What do you think?
Rate this book
The Seven Swords #2
The Kraken's Tooth
THE GREAT MERCHANT CITY OF CARTHULA—RAISED FROM THE BONES OF A KRAKEN ON THE WHIM OF A GODDESS WHERE NOBLE HOUSES CALL UPON DARK MAGIC TO TRIUMPH IN THEIR ENDLESS AND DEADLY GAME FOR DOMINION…
Landless one-time king Guyime, once called Pilgrim but known to history as the Ravager, has survived the fall of the Execration — an event that set him on a path to find the legendary Seven Swords. Guided by sorcery, Guyime journeys to Carthula in the centre of the First Sea to claim the mythical blade known as the Kraken's Tooth.
Aided by three companions — the beast charmer Seeker, a powerful sorceress and a scholarly slave — Guyime ventures into Carthula's perilous underbelly to secure a prize guarded by ancient magics, cursed spirits, and lethal traps.
But can he survive an ultimate ordeal crafted from his worst nightmares?
Continuing the epic story begun in A Pilgrimage of Swords, The Kraken's Tooth is a fast-paced tale of low intrigue and grand adventure from the New York Times bestselling author of the Raven's Shadow and Draconis Memoria trilogies.
Landless one-time king Guyime, once called Pilgrim but known to history as the Ravager, has survived the fall of the Execration — an event that set him on a path to find the legendary Seven Swords. Guided by sorcery, Guyime journeys to Carthula in the centre of the First Sea to claim the mythical blade known as the Kraken's Tooth.
Aided by three companions — the beast charmer Seeker, a powerful sorceress and a scholarly slave — Guyime ventures into Carthula's perilous underbelly to secure a prize guarded by ancient magics, cursed spirits, and lethal traps.
But can he survive an ultimate ordeal crafted from his worst nightmares?
Continuing the epic story begun in A Pilgrimage of Swords, The Kraken's Tooth is a fast-paced tale of low intrigue and grand adventure from the New York Times bestselling author of the Raven's Shadow and Draconis Memoria trilogies.
136 pages, Hardcover
First published September 30, 2020
About the author
Anthony Ryan
80 books9,240 followersAnthony Ryan was born in Scotland in 1970 but spent much of his adult life living and working in London. After a long career in the British Civil Service he took up writing full time after the success of his first novel Blood Song, Book One of the Raven’s Shadow trilogy. He has a degree in history, and his interests include art, science and the unending quest for the perfect pint of real ale.
For news and general wittering about stuff he likes, check out Anthony's blog at: http://anthonystuff.wordpress.com
For news and general wittering about stuff he likes, check out Anthony's blog at: http://anthonystuff.wordpress.com
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 93 reviews
May 14, 2022
These are fun little novellas. It’s a pretty standard quest plot, man searching for redemption has to gather up seven demon-cursed blades of immense power. He picks up stragglers who become friends along the way.
But what sells these stories for me are the characters I guess. Guyime makes it pretty clear he’s no hero - he’s got a past and we get to learn a good deal of it in this book.
And the banter he has with Lakorath, the lie-detecting soul-hungry demon who possesses his blade is so much fun. Not to mention Seeker and her animal charming abilities.
I appreciate that the books are quick. I enjoy the world building but mostly I enjoy that it doesn’t overshadow the story.
I’m going to have to go seek out the next book I suppose. Thank you to Subterranean Press and NetGalley for the eARC.
But what sells these stories for me are the characters I guess. Guyime makes it pretty clear he’s no hero - he’s got a past and we get to learn a good deal of it in this book.
And the banter he has with Lakorath, the lie-detecting soul-hungry demon who possesses his blade is so much fun. Not to mention Seeker and her animal charming abilities.
I appreciate that the books are quick. I enjoy the world building but mostly I enjoy that it doesn’t overshadow the story.
I’m going to have to go seek out the next book I suppose. Thank you to Subterranean Press and NetGalley for the eARC.
October 5, 2022
Check out my Booktube channel at: The Obsessive Bookseller
[3.5/5 stars] I gave a more detailed Review of Pilgrimage of Swords , so I’ll keep it brief here: I don’t know how Ryan manages to pack such rich word-building and depth into such a short book.
I’m really on board with the type of story being told in this series and have loved all the fun (aka perilous) adventures so far. Everything about this series is singing to me, and I can’t wait to find out what happens next! It’s a very bite-sized series and is a perfect refresher between denser reads.
Is the story good enough to merit $40 hardcovers? Probably not, but thankfully the ebook/audio combo is affordable. Unless you’re like me and must have all the hardcovers…
Recommendations: read them, they’re good.
Thank you to my Patrons: Filipe, Dave, Frank, Sonja, Staci, Kat, and Katrin! <3
Via The Obsessive Bookseller at www.NikiHawkes.com
Other books you might like:
[3.5/5 stars] I gave a more detailed Review of Pilgrimage of Swords , so I’ll keep it brief here: I don’t know how Ryan manages to pack such rich word-building and depth into such a short book.
I’m really on board with the type of story being told in this series and have loved all the fun (aka perilous) adventures so far. Everything about this series is singing to me, and I can’t wait to find out what happens next! It’s a very bite-sized series and is a perfect refresher between denser reads.
Is the story good enough to merit $40 hardcovers? Probably not, but thankfully the ebook/audio combo is affordable. Unless you’re like me and must have all the hardcovers…
Recommendations: read them, they’re good.
Thank you to my Patrons: Filipe, Dave, Frank, Sonja, Staci, Kat, and Katrin! <3
Via The Obsessive Bookseller at www.NikiHawkes.com
Other books you might like:
May 17, 2023
“It’s seems we are once again obliged to tread a forbidden path”.
Lo dicho. Esto cada vez se pone mejor. El autor ha cumplido y he de admitir que me he enganchado a la historia.
“We are bound , my liege. You to me and me to you. You cannot discard me. You cannot sell me. You cannot destroy me”.
El punto fuerte de la historia no es su argumento, sino la forma en que lo cuenta y la forma de escribir de Anthony Ryan. A pesar de presentarte la típica historia de búsqueda-aventuras él le da su toque oscuro con sus personajes grises y crea una gran historia corta muy intensa. Además, que poco a poco va profundizando en los personajes sobre todo en nuestro protagonista.
