The Atlantic

Harvard's Impossible Personality Test

New revelations from a lawsuit against the university capture the difficulty of comparing thousands upon thousands of talented teenagers.
Source: Brian Snyder / Reuters

Every year, Harvard’s admissions officers are charged with whittling a batch of 40,000 applicants down to a bare-bones selection to fill the institution’s roughly 1,600 freshman seats. Those officers can’t just set a high bar for test scores and GPAs to arrive at that selection; far too many candidates boast those qualifications. Plus, even if that arithmetic were possible, Harvard prides itself as an institution where students learn from each other in addition to their professors. Building each freshman class is, in turn, both an art and a science—one that effectively requires admissions officers to exercise a combination of number-crunching and intuition.

An organization representing Asian Americans who were at some point rejected from Harvard is suing the school for that art-and-science approach. The group, Students for Fair Admissions (SFFA), recently reignited tensions around that approach with a new legal filing that it says confirms suspicions that the university’s admissions practices discriminate on the basis of race. The , filed on Friday in federal court by SFFA, could influence admissions policies at universities across

You’re reading a preview, subscribe to read more.

More from The Atlantic

The Atlantic6 min read
Entitlement Is Not an Identity. It’s a Trap.
In July of this year, a U.S.-based company called CrowdStrike released an update for its widely used cybersecurity software, inadvertently triggering a massive system crash. In the hours that followed, what has since been described as the “largest ou
The Atlantic4 min read
This Election Actually Is About Taylor Swift
Taylor Swift has been an outspoken Democrat for some time now. After publicly regretting that she’d not campaigned against Donald Trump in 2016, she endorsed liberal candidates in Tennessee in 2018 and baked Biden-themed cookies in 2020. In some ways
The Atlantic7 min read
Nicole Kidman’s Perpetual Trick
A quick confession: I’ve never seen the original Stepford Wives because I’m so shamefully partial to the 2004 remake, in which Nicole Kidman plays both a ferocious redheaded television executive and her blissed-out, high-femme, blond doppelgänger. At

Related Books & Audiobooks