We all agree that manners today are not what they should be. Though the rules of civility have changed as the world has, David Coggins believes in the enduring importance of manners and a generous temperament even in the age of the iPhone. This timely book doesn’t tell you which fork to use or how to tie a bow tie. Rather, it reminds you of basic, respectful guidelines you may have forgotten or chosen to ignore. With essays, interviews and expert insight, Coggins makes the case for being the modern man who tips well, offers his seat, picks up the tab and who remembers to do what’s right even if it isn’t always rewarded.
David Coggins is the author of "The Believer: A Year in the Fly Fishing Life" (Scribner). His previous books include "The Optimist," "Men and Manners" and the NY Times best-seller "Men and Style" (Abrams). He writes The Contender, a newsletter about style, travel and design. His work appears in numerous publications, including Esquire, the Financial Times magazine and Robb Report. He lives in New York.
I think this is the third "men's manners" book I have read that begins with the qualifier, "This is not going to be one of those fusty books that tells you what forks to use . . . ."
"Men and Manners" is being carried at several stores I frequent, so I thought it might have some new, fresh insights. Most of the "essays, advice, and considerations" are recapitulations of common sense ways to comport yourself in public. Coggins does devote more time to manners while traveling than I have seen in other guides, so it does have that distinguishing feature. For the most part, though, "Men and Manners" simply points out everyday conduct that is rude or off putting that should be avoided.
If you have not recently read a guidebook on etiquette for the modern man, this will do nicely. If you own such a book or have read one in the past two years, I anticipate that "Men and Manners" will not fill a big void in your understanding of modern social mores.
I've always considered manners to be more of a learned disposition than a memorization of strict rules, and I was glad to see that David Coggins agrees (accept for square-toed shoes, never wear square-toed shoes). While much of what he lays out seems common sense to me, the book did help me go a little deeper, a little more thoughtful into various social situations, and for that I am thankful.
More of the social manners in general, which are mostly traditiional and applicable to western society ... some of those old school kinds may not be practise for young generations nowadays.
Great reminders, easily delivered for those who wish to be initiated in their daily social practices and experience. This book would greatly compliment King, Warrior, Magician. would recommend.
I'm a huge fan of David Coggins- he both writes well and seems to have a worldview I can get behind. His being an avid fly-fisherman also doesn't hurt my estimation of him as a human being. While a lot of the content of this book is simply "don't be stupid" stuff to those of us with common sense (and/or a sense of common decency) I think it's absolutely worthwhile to codify what it means to be a gentleman and to live graciously in an otherwise graceless age. This is a book I will keep and will delve back into from time to time.
A must for not just the would be lady or gentleman, but anyone who would consider themselves human, for civility and reason are what separates us from the beasts of the world.
***THIS BOOK WAS RECEIVED FROM A GOODREADS GIVEAWAY***
In a world becoming increasingly modern and digital, it’s a little odd to find a book like Men and Manners, especially since its weird page colors make it seem like it was written in the 1950’s. While this book did have some pieces of advice, it seemed to be as specifically tailored (like a high-end tuxedo) to Manhattan, New York, instead of being general advice for men in Manhattan, Kansas. Many of the locations and businesses explicitly mentioned in this book were complete mysteries to me since I don’t live in New York City. These references made it seem like the manners advice wasn’t relevant to me at all.
While I would have appreciated more thorough explanations of why particular manners should exist, this book seemed to be mostly filled with anecdotes from east coast elites about their opinion on certain matters. Sure, some of the people who provided their views were experts in their fields, but it would be better for the target audience (which I’m assuming is young men) to have an explanation as to why your shoe color should match your belt color. From my viewpoint, this book seemed like a lot of young Baby Boomers / older Gen-X-ers subtly complaining about Millennials and their habits/trends.
Despite the apparent bias on the part of the writer(s), this book did contain many pieces of useful advice, even if a lot of it—if not most of it—boiled down to common sense and common decency. Another aspect I seemed to notice with this book is that it is also aimed at the moderately wealthy, especially considering all the expensive hotels, restaurants, and businesses mentioned. I don’t think I’ve ever stayed at a hotel with a doorman. Consequently, it seems that manners are only available to the rich when it’s the less-wealthy among us that often need the gentle nudging toward good manners.
A primer for young men living in New York City, I give Men and Manners 3.0 stars out of 5.