What do you think?
Rate this book
Advise and Consent #2
A Shade of Difference
The sequel to the Pulitzer Prize winning bestseller Advise and Consent From Allen Drury, the 20th Century grand master of political fiction, a novel of the United Nations and the racial friction that could spark a worldwide powderkeg. International tensions rise as ambassadors and politicians scheme, using the independence of a small African nation as the focal point for hidden agendas. A cascade of events begun in the General Assembly Hall of the United Nations could lead to the weakening of the United States, the loss of the Panama Canal, and a possible civil war. Allen Drury paints a vivid and laseraccurate portrait of Washington and international politics, from top secret conferences, to elite cocktail parties, club luncheon rooms, and the private offices of the key players in government. A novel as relevant today as when it was first published.
773 pages, Mass Market Paperback
First published January 1, 1962
About the author
Allen Drury
80 books38 followersIn late 1943, Allen Stuart Drury, a 25-year old Army veteran, sought work. A position as the Senate correspondent for United Press International provided him with employment and insider knowledge of the Senate. In addition to fulfilling his duties as a reporter, he kept a journal of his views of the Senate and individual senators. In addition to the Senate personalities, his journal captured the events of the 78th & 79th Congresses.
Although written in the mid-1940s, his diary was not published until 1963. "A Senate Journal" found an audience in part because of the great success of "Advise and Consent," his novel in 1959 about the consideration in the Senate of a controversial nominee for secretary of state. His greatest success was "Advise and Consent," was made into a film in 1962. The book was partly inspired by the suicide of Lester C. Hunt, senator from Wyoming. It spent 102 weeks on the New York Times' best-seller list. 'Advise & Consent' led to several sequels. 'A Shade of Difference' is set a year later. Drury then turned his attention to the next presidential election after those events with 'Capable of Honor' & 'Preserve & Protect'. He then wrote two alternative sequels based on a different outcome of an assassination attack in an earlier work: 'Come Nineveh, Come Tyre' & 'The Promise of Joy'. In 1971, he published 'The Throne of Saturn', a sf novel about the 1st attempt at sending a manned mission to Mars. He dedicated the work "To the US Astronauts & those who help them fly." Political characters in the book are archetypal rather than comfortably human. The book carries a strong anti-communist flavor. The book has a lot to say about interference in the space program by leftist Americans. Having wrapped up his political series by '75, Drury began a new one with the '77 novel 'Anna Hastings', more about journalism than politics. He returned to the timeline in '79, with the political novel 'Mark Coffin USS' (tho the main relationship between the two books was that Hastings was a minor character in 'Mark Coffin USS's sequels). It was succeeded, by the two-part 'The Hill of Summer' & 'The Roads of Earth', which are true sequels to 'Mark Coffin USS' He also wrote stand-alone novels, 'Decision' & 'Pentagon', as well as several other fiction & non-fiction works. His political novels have been described as page-turners, set against the Cold War, with an aggressive USSR seeking to undermine the USA. Drury lived in Tiburon, CA from '64 until his '98 cardiac arrest. He'd completed his 20th novel, 'Public Men' set at Stanford, just two weeks before his death. He died on 9/2/98 at St Mary's Medical Center in San Francisco, on his 80th birthday. He never married.--Wikipedia (edited)
Although written in the mid-1940s, his diary was not published until 1963. "A Senate Journal" found an audience in part because of the great success of "Advise and Consent," his novel in 1959 about the consideration in the Senate of a controversial nominee for secretary of state. His greatest success was "Advise and Consent," was made into a film in 1962. The book was partly inspired by the suicide of Lester C. Hunt, senator from Wyoming. It spent 102 weeks on the New York Times' best-seller list. 'Advise & Consent' led to several sequels. 'A Shade of Difference' is set a year later. Drury then turned his attention to the next presidential election after those events with 'Capable of Honor' & 'Preserve & Protect'. He then wrote two alternative sequels based on a different outcome of an assassination attack in an earlier work: 'Come Nineveh, Come Tyre' & 'The Promise of Joy'. In 1971, he published 'The Throne of Saturn', a sf novel about the 1st attempt at sending a manned mission to Mars. He dedicated the work "To the US Astronauts & those who help them fly." Political characters in the book are archetypal rather than comfortably human. The book carries a strong anti-communist flavor. The book has a lot to say about interference in the space program by leftist Americans. Having wrapped up his political series by '75, Drury began a new one with the '77 novel 'Anna Hastings', more about journalism than politics. He returned to the timeline in '79, with the political novel 'Mark Coffin USS' (tho the main relationship between the two books was that Hastings was a minor character in 'Mark Coffin USS's sequels). It was succeeded, by the two-part 'The Hill of Summer' & 'The Roads of Earth', which are true sequels to 'Mark Coffin USS' He also wrote stand-alone novels, 'Decision' & 'Pentagon', as well as several other fiction & non-fiction works. His political novels have been described as page-turners, set against the Cold War, with an aggressive USSR seeking to undermine the USA. Drury lived in Tiburon, CA from '64 until his '98 cardiac arrest. He'd completed his 20th novel, 'Public Men' set at Stanford, just two weeks before his death. He died on 9/2/98 at St Mary's Medical Center in San Francisco, on his 80th birthday. He never married.--Wikipedia (edited)
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 21 of 21 reviews
December 23, 2023
This is the 2nd in the 6 book series by Drury on Politics in the US in the 1950-1960s. I read them all in the 1960s and am re-reading them now. This book could have been published now. It deals with racial problems in the US and how a UN resolution wanted to condemn the US and interview in the US internal situation.
