What do you think?
Rate this book
Molly Murphy #1
Murphy's Law
From the creator of the much-loved Constable Evan Evans mysteries comes a colorful new series set in turn-of-the-century New York City. When spirited redhead Molly Murphy was growing up a peasant on the coast of Ireland she always imagined there was something more in store for her. She couldn't have known how right she was until the day she became a murderer, albeit in self-defense. Under drastic circumstances, Molly is forced to strike out into a new world. With the police right behind her, Molly's only chance at escape is a false identity and a steamship that will take her far, far away: to America.
When her ship sails into New York Harbor, with the majestic figure of the Statue of Liberty providing comfort and inspiration, Molly is sure her whole life is in front of her. But she's got one last hurdle to clear: Ellis Island. She is just one among thousands of immigrants on the tiny island, awaiting their fate with anxiety and hope. Unfortunately for Molly, before she is able to leave the island a man is brutally murdered, his throat cut from ear to ear, and coincidence and fate make her a suspect in a crime she didn't commit. Under a cloud of suspicion, and due largely to a growing mutual attraction between Molly and the handsome police captain in charge of the case, she is allowed to leave Ellis Island for Manhattan. Unfortunately, she's got a mission she couldn't have anticipated: clear her own name of murder. Alone in a new country with no one to lean on, Molly hits the vibrant streets of New York intent on finding out what really happened. After all, if she can't, she'll be sent back to Ireland, where the dreaded gallows await.
With the sweeping skyline of 19th century New York and the gritty, pulsating underworld of recently arrived immigrants forming a vivid backdrop, Rhys Bowen transports readers back in time to America's not-so-distant past. The first entry in the Molly Murphy series is a fascinating look at our immigrant history as well as an intensely absorbing page-turner.
When her ship sails into New York Harbor, with the majestic figure of the Statue of Liberty providing comfort and inspiration, Molly is sure her whole life is in front of her. But she's got one last hurdle to clear: Ellis Island. She is just one among thousands of immigrants on the tiny island, awaiting their fate with anxiety and hope. Unfortunately for Molly, before she is able to leave the island a man is brutally murdered, his throat cut from ear to ear, and coincidence and fate make her a suspect in a crime she didn't commit. Under a cloud of suspicion, and due largely to a growing mutual attraction between Molly and the handsome police captain in charge of the case, she is allowed to leave Ellis Island for Manhattan. Unfortunately, she's got a mission she couldn't have anticipated: clear her own name of murder. Alone in a new country with no one to lean on, Molly hits the vibrant streets of New York intent on finding out what really happened. After all, if she can't, she'll be sent back to Ireland, where the dreaded gallows await.
With the sweeping skyline of 19th century New York and the gritty, pulsating underworld of recently arrived immigrants forming a vivid backdrop, Rhys Bowen transports readers back in time to America's not-so-distant past. The first entry in the Molly Murphy series is a fascinating look at our immigrant history as well as an intensely absorbing page-turner.
282 pages, Kindle Edition
First published October 12, 2001
About the author
Rhys Bowen
113 books8,837 followersI'm a New York Times bestselling mystery author, winner of both Agatha and Anthony awards for my Molly Murphy mysteries, set in 1902 New York City.
I have recently published four internationally bestselling WWII novels, one of them a #1 Kindle bestseller, and the Tuscan Child selling almost a million copies to date. In Farleigh Field won three major awards and was nominated for an Edgar. My other stand-alone novels are The Victory Garden, about land girls in WWI and Above the Bay of Angels, featuring a young woman who becomes chef for Queen Victoria.
April 2021 will mark the publication of THE VENICE SKETCHBOOK--another sweeping historical novel of love, loss and intrigue.
My books are currently translated into 29 languages and I have fans worldwide.
I also write the Agatha-winning Royal Spyness series, about the British royal family in the 1930s. It's lighter, sexier, funnier, wicked satire. It was voted by readers as best mystery series one year.
I am also known for my Constable Evans books, set in North Wales, and for my award-winning short stories.
I was born and raised in England but currently divide my time between California and Arizona where I go to escape from the harsh California winters
When I am not writing I love to travel, sing, hike, play my Celtic harp.
Series:
* Constable Evan Mystery
* Molly Murphy Mysteries
* Her Royal Spyness Mysteries
Awards:
Agatha Award
◊ Best Novel (2001): Murphy's Law
Reviewer's Choice Award
◊ Historical Mystery (2001): Murphy's Law
I have recently published four internationally bestselling WWII novels, one of them a #1 Kindle bestseller, and the Tuscan Child selling almost a million copies to date. In Farleigh Field won three major awards and was nominated for an Edgar. My other stand-alone novels are The Victory Garden, about land girls in WWI and Above the Bay of Angels, featuring a young woman who becomes chef for Queen Victoria.
April 2021 will mark the publication of THE VENICE SKETCHBOOK--another sweeping historical novel of love, loss and intrigue.
My books are currently translated into 29 languages and I have fans worldwide.
I also write the Agatha-winning Royal Spyness series, about the British royal family in the 1930s. It's lighter, sexier, funnier, wicked satire. It was voted by readers as best mystery series one year.
I am also known for my Constable Evans books, set in North Wales, and for my award-winning short stories.
I was born and raised in England but currently divide my time between California and Arizona where I go to escape from the harsh California winters
When I am not writing I love to travel, sing, hike, play my Celtic harp.
Series:
* Constable Evan Mystery
* Molly Murphy Mysteries
* Her Royal Spyness Mysteries
Awards:
Agatha Award
◊ Best Novel (2001): Murphy's Law
Reviewer's Choice Award
◊ Historical Mystery (2001): Murphy's Law
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 1,493 reviews
March 11, 2018
Women's history month is here and I decided to start the celebration with a bit of Irish spunk. Rhys Bowen is a celebrated writer, and my mother has been touting her Molly Murphy series for awhile now. As Irish luck would have it, my retro chapter chicks group is focusing on Irish women for the month of March. I decided that it was long overdue that I read Murphy's Law, the first of Molly Murphy's historical adventures.
Molly Murphy was never a traditional girl. She enjoyed swimming in the Atlantic Ocean, horseback riding, excelled in the classroom and was declared an "old maid" by the age of twenty three. Murphy had to be the mother to her younger brothers as her mother passed away when she was young. She did have a few suitors, yet one Englishman came on too strong to her and in the heat of the moment, she killed him. On the run from the English government who then controlled Ireland, Murphy fled her home village of Ballykillin and ended up in Liverpool, England. A chance meeting with Kathleen O'Connor lead to an instant friendship and resulted in Murphy escorting O'Connor's two young children to America as O'Connor lay dying of consumption.
