8 unspoken problems that some Singapore hawkers face

Aaron Tan
·5-min read

On 1 Jan 2024, the GST rate rose from 8% to 9%, and the cost of ingredients has significantly increased. As a result, hawkers have likely hiked prices or reduced portions, to the dismay of some unhappy Singaporeans. But have we ever put ourselves in the hawkers’ shoes? Do we empathise with the problems they face?

problems hawkers face - KF Seetoh

I came across an article titled “The Problem with Hawkers” written by none other than the renowned Mr KF Seetoh, the founder of Makansutra. And trust me, I was shell-shocked when I read it.

Cramped spaces, long hours on their feet, demanding customers, no time to visit the washroom— you thought you knew all their woes. But not after what Mr Seetoh shared— he is indeed a hero to all hawkers.

problems hawkers face - hawkers
problems hawkers face - hawkers

After leaving my 14-year career as a chef life in the F&B industry and joining Sethlui.com as a content writer for 2 years now, my love and respect for hawkers has skyrocketed. I’ve seen their struggles, listened to their stories and challenges, and developed friendships with many of them (I love my job!).

And with that, let me share a list of 8 unspoken problems that some Singapore hawkers face at Social Enterprise Hawker Centres (SEHC), as depicted by Mr KF Seetoh.

Do note that these problems do not apply to EVERY food centre, just in case some keyboard warriors do decide to attack me in the comments section (rolls eyes).

1. Unsubsidised stalls

Yup! If you think hawkers have it easy and get the stalls at subsidised rates, you are wrong. Instead, they have to bid for their stalls under NEA regulations. According to an article posted on Mothership in Nov 2023, a Golden Mile Food Centre hawker stall’s bid reached almost S$6,000.

Well, if it was back in 2013, new hawker stall owners could’ve taken over from existing stall owners without a fee, but NEA has since discontinued it. It looks like my friend who has a stall at Amoy Street Food Centre is sighing with relief.

2. Monthly rentals

problems hawkers face - hawker centre
problems hawkers face - hawker centre

Have you visited a hawker centre and thought to yourself, “Why isn’t there an old-fashioned wafer ice cream stall instead of the same-old duck rice or ban mian establishment that we spot everywhere?”

That’s because the SEHCs charge an average rental cost of S$2,000 (GST included) for any kind of food sold. As a result, hawkers have no choice but to sell food that can earn profits and is popular with Singaporeans.

3. Pay for cleaning & washing of utensils & crockery

Besides an average monthly dishwashing fee of about S$650, hawkers at some of these SEHCs have to top-up S$6 for every rack of about 30 plates and bowls— sometimes, a few racks are needed per day! Additionally, Services and Conservancy Charges of about S$380 also need to be paid (Amoy Street Food Centre charges S$175).

Luckily, my hawker friend at a food centre in Hougang doesn’t need to pay for the aforementioned extra fees since it’s included in the rent. However, he still needs to fork out S$4,000.

4. Must offer S$3 meals & 30 monthly “pay-it-forward” meals

The S$3 budget meal initiative is catered for the financially challenged or for senior citizens who are not working. But you meet well-to-do customers who take advantage of this. Can you imagine if every customer orders the S$3 meal? How on earth does the hawker earn enough to pay for his monthly rent then?

For newer hawker establishments, some hawkers are being forced to do “charity” by offering 30 free meals at their own expense (not for older food centres). I really agree with Mr Seetoh that charity should come from your own sincerity and not based on a contract.

15 stalls at Boon Lay Place Food Village to travel west for

5. Banned from using their own crockery

Some hawkers aren’t allowed to use their own plates and bowls. They have to purchase it from the SEHC ‘approved’ supplier which marks the SEHC company logo, with a minimum of 300 pieces for each type of ware.

Fortunately, my friend at Amoy Street Food Centre is able to use his own crockery and fully express his desired presentation.

6. Forced to use gas supplier chosen by the SEHC

problems hawkers face - cooking with gas
problems hawkers face - cooking with gas

Suggestions by the hawkers to utilise a more budget-friendly and equally reliable gas supplier were rejected by the SEHC. That’s it— all efforts to save money are gone.

7. Hawkers must have valid leave of absence, otherwise pay S$100 

If hawkers at some of these SEHCs need to take annual leave, MC, or leave for emergency purposes, it must be approved in advance. Otherwise, a S$100 fine will be imposed. So does that mean if a hawker is suddenly down with a bad fever and needs to take a last minute 3-day MC, he has to be fined S$300? That’s ridiculous!

8. Profit percentage & additional space charge

problems hawkers face - additional charges
Credit

If the hawkers have good business and hit their sales target; hooray! It means that they can finally earn profits. But no! Some of these SEHCs have to ruin it and charge a profit percentage, known in the industry as Gross Turnover (GTO), of up to 15%.

And WHAT? Hawkers are even charged for the tiny, inadequate space where suppliers leave their goods if they arrive early? That’s a little too much, isn’t it?