I want to quote from the final speech given by Senator Fry to the UN assembly. Senator Fly was dying from Leukemia and only had a few days to live.
pg 751 - 'i would like to think that the time has come for an end to hate in the world. I would like to think that we have reached a point in human history when we might all realize that hate is no longer effective, that hate, indeed is fatal.
It is time to appeal to all of us, without regard to nationhood or political policy, but simply as human beings to deal with one another kindly and charitably in all things.
Armies stand poised, nuclear arsenals are full to overflowing, rockets rest at the ready on launching pads around the earth. The arms race mounts and mounts and no one yet has managed to cancel out the logic of history which has always said before that arms races have but one ending.
Hand in hand with all this go suspicion and mistrust and jealousy, bad faith and bitterness, envy and hate. The peoples of the earth huddle in terror before the weight of disaster they have mustered to their command. Nothing but awful destruction seems to be ahead for humanity, and no fine words and no brave slogans seems any more able to prevent the blowing out of the tiny flame of hope.
How does mankind stand in this awful hour. Where does it find in all its pomp and pride and power the answer to its own fateful divisions? Where in this globe, where in this universe is there any help for us? Who will come to our aid, who have failed so badly in our trusteeship of the bounteous and lovely earth? Who will save us, if we do not save ourselves?
We are wedded to one another, it may be to our death, it may be to our living. We cannot escape one another, however hard we try. Though we fly to the moon and far beyond, we shall take with us what is in our hearts, and if it be not pure, we shall slaughter one another wherever we meet, as surely on some outward star ss there on earth.
This is the human condition - that we cannot flee from one another. For good, for ill, we await ourselves behind every door, down every street, at the end of every passageway. We try to remain apart, we fail. We try to hide, we are exposed. Nothing makes us better than we are.
I beg of you, here in this body of which men have hoped so much and for which they have already done so much, let us love one another. Let us love one another. It is all we have left"
Doesn't that sound like today? What do we have left, but to learn to love one another and help one another. Allen Drury speaks to all generations. He speaks to us today. Let us learn to love one another.
One to book 3.
I want to quote from the final speech given by Senator Fry to the UN assembly. Senator Fly was dying from Leukemia and only had a few days to live.
pg 751 - 'i would like to think that the time has come for an end to hate in the world. I would like to think that we have reached a point in human history when we might all realize that hate is no longer effective, that hate, indeed is fatal.
It is time to appeal to all of us, without regard to nationhood or political policy, but simply as human beings to deal with one another kindly and charitably in all things.
Armies stand poised, nuclear arsenals are full to overflowing, rockets rest at the ready on launching pads around the earth. The arms race mounts and mounts and no one yet has managed to cancel out the logic of history which has always said before that arms races have but one ending.
Hand in hand with all this go suspicion and mistrust and jealousy, bad faith and bitterness, envy and hate. The peoples of the earth huddle in terror before the weight of disaster they have mustered to their command. Nothing but awful destruction seems to be ahead for humanity, and no fine words and no brave slogans seems any more able to prevent the blowing out of the tiny flame of hope.
How does mankind stand in this awful hour. Where does it find in all its pomp and pride and power the answer to its own fateful divisions? Where in this globe, where in this universe is there any help for us? Who will come to our aid, who have failed so badly in our trusteeship of the bounteous and lovely earth? Who will save us, if we do not save ourselves?
We are wedded to one another, it may be to our death, it may be to our living. We cannot escape one another, however hard we try. Though we fly to the moon and far beyond, we shall take with us what is in our hearts, and if it be not pure, we shall slaughter one another wherever we meet, as surely on some outward star ss there on earth.