On board the Majestic steamliner Murphy fell into an instant rapport with O'Connor's two children Seamus and Bridie and assumed the identity of their mother. Her goal is to bring them to their father unharmed, yet crime seems to find her. One Thomas O'Malley thinks he can manhandle Murphy along with the rest of the ship that is until Murphy puts him in his place. He leaves her alone until the ship docks in Ellis Island, until on the first night in America, O'Malley is found murdered. The easy route is to accuse Murphy and her traveling companion Michael Larkin. It is up to Murphy to prove their innocence before either is returned to Ireland and English rule and hung.
In this opening book, Bowen introduces readers to police captain Daniel O'Sullivan, with whom it appears Murphy falls into a long lasting relationship with. She also paints the historical picture of the underbelly of New York politics at the turn of the 20th century, focusing on the corruption inside of Tammany Hall. Alderman MacCormack is a picture of corruption and Murphy is determined to prove his wrong doing to the police. Yet, MacCormack is the champion of the Irish people and everyone loves him. He is the annual marshal of the upcoming St Patrick's Day parade. Murphy, however, is certain that MacCormack is behind O'Malley's murder and puts herself in harms way to prove her friend's innocence before MacCormack and his gang strike again.
Rhys Bowen magically transports her readers to turn of the century New York, a time when the hole in the ground was just that, and America was the land of opportunity. The Irish ruled the city, and Molly Murphy is ready to take it by storm. In likable characters Murphy, O'Sullivan, and the O'Connors, Bowen has created a cast who I can enjoy for the long haul. As I am currently looking for a new go to mystery series, Molly Murphy is spunky and definitely one of my main contenders.
4 stars
Molly Murphy was never a traditional girl. She enjoyed swimming in the Atlantic Ocean, horseback riding, excelled in the classroom and was declared an "old maid" by the age of twenty three. Murphy had to be the mother to her younger brothers as her mother passed away when she was young. She did have a few suitors, yet one Englishman came on too strong to her and in the heat of the moment, she killed him. On the run from the English government who then controlled Ireland, Murphy fled her home village of Ballykillin and ended up in Liverpool, England. A chance meeting with Kathleen O'Connor lead to an instant friendship and resulted in Murphy escorting O'Connor's two young children to America as O'Connor lay dying of consumption.
On board the Majestic steamliner Murphy fell into an instant rapport with O'Connor's two children Seamus and Bridie and assumed the identity of their mother. Her goal is to bring them to their father unharmed, yet crime seems to find her. One Thomas O'Malley thinks he can manhandle Murphy along with the rest of the ship that is until Murphy puts him in his place. He leaves her alone until the ship docks in Ellis Island, until on the first night in America, O'Malley is found murdered. The easy route is to accuse Murphy and her traveling companion Michael Larkin. It is up to Murphy to prove their innocence before either is returned to Ireland and English rule and hung.
In this opening book, Bowen introduces readers to police captain Daniel O'Sullivan, with whom it appears Murphy falls into a long lasting relationship with. She also paints the historical picture of the underbelly of New York politics at the turn of the 20th century, focusing on the corruption inside of Tammany Hall. Alderman MacCormack is a picture of corruption and Murphy is determined to prove his wrong doing to the police. Yet, MacCormack is the champion of the Irish people and everyone loves him. He is the annual marshal of the upcoming St Patrick's Day parade. Murphy, however, is certain that MacCormack is behind O'Malley's murder and puts herself in harms way to prove her friend's innocence before MacCormack and his gang strike again.
Rhys Bowen magically transports her readers to turn of the century New York, a time when the hole in the ground was just that, and America was the land of opportunity. The Irish ruled the city, and Molly Murphy is ready to take it by storm. In likable characters Murphy, O'Sullivan, and the O'Connors, Bowen has created a cast who I can enjoy for the long haul. As I am currently looking for a new go to mystery series, Molly Murphy is spunky and definitely one of my main contenders.
4 stars
December 30, 2018
I listened to the audiobook of this one and was so grateful that the narrator managed to do her Irish accents without sounding ridiculous. Talented indeed.
Rhys Bowen is also talented especially at setting an historical scene and describing how people went about their daily lives. The ship's crossing from Liverpool to New York was beautifully done, as was life in New York itself.
Of course Molly's experiences were not strictly run of the mill - she had so many strokes of blind luck in this book that it was necessary to totally suspend belief much of the time. But that's the way of a cosy mystery and it still makes for an enjoyable reading experience.
I liked it anyway and will continue with the series which should give me many, many hours of future reading pleasure:)
Rhys Bowen is also talented especially at setting an historical scene and describing how people went about their daily lives. The ship's crossing from Liverpool to New York was beautifully done, as was life in New York itself.
Of course Molly's experiences were not strictly run of the mill - she had so many strokes of blind luck in this book that it was necessary to totally suspend belief much of the time. But that's the way of a cosy mystery and it still makes for an enjoyable reading experience.
I liked it anyway and will continue with the series which should give me many, many hours of future reading pleasure:)
August 6, 2021
I'm unwell today so my review will not be as scintillating as usual. I'm kidding. But I have to remind myself that reading this book made me forget my illness. This book is just what the doctor ordered.
It's to my complete liking. I loved that the author didn't tarry on the many architectural upheavals of post famine New York. Some authors, like Ian Rankin, know how to describe a city. However many of these authors fail in maintaining the plot to the fore and core.
But I liked Murphy's Law as there was no padding to it. It's a rare if not unique feeling to see this kind of author. I'm definitely going to read some of the sequels to this one. Now to another book! Ta.
It's to my complete liking. I loved that the author didn't tarry on the many architectural upheavals of post famine New York. Some authors, like Ian Rankin, know how to describe a city. However many of these authors fail in maintaining the plot to the fore and core.
But I liked Murphy's Law as there was no padding to it. It's a rare if not unique feeling to see this kind of author. I'm definitely going to read some of the sequels to this one. Now to another book! Ta.
March 2, 2019
Let me into how one heroine feels, with unhampered description, dialogue, and originality and I am carried away. I am pleased to find authors who achieve this balance and surprised by “Murphy’s Law”! In 2001, it débuted Rhys Bowen’s New York series, set in March 1901. It is “standard mystery” for its serious subjects. The history into which we are immersed is stunningly realistic and more acutely-educational than we expect. Reminiscent of Anne Perry’s Thomas Pitt hero, Molly too, was educated with the children of landowners.
An important point illustrated repeatedly is that females are no one’s sexual outlet: stature be damned. No soul is above another! Molly deflected advances and worried that there would be no employment but prostitution. The gift of strong, meticulous historic vibes, education, and compassion is that they fit Rhys’s fictional story. It trots along unencumbered, so enjoyably that a crime is needless. A fly in the ointment was reiterating “whiskers”; a bizarre word choice. It was so excessive, it annoyed me enormously! She should have said “beard” once in a while! I would disregard that but the denouement floundered: a preposterous scene in which opportunities abounded for Molly to make noise and avoid capture. It was equally farfetched for the murderer to recognize the protagonist. Five stars downgraded to four.
