The Masked Singer Delivers 1 of Jenny McCarthy's 'Favorite Smackdowns' on Harry Potter Night

Warning: This post contains spoilers from the latest episode of The Masked Singer.

The Masked Singer cast its spell on Wednesday — but one member of Group B had a less-than-enchanted evening.

Season 2’s Flamingo Adrienne Bailon-Houghton started off Wednesday’s Harry Potter Night with a rendition of “I Put a Spell on You” by Screamin’ Jay Hawkins.

Judges Ken Jeong, Jenny McCarthy, Nicole Scherzinger and Robin Thicke got into the spirit by dressing up as Severus Snape, Albus Dumbledore, Hermione Granger and Sirius Black, respectively.

Tiki started off the Group B performances by sharing in their clue package that they “really found the magic in my life these days.”

Tiki also said they reached a point in their career where they wondered, “Do you let yourself get watered down, or do you change with the times?”

Tiki chose the latter.

“I decided to put the hard-partying lifestyle on the back burner and my family on tap,” the tropical drink continued in the clue package that showed a piano and a grandfather clock. “I used to be up every night partying until 6 a.m. — now that’s what time my alarm goes off to take my kid to school.”

Tiki sang “Magic” by Pilot, which caused Thicke, 46, to decide to tell Tiki, “Your voice is so iconic and so legendary.”

The Sorting Hat placed Tiki into Gryffindor, which Tiki thought made sense. “You gotta be brave to be front and center of the types of stages I command,” Tiki said.

The panel thought Tiki could be Dave Grohl, Jon Bon Jovi, The Who’s Roger Daltrey or Led Zeppelin’s Robert Plant.

Husky followed up with a touch of vulnerability.

“Growing up, I was also an underestimated wizard,” Husky said in his clue package of how he related to the boy wizard. “As a young pup, I was picked on a lot.”

Husky said his peers called him "skinny," but he eventually “evolved from a skinny boy to a husky man.”

The clue package also included a rose, a globe and three King of Hearts playing cards.

“Despite all the love and inspiring some lovemaking, to this day I still don’t feel like I made it,” Husky admitted.

The snow dog got freaky to “Super Freak" by Rick James and ended up being sorted into Hufflepuff.

“I actually had a feeling I’d be the Hufflepuff because of my connection to Mr. Puff himself: P. Diddy,” Husky said.

Ginuwine, Brian McKnight and Tank arose as options for Husky.

Hawk flew onto the stage next.

“Not too long ago, someone close to me lost her battle with cancer,” Hawk confessed in his clue package. “She was my support system and my best friend. And after she passed, nothing seemed to matter.”

Hawk said that he sought help and learned “that while the pain will never go away, it lessens.” A teen slasher, a book marked “don’t open” and a message from Mama Hawk popped up in the clue package, too.

The bird of prey covered The Police’s “Every Little Thing She Does Is Magic.”

“Great performance through and through,” Jeong, 54, told Hawk.

The Sorting Hat put Hawk in Ravenclaw because of the bird connection.

“It makes a lot of sense that I’m Ravenclaw because I was a good student — or at least you saw me on TV pretending to be,” Hawk said.

That made the panel think Hawk could be Billie Joe Armstrong, Andrew Garfield or Ryan Phillippe.

With that, a surprising new contestant entered the competition: Sea Queen.

“I’ve always been a bit of a wildcard in life,” Sea Queen said in their clue package that featured a black widow and a CD player.

The underwater royal admitted they got fired from their first job giving museum tours and got kicked out of boarding school. But that didn’t limit Sea Queen’s success.

“Comedy, writing, singing, I’ve done it all and these days, I’m preparing for a new tour,” Sea Queen said.

Sea Queen put their spin on “Love Potion No. 9” by The Searchers before being sorted into Slytherin.

“Slytherin makes sense for me,” Sea Witch agreed. “I’ve always been clever in my career: you never know which genre you’ll catch me in next.”

The judges suspected Sea Queen might be Erykah Badu, Queen Latifah or Jenifer Lewis.

Host Nick Cannon informed the studio audience that the time had come for them to vote for their favorite performance of the night. The lowest ranking contestants would face off in The Smackdown. Cannon, 43, revealed that this week, it would be Tiki and Hawk battling it out.

They each stunned on "Monster" by Lady Gaga, making it tough for the judges to decide who to eliminate.

“Now that was a Smackdown,” said Scherzinger, 45.

McCarthy, 50, called it “one of my favorite Smackdowns of all time.”

In the end, the panel chose to advance Tiki to the Group B Finals and sent home Hawk. When Hawk unmasked, he ended up being Teen Wolf star — and newlywed! — Tyler Posey.

Never miss a story — sign up for PEOPLE's free daily newsletter to stay up-to-date on the best of what PEOPLE has to offer, from juicy celebrity news to compelling human interest stories.

The Masked Singer airs Wednesdays at 8 p.m. ET on Fox.