The Atlantic

The Indelible Awfulness of E. L. James’s <em>The Mister</em>

The author’s follow-up to her <em>Fifty Shades </em>series is hopelessly retrograde and dismally unentertaining.
Source: François Mori / AP

It is strange, when you pause to think about it, that E. L. James is still out there being as a transgressive, taboo-busting warrior for women’s desire, given that her fictional worlds position female characters somewhere between the saintly Dorothea Brooke and the wimple-wearing Maria von Trapp. Her women are blushing, impoverished virgins, pristine of heart and fragile of appetite; her men, meanwhile, are swaggering Lotharios whose wallets bulge even more conspicuously than their designer underwear. In James’s new book, , the hero is an English earl who’s also a model-slash-DJ-slash-photographer-slash-composer, and whose first page of interior monologue is a vainglorious ode to “mindless sex” and a “nameless fuck.” His name, if you can stomach it, is Maxim Trevelyan. And the ultimate object of his affections, the woman who will ensure the rake’s progress from libidinous playboy to loyal husband, is … his doe-eyed undocumented

You’re reading a preview, subscribe to read more.

More from The Atlantic

The Atlantic8 min read
How Colleges Should Address Anti-Semitism
After Hamas attacked Israel on October 7, and during Israel’s ongoing military response in Gaza, activists organized anti-Israel protests on dozens of college campuses. Amid rallies, encampments on quads, and occupations of campus buildings, anti-Sem
The Atlantic7 min read
Turn Down the Streetlights
Years ago, I called the local electric and streetlight utility, Seattle City Light, to ask why the block around the corner was lit up like a sleep-deprivation torture cell. Then as now, seven high-powered LED lights, plus two on facing corners, blaze
The Atlantic4 min read
A Good-Enough Prime-Time Debut
Kamala Harris and Tim Walz have now completed their CNN interview. On social media and cable TV, the responses have broken down pretty much as one might expect. Democrats think it was a home run. Republicans are sour and churlish. The truth is that t

Related Books & Audiobooks