The rest is unforgettable: a ship journey in steerage class, a two-day line-up to register at Ellis Island, how the currency-exchanger hoped to steal from immigrants who couldn’t count. Neighbourhoods were grouped ethnically and only employed their races. Rhys surely had a relative who told her what it was like, to write so perceptively. She achieves regular humour as well. “Murphy’s Law” was on my shopping list, until I noticed I owned the hardcover first edition! I have turned out to be a fan.
An important point illustrated repeatedly is that females are no one’s sexual outlet: stature be damned. No soul is above another! Molly deflected advances and worried that there would be no employment but prostitution. The gift of strong, meticulous historic vibes, education, and compassion is that they fit Rhys’s fictional story. It trots along unencumbered, so enjoyably that a crime is needless. A fly in the ointment was reiterating “whiskers”; a bizarre word choice. It was so excessive, it annoyed me enormously! She should have said “beard” once in a while! I would disregard that but the denouement floundered: a preposterous scene in which opportunities abounded for Molly to make noise and avoid capture. It was equally farfetched for the murderer to recognize the protagonist. Five stars downgraded to four.
The rest is unforgettable: a ship journey in steerage class, a two-day line-up to register at Ellis Island, how the currency-exchanger hoped to steal from immigrants who couldn’t count. Neighbourhoods were grouped ethnically and only employed their races. Rhys surely had a relative who told her what it was like, to write so perceptively. She achieves regular humour as well. “Murphy’s Law” was on my shopping list, until I noticed I owned the hardcover first edition! I have turned out to be a fan.
May 6, 2016
*4.5 stars
I have been wanting to read this series for awhile now. I absolutely love the Royal Spyness novels by Rhys Bowen! So I couldn't wait to read her Molly Murphy books. Of course, I've waited a long time but I FINALLY got to the first one! I can honestly say I am not disappointed at all! I love RB's writing. She makes me want to read all her books. I adored Molly--she was a spunky, independent, red headed Irish lass. I also enjoyed Daniel Sullivan.... I can't wait to see where their relationship goes (although I do have somewhat of an idea). The mystery was ok but it's the characters that make these stories good for me:) I will be reading the rest of this series.....I've already bought a few of them at the library sale.
I have been wanting to read this series for awhile now. I absolutely love the Royal Spyness novels by Rhys Bowen! So I couldn't wait to read her Molly Murphy books. Of course, I've waited a long time but I FINALLY got to the first one! I can honestly say I am not disappointed at all! I love RB's writing. She makes me want to read all her books. I adored Molly--she was a spunky, independent, red headed Irish lass. I also enjoyed Daniel Sullivan.... I can't wait to see where their relationship goes (although I do have somewhat of an idea). The mystery was ok but it's the characters that make these stories good for me:) I will be reading the rest of this series.....I've already bought a few of them at the library sale.
February 19, 2015
1.5 to 2 stars
This was just...not good. Maybe it's first book syndrome or maybe this was the author's first ever published book but whatever the case may be, it felt like it could have been written by a high school senior. The heroine, fleeing from the law in Ireland, manages to make her way to New York, in what I can only surmise is the late 1800s or early 1900s, through a series of highly (and totally unrealistic) fortuitous events. And that pretty much sums up Molly's experiences throughout the book. Despite being a naive Irish immigrant in her first big city, Molly manages to always stumble across the exact person she wants...out of all the hundreds of thousands of people in New York, and all manner of sordid types in the seediest parts of town let her go simply because they're amused by her spunk. Puh-leeze. I know this bit of historical fiction leans heavily towards the cozy mystery genre and thus some fluff is to be expected but this was even too dumb by those standards.
This was just...not good. Maybe it's first book syndrome or maybe this was the author's first ever published book but whatever the case may be, it felt like it could have been written by a high school senior. The heroine, fleeing from the law in Ireland, manages to make her way to New York, in what I can only surmise is the late 1800s or early 1900s, through a series of highly (and totally unrealistic) fortuitous events. And that pretty much sums up Molly's experiences throughout the book. Despite being a naive Irish immigrant in her first big city, Molly manages to always stumble across the exact person she wants...out of all the hundreds of thousands of people in New York, and all manner of sordid types in the seediest parts of town let her go simply because they're amused by her spunk. Puh-leeze. I know this bit of historical fiction leans heavily towards the cozy mystery genre and thus some fluff is to be expected but this was even too dumb by those standards.
June 13, 2017
Really enjoyed that one. So much so that I'm going to treat myself to # 2. Light reading but very entertaining.
September 20, 2011
Another entry into my historical mystery jag, this one was VERY similar to the other series I read, but for some reason I enjoyed it a bit less, which surprised me because I like this author's other historical series set in the 20's a lot.
Basically it started out really well, the heroine's journey to America, but for some reason after that she was a BIT too perfect and spunky for my tastes. And the love interest was really thinly drawn, which is probably my biggest criticism.
There's some interesting historical research though, especially to do with the Irish in NYC that I thought was cool, and I liked the mystery a lot. I may pick up the next book to see where it goes, definitely was a promising start!
Basically it started out really well, the heroine's journey to America, but for some reason after that she was a BIT too perfect and spunky for my tastes. And the love interest was really thinly drawn, which is probably my biggest criticism.
There's some interesting historical research though, especially to do with the Irish in NYC that I thought was cool, and I liked the mystery a lot. I may pick up the next book to see where it goes, definitely was a promising start!
July 3, 2023
This review was written on my Facebook page in 2018...
My 12 year old granddaughter (at the time) told me she was reading this book for her Language Arts class.
Being a mystery lover, and having read and discussed Rhys Bowen’s “Naughty in Nice – A Royal Spyness Mystery” on September 28, 2016 in our Library Book Discussion Group, I thought why not try this series, too. After all, it might be interesting to have a discussion about this book with my granddaughter.
Bowen has written a lovely, gentle mystery wrapped in historical fiction - with a dash of endgame romance.
She does a beautiful job of exploring the Irish immigrant experience coming to America during the early nineteenth century; as well as capturing the daunting process maneuvering through Ellis Island and on to the tempestuous streets and cramped tenement housing of Tammany-corrupt New York City.
I love the wit and steely resolve that Molly Murphy exhibits. She is such a captivating personality.
Following Molly navigate the streets of New York City to solve murders and make a life for herself is a journey I look forward to in the continuing books of this series.
Easy read and very entertaining.
My 12 year old granddaughter (at the time) told me she was reading this book for her Language Arts class.
Being a mystery lover, and having read and discussed Rhys Bowen’s “Naughty in Nice – A Royal Spyness Mystery” on September 28, 2016 in our Library Book Discussion Group, I thought why not try this series, too. After all, it might be interesting to have a discussion about this book with my granddaughter.
Bowen has written a lovely, gentle mystery wrapped in historical fiction - with a dash of endgame romance.
