Celebrity Celebrity Relationships Celebrity Dating Olivia Culpo Details Why She Broke Her 'No Athletes Ever Again' Dating Rule for Christian McCaffrey Culpo previously dated star athletes Tim Tebow, Ryan Lochte and Danny Amendola By Hedy Phillips Hedy Phillips Hedy Phillips is the Style Editor at PEOPLE. She has been working at PEOPLE since 2022. Her work has previously appeared in POPSUGAR, HelloGiggles, Reader's Digest and more. People Editorial Guidelines Published on November 7, 2022 11:25AM EST Photo: Rich Graessle/PPI/Icon Sportswire via Getty Olivia Culpo's had a change of heart. The influencer and model has been dating San Francisco 49ers running back Christian McCaffrey since 2019, and despite previously setting a "no athletes ever again" dating rule, she made an exception for McCaffrey. Culpo, 30, previously dated the likes of Ryan Lochte and Tim Tebow, but the relationships didn't pan out. However, she told Entertainment Tonight earlier this month that with her current boyfriend, she doesn't have some of the concerns she had with other athletes. "He's just the best, I feel like he is really everything that I could ever ask for," she said of McCaffrey, 26. "So I never have to worry about anything. I think that was the reason why I didn't want to date an athlete, no offense, because there is a reputation there." Olivia Culpo Reacts to Boyfriend Christian McCaffrey Being Traded to 49ers: 'I'm So Proud of You' Olivia Culpo Says Boyfriend Christian McCaffrey Restored Her 'Faith in Love' on Their Third Anniversary Culpo continued, "He just comes from a great family. We have a lot in common in that respect. I feel like you can really tell who a person is by the people that raise them, and I just love his parents so much. They have a great relationship." The Culpo Sisters told ET that McCaffrey has a "good head on his shoulders" and that the two are mapping out their future. The former Miss Universe is "excited" about what's to come for them and made sure to jokingly mention how "hot" her beau is. The two first met when they were set up by friends, Culpo shared in an Instagram post celebrating their third anniversary recently. She wrote that she wasn't sure she was ready to date but decided to go for it anyway. "I'm so grateful for the voice inside me that told me to give love another chance," she wrote. "The yin to my yang, you are the epitome of strength through humility. Thank you for being my rock and restoring my faith in love. You are everything I ever dreamed of and more ❤️ ❤️" Olivia Culpo Tearfully Opens Up About Traumatic Past Relationship in Trailer for 'The Culpo Sisters' Never miss a story — sign up for PEOPLE's free weekly newsletter to get the biggest news of the week delivered to your inbox every Friday. In a trailer for her new show with her sisters, Sophia and Aurora, on TLC, Culpo opened up about a past relationship that made her feel "less than human." "I worry all the time about the future. I always thought by 30 I would be married [and] I'd have kids," Culpo said in the clip. "I was with somebody that did really horrible, horrible things. I was made to feel like a less-than human in every sense of the word. I've never talked about it before," she admitted. Although it is unclear who the influencer is referring to in the emotional confessional, Culpo was in an on-and-off relationship with NFL player Danny Amendola, which resulted in a public falling out. In April 2019, the Detroit Lions wide receiver took to social media to slam Culpo's lifestyle and rumored romance with DJ Zedd on a now-deleted Instagram tirade.