“Heroes win theirs wars only to become tyrants. The worst of murderers may escape punishent but cannot escape their own souls and they will always die pitiful, friendless and unmourned. The Infernus is a eternal place of chaos and angony, but this world is worse. Vile we may be but at least a demon knows what it is. Mortals live their entire existence flaining in the effluent of their own delusions.
Eso sí, he de admitir que al ser una historia corta para mí por ejemplo siento que me falta más información sobre el mundo, pero es predecible porque en 100 páginas tiene que conformarse y poco a poco nos va contando un poco más sobre ese mundo maldito en el que viven los protagonistas.
“You embrace them, imagining death will be your release from me, no doubt. But it didn’t it ever occur to you, my liege there are worse fates tan mere death?”
Totalmente recomendado y directa a la tercera parte.
“God’s die and their promises are always empty.
Lo dicho. Esto cada vez se pone mejor. El autor ha cumplido y he de admitir que me he enganchado a la historia.
“We are bound , my liege. You to me and me to you. You cannot discard me. You cannot sell me. You cannot destroy me”.
El punto fuerte de la historia no es su argumento, sino la forma en que lo cuenta y la forma de escribir de Anthony Ryan. A pesar de presentarte la típica historia de búsqueda-aventuras él le da su toque oscuro con sus personajes grises y crea una gran historia corta muy intensa. Además, que poco a poco va profundizando en los personajes sobre todo en nuestro protagonista.
“Heroes win theirs wars only to become tyrants. The worst of murderers may escape punishent but cannot escape their own souls and they will always die pitiful, friendless and unmourned. The Infernus is a eternal place of chaos and angony, but this world is worse. Vile we may be but at least a demon knows what it is. Mortals live their entire existence flaining in the effluent of their own delusions.
Eso sí, he de admitir que al ser una historia corta para mí por ejemplo siento que me falta más información sobre el mundo, pero es predecible porque en 100 páginas tiene que conformarse y poco a poco nos va contando un poco más sobre ese mundo maldito en el que viven los protagonistas.
“You embrace them, imagining death will be your release from me, no doubt. But it didn’t it ever occur to you, my liege there are worse fates tan mere death?”
Totalmente recomendado y directa a la tercera parte.
“God’s die and their promises are always empty.
April 4, 2024
I’m really enjoying these quick dark adventures from Anthony Ryan
June 13, 2021
4/5
I haven't read much more Anthony Ryan since Blood Song, of which I got a kick out of. After being in a bit of a fantasy rut, I wanted to try something short to get me out of my fix and decided on The Seven Sword series (2 published so far with book 3 later this year). This quick review will encompass my thoughts on both parts 1 and 2.
This series is seemingly inspired by the Sword and Sorcery sub genre: a travelling band questing towards a common goal with the main lead being a demon-sword wielding northman with a violent past. Cliché I know but it's a ton of fun because the tropes are executed well and the mystery of 'Pilgrim's' past, the interactions with the talking sword, and the pure adrenaline pumping action of the set pieces all lend towards an entertaining romp.
The main conceit of the series is that there a 'god' that created a massive wasteland in this world and there are various pilgrimages made to request something from said 'god'. The journey is a torturous one with plenty of interaction between creeping beasties or subterfuge within the travelling group. The group are all provided monikers, such as Pilgrim, and this made me think on the same Canterbury Tales-like framing that Hyperion by Dan Simmons had. As the story progresses, it becomes a story to attempt to gather the other 6 demon-haunted swords.
Overall, this was pulp fiction at its finest and a good time was had. Ryan has proven to be a capable writer and I'm looking forward to more of his work.
I haven't read much more Anthony Ryan since Blood Song, of which I got a kick out of. After being in a bit of a fantasy rut, I wanted to try something short to get me out of my fix and decided on The Seven Sword series (2 published so far with book 3 later this year). This quick review will encompass my thoughts on both parts 1 and 2.
This series is seemingly inspired by the Sword and Sorcery sub genre: a travelling band questing towards a common goal with the main lead being a demon-sword wielding northman with a violent past. Cliché I know but it's a ton of fun because the tropes are executed well and the mystery of 'Pilgrim's' past, the interactions with the talking sword, and the pure adrenaline pumping action of the set pieces all lend towards an entertaining romp.
The main conceit of the series is that there a 'god' that created a massive wasteland in this world and there are various pilgrimages made to request something from said 'god'. The journey is a torturous one with plenty of interaction between creeping beasties or subterfuge within the travelling group. The group are all provided monikers, such as Pilgrim, and this made me think on the same Canterbury Tales-like framing that Hyperion by Dan Simmons had. As the story progresses, it becomes a story to attempt to gather the other 6 demon-haunted swords.
Overall, this was pulp fiction at its finest and a good time was had. Ryan has proven to be a capable writer and I'm looking forward to more of his work.
September 26, 2023
This book seamlessly continues from the previous with a little more backstory being introduced to the characters as well as the development of the relationship between them. I really liked this and hope it continues throughout the series.
The plot is again very fast paced as it’s a short story but nevertheless packs a punch in all the right places, I was very drawn into the story as it unfolded as there is so much going on. There are more interesting characters brought into the story which I always look forward to. I especially loved the sense of humour of the sword.
The world building in this book is spectacular for a short story. There is so much detail here it’s very inspiring.
To sum up this book is a very enjoyable read, very fast paced and full of action, dilemmas, and wonderful characters. I look forward to reading the next book in the series.
The plot is again very fast paced as it’s a short story but nevertheless packs a punch in all the right places, I was very drawn into the story as it unfolded as there is so much going on. There are more interesting characters brought into the story which I always look forward to. I especially loved the sense of humour of the sword.
The world building in this book is spectacular for a short story. There is so much detail here it’s very inspiring.
To sum up this book is a very enjoyable read, very fast paced and full of action, dilemmas, and wonderful characters. I look forward to reading the next book in the series.
March 15, 2022
Vrlo lepa klasična S&S novela iz pera Entonija Rajana, koja na solidan način nastavlja radnju iz prvog dela ove storije. Ako išta, era digitalnog izdavaštva omogućila je renesansu novela (koje su se u mom dečaštvu nazivale "kratkim romanima") i njihovo učestalo objavljivanje, što nesumnjivo doprinosi u budžetima njihovih autora. Kamo sreće da ima više ovakvih radova, u svim živim žanrovima.