She does a beautiful job of exploring the Irish immigrant experience coming to America during the early nineteenth century; as well as capturing the daunting process maneuvering through Ellis Island and on to the tempestuous streets and cramped tenement housing of Tammany-corrupt New York City.
I love the wit and steely resolve that Molly Murphy exhibits. She is such a captivating personality.
Following Molly navigate the streets of New York City to solve murders and make a life for herself is a journey I look forward to in the continuing books of this series.
Easy read and very entertaining.
May 19, 2023
I just finished this first book this afternoon and they were so good. I read them out of order as I did not realize this was a series. I especially enjoyed reading about her trip on a ship from the UK to NYC. When I was very young we went on a troop ship from Port Angeles to Yokohoma, Japan and it was just about as bad but we did get to see a whale which came up to the ship. That was very exciting for me.
Molly manages to get herself into one scrape after another so she is very entertaining. I wish there was another one and these could go on for years!
Molly manages to get herself into one scrape after another so she is very entertaining. I wish there was another one and these could go on for years!
June 4, 2017
This was one of those stories that GRs kept sending me a recommendation because I enjoy historical mysteries. That said.....
'Lord knows I never meant to kill him.'
A native of Ireland, Molly Murphy was on the run after thwarting an attack by one of the local gentry. As luck would have it, she had taken on the identity of a young mother before sailing for America and a new life. Before the voyage to her adopted country was over, she earned a friendship and made an enemy. Then a gruesome murder took place and Detective Daniel Sullivan took charge. He was a member of New York's Finest.
As in most first stories in a series, the setting was launched and important characters were introduced. Molly became Kathleen O'Connor, mother of two little ones in search of her 'husband'. She needed to find a job. She constantly placed herself in awkward situations and found Daniel calling her into his office.
I enjoyed the mystery; I thought the author did a good job researching the time period. I felt the friction between Molly and Daniel and knew at some point they would become involved. I just didn't know the when or why. The biggest issue I had with Murphy's Law was the awkward situations I mentioned above. I had a difficult time imaging a single woman on her own traveling to the seedier parts of the city and not being mugged or raped. Yes, she was gutsy but I don't think she made the wisest decisions.
Since I was left with some unanswered questions, I made the mistake of reading a few reviews of the next story. I don't like the direction that Daniel and Molly's relationship is leaning. Because of this, I most likely will not continue with the series. :((
'Lord knows I never meant to kill him.'
A native of Ireland, Molly Murphy was on the run after thwarting an attack by one of the local gentry. As luck would have it, she had taken on the identity of a young mother before sailing for America and a new life. Before the voyage to her adopted country was over, she earned a friendship and made an enemy. Then a gruesome murder took place and Detective Daniel Sullivan took charge. He was a member of New York's Finest.
As in most first stories in a series, the setting was launched and important characters were introduced. Molly became Kathleen O'Connor, mother of two little ones in search of her 'husband'. She needed to find a job. She constantly placed herself in awkward situations and found Daniel calling her into his office.
I enjoyed the mystery; I thought the author did a good job researching the time period. I felt the friction between Molly and Daniel and knew at some point they would become involved. I just didn't know the when or why. The biggest issue I had with Murphy's Law was the awkward situations I mentioned above. I had a difficult time imaging a single woman on her own traveling to the seedier parts of the city and not being mugged or raped. Yes, she was gutsy but I don't think she made the wisest decisions.
Since I was left with some unanswered questions, I made the mistake of reading a few reviews of the next story. I don't like the direction that Daniel and Molly's relationship is leaning. Because of this, I most likely will not continue with the series. :((
July 5, 2023
Really enjoyed this! Thought Molly was such a fun, vibrant character who was just trying to do the right thing and caught in a lot of bad situations. I loved the banter between her and Daniel, too. That’s going to be fun to read more of in the series. And of course, early 1900’s NYC? So fun. Definitely will pick up the next one soon!
May 31, 2019
Sadly wasn’t a fan. Love the other authors series but I just couldn’t get into this one at all
December 1, 2015
SUMMARY: From the creator of the much-loved Constable Evan Evans mysteries comes a colorful new series set in turn-of-the-century New York City. When spirited redhead Molly Murphy was growing up a peasant on the coast of Ireland she always imagined there was something more in store for her. She couldn't have known how right she was until the day she became a murderer, albeit in self-defense. Under drastic circumstances, Molly is forced to strike out into a new world. With the police right behind her, Molly's only chance at escape is a false identity and a steamship that will take her far, far away: to America.
When her ship sails into New York Harbor, with the majestic figure of the Statue of Liberty providing comfort and inspiration, Molly is sure her whole life is in front of her. But she's got one last hurdle to clear: Ellis Island. She is just one among thousands of immigrants on the tiny island, awaiting their fate with anxiety and hope. Unfortunately for Molly, before she is able to leave the island a man is brutally murdered, his throat cut from ear to ear, and coincidence and fate make her a suspect in a crime she didn't commit. Under a cloud of suspicion, and due largely to a growing mutual attraction between Molly and the handsome police captain in charge of the case, she is allowed to leave Ellis Island for Manhattan. Unfortunately, she's got a mission she couldn't have anticipated: clear her own name of murder. Alone in a new country with no one to lean on, Molly hits the vibrant streets of New York intent on finding out what really happened. After all, if she can't, she'll be sent back to Ireland, where the dreaded gallows await.
With the sweeping skyline of 19th century New York and the gritty, pulsating underworld of recently arrived immigrants forming a vivid backdrop, Rhys Bowen transports readers back in time to America's not-so-distant past. The first entry in the Molly Murphy series is a fascinating look at our immigrant history as well as an intensely absorbing page-turner.
REVIEW: Although this is a secular read, it is very clean and the storyline is excellent. The author has well researched New York in the early 1900's and this shows throughout the novel adding to the development of the story.. The storyline is intriguing and definitely keeps the reader's interest. Molly is a feisty, headstrong, independent woman who isn't afraid (sometimes to her detriment) to tackle anything in trying to find the murderer and exonerate Michael. The relationship development between her and Daniel (the Irish policeman in charge of the investigation) as well as that of her and Kathleen's children are sweet and tender.
This is a fun read with an enjoyable Irish lass in old New York City. I look forward to reading more in this sereis.
When her ship sails into New York Harbor, with the majestic figure of the Statue of Liberty providing comfort and inspiration, Molly is sure her whole life is in front of her. But she's got one last hurdle to clear: Ellis Island. She is just one among thousands of immigrants on the tiny island, awaiting their fate with anxiety and hope. Unfortunately for Molly, before she is able to leave the island a man is brutally murdered, his throat cut from ear to ear, and coincidence and fate make her a suspect in a crime she didn't commit. Under a cloud of suspicion, and due largely to a growing mutual attraction between Molly and the handsome police captain in charge of the case, she is allowed to leave Ellis Island for Manhattan. Unfortunately, she's got a mission she couldn't have anticipated: clear her own name of murder. Alone in a new country with no one to lean on, Molly hits the vibrant streets of New York intent on finding out what really happened. After all, if she can't, she'll be sent back to Ireland, where the dreaded gallows await.
