Sometimes, it can be tricky to shop for the special person in your life. You know, your loved one who seemingly has everything under the sun.
You want to pick up something they’ll love — and actually use, too — but struggle to officially complete the purchase. What if I find something better? Will they like it?
Introducing Etsy, the online hotspot for all things unique, one-of-a-kind and custom-made. Whether you’re shopping for a holiday gift (nudge nudge, it’s not too early) or perhaps a bridesmaid or anniversary gift, rest assured we have the list for you. (Related: Best personalized gifts).
The New York Post Shopping team selected the best of the best from Etsy to compile the ultimate cheat sheet of 50 gifts — all less than $50 — for you to ooh and aah over.
While you’re browsing our dynamite must-haves, check out our guides to the best gift ideas for women (options for your girlfriend and wife, too), as well as our top-recommended gifts for your boyfriend and this year’s hottest toys.
Click to jump to a specific category:
Best Etsy Gifts for Her
Personalized Coffee Tumbler with Name and Birth Flower
- Etsy shop: BluegrassSips
We’ve recently received the Personalized Coffee Tumbler with Name and Birth Flower from a loved one, and it’s one of our favorite items in our kitchen (for less than $15, too!) Customizable with your recipient’s birth flower and name, it’s a well-made, affordable purchase if they’re a coffee lover.
Custom Makeup Bag
- Etsy shop: WestwoodStudioDesign
For the makeup aficionado, pick up the Custom Makeup Bag from Etsy — in any of its fun, velveteen colors. Pro tip: fill up your gift with some travel-sized toiletries that they can use and enjoy for a little somethin’ something.
Vintage Canned Pickles Sweatshirt
- Etsy shop: PrimeTeeLab
OK, we’ve been seeing the Vintage Canned Pickles Sweatshirt all over TikTok, and it’s especially perfect for the woman who loves savory snacks (specifically, a good Kosher dill). Though we never thought we’d recommend a pickle-painted pullover here at New York Post Shopping, stranger things have happened.
Personalized Hand-Painted Name Keychain
- Etsy shop: JillMakes
For just $20, how can you say no to the Personalized Hand-Painted Name Keychain? It’s suitable for any age, comes with a fun and vibrant tassel and is the ideal addition to your recipient’s work tote or backpack. More, it’ll garner plenty of compliments.
Woolen Fairisle Handwarmer Gloves
- Etsy shop: AmberAndRose
You can never go wrong with a cozy pair of mittens or gloves, and Etsy is offering this handmade, adorable and one-of-a-kind set for less than $30. Simply put, we want to wear these all fall and winter long.
Personalized Travel Jewelry Box
- Etsy shop: PersonalizationLab
Meet one of our favorite Etsy gifts that we’ve personally given to our bestie: the Personalized Travel Jewelry Box. You can’t beat its less-than-$10 price point, and its compartments are well-divided to store your affordable fine jewelry and hoop earrings alike.
For more options, check out our guide to the best jewelry organizers.
Personalized Waffle Robe
- Etsy shop: CosmicChakraThread
Treat the woman in your life to a getting-ready robe that she’ll want to wear on repeat. There’s nothing quite like the Personalized Waffle Robe, an option that’s available in plenty of colors and customization options. Making a lovely less-than-$50 gift, it’s one they’ll get great use out of.
Customized Fluffy Slippers
- Etsy shop: LaceAndRufflesShop
When there’s a robe, there’s also a pair of slippers. The Customized Fluffy Slippers have a super plush look and feel, topped off with beautiful script detailing and an embroidered heart accent to match. Not to mention, these make exquisite bridesmaid gifts.
Wine Bottle Pajama Pant
- Etsy shop: ThePaisleyBox
Made perfect for the wine lover you know, the Wine Bottle Pajama Pant is one of Etsy’s top recommendations (simply because it’s something we’d say “yes, rosè” to. Adding to its must-buy acclaim, they double as loungewear.
For more options, check out our guide to the best women’s pajamas.
Personalized Cosmetic Brushes Set
- Etsy shop: LetteringGiftsStudio
Let’s be real — one can never have too many makeup brushes atop their makeup vanity. Take the gift one step further with the Personalized Cosmetic Brushes Set, a less-than-$25 option that includes a custom-made name holder that’ll come in handy when she’s on the go (#score).
