"Birnam Wood" attempts to blend eco-activism with the thriller genre. The novel has promise but ultimately falls short due to a prolonged build-up and"Birnam Wood" attempts to blend eco-activism with the thriller genre. The novel has promise but ultimately falls short due to a prolonged build-up and a perplexingly abrupt climax.
The novel's pacing is perhaps its most significant flaw. The author spends an inordinate amount of time having her characters’ interactions and backstories that feel meandering with only a few having implications later. The pace also works against the story's momentum. Somehow, it also takes the sting out of the villainy – in partially humanizing him or building a suspense around his motives, the author also makes the villain almost powerless compared to the resources at disposal.
The climax, contrastingly, is diminished by the abruptness with which it concludes. Like this! ...more
A good thriller that is in two parts in all sorts of ways. The Before part sears in one’s memories. The author creates a shocking set of events while A good thriller that is in two parts in all sorts of ways. The Before part sears in one’s memories. The author creates a shocking set of events while also keeping the story moving forward. The After part action is ordinary and with set pieces that are just too convenient. Overall, it's a good read, even if only in half!...more
“Determined” by Robert Sapolsky could have been a thought-provoking exploration of the age-old question of free will had its implications not gone too“Determined” by Robert Sapolsky could have been a thought-provoking exploration of the age-old question of free will had its implications not gone too extreme for the criminal justice system. For some part, the book’s approach is grounded in neuroscience and evolutionary biology, offering a scientific perspective on the long-standing mind-body problem and the nature of consciousness. However, the author’s ad hoc extensions into the moral realms jangle because of the deep logical flaws (even if one agrees with the conclusions).
In the first part, the author adeptly navigates the complexities of the brain, illustrating how many factors, including genetics, environment, and biochemical processes influence our choices and behaviors. He convincingly argues that scientific evidence does not support the notion of a separate, non-material "self" or "soul" that supposedly drives our actions. Instead, he presents a compelling case that our decisions and behaviors result from intricate neuronal interactions and chemical processes within the brain.
The book does well in concluding how factors beyond our conscious control largely predetermine choices we make. The arguments are not original and are better made in many other works, but the author also does well in covering various grounds. The book offers a wealth of empirical evidence and real-world examples. The writing is neither as scholarly nor as entertaining as the best one reads in popular literature with conclusions original only for the uninitiated, but overall, even the well-read on the subject will find the breadth covered impressive.
Unfortunately, all of these lead the book to question the validity of traditional notions of accountability and punishment within the criminal justice system. This is where arguments veer into the territory of excessive reductionism, where the author applies principles derived from the micro-scale of neuroscience to macro-scale moral and ethical frameworks.
In one of the earlier sections, the author proves that rules of one domain (in his case, quantum indeterminacy) cannot explain emergent properties of a higher domain (in his example, any supposed indeterminism of our neuronal behavior). For complex systems, the reverse is also true. Effectively, the author who relies on strong reasons should not have used micro-scale neuroscience conclusions on free will to macro-scale moral and ethical frameworks where free will has a different meaning. In other words, the book dismisses the possibility of higher-order ethical frameworks that cannot be solely reduced to their biological underpinnings despite using precisely the same framework all through to describe our behavior for its own conclusions.
There are other contradictions in arguments that want the justice system policymakers to focus on the violators’ inability to really choose what they did. If, as the author contends, we are all devoid of free will, then those tasked with reforming the justice system are equally constrained by deterministic forces. This logical inconsistency undermines any normative conclusions from purely descriptive premises.
Ultimately, "Determined" serves as a cautionary tale for overzealous reductionism; while intellectually stimulating, it also demonstrates the perils of extrapolating scientific findings into realms where they may not neatly apply. Take a different example: the universe will eventually end. This can be used, if one intends to, to render any action meaningless in a nihilistic leap. Just as one wouldn't console a grieving person by reminding them of the inevitable mortality, we cannot use the universe's deterministic nature – assuming true - to excuse inaction or apathy in the face of pressing moral and ethical challenges. The scientific pursuit of truth is invaluable, but it must be tempered with recognizing the complex, emergent phenomena that shape our lives and give them meaning.