With the sweeping skyline of 19th century New York and the gritty, pulsating underworld of recently arrived immigrants forming a vivid backdrop, Rhys Bowen transports readers back in time to America's not-so-distant past. The first entry in the Molly Murphy series is a fascinating look at our immigrant history as well as an intensely absorbing page-turner.
REVIEW: Although this is a secular read, it is very clean and the storyline is excellent. The author has well researched New York in the early 1900's and this shows throughout the novel adding to the development of the story.. The storyline is intriguing and definitely keeps the reader's interest. Molly is a feisty, headstrong, independent woman who isn't afraid (sometimes to her detriment) to tackle anything in trying to find the murderer and exonerate Michael. The relationship development between her and Daniel (the Irish policeman in charge of the investigation) as well as that of her and Kathleen's children are sweet and tender.
This is a fun read with an enjoyable Irish lass in old New York City. I look forward to reading more in this sereis.
September 1, 2013
I have been meaning to read the Molly Murphy series by Rhys Bowen for quite a while. Finally, I have read the first book in the series, Murphy's Law, and I can't believe I waited so long. I love the character of Molly Murphy, an Irish young woman who unexpectedly finds herself running from the English police and on a boat to America. She makes a deal with another young woman who is trying to get her children to New York City to be with their father. Molly agrees to escort the children when the woman gives her ticket to Molly because the mother is dying from consumption and not allowed to board the ship.
Molly's hope of arriving in America and quickly fading into the background of the masses is derailed when a murder occurs among the immigrants while waiting to leave Ellis Island, their point of entry to New York City. Our sassy Irish lass is discovered to have been in the vicinity of the murder during the hours it took place, so she must face further delay and suspicions from the police before embarking on her new life. The policeman in charge, Cpt. Daniel Sullivan, is an attractive descendent of what is known as the "black Irish," and he takes a keen interest in Molly's connection to the murder. After finally being released to enter NYC, Molly takes her two charges and meets their father. Her living arrangements at the father's cousin's apartment are precarious at best and don't last long. With the arrest of one of Molly's friends from onboard the ship to America as the murder suspect, Molly's challenges in starting a new life become complicated. Searching for the real murderer to clear her friend's name, trying to find employment, and needing a place to live all converge on Molly at once. She has her work cut out for her in this new world. Luckily, Molly Murhpy is one plucky gal, and she meets challenges head on with determination and strength.
Rhys Bowen has created a character-driven series that I am delighted to have finally started reading. I love the wit and steely resolve that Molly Murphy exhibits. She is such a captivating personality, bringing fresh air to all she encounters. Of course, for Captain Daniel Sullivan, Molly often brings exasperation along, too. Following Molly navigate the streets of New York City to solve murders and make a life for herself is a journey I look forward to in the continuing books of this series.
Molly's hope of arriving in America and quickly fading into the background of the masses is derailed when a murder occurs among the immigrants while waiting to leave Ellis Island, their point of entry to New York City. Our sassy Irish lass is discovered to have been in the vicinity of the murder during the hours it took place, so she must face further delay and suspicions from the police before embarking on her new life. The policeman in charge, Cpt. Daniel Sullivan, is an attractive descendent of what is known as the "black Irish," and he takes a keen interest in Molly's connection to the murder. After finally being released to enter NYC, Molly takes her two charges and meets their father. Her living arrangements at the father's cousin's apartment are precarious at best and don't last long. With the arrest of one of Molly's friends from onboard the ship to America as the murder suspect, Molly's challenges in starting a new life become complicated. Searching for the real murderer to clear her friend's name, trying to find employment, and needing a place to live all converge on Molly at once. She has her work cut out for her in this new world. Luckily, Molly Murhpy is one plucky gal, and she meets challenges head on with determination and strength.
Rhys Bowen has created a character-driven series that I am delighted to have finally started reading. I love the wit and steely resolve that Molly Murphy exhibits. She is such a captivating personality, bringing fresh air to all she encounters. Of course, for Captain Daniel Sullivan, Molly often brings exasperation along, too. Following Molly navigate the streets of New York City to solve murders and make a life for herself is a journey I look forward to in the continuing books of this series.
April 28, 2016
The mystery was probably the least interesting thing for me. I liked Molly, I liked Daniel and I loved the setting. Bowen really paints a vivid picture of NY at this time and how the Irish, Italians, Jews, etc., all formed their own tight-knit communities. The setting jumped off the page and was, in my opinion, the strongest thing about this book.
As for the mystery, everything relating to that felt a little too coincidental. I didn't really believe that so many things could align just right to keep putting Molly in the right place at the right time. Take the mystery out of this and I think I would have enjoyed this a lot more.
As for the mystery, everything relating to that felt a little too coincidental. I didn't really believe that so many things could align just right to keep putting Molly in the right place at the right time. Take the mystery out of this and I think I would have enjoyed this a lot more.
March 14, 2018
I look forward to the rest of this series.
New York, 1901
New York, 1901
December 3, 2023
Nice
I really enjoyed the story, love the Irish in NY theme. Molly is a bit of a frustrating character, but am looking forward to the next book.
I really enjoyed the story, love the Irish in NY theme. Molly is a bit of a frustrating character, but am looking forward to the next book.
August 29, 2015
I've read and enjoyed all of Ms. Bowen's Royal Spyness mysteries and have loved them, so when I was putting in my last order at my library I finally decided to include the first in her Molly Murphy series, which I'd heard nothing but good things about. I can say that I don't regret ordering them! This was a fun book that I read in one sitting.
In Murphy's Law Molly Murphy accidentally kills a man and because of her circumstances she must flee Ireland. She soon finds herself on a boat to America caring for two children. Once she reaches New York a murder happens, and Molly soon becomes a suspect. Molly soon begins to investigate to clear her name, before she lands behind bars, or worse, shipped back to Ireland.
I absolutely loved Molly, she was fiercely independent, yet at the same time loyal to those close to her. She thought everything through and used reason instead of feelings to dictate what she did; she was all-in-all a very strong main character that I enjoyed reading about. Daniel was also a fun character, who has a few similarities with one of Ms. Bowen's other characters in her Royal Spyness series, Darcy. However, despite their similarities, they are in no way carbon copies of each other and are separate enough that I don't think Daniel will do what Darcy does, or vice-versa.
The mystery was good, slightly above average. The murder victim was well-hated by almost everyone, so there were a lot of suspects. Molly didn't bombard suspects with questions, she used logic and quiet investigating to find the murderer, which I like. The murderer was a small surprise, and the scene where the murderer was ousted was wonderfully suspenseful.