4*
4*
September 24, 2020
The Kraken’s Tooth continues where A Pilgrimage of Swords leads off: with Pilgrim (AKA – Guyime) heading off with Seeker to find her daughter, as promised. This book was really similar to the first book in the series, and I thank author Author Anthony Ryan for that. After experiencing book 1, I was ready for more! I enjoyed reading the follow-up and am excited to see where the series goes from here.
I described Pilgrimage as adventure fantasy meets grimdark (see how I linked it there for your convenience?), and Kraken is much of the same. Pilgrim finds himself on yet ANOTHER quest with yet ANOTHER crew at his back (and sometimes at his front; and, actually, more often than not at his sides saving his ass from a demon with an attitude). It is a fun narrative, and one of the aspects of Kraken that I find so intriguing is that the stakes are higher this time. Pilgrim is not just out for himself as the was in Pilgrimage; he is helping someone he cares about, and that brings a little bit of a different tone in this book. Not that he was not willing to put himself in danger for the sake of others in the first book (as we came to find out), but in this book that is his goal from the beginning. And wouldn’t you know it, their goals (by chance!) are intertwined, and Pilgrim may be able to accomplish his goal while also getting Seeker what she is looking for. Talk about tension! Between the main story and subplots, this story is absolutely oozing with it.
Another great thing about Kraken is that, because we already were introduced to this world and the characters in book 1 (though with a narrow scope), it gives Ryan and opportunity to expand and provide more detail. We get some more of the history and different areas of the world, and some more about Pilgrim and Seeker’s pasts. On the flip side, we are introduced to a few new characters with one-of-a-kind skillsets that are perfect for this journey to find the kraken’s tooth. The world is really captivating, and the characters are unique. It is really cool the way the author is slowly opening this world to readers, one 100 plus-page novella at a time. Each book is like one piece of the puzzle that (hopefully) creates a full picture by the time we open them all.
I had a lot fun with this book. With The Kraken’s Tooth, Anthony Ryan has brought us another action-packed story full of as much adventure as one can fit in 150 pages or less. I recommend fantasy fans pick this series up if they have not, already. This is going to be a fun ride.
I described Pilgrimage as adventure fantasy meets grimdark (see how I linked it there for your convenience?), and Kraken is much of the same. Pilgrim finds himself on yet ANOTHER quest with yet ANOTHER crew at his back (and sometimes at his front; and, actually, more often than not at his sides saving his ass from a demon with an attitude). It is a fun narrative, and one of the aspects of Kraken that I find so intriguing is that the stakes are higher this time. Pilgrim is not just out for himself as the was in Pilgrimage; he is helping someone he cares about, and that brings a little bit of a different tone in this book. Not that he was not willing to put himself in danger for the sake of others in the first book (as we came to find out), but in this book that is his goal from the beginning. And wouldn’t you know it, their goals (by chance!) are intertwined, and Pilgrim may be able to accomplish his goal while also getting Seeker what she is looking for. Talk about tension! Between the main story and subplots, this story is absolutely oozing with it.
Another great thing about Kraken is that, because we already were introduced to this world and the characters in book 1 (though with a narrow scope), it gives Ryan and opportunity to expand and provide more detail. We get some more of the history and different areas of the world, and some more about Pilgrim and Seeker’s pasts. On the flip side, we are introduced to a few new characters with one-of-a-kind skillsets that are perfect for this journey to find the kraken’s tooth. The world is really captivating, and the characters are unique. It is really cool the way the author is slowly opening this world to readers, one 100 plus-page novella at a time. Each book is like one piece of the puzzle that (hopefully) creates a full picture by the time we open them all.
I had a lot fun with this book. With The Kraken’s Tooth, Anthony Ryan has brought us another action-packed story full of as much adventure as one can fit in 150 pages or less. I recommend fantasy fans pick this series up if they have not, already. This is going to be a fun ride.
October 12, 2021
1st reading: October 14th 2020 -> 4 stars
2nd reading: October 11th 2021 -> 5 stars
It’s an emotional and memorable sequel to The Seven Swords series.
“Heroes win their wars only to become tyrants. The worst of murderers may escape punishment but cannot escape their own souls and they will always die pitiful, friendless and unmourned. The Infernus is an eternal plane of chaos and agony, but this world is worse. Vile we may be but at least a demon knows what it is. Mortals live their entire existence flailing in the effluent of their own delusions.”
↠ I loved this more than at first.
↠ I learned more about Guyime's past. Really, I just really understood how much pain he was carrying in his heart. It is understandable why he wants to change at all costs.
↠ Although , but I learned more about the seven swords and their powers.
↠ I got a lot of adventures and excitement, again.
↠ I liked the two new characters. I'm glad the team has expanded.
↠ Here, too, I was part of a painful and deep love affair.
↠ Of course, there was also a little humor.
↠ Really everything was in this part as well, that I love.
↠ I can highly recommend reading this series! No matter how short, it is full of excitement, adventure, emotion and secrets.
“Lines drawn across plains and mountains. Drawn by those who don’t even live there. Lines that become barriers to the passage of free folk who have walked the same paths for generations. Maps are the cages of kings and princes.”
{ October 14th 2020 -> 4 stars } This is a very interesting, unique and exciting series. It was good to return to the world of Seven Swords. I really like Anthony Ryan’s style and idea. But it’s also very short, I would read a lot more about such a big world. I liked Guyime even more, especially since I learned more about his past in this one. I really liked the new location where the story continues and the new characters also added a lot to the story.
2nd reading: October 11th 2021 -> 5 stars
It’s an emotional and memorable sequel to The Seven Swords series.
“Heroes win their wars only to become tyrants. The worst of murderers may escape punishment but cannot escape their own souls and they will always die pitiful, friendless and unmourned. The Infernus is an eternal plane of chaos and agony, but this world is worse. Vile we may be but at least a demon knows what it is. Mortals live their entire existence flailing in the effluent of their own delusions.”
↠ I loved this more than at first.
↠ I learned more about Guyime's past. Really, I just really understood how much pain he was carrying in his heart. It is understandable why he wants to change at all costs.
↠ Although , but I learned more about the seven swords and their powers.
↠ I got a lot of adventures and excitement, again.
↠ I liked the two new characters. I'm glad the team has expanded.
↠ Here, too, I was part of a painful and deep love affair.
↠ Of course, there was also a little humor.
↠ Really everything was in this part as well, that I love.
↠ I can highly recommend reading this series! No matter how short, it is full of excitement, adventure, emotion and secrets.