This is the human condition - that we cannot flee from one another. For good, for ill, we await ourselves behind every door, down every street, at the end of every passageway. We try to remain apart, we fail. We try to hide, we are exposed. Nothing makes us better than we are.
I beg of you, here in this body of which men have hoped so much and for which they have already done so much, let us love one another. Let us love one another. It is all we have left"
Doesn't that sound like today? What do we have left, but to learn to love one another and help one another. Allen Drury speaks to all generations. He speaks to us today. Let us learn to love one another.
One to book 3.
September 8, 2016
This endless tome was the #3 bestseller in 1962. This review is the second installment of the 1962 reading challenge I set for myself in August. (For background on why 1962, see My Big Fat Reading Project: http://keepthewisdom.blogspot.com/200...) Finishing the novel also marked the completion of my list of Top Ten Bestsellers for that year.
I read Drury's first novel, Advise and Consent, a couple years ago. That one was the #1 bestseller of 1960 and also won the Pulitzer Prize. In any case, I knew what I was getting into this time.
Drury practically invented the Washington, DC, political novel genre, though thankfully his successors have not written in such wordy and dense prose. A Shade of Difference adds the United Nations to the mix and, as foreshadowed by the title, has racism as the underlying theme, making it a timely read. It is set during a year when Civil Rights was a contentious issue in America and when many African nations were seeking independence from colonial masters.
Since you might decide to read the book, I don't want to waste your time with a wordy and dense review. Believe me, you will need that time.
Of note to me was the tension Drury built between individuals who believed that change takes time and is best done within the systems of government as opposed to those who advocated force and violence to either achieve change or prevent it. One of the moderate characters is a Black member of the House of Representatives.
I was also interested in the author's portrayal of the United Nations. That made me want to learn more about both its history and current state. Any suggestions for good books, non-fiction or novels, about the UN would be welcome.
One other thing: both of Drury's novels were written a few years before their timescapes, so all the characters are fictional, including the POTUS. I find that somewhat disorienting and have to make myself stop trying to relate the novels to actual historical events. It is eerie though how prescient he was.
In 1962 I was beginning my sophomore year in high school. Though I was mostly interested in boys, it was a time when I began to be aware of political issues, especially Civil Rights. Reading books from the 1960s that deal with what was going on, particularly behind the scenes in government, is compelling and is also filling in gaps for me, showing me the issues that have loomed so large in my adult life.
I read Drury's first novel, Advise and Consent, a couple years ago. That one was the #1 bestseller of 1960 and also won the Pulitzer Prize. In any case, I knew what I was getting into this time.
Drury practically invented the Washington, DC, political novel genre, though thankfully his successors have not written in such wordy and dense prose. A Shade of Difference adds the United Nations to the mix and, as foreshadowed by the title, has racism as the underlying theme, making it a timely read. It is set during a year when Civil Rights was a contentious issue in America and when many African nations were seeking independence from colonial masters.
Since you might decide to read the book, I don't want to waste your time with a wordy and dense review. Believe me, you will need that time.
Of note to me was the tension Drury built between individuals who believed that change takes time and is best done within the systems of government as opposed to those who advocated force and violence to either achieve change or prevent it. One of the moderate characters is a Black member of the House of Representatives.
I was also interested in the author's portrayal of the United Nations. That made me want to learn more about both its history and current state. Any suggestions for good books, non-fiction or novels, about the UN would be welcome.
One other thing: both of Drury's novels were written a few years before their timescapes, so all the characters are fictional, including the POTUS. I find that somewhat disorienting and have to make myself stop trying to relate the novels to actual historical events. It is eerie though how prescient he was.
In 1962 I was beginning my sophomore year in high school. Though I was mostly interested in boys, it was a time when I began to be aware of political issues, especially Civil Rights. Reading books from the 1960s that deal with what was going on, particularly behind the scenes in government, is compelling and is also filling in gaps for me, showing me the issues that have loomed so large in my adult life.
January 31, 2014
Not quite as good as book one, but still an excellent read. It's interesting to read these books that were written in the 50's and 60's, during the cold war, desegregation, assassination, etc. They're written with kind of a "what if" viewpoint, but I'm reading them a good 50 years later, knowing full well what that "what if" turned into. Fascinating!
August 29, 2016
Read this whole series back in the 60's. Loved them then. Drury is the writer who got me started on political thrillers!