Overall a wonderful book. With great characters, an above average mystery, and a great setting Murphy's Law gets 5/5 stars. I'm already half-way through the next one!
In Murphy's Law Molly Murphy accidentally kills a man and because of her circumstances she must flee Ireland. She soon finds herself on a boat to America caring for two children. Once she reaches New York a murder happens, and Molly soon becomes a suspect. Molly soon begins to investigate to clear her name, before she lands behind bars, or worse, shipped back to Ireland.
I absolutely loved Molly, she was fiercely independent, yet at the same time loyal to those close to her. She thought everything through and used reason instead of feelings to dictate what she did; she was all-in-all a very strong main character that I enjoyed reading about. Daniel was also a fun character, who has a few similarities with one of Ms. Bowen's other characters in her Royal Spyness series, Darcy. However, despite their similarities, they are in no way carbon copies of each other and are separate enough that I don't think Daniel will do what Darcy does, or vice-versa.
The mystery was good, slightly above average. The murder victim was well-hated by almost everyone, so there were a lot of suspects. Molly didn't bombard suspects with questions, she used logic and quiet investigating to find the murderer, which I like. The murderer was a small surprise, and the scene where the murderer was ousted was wonderfully suspenseful.
Overall a wonderful book. With great characters, an above average mystery, and a great setting Murphy's Law gets 5/5 stars. I'm already half-way through the next one!
December 2, 2018
A new series for me. Molly Murphy escapes Ireland after killing a man in self defense. She arrives in New York in 1901 at Ellis Island and gets embroiled in a murder. Staying in a slum with an Irish family she helped out by escorting two children to their father. The squalor, poverty and general horribleness is captured well. Her narrow escapes and luck is hard to swallow and you have to suspend belief with all the coincidences and her luck. A good read.
June 25, 2015
The first book in the series. Molly Murphy fleeing for her life accepts an offer to take two children to America as their Mother. Arriving at Ellis Island she becomes a suspect in a murder of a follow passenger. Using her wits she must clear name. As an immigrate New York City is strange to her. Will she be able to clear name?
June 11, 2017
3 1/2 stars.
January 14, 2016
Agatha winner from 2001. Set in turn of the century New York, Molly Murphy has fled her native Ireland after fending off the advances of a member of the landed gentry. She has the bad luck to have been the cause of bad fall, resulting in a dead English man.
I listened to this book. The narration was enjoyable. Molly was, sometimes, a bit overly clueless - the incident where she is nearly trapped into prostitution is silly. No one is that stupid. The love interest sounds adorable, but has little actual personality. But, the book was engaging and the setting was enjoyable. I'd definitely give book 2 a try.
I listened to this book. The narration was enjoyable. Molly was, sometimes, a bit overly clueless - the incident where she is nearly trapped into prostitution is silly. No one is that stupid. The love interest sounds adorable, but has little actual personality. But, the book was engaging and the setting was enjoyable. I'd definitely give book 2 a try.
July 1, 2021
Ich liebe die Reihe 'Im Auftrag ihrer Majestät' von der Autorin und so war ich gespannt, ob mich auch Molly Murphy wird begeistern können, aber leider hat es zunächst nicht so gefunkt wie erhofft. Erst gegen Ende des Buches hat mich die Geschichte einfangen können.
Das Cover von Molly Murphy sieht frisch aus und eher wie ein Krimi, der auf der heiteren Seite des Crimes ist, doch da sollte man sich nicht täuschen. Molly Murphy spielt zu einem großen Teil in ärmlichsten Verhältnissen, die sicher sehr realistisch sind, aber kein Umfeld um zu entspannen und die ganze Trübnis der realen Welt auszublenden, wie ich es mir bei dem Cover erhoffte. Geschichtlich hat das Buch mich fasziniert und die Autorin hat es geschafft mich in die Zeit mitzunehmen. Eine zu den ländlichen Cottages in Irland, einer Schiffsreise nach Amerika und den beeindruckenden Wolkenkratzern in New York. Die damalige Zeit lebt auf und ich fühlte mich auch emotional mitgenommen. Die Problematiken des Auswanderns, die Armut und auch die Ungerechtigkeit Iren gegenüber werden gut geschildert. Gegen Ende des Buches hatte ich mich so gut eingelebt, dass ich einem zweiten Band nicht abgeneigt wäre.
Das Buch wurde mir vom Verlag als Rezensionsexemplar zur Verfügung gestellt.
Das Cover von Molly Murphy sieht frisch aus und eher wie ein Krimi, der auf der heiteren Seite des Crimes ist, doch da sollte man sich nicht täuschen. Molly Murphy spielt zu einem großen Teil in ärmlichsten Verhältnissen, die sicher sehr realistisch sind, aber kein Umfeld um zu entspannen und die ganze Trübnis der realen Welt auszublenden, wie ich es mir bei dem Cover erhoffte. Geschichtlich hat das Buch mich fasziniert und die Autorin hat es geschafft mich in die Zeit mitzunehmen. Eine zu den ländlichen Cottages in Irland, einer Schiffsreise nach Amerika und den beeindruckenden Wolkenkratzern in New York. Die damalige Zeit lebt auf und ich fühlte mich auch emotional mitgenommen. Die Problematiken des Auswanderns, die Armut und auch die Ungerechtigkeit Iren gegenüber werden gut geschildert. Gegen Ende des Buches hatte ich mich so gut eingelebt, dass ich einem zweiten Band nicht abgeneigt wäre.
Das Buch wurde mir vom Verlag als Rezensionsexemplar zur Verfügung gestellt.
February 21, 2020
Vibrant portrait of turn of the twentieth century New York in a cosy with a spunky Irish heroine.
The first outing in Rhys Bowen’s historical cosy crime series featuring flame-haired and spunky Irish immigrant, Molly Murphy, makes for an entertaining read with a compelling sense of place full of delightful turn of the twentieth century period detail.
In the week before she turns twenty-three, principled Molly Murphy of the village of Ballykillin, County Mayo accidentally kills the son of a wealthy English landowner whilst defending her honour. Despite committing the crime in self-defence, Molly knows killing a member of the gentry is a hanging offence and flees her small village for passage to England. Cold, tired and hungry after a day spent in a Liverpool replete with signs in factories saying, ‘No Irish Need Apply’, a flagging Molly is given shelter by a fellow Irishwoman. Mother of two, Kathleen O’Connor, is due to sail on the Majestic to New York with her young children the very next day where her husband, Seamus, awaits. A heart-wrenching confession by Kathleen that she is suffering from consumption and will fail the necessary medical sees Molly take her place and sail under another woman’s name and with her children in tow in order to safely deposit them with their father.