“Lines drawn across plains and mountains. Drawn by those who don’t even live there. Lines that become barriers to the passage of free folk who have walked the same paths for generations. Maps are the cages of kings and princes.”
{ October 14th 2020 -> 4 stars } This is a very interesting, unique and exciting series. It was good to return to the world of Seven Swords. I really like Anthony Ryan’s style and idea. But it’s also very short, I would read a lot more about such a big world. I liked Guyime even more, especially since I learned more about his past in this one. I really liked the new location where the story continues and the new characters also added a lot to the story.
March 21, 2024
4.5 Stars
Anthony Ryan finds a way to keep me captivated and feeling like it is a smooth ride to the end. His writing style is my cup of tea, and I love the characters!
How Ryan can manage to balance character-building, worldbuilding, and action in these novellas is magic. Ryan is a fucking wizard y'all.
Anthony Ryan finds a way to keep me captivated and feeling like it is a smooth ride to the end. His writing style is my cup of tea, and I love the characters!
How Ryan can manage to balance character-building, worldbuilding, and action in these novellas is magic. Ryan is a fucking wizard y'all.
November 28, 2020
Swords of Evil!!
Once again our man has to find another sword of evil. So Guyime aka Pilgrim an Seeker have to find a map to finds the sword an her daughter. Things don't turn out the way they want an a slave takes the sword an now travels along to find the next evil sword. The next place is in The Songs of the Dark. Ready for book #3.
Once again our man has to find another sword of evil. So Guyime aka Pilgrim an Seeker have to find a map to finds the sword an her daughter. Things don't turn out the way they want an a slave takes the sword an now travels along to find the next evil sword. The next place is in The Songs of the Dark. Ready for book #3.
April 23, 2024
Segundo capítulo de las aventuras del peregrino y su espada maldita. Mientras que el primer libro lo sentí como un prólogo, en este se puede decir que la historia empieza de verdad y Anthony Ryan no decepciona.
Tanto este como el anterior tienen un toque muy clásico, son un homenaje a artistas y autores que inspiraron a Ryan en su juventud y se nota mucho. Son historias sencillas y cortas, pero que brillan gracias a la gran calidad que tiene este autor para crear personajes.
Estoy disfrutando mucho estas novelas cortas. Son ideales para descansar de fantasía épica más pesada y también recomendables para introducirse en las obras de este gran autor que es uno de mis favoritos.
Tanto este como el anterior tienen un toque muy clásico, son un homenaje a artistas y autores que inspiraron a Ryan en su juventud y se nota mucho. Son historias sencillas y cortas, pero que brillan gracias a la gran calidad que tiene este autor para crear personajes.
Estoy disfrutando mucho estas novelas cortas. Son ideales para descansar de fantasía épica más pesada y también recomendables para introducirse en las obras de este gran autor que es uno de mis favoritos.
July 16, 2020
I was lucky and received an ARC of The Kraken's Tooth. I hadn't read Anthony Ryan before, and since this was the second novella in the Seven Swords series, I first tracked down the first novella, A Pilgrimage of Swords, and read that. It was a great introduction to the series, and an enjoyable read. I then started The Kraken's Tooth, and it was even better. Great characters, a great story, and great writing. Can't wait for future books in the series. Plus, this has made me realize that I've been missing Anthony Ryan's works, and will have to start working through his books.
For anyone with middle age children, I think these will also work and be enjoyed. I immediately show this to my 14 year old, and she thought it sounded interesting. I believe that she will enjoy it.
For anyone with middle age children, I think these will also work and be enjoyed. I immediately show this to my 14 year old, and she thought it sounded interesting. I believe that she will enjoy it.
June 6, 2024
4.5 Stars
For this and other book (and movie!) reviews, check out: medium.com/@essentialreadingsandrevie...
What's the story about: In the same vein and continuation of A Pilgrimage of Swords, The Kraken's Tooth is an adventure to find a lost sword and overcome perils along the way. The main characters who survived the previous ordeal are joined by two new characters that have a mysterious history.
2024 Reread: the only additional thing worth noting here is that there is a kind of slowness to the beginning of this one. In order to separate itself from A Pilgrimage of Swords, it takes awhile (for a novella) to get going but once it does, it's a sprint. Particularly, the second half is especially riveting.
All in all, The Kraken's Tooth is a great second book in this novella series. If you're considering reading this series, I implore you to not give up after the first one! A Pilgrimage of Swords is truly a first act that is a good primer, but The Kraken's Tooth is where the story really develops, deepening and expanding in the best ways. I highly recommend reading this one directly after the first and then make a decision to continue. These stories are definitely all a part of one overarching quest that I'm eager to explore and think the possibilities for future entries are endless. Highly recommend if you're looking for a fun adventure that occasionally tugs on the heart.
For this and other book (and movie!) reviews, check out: medium.com/@essentialreadingsandrevie...
What's the story about: In the same vein and continuation of A Pilgrimage of Swords, The Kraken's Tooth is an adventure to find a lost sword and overcome perils along the way. The main characters who survived the previous ordeal are joined by two new characters that have a mysterious history.
2024 Reread: the only additional thing worth noting here is that there is a kind of slowness to the beginning of this one. In order to separate itself from A Pilgrimage of Swords, it takes awhile (for a novella) to get going but once it does, it's a sprint. Particularly, the second half is especially riveting.
All in all, The Kraken's Tooth is a great second book in this novella series. If you're considering reading this series, I implore you to not give up after the first one! A Pilgrimage of Swords is truly a first act that is a good primer, but The Kraken's Tooth is where the story really develops, deepening and expanding in the best ways. I highly recommend reading this one directly after the first and then make a decision to continue. These stories are definitely all a part of one overarching quest that I'm eager to explore and think the possibilities for future entries are endless. Highly recommend if you're looking for a fun adventure that occasionally tugs on the heart.
April 3, 2021
The plot is pretty similar to the first one as it’s a straight forward quest, a gritty action-based dungeon crawl with a little drama and mystery expertly woven into it. The world building is so incredibly good, easily sucking us into this new and dangerous world and just leaves us wanting more. While the main character is without a doubt the main attraction, the main cast is noticeably smaller this time around so other characters do get more chances to shine and truly come to life. It’s a dark fantasy done right.
