The Paris Review

ANTONIO DI BENEDETTO

They’ll have to hire a girl. The father knows why. The daughter will no longer tolerate any housework that gets hands dirty. She gives excuses the father doesn’t believe, but he doesn’t argue.

After he lost the use of his legs, the daughter learned to organize her time and energy. She took care of him, made meals, kept house, and ran the shop, small enough to be tended by a single clerk, eight hours a day. That was fifteen years ago. Since then, the father has come to believe that the daughter is disillusioned with men. He’s only heard her mention them to deplore their vulgarity, as well as other, less obvious defects she later discovers.

When they took on the new clerk—who didn’t impress the father: too polished and composed, didn’t seem like much of a hard worker—the first hints of an evolution in her views appeared.

Now they have to hire a girl.

Over the course of the day, the little sign in the window attracts quite a number of them. Rosa Esther is the definitive choice. She was brought by her father, a real criollo, native-born, and that can be taken for a guarantee.

HAS THE DAUGHTER SPENT the past fifteen years wishing she could go to the movies by herself after dinner?

“Now that you have the girl to stay home with you . . . ” she says, night after night. Each time there’s some new film or double feature that interests her—that she can’t miss.

She comes in early, just after midnight. Once, she stayed out later.

“I ran into Manuel and he asked me to have a cup of chocolate. I couldn’t see why not. You don’t have to be standoffish just because you’re the owner.”

Another evening she announces in advance that she’ll be out late. She broaches the subject almost as if asking for permission. “Manuel invited me to the casino. I’ve never been to the casino, papá. If I say no, when will I have another chance? Who else is ever going to take me?”

The father understands. But he doesn’t like it. His daughter is forty-seven years old. The employee is twenty-three.

ROSA ESTHER IS PENSIVE and resigned. She watches over the master of the house in silence. When he switches the radio on to fill up the hours his daughter spends away from home, she accepts the classical music without hinting at any preference of her own. He studies her: she ignores the sounds streaming from the device completely, absorbed in something else that isn’t the music. When, after long and rigorous concentration, he moves a piece on the chessboard, as if he were up against a skilled opponent, she stays quietly in her corner, watching him, or watching who knows what. He notices her over there and thinks, She’s resting. Sometimes he says to himself, She’s resting, poor thing. She works harder and harder all the time.

She’s never come over to watch him play, all by himself. It’s clear she knows nothing about chess and believes it to be a solitary, individual pursuit.

One night, the master of the house has a visitor, an old man much like him, except he can walk. They play against each other. Rosa Esther observes the match from afar.

When they’re alone the following night, she works up the courage to ask, “Señor, what is that?”

“You don’t know?”

He’s amazed, and pleased with himself for having aroused her curiosity. He was once quite a player, hard to beat, “at a time when the pastimes of youth were more intellectual,” as he likes to maintain. He used to read.

He reveals to Rosa Esther that this is chess. A game, but a scientific game.

“Understand? This isn’t like other games, cards or darts. You need a welldeveloped brain to play. It demands a lot of thought.”

The first part of the lesson has captured her attention. It’s a game.

“Can I play, too?”

“No, no,” he replies, in all the aristocracy of his long experience. He quickly regrets this negative impulse, which demeans the girl, and softens his response. “I don’t think you can. You’re so young.”

Rosa Esther doesn’t protest. She doesn’t ask again. Will she resign herself to this, too?

The master doesn’t want the negative to be absolute. “There’s another solution. An easier game, also played on

You’re reading a preview, subscribe to read more.

More from The Paris Review

The Paris Review28 min read
The Ways of Paradise: Selected Notes from a Lost Manuscript
The author of this text was a familiar figure at the National Library of Sweden in Stockholm’s Humlegården park. Almost every day for more than three decades he could be spotted in the serene reading room, absorbed in his studies and in reverie. It w
The Paris Review1 min read
Emajendat
emajendat is, like much of Lauren Halsey’s work, a love letter to the neighborhood of South Central in Los Angeles, where she was born and still lives; it was there, too, that she started making collages, on the walls of her childhood bedroom. This p
The Paris Review2 min read
Paper Bags
G. Peter Jemison was born in 1945 to an ironworker father and a stay-at-home mother, both of the Seneca Nation of Indians. He grew up in Irving, New York, on the border of the Cattaraugus Reservation, where he often visited his cousins and grandmothe

Related Books & Audiobooks