The Independent's journalism is supported by our readers. When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn commission.
We tried and tested devices from all the major tech players
For most shoppers, choosing the best smartwatch in 2024 is refreshingly straightforward. The major tech players each have their own device, designed to work hand-in-glove with their respective smartphone. The Apple Watch goes with the iPhone, the Galaxy Watch goes with the Galaxy phone, the Pixel Watch with the Pixel phone. You get the idea.
But there are still some complications – excuse the watch pun – when it comes to finding the right smartwatch for your needs. Even within the Apple ecosystem there are choices to make. You can opt for a rugged adventure watch in the Apple Watch Ultra or a leaner and cheaper option in the Apple Watch SE.
With Android smartwatches your options are expanded even more. Fitness-focused Garmin smartwatches are best for runners and outdoor training, while slimmer Fitbits are great for tracking steps and overall health around the clock. The Pixel Watch, OnePlus Watch 2 and Galaxy Watch 6 are less specialised, more lifestyle-focused and try to do it all: fitness tracking, workout metrics, and on-wrist calls, notifications, directions and assistance.
The line between smartwatch and fitness tracker has been blurred, meaning it’s worth putting in the research to find a wearable that does everything you need it to at the right price, while focusing on the features you care about. Do you want a smartwatch that looks great in the evening, with custom bands and a traditional design? Or do you want a beast of a smartwatch that can survive underwater or take a few knocks on challenging hikes?
To help you decide what to put on your wrist, we’ve rounded up the best smartwatches in 2024 for every kind of user.
IndyBest has been testing smartwatches for years, pairing each new wearable with a range of iPhone and Android phones to compare things like performance, looks, fitness tracking and sleep tracking.
Cycling and running are our testers’ preferred workouts, so while we check out as wide a range of workouts as we can, our testing mainly focused on those two popular exercises. We measure heart rate accuracy by comparing each smartwatch’s results with a chest strap monitor – specifically the MyZone MZ-3 (£79.99, Myzone.org) – and pay close attention to consistency. Consistency of results is more important than overall accuracy, as it’s this measurement that charts improvements to your fitness over time.
We also wear the leading smartwatches around the clock and overnight for sleep tracking, to determine how comfortable each device is to wear in the long-term, and to measure their usefulness for things like directions, notifications and making and taking calls and messages.
Want to bookmark your favourite articles and stories to read or reference later? Start your Independent Premium subscription today.
The Apple Watch Series 9 is the best smartwatch you can buy in 2024, with the caveat that it’s designed to work exclusively with the iPhone – it’s such an excellent smartwatch that it’s worth factoring in when considering which phone to buy. That said, Samsung has more than caught up with the Galaxy Watch 6, and even Google has made impressive strides with the neat design and comprehensive fitness tracking of the Pixel Watch 2.
The best smartwatch for you mostly depends on the type of phone in your pocket, but it’s worth considering what you’ll use the watch for. We recommend Garmin Forerunner 265 for serious runners, and the lifestyle-focused Fitbit Sense 2 for round-the-clock wellness and stress monitoring.
Looking for Some tech to aid in your fitness? Check out out round-up of the best running watches
Or if you would prefer:
Hi {{indy.fullName}}