August 15, 2022
So this is definitely not one for the faint of heart as it's a book about geopolitics and race relations set in the late '60's and written in 1962, and it only follows about 2-3 weeks of time over it's dense 800 pages. I picked it up out of an inherited bunch of paperbacks and didn't realize the commitment I had made till was into it a bit, but I'm glad I did so. The multiple overlapping stories about school desegregation, colonialism in Africa, numerous politicians destinies and hopes are all fictional but Drury was building off where we were in 1962 in terms of our race with the Soviets, our fractioning on civil rights, and the beginning of true world governance as the UN is the prime focal point here. The reader definitely has to have some interest in pages and pages of thoughts and dialogue about how countries feel toward each other and how politicians are always trying to balance things, but for the political history buff, it's a good fictional read.
June 12, 2018
8 out of 10
October 31, 2018
A little easier to get into than Advise and Consent. If read first, a lot of the Advise and Consent characters are already familiar, but it doesn't really spoil the first book.
March 10, 2021
A really Good read and a worthy follow up to Advise and Consent. Hal Fry tells us love is the answer. Hal is so right.
August 17, 2024
It's okay
Read
March 11, 2017This book is not so much reviewed as it is discussed in my blog post "Too much Allen Drury": https://librarianslauderdale.wordpres...
21st century readers who have heard of "Advise and Consent" the book or "Advise & Consent" the movie may not also know that "Advise and Consent" is the first in a series of six books that Drury wrote over a span of sixteen years. I really wasn’t planning on reading more than that first book until I read about the premise of 1962’s "A Shade of Difference" on Wikipedia ...
21st century readers who have heard of "Advise and Consent" the book or "Advise & Consent" the movie may not also know that "Advise and Consent" is the first in a series of six books that Drury wrote over a span of sixteen years. I really wasn’t planning on reading more than that first book until I read about the premise of 1962’s "A Shade of Difference" on Wikipedia ...
April 10, 2017
Allen Drury takes his unique style from the Senate to another flawed but necessary institution, the United Nations General Assembly. Orrin Knox, a featured Senator from Advise and Consent has been promoted by the new President to Secretary of State. Many of the other players from Advise and Consent are also here in featured and side roles.
This is a big book, but it’s also a big topic: race relations in the United States, in the world, and the growth of freedom in both spheres. Drury doesn’t pull any punches, and characters who were on the right side in the previous book end up on the wrong side here, because that’s the way things were. But as in the previous book, Drury goes out of his way to provide his characters with motivations that make sense and that keep all sides human.
More amazingly, as in his previous book this one seems to be set a few years in the future. He wrote it in 1960 to 1962, but in the book, I think, we have just landed people on the moon (the book isn’t explicit about this, but does say we have a successful “expedition”). And he describes activists in the United States more as they appeared in the late sixties than the late fifties, even predicting the intimidation of traitors to causes.
He also plays with stereotypes in a stereotypically Drurian way. For example, among all the nations of the UN he describes Britain as other writers would describe the then-Orient, as enigmatic mysteries never fully revealing themselves.
One of the better characterization’s is Orrin Knox’s transition from senator to administration official, and how it changes him.
It starts with some members of the United Nations trying to intimidate the United States for segregation—a noble action for, unfortunately, ignoble motives. Throughout the book, the United States delegation has to grapple with the fact that the motion they’re trying to defeat addresses a real and horrendous problem within the United States. But addressing it in this way may well mean the end of the United Nations.
This is a big book, but it’s also a big topic: race relations in the United States, in the world, and the growth of freedom in both spheres. Drury doesn’t pull any punches, and characters who were on the right side in the previous book end up on the wrong side here, because that’s the way things were. But as in the previous book, Drury goes out of his way to provide his characters with motivations that make sense and that keep all sides human.
More amazingly, as in his previous book this one seems to be set a few years in the future. He wrote it in 1960 to 1962, but in the book, I think, we have just landed people on the moon (the book isn’t explicit about this, but does say we have a successful “expedition”). And he describes activists in the United States more as they appeared in the late sixties than the late fifties, even predicting the intimidation of traitors to causes.
He also plays with stereotypes in a stereotypically Drurian way. For example, among all the nations of the UN he describes Britain as other writers would describe the then-Orient, as enigmatic mysteries never fully revealing themselves.
One of the better characterization’s is Orrin Knox’s transition from senator to administration official, and how it changes him.
It starts with some members of the United Nations trying to intimidate the United States for segregation—a noble action for, unfortunately, ignoble motives. Throughout the book, the United States delegation has to grapple with the fact that the motion they’re trying to defeat addresses a real and horrendous problem within the United States. But addressing it in this way may well mean the end of the United Nations.
