. Great teams are: transcendent (alignment with a higher purpose), cross-functional (have all skills to complete the project), autonomous (influence planning and decision-making process, freedom to decide "how" to deliver). Optimal size 7 (+-2)
2. Iterate fast. Plan => Do => Check => Act. Week or two for each iteration (Sprint). At the end of the iteration have some version of the product/feature that you can give to your customers to play with and interact.
3. Productivity:
Multitasking makes everybody slower. Half-done things create a lot of waste. Avoid to have a lot "in process tasks". Working too hard/long hours makes you less productive in a long run. Focus is a key (switching cost between projects is very high)
4. Scrum Process:
- don't plan a lot. Just have a vision (picture where you're heading)
- create a list of everything that needs to be done on the project. Prioritize it (start with highest value and the lowest effort tasks)
- create a plan to keep your team busy for the next iteration/Sprint (plan it together with team).
- visualize. have a board with: Priorities (Backlog/user stories), to do, doing, done columns.
- work is a Story: think who you're doing it for, what is it, why the need it.
- estimate tasks (stories) complexity relatively (not absolutely), groupdecide on that, track team's velocity and set ambitious goals;
- meet every day for 15 min at the same time to update a) what each member done yesterday and b) going to do today to successfully complete the Sprint, c) are there any obstacles?
- finish each Sprint with demo (involve stakeholders, customers)
- make a Sprint retrospective (what went right, what could have gone better, how to improve the process and make everybody happier during the next Sprint (kaizen))
- transparency in everything
1. Great teams are: transcendent (alignment with a higher purpose), cross-functional (have all skills to complete the project), autonomous (influence planning and decision-making process, freedom to decide "how" to deliver). Optimal size 7 (+-2)
2. Iterate fast. Plan => Do => Check => Act. Week or two for each iteration (Sprint). At the end of the iteration have some version of the product/feature that you can give to your customers to play with and interact.
3. Productivity:
Multitasking makes everybody slower. Half-done things create a lot of waste. Avoid to have a lot "in process tasks". Working too hard/long hours makes you less productive in a long run. Focus is a key (switching cost between projects is very high)
4. Scrum Process:
- don't plan a lot. Just have a vision (picture where you're heading)
- create a list of everything that needs to be done on the project. Prioritize it (start with highest value and the lowest effort tasks)
- create a plan to keep your team busy for the next iteration/Sprint (plan it together with team).
- visualize. have a board with: Priorities (Backlog/user stories), to do, doing, done columns.
- work is a Story: think who you're doing it for, what is it, why the need it.
- estimate tasks (stories) complexity relatively (not absolutely), groupdecide on that, track team's velocity and set ambitious goals;
- meet every day for 15 min at the same time to update a) what each member done yesterday and b) going to do today to successfully complete the Sprint, c) are there any obstacles?
- finish each Sprint with demo (involve stakeholders, customers)
- make a Sprint retrospective (what went right, what could have gone better, how to improve the process and make everybody happier during the next Sprint (kaizen))
- transparency in everything
May 15, 2023
This book was annoying, the author is the best human who has ever walked this planet, and everything he touches turns to gold. This was singing glory for his methods with weak pointers towards implementing Scrum.
I tolerated the book, but at one point, the author suggested that losing to the Lithuanian national team in basketball was a disgrace; I was done with it. Lithuanians are ranked in the top 10 teams in the world. Perhaps it's worth looking beyond America before dissing skilful sportspeople. And before you at me - no, I'm not Lithuanian. :D
Don't think that it's a useless book. It presents the background for how Scrum was introduced and gives some understanding and tips on the method; however, it isn't something you can use to implement in your company or daily life without looking up other books, research and articles.
I do have to say that this book made me question Scrum. The author was so obsessed with doing more, better, and quicker, but I felt like the team and people behind the work took a background role. Unfortunately, burnout, impact on mental health and turnover rates were not considered in this book, nor having an agile mindset before committing to Scrum - it would have been interesting to see these points from the author.
