TV Article Real ''Scary Movie''s Real ''Scary Movie''s -- Stars from Justin Timberlake to Nick Nolte talk about the creepiest films they've seen By William Keck Published on July 14, 2000 04:00AM EDT With the spoof Scary Movie slashing into theaters, we asked stars for their fave fright flick: MICHAEL MICHELE (ER)”Carrie. I was afraid to go to my prom.” JOHN C. REILLY (The Perfect Storm)”Jaws. I couldn’t take a bath for a long time.” MATTHEW LILLARD (Love’s Labour’s Lost)”Scream. Is that wrong to say something I was the killer in?” JUSTIN TIMBERLAKE (‘N Sync)”When I was 4, I saw When a Stranger Calls. It was really lame but scared the crap out of me.” KIMBERLY WILLIAMS (Father of the Bride)”Heathers — because high school is a truly terrifying time.” NICK NOLTE (Trixie)”Howdy Doody.” CHRIS KIRKPATRICK (‘N Sync)”Ishtar. I sat through the whole thing and, trust me, that was scary.”