These 8 problems are just the tip of the iceberg. Mr KF Seetoh’s article addresses more issues, and we really need to help our hawkers.

A round-up of 2023’s best hawker food spots found in Singapore

The post 8 unspoken problems that some Singapore hawkers face appeared first on SETHLUI.com.

  • Up next
  • Up next
  • Up next
  • Up next

Latest stories

  • Microsoft outage leaves China largely untouched as tech self-sufficiency campaign pays off

    The Microsoft Windows outage that affected foreign businesses and luxury hotels in China on Friday left the country's key infrastructure, from airlines to banks, largely unaffected, according to industry sources and social media posts. As of 6pm local time, there have been no reports in mainland China of infrastructure breakdowns, while many airports in the Asia-Pacific region, from Hong Kong to Australia, were hit with disruptions. The international airports in Beijing and Shanghai were operati

  • Porsche replaces China boss amid sales slump

    FRANKFURT (Reuters) -German luxury sportscar maker Porsche AG will replace the chief executive of its China business, it said on Saturday, a move that follows a major drop sales in the world's largest automotive market. Alexander Pollich will become Porsche China CEO on Sept. 1, 2024, at the earliest, the company said, replacing Michael Kirsch, who will move to another unspecified role within the company. With 57-year old Pollich, Porsche's China business will be led by an "internationally experienced sales expert" who has been with the company for more than 23 years, most recently as chairman of the executive board of Porsche Deutschland GmbH, the carmaker said.

  • Global tech outage: Microsoft VP explains what went wrong

    It's a software update that had huge repercussions. All around the globe, companies have faced technology troubles after an update from cybersecurity firm CrowdStrike (CRWD) impacted Microsoft (MSFT) systems. It led to delayed and canceled flights, stores closing their doors for the day, and headaches for millions. CrowdStrike CEO George Kurtz posted on X the outage wasn't caused by a cyberattack and that a fix had been deployed. Many believe it could take a few days for all systems to be fully back online.  Microsoft corporate vice president and deputy CISO Ann Johnson tells Market Domination about what went wrong. Johnson used the analogy of updating an app on your smartphone overnight. That's basically what CrowdStrike did; they issued an update overnight, and that update ended up roiling systems. Johnson explains that Microsoft is working with CrowdStrike to help those customers who were impacted by the update, adding that Microsoft has engineers working to help businesses implement the fix.  Johnson says it's hard to say how long it will take for all issues to be fully resolved, but ultimately believes CrowdStrike likely did test the update thoroughly and that the problem was "something that was unexpected."  For more expert insight and the latest market action, click here to watch this full episode of Market Domination. This post was written by Stephanie Mikulich.

  • How China swerved worst of global tech meltdown

    Very few organisations will buy software from the US firm, partly thanks to its criticism of Beijing.

  • Chinese industry body tells EU to correct its findings on EVs

    EU tariffs on electric vehicles built in China breach global trading rules and must be corrected, an industry body representing 12 Chinese automakers told the European Commission in a hearing this week. The China Chamber of Commerce for Import and Export of Machinery and Electronic Products (CCCME) presented its view at a hearing on Thursday that the EU's preliminary assessment is incompatible with EU and World Trade Organization rules. The European Union imposed provisional tariffs of between 17.4% and 37.6% earlier in July on EVs made in China, including Chinese brands BYD, Geely and SAIC as well as models built in China by Western manufacturers such as Tesla and BMW.

  • US Fed fines Green Dot $44 million for numerous unfair and deceptive practices

    The U.S. Federal Reserve announced on Friday it had fined Utah-based Green Dot $44 million for numerous "unfair and deceptive" practices, as well as deficient risk management. The central bank said in a statement the firm, which issues prepaid debit cards, violated consumer law in marketing those products, as well as its tax return preparation payment services. The Fed said the company also improperly blocked accounts of legitimate customers receiving unemployment benefits, and lacked policies to address the errors.

  • Who will pay for the worst IT outage the world has seen?

    After the chaos of Friday's global IT outage - without doubt the worst the world has seen - questions are starting to be asked about who, if anyone, will pick up the bill. The first is that it is impossible, this soon after the outage, to establish the sheer quantum of losses arising from it. Secondly, even if a business or an individual consumer has been affected by the outage, it will not necessarily be straightforward to prove that any losses incurred were as a result of the outage.

  • CrowdStrike's terms and conditions say most customers would just get a refund due to the massive outage, cybersecurity lawyer says

    CrowdStrike and cybersecurity insurers can expect years of lawsuits after a botched update sparked a devastating outage.

  • How Can I Cover $4,000 in Monthly Living Expenses? I'm 60 With $800k, and Won't Collect Social Security for 5 Years

    Imagine that you’re 60 years old with $800,000 in retirement savings and $4,000 in monthly living expenses. However, you want to wait until age 65 to claim Social Security, so you need to find a way to generate additional income for five more years. Whether you plan to delay Social Security or not, a financial […] The post How Do I Cover $4,000 in Monthly Living Expenses? I’m 60 With $800k in Retirement Savings, But I Won’t Collect Social Security for 5 Years appeared first on SmartReads by Smar

  • CrowdStrike and Microsoft: What we know about global IT outage

    A mass IT outage has caused chaos around the world, with major airlines among the victims.