I tolerated the book, but at one point, the author suggested that losing to the Lithuanian national team in basketball was a disgrace; I was done with it. Lithuanians are ranked in the top 10 teams in the world. Perhaps it's worth looking beyond America before dissing skilful sportspeople. And before you at me - no, I'm not Lithuanian. :D
Don't think that it's a useless book. It presents the background for how Scrum was introduced and gives some understanding and tips on the method; however, it isn't something you can use to implement in your company or daily life without looking up other books, research and articles.
I do have to say that this book made me question Scrum. The author was so obsessed with doing more, better, and quicker, but I felt like the team and people behind the work took a background role. Unfortunately, burnout, impact on mental health and turnover rates were not considered in this book, nor having an agile mindset before committing to Scrum - it would have been interesting to see these points from the author.
March 6, 2016
Neat process, terrible book.
October 23, 2019
Essential.
January 6, 2020
Good management is good management. Cargo cult gibberish is cargo cult gibberish. And the intersection of the two is Scrum, a management philosophy that promises orders of magnitude improvements everywhere.
Some parts of scrum are obvious. Spend time doing things that are valuable to the customer. Delivery that value quickly and incrementally. Don't get bogged down in monumental efforts tied to thousands of pages of documentation that no one has actually read, or actually understands. The basic unit of action is a small, 5-7 person, cross-functional team, capable of moving a project from conception to done. Happy is contagious, and happy teams are effective teams.
But the cargo cult elements of scrum are in the jargon, which obscure the hard points of writing code. Story points, daily-stand ups, and sprint cycles are all well and good, but if you haven't figured out what you're doing and why, it doesn't matter. Small teams can self-organize, but what about coordinating big organizations and big projects? And while cross-functionality seems very important, most conventional businesses are organized in top-down, 'disciplinary' silos (sales, IT, development, finance, etc), so how do product owners and scrum masters interact with the conventional management hierarchy. And of course the big questions remain largely unanswered. How does a team figure out what objectives and capabilities are important, and how do you do a proper sprint retrospective to capture what went right?
And finally, some of the examples Sutherland uses are not quite right. There's a lot of pointing to Boyd's OODA loop, which Sutherland says he learned as a RF-4 pilot in Vietnam, except John Boyd only developed the OODA loop after his stint as Commander of 56th Combat Support Group in 1973. And Sutherland points to Valve as a company which has successfully implemented scrum, which may be true, except that despite sitting on a literal neverending pile of money in the form the Steam store, Valve hasn't released a significant game of its own since 2013. Rich Geldritch, a disgruntled former manager, alleges Valve is a morass of abusive management and inefficiency.
This book is enthusiastic, but cheering 'hip hip hooray being great!' is a far cry from actually being great.
Some parts of scrum are obvious. Spend time doing things that are valuable to the customer. Delivery that value quickly and incrementally. Don't get bogged down in monumental efforts tied to thousands of pages of documentation that no one has actually read, or actually understands. The basic unit of action is a small, 5-7 person, cross-functional team, capable of moving a project from conception to done. Happy is contagious, and happy teams are effective teams.
But the cargo cult elements of scrum are in the jargon, which obscure the hard points of writing code. Story points, daily-stand ups, and sprint cycles are all well and good, but if you haven't figured out what you're doing and why, it doesn't matter. Small teams can self-organize, but what about coordinating big organizations and big projects? And while cross-functionality seems very important, most conventional businesses are organized in top-down, 'disciplinary' silos (sales, IT, development, finance, etc), so how do product owners and scrum masters interact with the conventional management hierarchy. And of course the big questions remain largely unanswered. How does a team figure out what objectives and capabilities are important, and how do you do a proper sprint retrospective to capture what went right?
And finally, some of the examples Sutherland uses are not quite right. There's a lot of pointing to Boyd's OODA loop, which Sutherland says he learned as a RF-4 pilot in Vietnam, except John Boyd only developed the OODA loop after his stint as Commander of 56th Combat Support Group in 1973. And Sutherland points to Valve as a company which has successfully implemented scrum, which may be true, except that despite sitting on a literal neverending pile of money in the form the Steam store, Valve hasn't released a significant game of its own since 2013. Rich Geldritch, a disgruntled former manager, alleges Valve is a morass of abusive management and inefficiency.
This book is enthusiastic, but cheering 'hip hip hooray being great!' is a far cry from actually being great.