By the fourth episode of the Harriett Gordon series, Terror in Topaz offers fewer charms due to its colonial Malaya backdrop. Readers may find themselBy the fourth episode of the Harriett Gordon series, Terror in Topaz offers fewer charms due to its colonial Malaya backdrop. Readers may find themselves less captivated by the romanticized depiction of the aristocratic class, and the efforts to address racial stereotypes feel contrived and superficial. The author goes to great lengths to transport the entire cast to Kuala Lumpur, but the coincidences that bring them back together and have them working collaboratively strain credulity.
The contortions required to maintain the old storylines and conveniently adjust the settings to accommodate the lead character's involvement make the narrative feel increasingly artificial and forced. Furthermore, the central murder mystery itself lacks originality, having been explored in greater depth and with more vivid descriptions in other works. The loss of freshness and the transparent devices employed to keep the leads intact are inadequately compensated by any novel elements introduced by the new societal backdrop....more
Christopher Buckley's 1994 satire is clever and biting while taking aim at the spin doctors and corporate apologists of the tobacco industry. However,Christopher Buckley's 1994 satire is clever and biting while taking aim at the spin doctors and corporate apologists of the tobacco industry. However, the book's central premise - the behind-the-scenes story of a charismatic lobbyist selling a deadly product - ends up feeling a bit too familiar three decades later.
The writing is sharp and the novel is brimming with quotable zingers skewering the mercenary mentality of Big Tobacco's PR machine. Yet for all its wry wit and trenchant social commentary, the book treads very well-worn ground in its depiction of soulless corporate hucksters.
The Biggest Ideas in the Universe by Sean Carroll is a colossal letdown for anyone seeking an accessible exploration of the profound concepts it promiThe Biggest Ideas in the Universe by Sean Carroll is a colossal letdown for anyone seeking an accessible exploration of the profound concepts it promises to unveil. Marketed as a gateway to comprehending the deepest mysteries of the cosmos, the book is instead a dense, impenetrable thicket of esoteric jargon and mathematical formalism, utterly impervious to the uninitiated.
Right from the start, the book’s style is a jarring departure from the engaging, clear exposition one anticipates from the author (who is a personal favorite of this reviewer). The chapters resemble a collection of advanced physics lectures, filled with complex equations and their explanations. It's almost as if the book is addressing a seminar of doctoral candidates rather than the inquisitive lay reader.
Take, for example, the discussions of quantum field theories (QED and QCD). Instead of shedding light on the fundamental concepts through relatable analogies and thought experiments, the book primarily presents sets of differential equations and tensor calculus. While these formalisms may be essential for the practicing physicist, they are not the material a book like this should be presenting to its readers.
The audio format, in particular, is a disaster. Navigating dense equations in audio form is a frustrating experience, and the publisher should have never allowed it. Even without the audio, the book is a textbook only suitable for students or experts who can decipher complex math and dedicate significant time and effort to deciphering the material. Multiple readings, cross-referencing, and outside resources are required to grasp the intricacies. This reviewer is incapable of rating the book if it were course material. ...more
The Echo of Old Books begins with an intriguing structure of multiple timelines and parallel viewpoints. The initial chapters provide an engrossing reThe Echo of Old Books begins with an intriguing structure of multiple timelines and parallel viewpoints. The initial chapters provide an engrossing reading experience, along with a few unexpected twists to create a good build-up.
However, as the story unfolds, the initial promise starts to meander predictably, ultimately settling into the well-trodden path of a typical romantic story roiled by preventable miscommunications. Worse, as the story stretches on, the premise becomes less and less believable and characters less relatable. The more their stories are explored, the more their actions and motivations seem contrived to move towards the same old finale....more
Anil Seth's "Being You" is a triumph of lucid scientific writing. He tackles the age-old question of consciousness with clarity and a refreshing direcAnil Seth's "Being You" is a triumph of lucid scientific writing. He tackles the age-old question of consciousness with clarity and a refreshing directness. Unlike many academics, Seth doesn't shy away from providing conclusions, albeit tentative ones, which makes the book both thought-provoking and accessible to a wider audience.