  • Boeing expects 787 suppliers to catch up by year's end, restoring output

    Boeing expects delayed suppliers to catch up on parts that have slowed production of its 787 jets to below a rate of five a month, as the U.S. planemaker works to restore output of two key commercial programs by the year's end. Boeing and its European rival Airbus are struggling to meet strong airline demand for jets as they wrestle with problems within their supply chains and factories. Such concerns are set to cast a shadow at the Farnborough Airshow from July 22 to 26, despite strong travel demand.

  • Economy booms but India's young hanker for government jobs

    Sunil Kumar, a 30-year-old, has spent the last 9 years of his life chasing a job in the Indian government. Packed with scores of others in makeshift classrooms under tin roofs with barely enough light and air, Kumar has spent years cramming for a variety of tests, including the prestigious civil services exam needed to get a job as a federal government bureaucrat. A resident of Uttar Pradesh, the country's most populous state, Kumar says he will continue to try for a government job until he turns 32, three years short of the cut-off for him to appear in a civil services exam.

  • 53-Year-Old Caller Asks Dave Ramsey, 'Are We Going To Have To Live On Beans And Rice Through Retirement?' — Here's Where They're At

    A recent episode of "The Ramsey Show" featured 53-year-old Lisa from Waco, TX, seeking retirement advice for herself and her 59-year-old husband. Together, they have a household income of $7,700, but their nest egg isn't quite where it should be, with her husband just a few years away from his desired retirement age. Don't Miss: Are you richer than most people you know? Here’s the net worth you need at every age to be above average. Can you guess how many Americans successfully retire with $1,00

  • I’m Planning My Retirement: 9 Ways the Election Outcome Affects My Plan

    Jane F. has been looking forward to her retirement for years. "My Google calendar has a countdown!" she shared. The 71-year-old food service worker is watching the election closely because she knows...

  • Australian court fines AmEx $5.3 million over breach of credit card rules

    The court found that American Express Australia distributed two credit cards primarily to customers in stores of luxury brand David Jones between late May and early July in 2022 without appropriately determining the target market. "A penalty of this order ensures it has a 'sting' sufficient to deter both repetition by American Express and contravention by other providers of financial products, and one that goes beyond being a mere 'cost of doing business'," Federal Court Justice Ian McNeil Jackman said.

  • Crowdstrike's massive global IT crash: Here's what you need to know

    US cybersecurity firm CrowdStrike on Friday said it ‘had deployed’ a fix for a faulty software update that caused technology outages in much of the world, disrupting banks, airports, health care and media. Experts say the disruptions to companies and services reflect a worldwide dependence on software made by just a few providers. Much of the world faced online disarray Friday as a widespread technology outage affected companies and services across industries — grounding flights, knocking banks

  • Binance.US gets federal judge nod to invest customer assets in Treasury bills

    The order frees Binance.US from restrictions levied by the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission, the affiliate said on Friday. Binance will transfer crypto to a third-party custodian not affiliated with the exchange, the order stated. Binance.US operator BAM has also been permitted to invest certain customer fiat funds, custodied at crypto custody firm BitGo, in U.S. Treasury bills.

  • Grant Cardone: $5 Million Is Now the Magic Number for Retirement Savings

    Grant Cardone, a private equity fund manager and real estate investor, is proposing a new federal financial education program that would improve financial literacy across the U.S. Cardone's...

  • Chip Stocks Have Gotten Hammered. Why the Damage Might Be Overdone.

    The has dropped 8.1% from July 10 through Thursday’s close, while Nvidia stock has fallen 10%. Pushing them down: A weaker-than-expected inflation print that investors bet would give the Federal Reserve cover to cut interest rates in September; comments by former President Donald Trump, who said that he would force Taiwan to pay for the protection it receives from the U.S.; and news this week that the Biden Administration floated the possibility of stepped-up restrictions on certain semiconductor equipment makers’ sales to China. For starters, Nvidia, AMD, and Broadcom got about 20% of their total sales in the past 12 months from China, according to our calculations of FactSet data.

  • Traders eye return to business as usual after cyber outage, issues remain

    LONDON/NEW YORK (Reuters) -Trading returned to normal on Friday after a global technology outage hampered operations at financial firms from London to Singapore and New York, although a few residual problems remained, including outages at some JPMorgan Chase automated teller machines. The outage sent ripples through financial markets during Asia and early European trading hours with a number of firms involved in various aspects of the trading process affected. LSEG Group, which runs the London Stock Exchange, said its Workspace news and data platform, regulatory news service and currency spot and forward prices had been affected by the outage caused by a "third-party global technical issue".