September 7, 2015
I can say , this is a "Myth & Rule Breaker" book. It is a revolution-creating , trend setting , thought-provoking , boldly truth spreading , Modern SDLC patterned , long - awaited successful-system-for-work telling Book. Jeff's metaphor for Scrum " Careful alignment, unity of purpose, and clarity of goal come together" proves that, he really spent worth-time to interrogate , analyse our present organisational system by "looking at how people ACTUALLY work, rather than how they SAY they work" :) I agree with some of his well defined strategies for win-win state , like Happiness Metric , Make Everything Visible ( Transparency , Delivering happiness , Inspect and adapt , Sprint Style of working etc. If you really let me to review and speak about this book , I can say on and on and on.... But , some books we have tot REALLY read , chew , swallow and follow ;). This is one among them... Great Book!
June 8, 2015
Five enthusiastic stars for Scrum. I wish I had read this book a long time ago. While a large part of this book is the "why" of Scrum, there is enough "how" in here to get you started, even though it does just scratch the surface. I dare you to read this book and not want to look for more resources online to help you implement Scrum. Whether you are managing a team of engineers, writing a book, or planning a wedding, Scrum can have a profound impact on your ability to complete a project on time as well as allow you to harness the power of your team's talent. This book and the Scrum methodology represents a real world example of the principals discussed in Multipliers.
June 28, 2018
Most valuable book in a long time! Besides that it is an easy and quick read. Don't see any reason not to read it ;)
March 1, 2019
[Hörbuch / deutsche Ausgabe: Die Scrum Revolution] Gelesen hätte ich das Buch nicht (hab es mir angehört). Die unzähligen Wiederholungen anhand von Beispielen machen einen zum Schluss fast irre. Man hat bereits nach den ersten Beispielen verstanden, um was es bei Scrum geht und wie effizient die Methodik ist. Vielmehr wäre das Durchspielen anhand von einem Beispiel deutlich wertvoller gewesen. Die Militäranalogien sind nicht so meins, bei einem ehemaligen US Aircraft Commander als Autor aber nicht verwunderlich.
Ich wollte die Projektmanagementmethode Scrum besser verstehen und konnte das durch dieses Buch auch. Ohne zu tief ins Detail zu gehen und die ganzen Scrum Terminologien zu verwenden, muss ich sagen, dass mir der Ansatz sehr gefällt und ich ihn mir sehr gut im Arbeitsalltag vorstellen kann. Sei es für einen Website Relaunch oder für das Management eines Blogs, die Methode wirkt für unterschiedlichste Anwendungsfälle sehr vielversprechend.
Das Buch ist dennoch etwas trocken und mit zu vielen Beispielen aufgebläht. So kompliziert ist der Ansatz dann nun auch nicht, dass man ihn so ausschweifend vertiefen muss.
Ich wollte die Projektmanagementmethode Scrum besser verstehen und konnte das durch dieses Buch auch. Ohne zu tief ins Detail zu gehen und die ganzen Scrum Terminologien zu verwenden, muss ich sagen, dass mir der Ansatz sehr gefällt und ich ihn mir sehr gut im Arbeitsalltag vorstellen kann. Sei es für einen Website Relaunch oder für das Management eines Blogs, die Methode wirkt für unterschiedlichste Anwendungsfälle sehr vielversprechend.
Das Buch ist dennoch etwas trocken und mit zu vielen Beispielen aufgebläht. So kompliziert ist der Ansatz dann nun auch nicht, dass man ihn so ausschweifend vertiefen muss.
November 2, 2015
Классическая книга от основателя метода. Моя подробная рецензия на книгу в блоге: http://s-kalinin.blogspot.ru/2015/10/...
Кому некогда читать))) - вот основные выводы:
1) Если вы интересуетесь персональным тайм-менеджментом - книгу однозначно рекомендую! Найдёте много новых идей и полезные инструменты. Кстати, добавлю ещё по секрету, что SCRUM отлично сочетается с "помидорным тайм-менеджментом" ;)
2) Если вы руководитель небольшой компании или проектной группы, и ваш проект не имеет очень жёстких ограничений (это важно!) по финансам, то скрам может оказаться той самой "серебряной пулей", которая поможет вам работать гораздо успешнее :). Попробовать стоит!