The author’s central thesis - that our conscious experience is a kind of "controlled hallucination" constructed by our brains - is novel, even if not immediately intuitive. The framework rests on the theory of Predictive Processing, which posits that our brains are constantly generating predictions about the world based on prior experiences and incoming sensory data. Consciousness, as per this theory, arises from the brain's efforts to minimize "free energy," the discrepancy between its predictions and the actual sensory input. In essence, we are continuously striving to make sense of the world by refining our internal model of reality.
While this approach is more grounded in objective, measurable phenomena than, say, Integrated Information Theory, it ultimately falls prey to the same unfalsifiable claims. The very concept of "free energy" hinges on elusive notions of "predictions" and "expectations" that are inherently subjective and difficult to quantify. How do we accurately measure the gap between prediction and reality within the brain? Without a concrete means of measuring these variables, Predictive Processing, despite its elegance, risks becoming another subjective explanation with limited practical utility.
Furthermore, as our understanding of the brain advances, with increasingly sophisticated neural mapping techniques, any single-measure definition of consciousness is likely to fall short. We will inevitably face a future where machines surpass any predetermined threshold we set for consciousness, rendering our definitions unacceptable to everyone who would want to keep humanity as something unique. As we delve deeper into the intricate signal-processing mechanisms of the brain, theoretical frameworks like Predictive Processing will face mounting challenges, with each new discovery potentially exposing flaws in their assumptions.
Ultimately, our psychological need for a fixed definition of consciousness - something to cling to as machines outpace us in cognitive abilities, just as they did in physical prowess - may force us to keep shifting the definition to ensure we keep calling ourselves superior. ...more
“Close to Death” is a gripping whodunit that keeps readers hooked not as much through the central mystery as through the engaging characters, fast-pac“Close to Death” is a gripping whodunit that keeps readers hooked not as much through the central mystery as through the engaging characters, fast-paced narrative, and the author’s superb storytelling skills. The novel deftly balances character backstories with a rapid series of tense events and shifting suspicions.
What truly sets this book apart is its masterful writing and ability to insert the author himself as an underdog character (a feature through the series) that readers can't help but root for. The novel has a delightfully meta quality as the author's fictional self gets entangled in the investigation. The master children’s book writer has a talent for blending humor and suspense, which takes the form of charming, self-deprecating that undercuts the tension with welcome levity. Yet he's also able to ratchet up the stakes with tangible feelings of danger and high-stakes intrigue. This personal involvement lends the story a wonderful Sherlockian, first-person writing flair.
The central mystery is not bad, even though not something that would really surprise too many. The joy of the book is not in its mystery parts....more
The idealism and zeal exemplified by Adrian Hong are, arguably, exactly what the world needs, especially when prevailing attitudes are overly logical The idealism and zeal exemplified by Adrian Hong are, arguably, exactly what the world needs, especially when prevailing attitudes are overly logical and patient. However, the very naivety that fuels their purpose can also pose significant risks, not only to themselves but also to others, as they pursue their ambitious goals. "The Rebel in the Kingdom" masterfully explores this double-edged sword of passion and peril.
The book inspires hope and simultaneously highlights the dire circumstances faced by certain societal segments, often ignored by most of us. Through a narrative that meticulously details the efforts and failures of a small, determined group, the author captures the tragic yet hopeful essence of their journey. This saga, marked by both profound despair and a glimmer of optimism, makes "The Rebel in the Kingdom" a compelling read....more
Sean Carroll's course on quantum mechanics from The Great Courses is genuinely extraordinary. He explains complex topics with amazing clarity, providiSean Carroll's course on quantum mechanics from The Great Courses is genuinely extraordinary. He explains complex topics with amazing clarity, providing a definitive yet balanced view that primarily champions the many-worlds interpretation (MWI) while giving fair treatment to other interpretations. As in all his works, the professor’s passion for MWI shines through, making a compelling case for its elegance and explanatory power. The best parts are the sections on alternative theories, presented fairly and adequately.