November 30, 2022
The second in what I think will be a 7-novella series. Nice to have another novella series to look forward to. I'm a big fan of Lois McMaster Bujold Penic and Desdemona novella series and of course, Dunk & Egg novellas series. The first in the series introduces us to the Pilgrim aka Guyime, the main character and owner of a demon possessed sword. In this tale Guyime and Seeker are joined by a mage and her slave to find the sword that killed a Kraken. But to do it the small group must pass several tests to reach the goal. on to novella #3 City of Songs.
June 11, 2024
Quick and entertaining novella series for the epic fantasy lover! Really enjoying these.
July 14, 2020
Much like its predecessor, Kraken’s Tooth, jumps right into the action and maintains that pace throughout the length of the story. It continues the journey of Guyime and Seeker, each looking to right their wrongs. Seeker continues the search for her daughter while Guyime searches for the other demonic weapons in an effort to destroy them. Despite its short length, this story is rich enough in detail that readers will be able to picture the landscape as they progress. And true to Anthony Ryan’s style, the fighting remains action packed and crisp. This follow up does its predecessor, A Pilgrimage of Swords, justice.
July 4, 2021
My Review for The Kranken's Tooth by Anthony Ryan.
Check out my Book Blog
“I have been wielded by heroes of legend and villains of infamy. By the worst scum and the most noble spirit. And in all that time you know what I learned, my liege? There was no meaning in any of it, no purpose that counted for more than shit in the end. Heroes win their wars only to become tyrants. The worst of murderers may escape punishment but cannot escape their own soul and they will always die pitiful, friendless and unmourned.”
So what’s the book about?
Having survived the fall of the Execration, the former King Guyime must now forge new paths so that he can find the seven legendary swords. In doing so, he once again contains support from his cursed sword, but also from the beast summoner Seeker, who also supports his goal, but actually has her own goal entirely. For they must go to the great trading city of Karthulara, created from the Kraken bones, to triumph in the endless and deadly game for domination. In the centre of the first sea, he also gains new allies to help him fight the deadly game, a powerful mage and a scholarly slave. Thus, Guyime ventures into the dangerous body of Carthage to secure the next sword, guarded by ancient magic, cursed spirits and deadly traps. How he to win the deadly game that no one has ever left alive?
These aspects attracted me the most while reading.
The game to be played here was created by a deity who again makes it difficult for seekers to reach the goal, thus the sword. To reach this goal, Guyime and Seeker have to solve many puzzles, avoid traps and compete against various opponents. I had the feeling that I was in a dungeon with no end in sight, that it was taking your breath away. The vivid images that spring up in this dungeon could also make me want to play the deadly game where everything was given so that the goal could be achieved. I literally felt myself trying to choose the right answer like in a computer game so that I could get to the next dialogue in the game and be closer to my final goal. This deadly and gloomy game was filled with many exciting smaller puzzles and I especially liked the labyrinth. Every single player in this game was shown other sins of their previous life in the labyrinth, where they had to go through this memory to be able to choose the right way out of the labyrinth. Only from Guyime you learn the sins that give you an even deeper understanding of the character. Whether I would have managed to play this game and escape this deadly realm, we will never find out, but whether Guyime and Seeker manage to escape this game, we will definitely find out – but I have more hope in these two than in myself.
The world that seems like a nightmare becomes more and more depressing and dark. The world is so hopeless, also are the characters and the goal, that you already know that the story will have a tragic course. For one thing, the story and the motivation of Guyime and Seeker give us an almost unattainable goal, which the characters make seem even more depressing. But the dangers that the two seekers encounter also embody this hopelessness. For the world they live in is on the brink, visited by grotesque creatures, by deities who devise hideous games to make the world even more desperate, and also by the inhabitants of this world, where one does not know whether they want anything good for the world. And the poor souls Guyime and Seeker are only trying to pull this world out of the abyss.
We learn more and more about the mysterious and sinister character Guyime and I don’t know if it makes him seem more sympathetic or if he is just as dark as the world around him. Because at first, only his cursed sword kept revealing Guyime’s true identity, that he is not a hero but that he is the bad guy, and now we get fragments of memories from his former life that show his true nature. For Guyime is certainly no hero, which is why he is surely now taking this daring path to find the swords to atone for his sins. Again and again we get these fragments from his past life through the journey to the octopus bones, to find out about great sins in his life later in the game of the labyrinth. For one sin in particular really shocked me, as Guyime grows on you as he seems so self-sacrificing, yet none of this quality shows in his past life. Now he is a broken man who is simply seeking his way back into the light.
The Second.
To compare the story of the first volume to the second is quite difficult. In the first, I liked especially that the whole world and the characters are very mysterious, this mysterious is lifted a little in the second volume, because you learn more and more about Guyime and you build a bond with him. But this game that is played in volume two could fully excite me that I liked it even better. Also, here in the few pages still a little political undertone are brought in and two extraordinarily exciting new characters. The second volume could convey the mood even better and the gloomy world could pull even more in the volume.
So what are my final thoughts about it?
This pictorial world just completely blows me away, because this dark world with this fascinating main character Guyime just makes all the dreams of a fantasy book come true for me. Sometimes a book doesn’t need this elaborate side stories to create a brilliant book, because this book captivates by the inevitable story that the seven swords have to be found, which is why this path can be walked without any circumlocutions and still you are completely immersed in this world. This gloomy and dark mood leaves one even after finishing the book with a sense of wonder and especially the end of the book had it in itself. Because every victory also means a defeat, even if people can be saved, a bloody end often does remain. I find it a pity that I have to emerge so quickly from this world again, because it is very short with its 130 pages, yet I want to emphasize that the book still brings an incredible atmosphere, great and detailed characters that you just do not want to leave. Incidentally, this series would be the perfect story to make a movie series out of it. I am already very curious how this story continues in the next volume and what paths Guyime and Seeker must take this time.
Check out my Book Blog
“I have been wielded by heroes of legend and villains of infamy. By the worst scum and the most noble spirit. And in all that time you know what I learned, my liege? There was no meaning in any of it, no purpose that counted for more than shit in the end. Heroes win their wars only to become tyrants. The worst of murderers may escape punishment but cannot escape their own soul and they will always die pitiful, friendless and unmourned.”
So what’s the book about?