3) Если вы IT-специалист или IT-руководитель, то книга, скорее всего, будет интересна для вас только как сборник "городских легенд" :)), о том как возник и на каких кейсах формировался SCRUM. Для айтишников книга будет скорее носить мемуарно-исторический характер, а не практический.
Кому некогда читать))) - вот основные выводы:
1) Если вы интересуетесь персональным тайм-менеджментом - книгу однозначно рекомендую! Найдёте много новых идей и полезные инструменты. Кстати, добавлю ещё по секрету, что SCRUM отлично сочетается с "помидорным тайм-менеджментом" ;)
2) Если вы руководитель небольшой компании или проектной группы, и ваш проект не имеет очень жёстких ограничений (это важно!) по финансам, то скрам может оказаться той самой "серебряной пулей", которая поможет вам работать гораздо успешнее :). Попробовать стоит!
3) Если вы IT-специалист или IT-руководитель, то книга, скорее всего, будет интересна для вас только как сборник "городских легенд" :)), о том как возник и на каких кейсах формировался SCRUM. Для айтишников книга будет скорее носить мемуарно-исторический характер, а не практический.
August 12, 2017
Uma vez que o autor é o próprio criador do método, achei que o livro está mais para uma publicidade para incentivar seu uso do que para mostrar a realidade.
Por exemplo ele não menciona em nenhum momento as limitações que quem já conhece o método sabe que existem como por exemplo sua aplicação a projetos com muitas dependências externas (que é o caso da maioria dos projetos grandes e que seriam melhor executados com a maior economia de tempo e dinheiro, segundo a teoria do autor sobre o método).
Enfim, é um livro interessante para quem se interessou pelo assunto mas ainda não soube por onde começar, mas deve-se ficar atento para não ser ludibriado e no fim achar que todos os problemas do mundo se resolveriam com Scrum.
Por exemplo ele não menciona em nenhum momento as limitações que quem já conhece o método sabe que existem como por exemplo sua aplicação a projetos com muitas dependências externas (que é o caso da maioria dos projetos grandes e que seriam melhor executados com a maior economia de tempo e dinheiro, segundo a teoria do autor sobre o método).
Enfim, é um livro interessante para quem se interessou pelo assunto mas ainda não soube por onde começar, mas deve-se ficar atento para não ser ludibriado e no fim achar que todos os problemas do mundo se resolveriam com Scrum.
November 10, 2014
Well, a book about Scrum from the father of Scrum.
It is not a book for beginners and it is not a book for experts (are there any books for experts at all?)
If you are in the HA state of using/implementing agile, you or team members tend to ask things like "Can we skip this?" or "Can we change this to that?".
This book explains the answer to these questions by stating why something is defined like it it is now.
All in all a great and amusing audio book which I highly recommend.
It is not a book for beginners and it is not a book for experts (are there any books for experts at all?)
If you are in the HA state of using/implementing agile, you or team members tend to ask things like "Can we skip this?" or "Can we change this to that?".
This book explains the answer to these questions by stating why something is defined like it it is now.
All in all a great and amusing audio book which I highly recommend.
January 13, 2018
I already knew quite a lot about Scrum, but it was an interesting short read nonetheless. I forgot some things I learned years ago, and this book served both as reminder and gave me a few new ideas to try. I was surprised to learn Scrum was inspired by Lean, including waste elimination, reducing WIP, all that.
The book is a bit overpromising, though, and doesn't mention challenges or overcoming them. It's mostly about selling the idea than about any advanced implementation.
The book is a bit overpromising, though, and doesn't mention challenges or overcoming them. It's mostly about selling the idea than about any advanced implementation.
September 24, 2020
very useful, it's about planning and continuously changing and adapting your plan to the new variables and problems you face as you go along instead of planning and working in a linear way and sticking to the same solution no matter how the different variables may change, the former way is probably our best option and offers a life that's more organic and coherent.
June 8, 2020
No soy muy fan de este tipo de libros, pero me ha gustado, sus consejos son muy buenos y pienso llevar a la práctica varios de ellos. He llevado a cabo el modelo de cascada y no me ha resultado tan bueno, creó que en el próximo proyecto grande probaré con la metodología SCRUM a ver que tal me va.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 1,922 reviews