October 12, 2012
It's quite a book! This book is a political fiction novel based on actual historical events. It takes place in the 1960's when segregation was just being implemented in the schools. A good deal of the story takes place in the assembly of the United Nations in New York and in the senate in Washington DC. You feel like you are there in an assembly of the United Nations with U.S. senators, congressmen, majority leaders, newspaper men, and representatives and ambassadors of other countries. You hear verbal debates, threats, bluffs, and eventually a resolution for adoption put forth by the His Royal Highness the M'Bulu of Mbuele of Gorotoland, and later an amendment by the Ambassador of Panama. From here the book moves forward depicting the struggle of how the United States defends itself while many of the other countries are in favor of the amendment.
It is a book full of passion and compassion, the characterization is excellent, and the author is
brilliant in the way he handles this story. The book is written in present tense, first person, and is divided into five segments, the first four are by four of the main characters of the story. However there are many others who are actively involved throughout. To me it starts out slowly but stick with it and you will be glad you did. The author makes the characters live in the eye of the reader and even though it may be over six hundred pages, for me it was sad when I reached the end.
It is a book full of passion and compassion, the characterization is excellent, and the author is
brilliant in the way he handles this story. The book is written in present tense, first person, and is divided into five segments, the first four are by four of the main characters of the story. However there are many others who are actively involved throughout. To me it starts out slowly but stick with it and you will be glad you did. The author makes the characters live in the eye of the reader and even though it may be over six hundred pages, for me it was sad when I reached the end.
Currently reading
October 6, 2008This is the second novel in a four novel series written by political reporter Allen Drury. I've read the opening act ("Terrible Terry's book") and it seems quite similar in style to Drury's earlier work, "Advise and Consent."
The critique of Drury's writing is that he is slow and methodical in his approach to the plot, leading to a slow and methodical approach by this reader.
Each plot point is met not by the subsequent action, but by paragraphs and pages of response from each of his main characters. The narrator is an omniscient being who chooses to focus on one character for a few paragraphs before switching to another. The writing is clear, so there's never confusion, but the plot slows down immensely.
Having covered the fact that Drury is not a cheap thrills paperback novelist, we move on to his redeeming qualities. Drury weaves a fantastically complex web of characters, motives, and actions. He is skilled at creating memorable characters whose actions are clear results of their motives, and so his books are a true delight for a reader willing to sift through enough prose to enjoy it.
The critique of Drury's writing is that he is slow and methodical in his approach to the plot, leading to a slow and methodical approach by this reader.
Each plot point is met not by the subsequent action, but by paragraphs and pages of response from each of his main characters. The narrator is an omniscient being who chooses to focus on one character for a few paragraphs before switching to another. The writing is clear, so there's never confusion, but the plot slows down immensely.
Having covered the fact that Drury is not a cheap thrills paperback novelist, we move on to his redeeming qualities. Drury weaves a fantastically complex web of characters, motives, and actions. He is skilled at creating memorable characters whose actions are clear results of their motives, and so his books are a true delight for a reader willing to sift through enough prose to enjoy it.
Read
September 9, 2016I remember reading both these books not long after they were published (I was a 9th-grader in '62) but I'm not certain that at least one was in a Reader's Digest Condensed version; in any case I had a lot more patience for long, long books back then. It's fun revisiting some of the books you have in your project although I probably won't reread -- my reading time is growing short (although I keep believing I have 20 years left!) Of course, I also enjoy reading about the books you read that I haven't read.
June 1, 2023
I actually read this first, not realizing it was a sequel to "Advise and Consent." I circled around to reread it after reading the first book, which I then considered a prequel. This one focuses on the United Nations. A small African nation wants independence. The United States and Russia use it as a pawn to try to gain international advantage on one another during the Cold War. As things escalate, integration of public schools in the southern states, the possibility of losing the Panama Canal, and a Civil War are all negotiated in private offices, at elite cocktail parties, and somewhat openly in public places. It is an interesting read, and some parts of the fictional novel came to pass over the years, which makes you wonder when the rest will actually happen. Not as good as the first book in the series, but it doesn't miss by much. The characters here aren't as interesting, but the story holds up well.
July 20, 2007
It's been more than 25 years since I read this book, but I've been wanting to re-read it and now I shall. It was the sequel to Advise and Consent, Drury's Pulitzer Prize-winning novel.
September 5, 2013
Interesting to read and very detailed
November 4, 2015
couldn't find the books
November 6, 2023
It just didn’t hold my interest. I grew tired of Terrible Terry. I also found the prose overloaded. It was not worth finishing.
Read
August 21, 2008F Dru
June 13, 2014
Book two in the Advise and Consent series
Displaying 1 - 21 of 21 reviews