With the crossing taking seven days and the passengers in steerage confined in close proximity, Molly attracts the attentions of a leering loudmouth by the name of O’Malley, whom she subsequently slaps for his cheek. But Molly is not the only passenger that reptilian O’Malley tries to make trouble for and sincere young Michael Larkin, who is only too willing to help Molly entertain the children, is another. As Lady Liberty welcomes the Majestic to the New World and the travellers await processing on Ellis Island the discovery that O’Malley had been murdered overnight in his bed puts a temporary halt to the influx of arrivals until the guilty party is identified. When Michael is arrested, a fiercely determined Molly feels duty-bound to clear her friends name.
Pretending to be Mrs Kathleen O’Connor, lodging with Seamus and his cousins in a filthy and cramped room on the Lower East Side, trying to get a job and trying to clear an innocent man’s name sees Molly take some serious risks as she starts sleuthing and snooping! More blunderer than gifted detective, Captain Daniel Sullivan of the NYPD and Irish stock bears witness to many of her escapades in an unrelenting effort to identify the real killer whilst he is simultaneously earbashed and amused by her theories.
As Molly follows the course of her investigation around the city the narrative gives a impressively vivid portrayal of what life was like for the many immigrants who flocked to the New World and how the city was characterised by pockets of different nationalities. As her bluster and smart mouth take Molly into some unexpected quarters the novel also makes for an introduction into the corridors of power in a Tammany Hall controlled by the Irish. Furthermore the details on the freedom fighters and the hostility between the English and Irish of the era in Molly’s native country raises awareness of the political landscape across the Atlantic.
With the exception of Molly and charming police Captain Daniel Sullivan the characterisation of the wider cast is a little flat, however the chemistry and burgeoning romance between the two lead characters is charming rather than overpowering and keeps the novel zipping along. Admittedly Molly relies on convenience and benefits from luck more than judgement, wrongly pinning the crime on two innocent men before identifying the guilty party, but for the sense of place and period colour alone - even without likeable and well-intentioned Molly Murphy - this is a series I intend to read more of.
The first outing in Rhys Bowen’s historical cosy crime series featuring flame-haired and spunky Irish immigrant, Molly Murphy, makes for an entertaining read with a compelling sense of place full of delightful turn of the twentieth century period detail.
In the week before she turns twenty-three, principled Molly Murphy of the village of Ballykillin, County Mayo accidentally kills the son of a wealthy English landowner whilst defending her honour. Despite committing the crime in self-defence, Molly knows killing a member of the gentry is a hanging offence and flees her small village for passage to England. Cold, tired and hungry after a day spent in a Liverpool replete with signs in factories saying, ‘No Irish Need Apply’, a flagging Molly is given shelter by a fellow Irishwoman. Mother of two, Kathleen O’Connor, is due to sail on the Majestic to New York with her young children the very next day where her husband, Seamus, awaits. A heart-wrenching confession by Kathleen that she is suffering from consumption and will fail the necessary medical sees Molly take her place and sail under another woman’s name and with her children in tow in order to safely deposit them with their father.
With the crossing taking seven days and the passengers in steerage confined in close proximity, Molly attracts the attentions of a leering loudmouth by the name of O’Malley, whom she subsequently slaps for his cheek. But Molly is not the only passenger that reptilian O’Malley tries to make trouble for and sincere young Michael Larkin, who is only too willing to help Molly entertain the children, is another. As Lady Liberty welcomes the Majestic to the New World and the travellers await processing on Ellis Island the discovery that O’Malley had been murdered overnight in his bed puts a temporary halt to the influx of arrivals until the guilty party is identified. When Michael is arrested, a fiercely determined Molly feels duty-bound to clear her friends name.
Pretending to be Mrs Kathleen O’Connor, lodging with Seamus and his cousins in a filthy and cramped room on the Lower East Side, trying to get a job and trying to clear an innocent man’s name sees Molly take some serious risks as she starts sleuthing and snooping! More blunderer than gifted detective, Captain Daniel Sullivan of the NYPD and Irish stock bears witness to many of her escapades in an unrelenting effort to identify the real killer whilst he is simultaneously earbashed and amused by her theories.
As Molly follows the course of her investigation around the city the narrative gives a impressively vivid portrayal of what life was like for the many immigrants who flocked to the New World and how the city was characterised by pockets of different nationalities. As her bluster and smart mouth take Molly into some unexpected quarters the novel also makes for an introduction into the corridors of power in a Tammany Hall controlled by the Irish. Furthermore the details on the freedom fighters and the hostility between the English and Irish of the era in Molly’s native country raises awareness of the political landscape across the Atlantic.
With the exception of Molly and charming police Captain Daniel Sullivan the characterisation of the wider cast is a little flat, however the chemistry and burgeoning romance between the two lead characters is charming rather than overpowering and keeps the novel zipping along. Admittedly Molly relies on convenience and benefits from luck more than judgement, wrongly pinning the crime on two innocent men before identifying the guilty party, but for the sense of place and period colour alone - even without likeable and well-intentioned Molly Murphy - this is a series I intend to read more of.
July 3, 2023
Quite an enjoyable historical mystery featuring the spunky heroine Molly Murphy who travells from Ireland where she has 'accidentally' murdered a landowner who was trying to rape her. And because he was a rich man, and she a poor girl, Molly knows she has no option but to escape. When chance hands her a ticket on a ship sailing to NY under an assumed identity of a married woman, she takes it with both hands. In turn, she has to deliver two kids to their father who is already in the USA.
But as Murphy's law has it, things don't go right for our Ms Murphy right from the beginning of her journey, and when a man who was seen arguing with her on the ship is found dead when they reach the port, she is definitely a suspect. From there, she has to manage to find a place to live, a place to work, help a friend who's almost certainly going to be hanged for the murder on the ship and manage all this alongside her burning feelings for the inspector in charge for whom she is a married woman with kids! Phew! Quite a lot on Molly's plate for sure.
I definitely enjoyed the book mainly because of Molly's character and I think I will read the next in the series, although I am in no hurry to do so. Recommended for when you're in the mood for a light, historical mystery with a heroine to cheer for.
But as Murphy's law has it, things don't go right for our Ms Murphy right from the beginning of her journey, and when a man who was seen arguing with her on the ship is found dead when they reach the port, she is definitely a suspect. From there, she has to manage to find a place to live, a place to work, help a friend who's almost certainly going to be hanged for the murder on the ship and manage all this alongside her burning feelings for the inspector in charge for whom she is a married woman with kids! Phew! Quite a lot on Molly's plate for sure.
I definitely enjoyed the book mainly because of Molly's character and I think I will read the next in the series, although I am in no hurry to do so. Recommended for when you're in the mood for a light, historical mystery with a heroine to cheer for.
July 25, 2021
I had to keep my patience with Irish amateur sleuth, Molly Murphy because it took awhile before the "mystery" really got underway. In this first installment in the series, Molly must leave Ireland and heads to America using the identity of another Irish woman. But her arrival on Ellis Island is overshadowed by a murder and all fingers appear to point to Molly.
I enjoyed the narrator and I was soon deep in the plot trying to figure it all out. I have also used an Audible credit for the 2nd book in the series.