Having survived the fall of the Execration, the former King Guyime must now forge new paths so that he can find the seven legendary swords. In doing so, he once again contains support from his cursed sword, but also from the beast summoner Seeker, who also supports his goal, but actually has her own goal entirely. For they must go to the great trading city of Karthulara, created from the Kraken bones, to triumph in the endless and deadly game for domination. In the centre of the first sea, he also gains new allies to help him fight the deadly game, a powerful mage and a scholarly slave. Thus, Guyime ventures into the dangerous body of Carthage to secure the next sword, guarded by ancient magic, cursed spirits and deadly traps. How he to win the deadly game that no one has ever left alive?
These aspects attracted me the most while reading.
The game to be played here was created by a deity who again makes it difficult for seekers to reach the goal, thus the sword. To reach this goal, Guyime and Seeker have to solve many puzzles, avoid traps and compete against various opponents. I had the feeling that I was in a dungeon with no end in sight, that it was taking your breath away. The vivid images that spring up in this dungeon could also make me want to play the deadly game where everything was given so that the goal could be achieved. I literally felt myself trying to choose the right answer like in a computer game so that I could get to the next dialogue in the game and be closer to my final goal. This deadly and gloomy game was filled with many exciting smaller puzzles and I especially liked the labyrinth. Every single player in this game was shown other sins of their previous life in the labyrinth, where they had to go through this memory to be able to choose the right way out of the labyrinth. Only from Guyime you learn the sins that give you an even deeper understanding of the character. Whether I would have managed to play this game and escape this deadly realm, we will never find out, but whether Guyime and Seeker manage to escape this game, we will definitely find out – but I have more hope in these two than in myself.
The world that seems like a nightmare becomes more and more depressing and dark. The world is so hopeless, also are the characters and the goal, that you already know that the story will have a tragic course. For one thing, the story and the motivation of Guyime and Seeker give us an almost unattainable goal, which the characters make seem even more depressing. But the dangers that the two seekers encounter also embody this hopelessness. For the world they live in is on the brink, visited by grotesque creatures, by deities who devise hideous games to make the world even more desperate, and also by the inhabitants of this world, where one does not know whether they want anything good for the world. And the poor souls Guyime and Seeker are only trying to pull this world out of the abyss.
We learn more and more about the mysterious and sinister character Guyime and I don’t know if it makes him seem more sympathetic or if he is just as dark as the world around him. Because at first, only his cursed sword kept revealing Guyime’s true identity, that he is not a hero but that he is the bad guy, and now we get fragments of memories from his former life that show his true nature. For Guyime is certainly no hero, which is why he is surely now taking this daring path to find the swords to atone for his sins. Again and again we get these fragments from his past life through the journey to the octopus bones, to find out about great sins in his life later in the game of the labyrinth. For one sin in particular really shocked me, as Guyime grows on you as he seems so self-sacrificing, yet none of this quality shows in his past life. Now he is a broken man who is simply seeking his way back into the light.
The Second.
To compare the story of the first volume to the second is quite difficult. In the first, I liked especially that the whole world and the characters are very mysterious, this mysterious is lifted a little in the second volume, because you learn more and more about Guyime and you build a bond with him. But this game that is played in volume two could fully excite me that I liked it even better. Also, here in the few pages still a little political undertone are brought in and two extraordinarily exciting new characters. The second volume could convey the mood even better and the gloomy world could pull even more in the volume.
So what are my final thoughts about it?
This pictorial world just completely blows me away, because this dark world with this fascinating main character Guyime just makes all the dreams of a fantasy book come true for me. Sometimes a book doesn’t need this elaborate side stories to create a brilliant book, because this book captivates by the inevitable story that the seven swords have to be found, which is why this path can be walked without any circumlocutions and still you are completely immersed in this world. This gloomy and dark mood leaves one even after finishing the book with a sense of wonder and especially the end of the book had it in itself. Because every victory also means a defeat, even if people can be saved, a bloody end often does remain. I find it a pity that I have to emerge so quickly from this world again, because it is very short with its 130 pages, yet I want to emphasize that the book still brings an incredible atmosphere, great and detailed characters that you just do not want to leave. Incidentally, this series would be the perfect story to make a movie series out of it. I am already very curious how this story continues in the next volume and what paths Guyime and Seeker must take this time.
December 30, 2022
Follow me on Twitter: Twitter.com/wolfmantula
For more reviews, go to www.wolfmantula.com/book-reviews
MY ⭐️ RATING: 4.25/5
FORMAT: Kindle Whispersync
I enjoyed this story a little more than A Pilgrimage of Swords and that may be due to already knowing the two main characters. The story is plot driven and fast paced, with a dungeon-crawl type of feel to it, which leads to some pretty tense, yet exciting moments. Fight scenes were pretty exciting and lasted longer than they did in the previous book. I also liked adding in the solving of riddles and even navigating a maze and avoiding traps that made the story a little better as the characters had to figure out the next step to find The Kraken’s Tooth. Also, I LOVE, LOVE, LOVE THESE COVERS
The characters got a little more development as we get to know a little more about Pilgrim also known as Guyime, his past, and his complicated relationship with Lakorath, the demon imbued sword, who have some pretty entertaining banter. Seeker, the beast charmer doesn’t get as much development, but there is something there that makes me feel that finding her daughter is tied in to Guyime and may play a bigger part later on.
For such a short story, this had a good amount of action, story telling and character development that kept me engaged the entire time. Count me on more stories about Guyime, Lakorath and Seeker!
For more reviews, go to www.wolfmantula.com/book-reviews
MY ⭐️ RATING: 4.25/5
FORMAT: Kindle Whispersync
I enjoyed this story a little more than A Pilgrimage of Swords and that may be due to already knowing the two main characters. The story is plot driven and fast paced, with a dungeon-crawl type of feel to it, which leads to some pretty tense, yet exciting moments. Fight scenes were pretty exciting and lasted longer than they did in the previous book. I also liked adding in the solving of riddles and even navigating a maze and avoiding traps that made the story a little better as the characters had to figure out the next step to find The Kraken’s Tooth. Also, I LOVE, LOVE, LOVE THESE COVERS
The characters got a little more development as we get to know a little more about Pilgrim also known as Guyime, his past, and his complicated relationship with Lakorath, the demon imbued sword, who have some pretty entertaining banter. Seeker, the beast charmer doesn’t get as much development, but there is something there that makes me feel that finding her daughter is tied in to Guyime and may play a bigger part later on.
For such a short story, this had a good amount of action, story telling and character development that kept me engaged the entire time. Count me on more stories about Guyime, Lakorath and Seeker!
