Jennifer Garner, Jimmy Fallon, Cuba Gooding Jr. play Truth or Door on The Tonight Show

Truth or Dare is one of the oldest games in the book, so Jimmy Fallon gave it a new twist on Wednesday’s show. He challenged Jennifer Garner and Cuba Gooding Jr. to a game of “Truth or Door,” in which contestants had the choice between answering a question truthfully or opening a door to a random dare.

Gooding went first and chose a door. Hiding behind door number two was the challenge to dress up like a cowboy. This costume wasn’t a half-effort, either; Gooding ended up in a giant red hat, a colorful denim outfit, and even a giant piece of wheat to chew on.

WANT MORE? Keep up with all the latest late-night coverage by subscribing to our newsletter. Head here for more details.

Garner went next and also chose door. Though her dare was less colorful than Gooding’s, it was still ridiculous: she was forced to hold frozen water balloons in her arms for the rest of the game.

At first, Fallon tried to be a combo-breaker by taking truth, but when the question was, “How did you lose your virginity?”, the host opted for door instead. Behind this door was a bunch of paint, which Garner and Gooding were entitled to use to paint Fallon’s face however they wanted. And so the game concluded in colorful style, with a painted Fallon, Garner clutching her water balloons, and a cowboy Gooding.

Watch the full clip below.