Goodreads review published 25/07/21
I enjoyed the narrator and I was soon deep in the plot trying to figure it all out. I have also used an Audible credit for the 2nd book in the series.
Goodreads review published 25/07/21
March 21, 2017
3.8 Stars...for this first book in a new mystery series starring Molly Murphy...who finds that she must escape from Ireland in 1901 or face charges for killing a man who tries to rape her. She finds passage to America as the caretaker of two small children whose father awaits them in New York. Upon arrival, Molly finds life in the big city far from magical as she sets out to make a new life but first finds herself tangled up with murder, shady politics and the "charmingly-frustrated-with-her" NYPD's own Detective Daniel Sullivan. Being the granddaughter of Irish immigrants who settle in NYC, and the daughter of their second son born in 1918, it was an eyeopener for me to see New York City as it was for my own family and the many others alighting onto its shores hoping for a better life but finding themselves alone and penniless among the congested and often unfriendly streets of Lower Manhattan.
August 23, 2020
Really enjoyed reading this book! Looking forward to the next book in the series!
May 21, 2015
like books set during the turn of the century from around the late part of the Gilded age on through the 20s. I especially like them set in New York during this time. One of the first books I ever read that spurred my interest in this time period was The Alienist
It can be challenging to find good genre fiction set during this time, so when I do I tend to try to read it.
I had good luck with The Nell Sweeney Historical Mysteries: A Six-Book Boxed Set Series so when these came across my radar, I decided to give this one a try.
I wasn't crazy about this book. But I am chalking it up to what I call 'first book in a series' syndrome. Sometimes when you read the first book in a series, it feel like set up or the author hasn't really found the the core of their characters. Or maybe they are still figuring out how they want to tell their story. Whatever it is, this book seemed to suffer from it.
In this book Molly Murphy flees from Ireland to England because she has killed a man. An overzealous landowner's son who tried to have his wicked way with her. Because Molly was educated along with the daughters of the household (the lady of the house liked Molly's sassiness) , she has always been viewed as being a bit uppity. But in the end she is a poor Irish girl who killed a man of property. So she gets the heck out of dodge real quick.
Luckily (and Molly has a LOT of luck throughout this book) she manages in quick succession to meet a young mother in London who needs a HUGE favor. Would Molly take her place on a ship to America? The young mother can't go. And, oh by the way, please deliver her two kids to their dad who sent them the tickets.
This sets off a chain of events where Molly meets memorable people on the passage over starting with the victim of a murder and ending with the poor guy who is arrested for it. But not before Molly herself is a suspect.
This is what precipitates Molly's foray into amateur sleuthing. She first needs to make sure her own name is clear, then she needs to clear the name of her young friend who was arrested.
There are really great parts of the book. These seem to be the parts where the author has dome some research in order to create the setting. I think the book really sings when the author is describing the passage over on the ship with all the poor immigrants in steerage and the relationships they forge due to the enforced closeness. And then the arrival onto Ellis Island, the process the immigrants had to tho through to get entry as well as the sights and sounds of a young New York City as seen through the eyes of someone like Molly. These passages were fun to read and did a lot to create a sense of time and place.
Also, Molly was a good main character to act as a narrator. She was engaging and smart. And I can tell a mile away that Daniel Sullivan, the handsome police captain she meets in New York will probably be a love interest in upcoming books.
But that was not enough to make the book truly work. The weakness was all the stuff dealing with Molly's amateur sleuthing. It was chock full of coincidences, luck and, given some of the stuff Molly did in her 'detecting', an alarming lack of real danger. Molly was frankly homeless and mostly penniless and wandered around New York all hours of the day and night. She asked the most obvious and blundering questions and leaped to conclusions that always seemed to be right or at least lead her onto the right track. And Daniel also seemed to pop up conveniently whenever Molly needed him.
So as a satisfying mystery is didn't quite do it for me. But there is something there and I will probably try the next book to see if this really is a case of 'first book in a series' syndrome. Hopefully the mysteries will get more interesting and Molly will smooth out into more than just a lucky plot catalyst with great hair.
It can be challenging to find good genre fiction set during this time, so when I do I tend to try to read it.
I had good luck with The Nell Sweeney Historical Mysteries: A Six-Book Boxed Set Series so when these came across my radar, I decided to give this one a try.
I wasn't crazy about this book. But I am chalking it up to what I call 'first book in a series' syndrome. Sometimes when you read the first book in a series, it feel like set up or the author hasn't really found the the core of their characters. Or maybe they are still figuring out how they want to tell their story. Whatever it is, this book seemed to suffer from it.
In this book Molly Murphy flees from Ireland to England because she has killed a man. An overzealous landowner's son who tried to have his wicked way with her. Because Molly was educated along with the daughters of the household (the lady of the house liked Molly's sassiness) , she has always been viewed as being a bit uppity. But in the end she is a poor Irish girl who killed a man of property. So she gets the heck out of dodge real quick.
Luckily (and Molly has a LOT of luck throughout this book) she manages in quick succession to meet a young mother in London who needs a HUGE favor. Would Molly take her place on a ship to America? The young mother can't go. And, oh by the way, please deliver her two kids to their dad who sent them the tickets.
This sets off a chain of events where Molly meets memorable people on the passage over starting with the victim of a murder and ending with the poor guy who is arrested for it. But not before Molly herself is a suspect.
This is what precipitates Molly's foray into amateur sleuthing. She first needs to make sure her own name is clear, then she needs to clear the name of her young friend who was arrested.
There are really great parts of the book. These seem to be the parts where the author has dome some research in order to create the setting. I think the book really sings when the author is describing the passage over on the ship with all the poor immigrants in steerage and the relationships they forge due to the enforced closeness. And then the arrival onto Ellis Island, the process the immigrants had to tho through to get entry as well as the sights and sounds of a young New York City as seen through the eyes of someone like Molly. These passages were fun to read and did a lot to create a sense of time and place.
Also, Molly was a good main character to act as a narrator. She was engaging and smart. And I can tell a mile away that Daniel Sullivan, the handsome police captain she meets in New York will probably be a love interest in upcoming books.
But that was not enough to make the book truly work. The weakness was all the stuff dealing with Molly's amateur sleuthing. It was chock full of coincidences, luck and, given some of the stuff Molly did in her 'detecting', an alarming lack of real danger. Molly was frankly homeless and mostly penniless and wandered around New York all hours of the day and night. She asked the most obvious and blundering questions and leaped to conclusions that always seemed to be right or at least lead her onto the right track. And Daniel also seemed to pop up conveniently whenever Molly needed him.
So as a satisfying mystery is didn't quite do it for me. But there is something there and I will probably try the next book to see if this really is a case of 'first book in a series' syndrome. Hopefully the mysteries will get more interesting and Molly will smooth out into more than just a lucky plot catalyst with great hair.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 1,493 reviews