February 16, 2021
I did like this a little bit better then the first book but the issue I am having still remains. That issue is these books are just too short. I want them to be longer. I want to play in this sandbox. Just as I get invested and start enjoying myself the book has ended. But that is what you get with Novellas and there is nothing I can do about it.
Anthony Ryan does a wonderful job with this novella series but it is always going to be one where I am left wanting more. I think the story is paced very well. The characters have purpose and clear motivations. The history and mythology of the world is rich. The Kraken's Tooth is a slight step up and I can't wait for the next adventure.
Anthony Ryan does a wonderful job with this novella series but it is always going to be one where I am left wanting more. I think the story is paced very well. The characters have purpose and clear motivations. The history and mythology of the world is rich. The Kraken's Tooth is a slight step up and I can't wait for the next adventure.
May 13, 2024
Good I like it, op naar boek 3
October 22, 2020
4.4 / 5 ✪
https://arefugefromlife.wordpress.com...
Second entry in the Seven Swords reunites us with Pilgrim and Seeker, fresh off their battle in the Execration against a mad god. While the Seeker remains shrouded in mystery, her path forward has become clear. She seeks a certain girl, sold into slavery, one that bears a striking resemblance to she herself. The Pilgrim however, has been unmasked. Guyime, known to history as the Ravager, seeks the Seven Swords—a collection of demon blades that imbue their wielders with power and unnaturally long life. A life that Guyime would escape.
But to do that he must travel to Carthula and claim the Kraken’s Tooth, a mythical sword said to be lodged in the heart of a long dead Kraken. Accompanying him on this fool’s errand are: Seeker, whose path seems to parallel his own, for now; a powerful sorceress from an equally powerful clan; and her’s father’s slave, a man that never forgets anything he’s ever learned. But will this trio be enough to help Guyime through a maze built from his worst nightmares and memories, or will this fellowship crumble once their quarry is in sight?
Other than the previous Pilgrimage of Swords, the Kraken’s Tooth has nothing to do with any of Ryan’s other work (that I know of, at least). As with the first, I wouldn’t’ve minded a full novel dedicated to this, though it works well enough as an installment of novellas. I’m not a huge fan of novellas, particularly those I’ve seen from the author, but these two have so far broken the mold. Kraken’s Tooth tells a complete story, with no skimping on plot or fantasy. It’s light on details, yet still manages to convey more than enough to paint the Seven Swords in vibrant colors. I had no issue getting into or following the story, and if anything even less imagining it. Any character development does suffer from the lack of material, with details such as interpersonal relationships, reliability or anything more than brief flashbacks are absent. The characters themselves might as well be mannequins, except for Guyime, who has overcome his stoicism from Book #1 and now just seems gruff and distant (and maybe Seeker, who I’m assuming is supposed to just be mysterious, though it’s difficult to tell).
Other than the character aspect, I had no problem getting through Kraken’s Tooth. There was more than enough action and adventure to entertain, while the story holds a political undertone and throws in a bit of mystery and drama that didn’t hurt either. And as I’ve already mentioned, the world is well rendered—with just enough detail left out that the Carthula I imagined likely won’t be the same as anyone else’s—while still getting the most important aspects of the story across. It may be imperfect, but I’d definitely recommend the Seven Swords to any fan of mainstream fantasy, epic, grimdark, and more. I can’t wait to read the next installment and see where the story takes us next!
https://arefugefromlife.wordpress.com...
Second entry in the Seven Swords reunites us with Pilgrim and Seeker, fresh off their battle in the Execration against a mad god. While the Seeker remains shrouded in mystery, her path forward has become clear. She seeks a certain girl, sold into slavery, one that bears a striking resemblance to she herself. The Pilgrim however, has been unmasked. Guyime, known to history as the Ravager, seeks the Seven Swords—a collection of demon blades that imbue their wielders with power and unnaturally long life. A life that Guyime would escape.
But to do that he must travel to Carthula and claim the Kraken’s Tooth, a mythical sword said to be lodged in the heart of a long dead Kraken. Accompanying him on this fool’s errand are: Seeker, whose path seems to parallel his own, for now; a powerful sorceress from an equally powerful clan; and her’s father’s slave, a man that never forgets anything he’s ever learned. But will this trio be enough to help Guyime through a maze built from his worst nightmares and memories, or will this fellowship crumble once their quarry is in sight?
Other than the previous Pilgrimage of Swords, the Kraken’s Tooth has nothing to do with any of Ryan’s other work (that I know of, at least). As with the first, I wouldn’t’ve minded a full novel dedicated to this, though it works well enough as an installment of novellas. I’m not a huge fan of novellas, particularly those I’ve seen from the author, but these two have so far broken the mold. Kraken’s Tooth tells a complete story, with no skimping on plot or fantasy. It’s light on details, yet still manages to convey more than enough to paint the Seven Swords in vibrant colors. I had no issue getting into or following the story, and if anything even less imagining it. Any character development does suffer from the lack of material, with details such as interpersonal relationships, reliability or anything more than brief flashbacks are absent. The characters themselves might as well be mannequins, except for Guyime, who has overcome his stoicism from Book #1 and now just seems gruff and distant (and maybe Seeker, who I’m assuming is supposed to just be mysterious, though it’s difficult to tell).
Other than the character aspect, I had no problem getting through Kraken’s Tooth. There was more than enough action and adventure to entertain, while the story holds a political undertone and throws in a bit of mystery and drama that didn’t hurt either. And as I’ve already mentioned, the world is well rendered—with just enough detail left out that the Carthula I imagined likely won’t be the same as anyone else’s—while still getting the most important aspects of the story across. It may be imperfect, but I’d definitely recommend the Seven Swords to any fan of mainstream fantasy, epic, grimdark, and more. I can’t wait to read the next installment and see where the story takes us next!
April 10, 2022
This one was very good, but not as awesome as the first book in the series. Seemed to suffer from the classic 'second book syndrome'.
Nevertheless, it was a riveting read.
Recommended.
Nevertheless, it was a riveting read.
Recommended.
August 16, 2022
Heerlijk om tijdens het wandelen te luisteren. Goed lopend verhaal, niet te moeilijk. Benieuwd naar de volgende delen
November 5, 2023
Another day another stunner from Anthony Ryan
June 20, 2024
Ik heb geen idee wat er gebeurd is
May 11, 2022
3 out of 5 stars.