While I deeply enjoy the MWI defense, I find myself drawn to alternative explanations that might resolve the mysteries of the quantum realm without needing a constantly multiplying multitude of universes. My current line of thought is admittedly speculative and without any technical rigor – but at least something that sits better with me is the rest of this review as my takeaways. It relies on the often-overlooked concept of “recoherence” and its implications for our understanding of quantum phenomena.
My view effectively focuses on the dynamic interplay of decoherence and recoherence. Imagine fundamental particles possessing intrinsic properties, such as spin, represented by a "fuzzy pin." This pin has a definite orientation along one axis, signifying a decohered state for that specific property, while remaining fuzzy and indeterminate in all other directions—a superposition of possibilities waiting to be realized.
This fuzzy pin persists in its state until an "interaction" occurs, causing a perturbation that disrupts its current orientation and establishes a new axis of decoherence. Imagine a gentle nudge causing the pin to tilt, changing its alignment axis while the fuzziness now encompasses the previously definite direction. This dynamic process reflects the ever-evolving nature of quantum systems as they interact with their environment.
The crucial question then becomes: what triggers this "interaction" and subsequent shift in decoherence? Two main possibilities emerge:
a) Collective Influence: Similar to the pilot wave theory, the combined force of nearby wave functions, particularly within macroscopic objects where countless particles interact, creates a perturbation that nudges the fuzzy pin onto a new axis. This collective "push" from the environment influences the particle's state, causing it to decohere along a specific direction based on the net effect of surrounding influences.
b) Localized Interactions: Alternatively, the perturbation could arise from individual interactions between particles when they come within a highly close proximity, almost colliding. This suggests that decoherence is a more localized phenomenon occurring at the micro-level during close encounters between particles. The probability of such close encounters increases significantly within macroscopic objects due to the sheer number of particles involved, leading to a higher likelihood of decoherence along a specific axis relevant to the measurement context.
This refined perspective aligns with elements of both pilot wave theory and other interpretations that emphasize the role of interactions in shaping quantum behavior. It suggests that decoherence is not a one-time event but rather a dynamic process where particles continuously shift between definite and indeterminate states based on their interactions with the environment. The fuzzy pin analogy captures this fluidity, with its axis of decoherence constantly adapting to the influences it encounters.
This interpretation, which ties with what we observe in sciences elsewhere, is not just a mere speculation. It may contain hidden variables or sub-theories, or alternatively, it could be one that should be falsifiable fairly quickly in all various forms, providing a solid foundation for further exploration.
Back to the course, it is a valuable resource for anyone interested in the field. ...more
"A Calamity of Souls" by David Baldacci is a compelling and thought-provoking novel that delves deep into the heart of racial injustice in the 1960s U"A Calamity of Souls" by David Baldacci is a compelling and thought-provoking novel that delves deep into the heart of racial injustice in the 1960s United States. The novel is a powerful exploration of the complexities of race relations and the legal system during a time of great social upheaval.
The book shows how Mr. Baldacci can be far more than just a regular potboiler writer (and this reviewer loves him for that, too). What makes it stand out is the author’s ability to tell a story that, while not at all new, feels so lovable, moving, and relevant. As always, the writing is engaging and thought-provoking, but this time drawing readers into the world of 1960s Virginia and the struggle for racial justice. The characters are well-developed with their own personal histories; they may be largely one-dimensional, but the author has a way of throwing a few surprises for a handful of them with the side tales.
Of course, the author is not known for his courtroom dramas. Here, too, he takes upon something that is mastered by some great writers and in a field where finding anything new is not for the novice. The author still comes up with the Trumps through the ways in which he uses a series of small victories, uplifting legal debate moments, and minor mysteries to keep his underdogs going and the readers warm.
In raising important questions about racial justice and the role of the legal system in perpetuating inequality, the book is bound to win the hearts of most, particularly when dealing with difficult topics is not what one expects in the author’s books. With his star power, Baldacci has the ability to take these issues to a far wider audience.