Personalized Marble Cheese Board
- Etsy shop: SahuaroLane
The Personalized Marble Cheese Board is apt for the charcuterie lover you know, the product going the extra mile in the custom-made department. Not to mention, it doubles as countertop decor and makes a pretty iconic hostess gift, if we do say so ourselves.
Birth Flower Bracelet
- Etsy shop: MinettaJewellery
For lovers of gold and florals alike, there’s nothing better than the Birth Flower Bracelet. Also available in silver, it’s the dainty touch that’s equally as meaningful, as this Etsy shop allows you to hand-pick your recipient’s birth month to custom-make its flower accent.
Personalized Canvas Bag with Initials
- Etsy shop: VictoriaMeroy
We found the Etsy gift that’s a no-brainer for any age (because, after all, you can’t have enough carry-all totes). The Personalized Canvas Bag with Initials comes in plenty of color options and design choices. Oh, and it’s supremely well made, thanks to its braided strap detailing.
Personalized Dog Blanket
- Etsy shop: WanderingHeartSigns
Attention, everyone who’s shopping for a dog lover. This less-than-$15 Personalized Dog Blanket has captured our attention and never left. In short, there’s nobody who’s obsessed with their dog who wouldn’t want this gift. Simply upload a photo of your loved one’s pup, customize and enjoy.
For more options, check out our guide to the best blankets we reviewed.
Personalized Journal for Best Friend
- Etsy shop: OlivePressCo
Show your BFF just how much she means to you with the Personalized Journal for Best Friend. With options to customize both the front and back covers, it’s a practical yet touching find that they’ll treasure for personal journaling or taking work notes alike.
Peanut Butter and Jelly BFF Necklaces
- Etsy shop: PixieCovegifts
OK, though this gift screams more “teen,” we’re kind of obsessed with its sentimental and corny charm for any age. For less than $20, it’ll be a staple in your loved one’s jewelry collection, for sure. Side note: the realistic texture is also pretty impressive.
Orange Cinnamon Artisanal Scented Soy Candle
- Etsy shop: Saugette
Is it just us, or does orange and cinnamon sound like a heavenly combo? Gift the gal who’s obsessed with candles the Orange Cinnamon Artisanal Scented Soy Candle — a fine choice on Etsy for less than $25. We want to burn it right along with you, just sayin’.
Best Etsy Gifts for Him
Special Place Map Print
- Etsy shop: VerbatimARTUK
An incredible gift for boyfriends, the Special Place Map Print is that meaningful purchase that he’ll swoon over — reminding him of where you first met. It’s also a must-have if you share a home together or have recently purchased one.
Custom Headphone Stand
- Etsy shop: Meow3DStore
Real talk — we all know a gamer, and the Custom Headphone Stand is a gift he’ll appreciate if he can’t seem to hop off his Playstation or Xbox. When personalized with his name, it’s all three things that compose a great gift: nifty, personalized and practical.
Personalized Full Grain Leather Dopp Kit
- Etsy shop: SRPLLeather
One of our top-recommended gifts is the Personalized Full Grain Leather Dopp Kit (hint hint, it’s also great for groomsmen gifts). Available in a suite of leather shades to choose from, it’s one that’s worth the pick-me-up, and also one you may want to fill with one of the best men’s razors for sensitive skin.
Personalized Cord Charger Organizer
- Etsy shop: MopsLeather
For the guy who can’t seem to keep his tech cords in order, the Personalized Cord Charger Organizer is the gift that keeps on giving. We love its plentiful compartments and handsome exterior, too.
Custom House Portrait for New Home
- Etsy shop: LMTCreativeAtHome
Add a sentimental touch to your recipient’s gift with the Custom House Portrait for New Home. Not only is it a legendary housewarming gift (but that goes without saying), it makes a great piece of decor for one’s foyer or living room.
Custom Engraved Marble Wooden Coasters
- Etsy shop: AvadirAndCo
Pick up the Custom Engraved Marble Wooden Coasters for budget-friendly coffee table toppers that he’ll cherish for a long time. They also make great wedding gifts for couples, and we can’t stop glossing over its multi-textured design.
Leather Golf Bag Tee Holder with Personalized Premium Bamboo Golf Tees
- Etsy shop: GodsoeEngravings
Calling all golf lovers: the Leather Golf Bag Tee Holder with Personalized Premium Bamboo Golf Tees is a gift we can’t believe is less than $15, either. Rest assured that this premium bundle will make its way out on the putting green for years and years, too.