I liked this book better than the first one.
One of the reasons is that there are a lot less characters, so the author gets the chance to focus a bit more on each of them. So they actually feel like people instead of cardboard cutouts. It helps that we already met Seeker and Pilgrim in the first book, so the author doesn't have to reintroduce us to them. He can focus on fleshing them out more instead.
This is where comes my first complaint. Pilgrim is the only one deserving fleshing out and a back story, it seems. Oh, we delve into his past plenty in this book. We even learn how he got bound to his demon sword. Don't get me wrong, it's interesting and I welcomed the knowledge... I just wish the author would have done the same with Seeker.
As it stands, she is still the mysterious beast master who is looking for her kidnapped daughter. Deadly with a bow, masterful in animal control, silent and not very fleshed out. We don't even get to learn her name, unlike Pilgrim. Oh, and we still haven't found her daughter, imagine that. I hope that the author pays her more attention in the next book, because she is an interesting character who deserves to come out of Pilgrim's shadow and get a voice of her own.
The world continues to be imaginative and intriguing. There are gods, demons, ancient heroes, and strange cartographers who are much older than they appear. I'm not entirely sure how all this fits together just yet, but I'm happy to stick along for the ride and hope that the hints thrown here and there in the books end up fitting into a coherent picture in the end.
Can't help but notice that so far all Pilgrim and Seeker did in their quest was bring ruin and destruction to magical places that had stood for millennia. I hope that's not a trend. Otherwise by the time Pilgrim assembles all the cursed swords, the world would be in ruins.
PS: I received an advanced copy of the book from Netgalley in exchange for an honest review.
I liked this book better than the first one.
One of the reasons is that there are a lot less characters, so the author gets the chance to focus a bit more on each of them. So they actually feel like people instead of cardboard cutouts. It helps that we already met Seeker and Pilgrim in the first book, so the author doesn't have to reintroduce us to them. He can focus on fleshing them out more instead.
This is where comes my first complaint. Pilgrim is the only one deserving fleshing out and a back story, it seems. Oh, we delve into his past plenty in this book. We even learn how he got bound to his demon sword. Don't get me wrong, it's interesting and I welcomed the knowledge... I just wish the author would have done the same with Seeker.
As it stands, she is still the mysterious beast master who is looking for her kidnapped daughter. Deadly with a bow, masterful in animal control, silent and not very fleshed out. We don't even get to learn her name, unlike Pilgrim. Oh, and we still haven't found her daughter, imagine that. I hope that the author pays her more attention in the next book, because she is an interesting character who deserves to come out of Pilgrim's shadow and get a voice of her own.
The world continues to be imaginative and intriguing. There are gods, demons, ancient heroes, and strange cartographers who are much older than they appear. I'm not entirely sure how all this fits together just yet, but I'm happy to stick along for the ride and hope that the hints thrown here and there in the books end up fitting into a coherent picture in the end.
Can't help but notice that so far all Pilgrim and Seeker did in their quest was bring ruin and destruction to magical places that had stood for millennia. I hope that's not a trend. Otherwise by the time Pilgrim assembles all the cursed swords, the world would be in ruins.
PS: I received an advanced copy of the book from Netgalley in exchange for an honest review.
October 7, 2020
Last year when Pilgrimage of Swords came out I gobbled it up from the library and loved it. I raved to my husband and friends to 'read this please!'. At the time I don't recall if I pushed out a review (I was probably several months into a high risk pregnancy) but I know I wanted to shout about it. So when I saw the chance to read The Kraken's Tooth I jumped.
Pilgrimage begins as a classic quest fantasy, but develops and twists in ways you won't see coming. The ending on this one was fantastic. By far my favorite characters were Pilgrim and Player, and the teases we got of Pilgrim were like catnip. I had to know more. He may feel, at first blush like your typically stoic hero with a soiled past but I genuinely felt a lot of the grief and anger he carried and because of that he felt well made and written.
The Kraken's Tooth picks up at the end of Pilgrimage with our primary heroes. This second book has changed the style of the writing a bit, and within the first couple of pages that becomes very clear. Pilgrim no longer goes by his moniker but by his actual name. The story feels more personal this time around, a bit more of the expected style for a today's Epic Fantasy. This doesn't hinder the story but going directly from one book to the next you can see the difference.
I can't speak too much to the plot, but I'll say (and this applies directly to Swords and Tooth) Anthony Ryan is clearly picking up very expected fantasy tropes and trying extremely hard to do them right. It works too, exceptionally well. I cringe when I see a lot of these same things used, but here, they work well.
Overall both stories keep an excellent world and atmosphere about them. Our characters feel solid and three dimensional even in the short amount of time we have them, and Anthony Ryan's use of fantasy tropes and clichés is fantastic. I highly recommend both of these.
Pilgrimage begins as a classic quest fantasy, but develops and twists in ways you won't see coming. The ending on this one was fantastic. By far my favorite characters were Pilgrim and Player, and the teases we got of Pilgrim were like catnip. I had to know more. He may feel, at first blush like your typically stoic hero with a soiled past but I genuinely felt a lot of the grief and anger he carried and because of that he felt well made and written.
The Kraken's Tooth picks up at the end of Pilgrimage with our primary heroes. This second book has changed the style of the writing a bit, and within the first couple of pages that becomes very clear. Pilgrim no longer goes by his moniker but by his actual name. The story feels more personal this time around, a bit more of the expected style for a today's Epic Fantasy. This doesn't hinder the story but going directly from one book to the next you can see the difference.
I can't speak too much to the plot, but I'll say (and this applies directly to Swords and Tooth) Anthony Ryan is clearly picking up very expected fantasy tropes and trying extremely hard to do them right. It works too, exceptionally well. I cringe when I see a lot of these same things used, but here, they work well.
Overall both stories keep an excellent world and atmosphere about them. Our characters feel solid and three dimensional even in the short amount of time we have them, and Anthony Ryan's use of fantasy tropes and clichés is fantastic. I highly recommend both of these.
January 31, 2022
This is again an action book, just like the first one. But it is interesting. The new characters are a bit shallow due to the focus on action, not on motivation. Due to the sword capability, you're exposed to their intent, but only to the extent the main character is interested in them, which is not much. The description of the environment are vivid which really set a nice pace, making the whole reading experience enjoyable, if not suspenseful.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 93 reviews