Overall, the story – which will always remind readers of other works or tv shows - moves beautifully, with great characters and intriguing events to create a highly readable, thoughtful legal, crime, suspense drama. ...more
The book, with the predictable plot, is a long waiting game for something to happen. During those endless pages, one comes across a host of politicallThe book, with the predictable plot, is a long waiting game for something to happen. During those endless pages, one comes across a host of politically-tinted events that are surely not going to sit well with people from different political domains. The badly-drawn characters draw little sympathy while the plot turns ever more ludicrous in the name of science. Even the climax fails to provide any thrills....more
I am going to have fun poking holes at all the so re-used, cheesy, tacky and movie-driven formulas deployed in the book. But remember that my rating iI am going to have fun poking holes at all the so re-used, cheesy, tacky and movie-driven formulas deployed in the book. But remember that my rating is five stars and that's simply because of the big mystery and important, invaluable things one learns from it.
a. The worst of the DVC rip-offs are from Mr Brown himself. And this book is at the shameless extreme. Another loner killer (thankfully not an albino) from a sect thoroughly vilified. Another historic city with museums and churches to go through in one night with codes to be broken from Blake this time. A similar damsel in tow. The police and influential people playing their roles similar to those in the previous books amid all the set pieces. Coincidences and last-minute escapes are mirror images of many in DVC and its other "copies" (ie, the other Langdon novels). b. The author is almost amateurish in the way he tries to build up the big suspense multiple times. He goes on and on for a few chapters in the first attempt even when he makes it almost fully known in advance that the secret was not coming out then. Towards the middle, the protagonists almost have the "key" and are required to re-start through a laughable "drop". The same stretched preamble is repeated again at the time of the revelation. c. An irrelevant (possibly irreverent too) and purposeless royal family side-story is created to create an illusion of certain villains and to provide the protagonists with enormous resources like helicopters etc when needed. d. One does not have to be a Sherlock to figure out almost as early as in the first third of the book who is going to turn out to be the master perpetrator. e. And the way the book is written, one almost visualises Tom Hanks all the time.
Despite these big flaws, the story keeps the readers engaged. What makes the book extraordinary is the big secret at the end. For those who are not exposed to the increasingly extensive work on technology evolution, the author masterfully explains where the humanity is potentially headed. This section is well chosen as the core topic, as something the most important to humanity. The hypothesis on where we came from too is interesting.
For those who have read Kutzwell, Harari etc, the big revelation here will be a bit of a dud but the author has written a novel that will likely raise the singularity awareness far more than anybody else so far. It is also being imparted in the capsules coated by Hanks/DVC sequences.
Merged review:
I am going to have fun poking holes at all the so re-used, cheesy, tacky and movie-driven formulas deployed in the book. But remember that my rating is five stars and that's simply because of the big mystery and important, invaluable things one learns from it.
a. The worst of the DVC rip-offs are from Mr Brown himself. And this book is at the shameless extreme. Another loner killer (thankfully not an albino) from a sect thoroughly vilified. Another historic city with museums and churches to go through in one night with codes to be broken from Blake this time. A similar damsel in tow. The police and influential people playing their roles similar to those in the previous books amid all the set pieces. Coincidences and last-minute escapes are mirror images of many in DVC and its other "copies" (ie, the other Langdon novels). b. The author is almost amateurish in the way he tries to build up the big suspense multiple times. He goes on and on for a few chapters in the first attempt even when he makes it almost fully known in advance that the secret was not coming out then. Towards the middle, the protagonists almost have the "key" and are required to re-start through a laughable "drop". The same stretched preamble is repeated again at the time of the revelation. c. An irrelevant (possibly irreverent too) and purposeless royal family side-story is created to create an illusion of certain villains and to provide the protagonists with enormous resources like helicopters etc when needed. d. One does not have to be a Sherlock to figure out almost as early as in the first third of the book who is going to turn out to be the master perpetrator. e. And the way the book is written, one almost visualises Tom Hanks all the time.
Despite these big flaws, the story keeps the readers engaged. What makes the book extraordinary is the big secret at the end. For those who are not exposed to the increasingly extensive work on technology evolution, the author masterfully explains where the humanity is potentially headed. This section is well chosen as the core topic, as something the most important to humanity. The hypothesis on where we came from too is interesting.