Handcrafted Custom Leather Watch Case and Storage Organizer
- Etsy shop: TuliServices
We always recommend a good watch box as a gift men will appreciate, but the Handcrafted Custom Leather Watch Case and Storage Organizer takes the cake out of the catalog of options to choose from online. For even more of a splurge, pick up a quality men’s watch that he’ll treasure (and wear) forever.
Personalized Leather Belt
- Etsy shop: WoodPresentStudio
For another personalized accessory, look no further than the Personalized Leather Belt. It simply looks high-quality and comes in a multitude of size, color and accent materials to choose from — so you may want to pick up a few for more than one guy on your gift list.
For more options, check out our expert-backed guide to the best men’s belts.
Wooden Docking Station
- Etsy shop: RoyalWoodArt
As seen on nearly every gift guide you’ve probably seen on the internet, an all-in-one docking station hub is both practical and unique. We ran the gamut of these and wholeheartedly recommend the Wooden Docking Station, much ado to its premium wooden accents, customized name section and slots to store your sunglasses, watch, wallet and more.
Large Personalized Grill Gloves
- Etsy shop: AllAboutImpressions
For the grill-master, we can’t ignore the Large Personalized Grill Gloves. They’re thoughtful, useful and can easily fit in one’s stocking (a huge plus, may we add), and recommend them as the only pair the man in your life will need — truly.
BBQ Grilling Personalized Plate
- Etsy shop: OurPlatter
When there’s grilling, there’s a custom grilling plate waiting to be picked up as well. Shop the BBQ Grilling Personalized Plate, especially perfect for daughters and sons to gift to their fathers. And, even though Father’s Day is labeled on the pictured plate, you can format the text with whatever you’d like, should you purchase it for another occasion.
Custom Photo Leather Wallet
- Etsy shop: southernkickleather
We’ve been recommending the Custom Photo Leather Wallet so much IRL, simply because it’s sleek and not too flashy, yet adds a personalized gifting touch for anyone on your list. For less than $25, too, it’s time to up the ante on your man’s wallet.
Handmade Bourbon Vanilla Soap
- Etsy shop: PinkParchmentSoaps
If the man you’re shopping for loves bourbon, pick up the unique Handmade Bourbon Vanilla Soap on Etsy for less than $10. Who can really resist a handmade soap, after all, especially with these two alluring scent notes that will make any shower or bath a dream?
Personalized Wine Stopper
- Etsy shop: PacificCustoms
Classy and elegant, the Personalized Wine Stopper is one you simply can’t ignore. Once the cork is off, you need something to top off your favorite bottle, so this custom gift is a no-brainer.
For another add-on, shop from one of the best wine delivery services we rounded up.
Hive Personalized Cufflink Stand
- Etsy shop: MijMojDesign
We typically recommend a quality pair of cufflinks as a gift any man will love, but a cufflinks stand? Now that’s one to pick up for a unique present.
Whether positioned atop his dresser or as part of his walk-in-closet setup, this less-than-$40 option will double as handsome decor and a convenient storage solution for his accessories. Yes, please.
Personalized Guitar Pick with Holder
- Etsy shop: HandCraftWoodStudio
For the man who loves his guitar, we found the hottest gift around: the Personalized Guitar Pick with Holder. It’s the sweetest keepsake we’ve found in a long time, and one he’ll certainly treasure for years to come.
Best Etsy Gifts for Babies and Kids
Personalized Name Puzzle with Pegs
- Etsy shop: BusyPuzzle
The Personalized Name Puzzle with Pegs is a gift we’ve been seeing all over Etsy for years, and it’s time we announced it for all to see. Little ones love puzzles (and, taking things apart and putting them back together again), so this popular pick isn’t one you should sleep on.
Personalized Kids Small Backpack
- Etsy shop: PenleyDCBshop
Whether for school or dance class, the Personalized Kids Small Backpack has to be cutest accessory we’ve seen in a good while. the best part? It’s less than $30, aside from being adorably custom-made with its pastel colors.
For more options, check out our guide to the best back-to-school backpacks that are versatile enough for any adventure.
Wooden Toddler 29-Piece Tool Set
- Etsy shop: joytotheshop
Do-it-yourself-inspired toy sets are all the rage these days, and for a good reason — they help strengthen fine motor skills and individualized play. Whether shopping for your two-year-old or three-year-old, this 29-Piece Tool Set is colorful, original and beyond cute.
