The complete Staten Island pizza map: 178 spots to buy a slice or pie (updated)

Pizza

Where are you going for a slice or pie? Here's a map to try every spot in the borough. (Courtesy of Megan Lovallo) (Courtesy of Megan Lovallo)

By

STATEN ISLAND, N.Y. — Visuals often help to express the depth and breadth of a subject — like pizza. It’s a vast concept on Staten Island with 177 options, at the moment.

And there’s a map for all that.

Check out our interactive plotting based on the currently active food licenses as per the NYC Department of Health and Mental Hygiene and research of menus.

If you are reading on a mobile device, click here to view the map >>

Here are a few take-aways:

  • Highly concentrated areas lend themselves to DIY pizza tours by foot or bicycle.
  • Flatbreads count as pizza in our book, as at Pastavino in Stapleton, Tommy’s Tavern at the Staten Island Mall, Dolce Fantasia in Charleston and Violette’s in Grant City.
  • Bar pies aka personal pies only can be found at Panino Rustico in Huguenot and Grant City and Aunt Butchies of Richmond Valley.
  • Island Social of Great Kills serves late-night pizza, after 10 p.m. only.
  • The North Shore has great “Pepperoni Alley” potential where the New York slice takes centerstage, notably among Metro in West Brighton plus Port Richmond’s Gino’s and North Shore Pizzeria. Ungaro’s Coal Fired Pizza of the same neighborhood adds a charcoal-fired twist in the options.
  • We see Great Kills has a great trio of close places that are ideal for a manageable walking food tour, notably, among Nonna’s, Village Maria and Mimmo’s. But the marina area up through Hylan Boulevard also offers a range of high-density deliciousness between Big Al’s, Goodfella’s and Reggiano’s II.
  • Speaking of Reggiano’s, the Tottenville location closed on July 1.
  • Rosebank lends itself to be the “Corridor of Crust” from Rosebank Pizza down to Pronto, or the other way around, with a total of five parlors to hit.

This map will be updated as we go along. Send feedback to [email protected].

Other articles related to our pizza series:

What is pizza? Your official guide to classifiying the food

Pamela Silvestri

Most Popular Stories by Pamela Silvestri

If you purchase a product or register for an account through a link on our site, we may receive compensation. By using this site, you consent to our User Agreement and agree that your clicks, interactions, and personal information may be collected, recorded, and/or stored by us and social media and other third-party partners in accordance with our Privacy Policy.