For those who have read Kutzwell, Harari etc, the big revelation here will be a bit of a dud but the author has written a novel that will likely raise the singularity awareness far more than anybody else so far. It is also being imparted in the capsules coated by Hanks/DVC sequences.
Merged review:
I am going to have fun poking holes at all the so re-used, cheesy, tacky and movie-driven formulas deployed in the book. But remember that my rating is five stars and that's simply because of the big mystery and important, invaluable things one learns from it.
a. The worst of the DVC rip-offs are from Mr Brown himself. And this book is at the shameless extreme. Another loner killer (thankfully not an albino) from a sect thoroughly vilified. Another historic city with museums and churches to go through in one night with codes to be broken from Blake this time. A similar damsel in tow. The police and influential people playing their roles similar to those in the previous books amid all the set pieces. Coincidences and last-minute escapes are mirror images of many in DVC and its other "copies" (ie, the other Langdon novels). b. The author is almost amateurish in the way he tries to build up the big suspense multiple times. He goes on and on for a few chapters in the first attempt even when he makes it almost fully known in advance that the secret was not coming out then. Towards the middle, the protagonists almost have the "key" and are required to re-start through a laughable "drop". The same stretched preamble is repeated again at the time of the revelation. c. An irrelevant (possibly irreverent too) and purposeless royal family side-story is created to create an illusion of certain villains and to provide the protagonists with enormous resources like helicopters etc when needed. d. One does not have to be a Sherlock to figure out almost as early as in the first third of the book who is going to turn out to be the master perpetrator. e. And the way the book is written, one almost visualises Tom Hanks all the time.
Despite these big flaws, the story keeps the readers engaged. What makes the book extraordinary is the big secret at the end. For those who are not exposed to the increasingly extensive work on technology evolution, the author masterfully explains where the humanity is potentially headed. This section is well chosen as the core topic, as something the most important to humanity. The hypothesis on where we came from too is interesting.
For those who have read Kutzwell, Harari etc, the big revelation here will be a bit of a dud but the author has written a novel that will likely raise the singularity awareness far more than anybody else so far. It is also being imparted in the capsules coated by Hanks/DVC sequences....more
After Death is a meandering mess that fails to deliver on any front. The plot is utterly senseless, aimlessly wandering without any clear direction orAfter Death is a meandering mess that fails to deliver on any front. The plot is utterly senseless, aimlessly wandering without any clear direction or purpose. The sole purpose of the painfully stretched build-up seems to be to avoid any action between the hero and hopelessly powerless villains.
In the process, the author turns preachy and often worse than that with some of his views on racism. The expositions on “singularity” are equally worse. The central character's "singularity" abilities are laughable; a superhero gaining powers from a potion would be more plausible than supposedly scientifically accorded powers here.
The villains fare no better with their clownish, stereotypical characterization and mindless actions. They make the book even more a slog of a read, devoid of any thrills, suspense or credibility. ...more
"Same as Ever" is a profound work that challenges our most fundamental assumptions while stating the obvious. From the first page to the last, it read"Same as Ever" is a profound work that challenges our most fundamental assumptions while stating the obvious. From the first page to the last, it reads like a string of eternal verities. It is a title that whispers of stagnation yet explodes with dynamism. Each section dissects the ordinary, revealing the extraordinary within. We are left raw, exposed, and undeniably awake
As much as the message, it is the style. Short sentences repeatedly lay bare the intricate dance between the mundane and the profound. The words, stark and unadorned, resonate with an unsettling familiarity. Quotes appear familiar, yet they appear more applicable than ever to whatever situation one may be in.
To be clear, House’s universal truths are not universal. Each one could be argued. In a different society, each one could be disputed. The author’s implicit context is a certain type of individual in a certain type of society. However, if one sheds the mindset of nitpicking, there is a lot to take away on every page.
One can pick up the book any time and any number of times. And begin reading randomly from anywhere. In no time, one is guaranteed to come across insights that are universally applicable yet deeply personal.