Personalized 15-Piece Pink Polka Dot Tea Party Set
- Etsy shop: PersonalizationMall
The girliest tea party ever, unlocked. Shop the Personalized 15-Piece Pink Polka Dot Tea Party Set for a custom-made set your little girl will tap into for years. If its fascinating polka-dot pattern isn’t enough to lure you in, its script-embossed travel set will.
Personalized Piggy Bank with Name
- Etsy shop: OmegaCraftShop
Personal finance starts at, well, age one, so pick up the Personalized Piggy Bank with Name for a sweet nursery decor piece that’ll teach your baby or toddler the importance of the hard-earned dollar. For less than $15 right now, this seller allows you to customize your name and shade preference before checkout.
Personalized Name Toy Truck
- Etsy shop: TrucksAndMoreToys
Trucks are cool and all, but this one drives all of the competition away. Shop the Personalized Name Toy Truck for less than $15. Customizability aside, you can also choose your little one’s favorite color to have the most ultimate gift ever.
2-Piece Name Jogger Set for Kids
- Etsy shop: TinyKindCo
Hey, loungewear is just as important for kiddos as it is for adults, and the 2-Piece Name Jogger Set for Kids is a great option for any gender or age. With an elastic waistband at the bottoms and a traditional crewneck style for the top, it’s a photogenic matching set that we recommend.
Personalized Musical Carousel for Kids
- Etsy shop: AncerlStudio
If your little one loves ponies, the mall’s carousel ride and music, we have the gift for you. Shop the Personalized Musical Carousel for Kids — both a toy and a keepsake — that would look beautiful on their bedroom’s bookshelf.
Personalized Children’s Step Stool
- Etsy shop: LetsMakeMemoriesUS
The Personalized Children’s Step Stool is practical enough to transition your little one from their first steps to climbing, and we love how this gift (that, yes, is only one cent away from $50) is something they’ll put to good use. Even better, it doubles as a miniature play table if they sit on the floor.
Custom Wooden Personalized Animal Crochet Rattle
- Etsy shop: BeWellGroup
Soothing toys that are easy to grab are what we recommend for one-year-olds, and the Custom Wooden Personalized Animal Crochet Rattle fits the bill perfectly. We love its well-made wooden design, soft crochet detailing and ability to customize with one’s name and favorite animal.
Embroidered Knit Baby Blanket with Name
- Etsy shop: GloryParty
Speaking of one-year-olds, we can’t ignore the Embroidered Knit Baby Blanket with Name. It’s the most fitting gifts for newborns (and, after all, one can never have too many blankets — one for the car seat and another for their crib).
Custom Nature Scavenger Hunt Montessori Toy
- Etsy shop: heyhooray
Allow your little one to explore their senses and the nature world at large with the Custom Nature Scavenger Hunt Montessori Toy. They’ll have so much fun scouring your park or backyard for leaves, rocks, bark and more with this interactive sorting gift, too.
Montessori Personalized Toy Phone
- Etsy shop: HeritageWayLiving
BRB, we’re purchasing the Montessori Personalized Toy Phone for our nieces. It’s especially fitting for the three-year-old stage — where they may be starting to head to nursery school, dance school or sports — because it’ll have mommy or daddy’s phone number engraved onto it, should an emergency arise.
Magnetic Kids Fishing Game
- Etsy shop: MaisieTaylorDesigns
No fishy gifts here, only the Magnetic Kids Fishing Game that’s a unique find for lovers of the ocean and fish tanks alike. Its magnetic charm results in easy cleanup when done, and it’s a great way to learn about colors, sorting and even a bit of science, thanks to its magnetic design.
Handmade Crochet Princess Dolls
- Etsy shop: FayeFayeMommy
News alert: Disney always makes a good gift for the little one you’re shopping for, and it’s no surprise those under three love lining up toys and playing with them. For less than $40, this bundle will serve as the toy store smorgasbord they’ve always wanted.
Montessori Makeup Toy Set
- Etsy shop: ArtEstBeautiful
If your little one loves playing with your lipstick, the Montessori Makeup Toy Set has to be one of the most adorable toy bundles we’ve seen (c’mon, just look at that wooden hair straightener and nail polish bottle!) You can’t pass this up for less than $40, either.
Check out the New York Post Shopping section for more content.