The Paris Review

Love and Badness in America and the Arab World

Diya Abdo and her grandmother, on the porch of their farm in al-Libban, ca. 2002.

Firstborn children are good. Saturated, no doubt, with the anxiety of first-time parenthood, firstborns are rule followers, pleasers.

When I tell my firstborn, five-year-old daughter, Aidana Sabha, that she has to drink the juice covertly because the bouncy house does not allow outside food or beverages, she crouches, doubled over under the table, hiding the silver pouch underneath her arched body. Unable to go against the place’s regulations, she asks to leave; she is thirsty but would rather give up playing to go home and drink than break the rules.

In Jordan, to be a firstborn female child came with added pressure—to be maddaleh, sitt el-banāt, btiswi thuglik dhahab, worth your own weight in gold.

Whenever my grandmother uses this phrase to describe some woman or other, I keep a tally of the qualities she admires. When she uses it to describe my mother, though always in the past tense, it means that my mother had listened, obeyed, self-abnegated—the butter would not melt in her mouth.

When she uses it to describe my uncle’s wife, her daughter-in-law, it means that daughter-in-law is content with her lot, her dirty laundry unaired—her secrets in a well.

When she uses it to describe her neighbor, it means that the neighbor is chaste, never flirting, never yielding to men’s plying compliments and denuding gazes—as pure as yogurt.

But most importantly, to be worth your weight in gold means that your , your narrative, your story, is not on every tongue. A woman like this is given the highest compliment—she is, ironically, a man () or the closest approximation, the sister of men (). My grandmother was definitely worth her weight in gold—. An illiterate Palestinian villager, she was married at—her reputation was golden. 

You’re reading a preview, subscribe to read more.

More from The Paris Review

The Paris Review1 min read
Credits
Cover: © Jeremy Frey, courtesy of the artist, Karma, and the Metropolitan Museum of Art. Page 12, © Jeremy Frey, courtesy of the artist, Karma, and the Metropolitan Museum of Art; pages 34, 43, 48, 50, courtesy of Mary Robison; page 53, photograph by
The Paris Review16 min read
Red Lungi
There’s no end to the woes that mothers face come summer vacation. All the children are at home. When they’re not in front of the TV, they’re either climbing the guava tree in the front yard or perched on the compound wall. What if one of them falls
The Paris Review3 min read
The Paris Review
EDITOR EMILYSTOKES MANAGING EDITOR KELLEY DEANE McKINNEY SENIOR EDITOR HARRIET CLARK ASSOCIATE EDITOR AMANDA GERSTEN WEB EDITOR SOPHIE HAIGNEY ASSISTANT EDITORS OLIVIA KAN-SPERLING, ORIANA ULLMAN EDITOR AT LARGE DAVID S. WALLACE POETRY EDITOR SRIKANT

Related Books & Audiobooks