Germany legend Lothar Matthaus claims Hansi Flick gave Japan 'an invitation to attack' by taking off Havertz, Muller and Musiala early in shock defeat - and compares it to when he was subbed off in 1999 Champions League final
- Japan came from behind to stun Germany with a 2-1 win on Wednesday in Qatar
- World Cup winner Lothar Matthaus criticised Hansi Flick's late substitutions
- He claimed taking off stars caused a lack of rhythm as Germany sought victory
- To relive all the action from the seismic game see Sportsmail's match report
- For all the latest updates from Qatar follow Sportsmail's LIVE World Cup blog
- Click here for the latest World Cup 2022 news, fixtures, live action and results
Lothar Matthaus has criticised Germany manager Hansi Flick's substitutions in their shock opening match defeat to Japan on Wednesday in Qatar.
The German legend likened the result to Bayern Munich's last-minute defeat to Manchester United in the 1999 Champions League final - in which Matthaus was taken off late on.
As the overwhelming favourites for the tie began to falter, the former Bayern manager rang the changes, taking off Ilkay Gundogan, Kai Havertz, Jamal Musiala, Thomas Muller and Serge Gnabry - a move that Matthaus does not agree with.
![Lothar Matthaus has criticised Hansi Flick's substitutions late in the game against Japan](https://i.dailymail.co.uk/1s/2022/11/24/11/64899289-11465617-image-a-31_1669290955827.jpg)
Lothar Matthaus has criticised Hansi Flick's substitutions late in the game against Japan
![Chelsea's Kai Havertz was among the German flops given a low score in Bild's ratings](https://i.dailymail.co.uk/1s/2022/11/24/12/64889973-11465617-Chelsea_s_Kai_Havertz_was_among_the_German_flops_given_a_low_sco-a-42_1669291689279.jpg)
Chelsea's Kai Havertz was among the German flops given a low score in Bild's ratings
![](https://i.dailymail.co.uk/1s/2022/11/24/12/64899281-11465617-image-a-51_1669292556773.jpg)
Two late goals sunk the Germans in the opening fixture of Group E at the Khalifa Stadium
'I thought of the 1999 final, when (Ottmar) Hitzfeld substituted me shortly before the end, and Manchester United won 2-1.
'You take a personality off the field that your opponent respects, and you're letting them know you feel safe, too sure! An invitation to attack. It was like that now.
'By substituting Müller and Gündogan, two experienced players at the same time, the order lost. The rhythm was lost.'
![Bild gave five German players a score of 5 - the second-lowest possible - after the loss](https://i.dailymail.co.uk/1s/2022/11/24/12/64890015-11465617-Bild_gave_five_German_players_a_score_of_5_the_second_lowest_pos-a-46_1669291721009.jpg)
Bild gave five German players a score of 5 - the second-lowest possible - after the loss
Having taken the lead through an Ilkay Gundogan penalty in the first half, Germany had looked set to take all three points against Japan on Wednesday.
However a second half comeback, inspired by Ritsu Doan and Takuma Asano saw the underdogs fight back to take the victory and stun both Germany and the football world.
But the team were not functioning incredibly well before the substitutions were made, either, and the entire team came in for a scathing review from Bild.
In total, five players from the team were awarded a rating of 5 - the second-lowest possible score according to the German outlet's rating system.
Havertz was joined by Gnabry, David Raum, Nicklas Sule and Nico Schlotterbeck.
At 1-0 the former Bayern coach began to make changes, with Gundogan and Muller making way for Leon Goretzka and Jonas Hoffman respectively.
![Hansi Flick's side must now beat Spain on Sunday to rescue their hopes of progression](https://i.dailymail.co.uk/1s/2022/11/24/12/64899845-11465617-image-a-47_1669291888893.jpg)
Hansi Flick's side must now beat Spain on Sunday to rescue their hopes of progression
But after Japan's equaliser through Freiburg's Doan, another double substitution saw the woeful Havertz replaced with Niclas Fuulkrug and Musiala hooked for hero of 2014 Mario Gotze.
![Matthaus compared the subs to Bayern's late defeat to Manchester United in 1999](https://i.dailymail.co.uk/1s/2022/11/24/12/64899843-11465617-image-a-50_1669291975496.jpg)
Matthaus compared the subs to Bayern's late defeat to Manchester United in 1999
Then after Japan's dramatic second goal - which proved to be the winner - Gnabry was taken off for youngster Youssoufa Moukoko in a last, desperate throw of the dice from Flick, which ultimately failed to come good.
But it was not just the substitutions that were savaged by Matthaus, who also saw plenty worth criticising in Flick's starting XI before the game.
'I always stand by Hansi Flick, but I didn't understand a few things about the game. The national coach has to put up with questions,' he said.
'For example the formation of the full-backs. Why doesn't (Thilo) Kehrer play, who has always played lately? The goals conceded came from outside. Süle is not a full-back. At 2-1, the space is far too far forward, but defenders are there to defend.
'Then Schlotterbeck looks surprised, doesn't go aggressively enough, Süle cancels the offside.'
![](https://i.dailymail.co.uk/i/pix/2017/08/02/636x90_facebook_ad_sport.png)
Most watched Sport videos
- Giants fans burn quarterback Daniel Jones' jersey after loss
- John Hunt makes a poignant return to the commentary box at Brighton
- Moment Miami Dolphin's Tyreek Hill is arrested by police
- Tyreek Hill speeds by police before cops aggressively pull him over
- Shocking bodycam of Tyreek Hill arrest released by Miami-Dade PD
- Woman exposes NRL boyfriend for leaving her for another
- Johnny Gaudreau's wife Meredith announces she is pregnant
- Awkward moment footy great can't pronounce NRL player's name
- Jason Kelce bares all with ex-Eagles teammate in revealing beer ad
- Ireland fans mock Queen's death aiming chants at England fans
- Sinner defeats home favourite Fritz to win the US Open title
- Las Vegas Raiders fan body slams a woman during brawl