This is a rare gem - a work that enlightens without preaching, that speaks truth without dogma. One will find solace, a path forward, and perhaps, even solutions. This is written for all, and still a personal journey inward. ...more
Rarely does a novel pack in as many tangled personal relationships and salacious twists as "House of Doors." – and not in the literary world. Tan TwanRarely does a novel pack in as many tangled personal relationships and salacious twists as "House of Doors." – and not in the literary world. Tan Twan Eng transports us to colonial Penang's sweltering, morally ambiguous milieu. Against this backdrop, a compelling narrative unfolds that is equal parts about a nomadic aristocrat's idle pursuits, a perceptive and ambitious housewife's efforts to live for herself, a historic revolution's germination, and a murder mystery, all combining as a poignant elegy for a bygone era. Written exquisitely, the fast-moving tale is able to keep the themes era-appropriate while holding any modern reader's interest, even those with little appetite for the history of the time and the place.
It helps that the diverse cast of characters includes fictional protagonists and the real-life figures of revolutionary Sun Yat-Sen and renowned author W. Somerset Maugham. This deft blending of fact and fiction lends an air of authenticity to the proceedings, drawing the reader deep into the intrigues and power struggles of the time while educating him on events that shaped the future we identify with.
Yet, it's precisely here that the novel slightly stumbles. The sheer number of affairs and their interconnected secrets create a web that sometimes feels slightly overwrought. However, what redeems the tangled plot is the book's prose and the author's ability to throw the spotlight on underlying racial, marital, political, and cultural issues without explicitly talking about them.
Personal dramas that unfold against this grand historical canvas are not extraordinary but good enough for the book never to turn dull. Overall, the book works the best because of the blend of historical fiction and page-turning stories of extramarital affairs of different shades. Fans of literary thrillers and those interested in the social and cultural dynamics of colonial-era Southeast Asia will find much to savour in this multi-faceted work.
"The Blue Machine" is an enlightening journey into the uncharted waters of oceanography, a critical and scarcely explored theme. With a blend of deep "The Blue Machine" is an enlightening journey into the uncharted waters of oceanography, a critical and scarcely explored theme. With a blend of deep scientific expertise and captivating storytelling, this work becomes a seminal exploration of the ocean's currents, waves, the life within, and their indispensable role in Earth's ecosystem.
The author, leveraging a background in both physics and oceanography, unravels the complex dynamics in a manner that is both accessible and profound. It demystifies oceanographic concepts by segmenting them into easily digestible chapters. The sections dedicated to energy transfer through waves and examining ocean currents shed light on long-range impacts in ways that would intrigue and educate readers, irrespective of their prior knowledge.
This approach illustrates the vast, interconnected network of the world's oceans. It provides unique insights into phenomena like the transmission of sound waves across hundreds of miles—a stark contrast to the limitations of light waves underwater.
The ocean is a kaleidoscope of biodiversity, from the vibrant coral reefs teeming with colorful fish and invertebrates to the eerie, alien-like creatures that dwell in the deepest trenches. The author's vivid descriptions and captivating examples transport readers to these diverse realms, showcasing the remarkable adaptations that enable life to flourish in even the most extreme conditions. Whether it's the bioluminescent organisms that light up the depths or the bizarre creatures that call hydrothermal vents home, from the intense pressures of the deep sea to the fluctuating temperatures and nutrient levels, life in the ocean must adapt to a range of harsh environments. The book highlights the ingenious strategies employed by various species, such as using specialized tissues and organs to withstand immense pressures or surviving prolonged periods of darkness and limited food availability.
One of the fascinating aspects of ocean life that Czerski explores is the relationship between the size of marine organisms and their biomass. From microscopic plankton to massive whales, the ocean hosts an incredible diversity of living beings, and each adapted to thrive at different scales. This scaling phenomenon offers profound insights into marine ecosystems' intricate balance and efficiency. The author reveals how the laws of physics and fluid dynamics shape how nutrients are distributed, and energy is transferred, ultimately determining the abundance and distribution of life in the ocean.
In many ways, the blue machine is a fascinating application of fundamental laws of physics that are different from the manifestations we are used to. By exploring fluid dynamics, thermodynamics, and mechanics, the book shows how these forces shape the ocean's behaviour over time.
The book celebrates the ocean not just as an element, but as a vital part of life for countless communities overland through the impact on the weather, seasons, shorelines, and involvement in the carbon cycle. Moreover, the book does not shy away from addressing the pressing issues of melting ice caps, global warming, and the potential exacerbating role of the oceans in climate change. Through this lens, the author calls attention to the delicate balance we must maintain to protect this invaluable resource.
"The Blue Machine" is a compelling call to recognize the beauty, complexity, and critical importance of the oceans to life on Earth. With its rich blend of scientific insight, vivid storytelling, and a palpable passion for the subject matter, this book is a must-read for anyone interested in the mysteries that lie beneath the waves. ...more
Jay Owens's Dust sets out to illuminate the often-overlooked role of dust in our environment and, consequently, climate crises. But, the title turns mJay Owens's Dust sets out to illuminate the often-overlooked role of dust in our environment and, consequently, climate crises. But, the title turns misleading as the environmentalist author cannot yield to the topic's primacy and keeps veering off to ideas, views, and narratives dear to her heart. The need to connect them to "Dust" weakens those discussions, as she is forced to return to the topic that is not precisely her real love, if not the area of expertise.
Effectively the book is a wide-ranging exploration of the environmental damages wrought by humanity. The disjointed essays touch on important topics like soil erosion, expanding drylands, melting glaciers, and other critical issues facing the planet. One travels back in time and across geographies, leading to some great discussions at times. The chapter on the Dust Bowl's legacy was this reviewer's favorite. This is where the author describes the lingering devastation of the Dust Bowl, demonstrating how once-thriving farmlands can be reduced to barren wastelands.
Unfortunately, these high points only emphasize how lacking the overall scholarly analysis of dust as a singular phenomenon ends up being. Compared to how authors like Mark Kurlansky (Salt), Helen Czerski (The Blue Machine, about the oceans), or Vaclav Smil (Energy and Civilization) exhaustively chronicle the histories, compositions, cultural impacts, and future implications of their respective subjects, Owens takes a decidedly scattershot approach. Discussions about dust's origin, composition, variations across time and geography, and potential mitigation strategies are hinted at but never fully realized. This book may feel somewhat superficial for a reader seeking a comprehensive understanding of dust.
Without a doubt, the author's cries for help on critical issues like soil degradation, water scarcity, to air pollution need to be heard. Some of her views against modernity will not be agreeable to all, but they do not make the need to focus on these eco-crises and their damages any less valid.
All that said, the book is almost as if the author or the publisher wanted to graft a ubiquitous, novel subject like dust to discuss these topics in a different garb. Unfortunately, the approach does not work.
All through, "The Hunter" stays off the well-trodden path of traditional murder mysteries. The central crime takes a backseat to the exploration of chAll through, "The Hunter" stays off the well-trodden path of traditional murder mysteries. The central crime takes a backseat to the exploration of character and setting, as is the wont with Ms. French, but far more than her usual. Unfortunately, its publishers have marketed the novel as a thriller; what gradually unfolds will confound readers expecting a whodunit. When the murder discussed in the second line of the burb does not happen until well into the story's second half, the misrepresentation is not just jarring but begs the question of what the book's producers were really thinking.
The delayed crime means the focus is on the slow build of character interactions and the setting's atmosphere. This approach reinforces the author's inclination to prioritize social and societal dynamics over the mystery. While this will not surprise those who have read the author before, a lack of novelty will.
Comparatively, the book doesn't match the vibrancy or the intricate character dynamics of any of the author’s previous work. The pacing feels sluggish, lacking the layers and character complexities to pull the reader in. The relationships explored are carryovers from the predecessor with little new. Even the setting, the Irish countryside, which usually acts as a character in its own right, fails to add anything novel to the narrative, missing an opportunity to enrich the story with fresh perspectives or insights.
In strange ways, the book may appeal those who did not read The Searcher. The author's ability to craft a scene and delve into the subtleties of human nature remains evident, offering a contemplative, if not thrilling, reading experience. The book's mood and aura are great, except that it is the same as in the first book.
Ultimately, "The Hunter" disappoints because of the standards set by Ms French through all her works. ...more
Loading...
