The Atlantic

Brooklyn’s Anti-masking Protests Betray a Broken Culture

The demonstrations say less about one particular community than they do about the brokenness of the American condition.
Source: Spencer Platt / Getty

Over the past week, ultra-Orthodox Jews in Brooklyn have engaged in anti-mask, anti-shutdown protests. It may be tempting to see these protests as the product of communities that are at odds with the dominant culture, adamantly refusing to comply with American behavioral and social norms, but that gets the story precisely backwards. The protests are profoundly American. The members of these communities are so at home in the American public square that they can air their grievances without fear of retribution, as their own particular expression of their constitutional rights. The callousness of these protests and of their cause

You’re reading a preview, subscribe to read more.

More from The Atlantic

The Atlantic8 min read
How Colleges Should Address Anti-Semitism
After Hamas attacked Israel on October 7, and during Israel’s ongoing military response in Gaza, activists organized anti-Israel protests on dozens of college campuses. Amid rallies, encampments on quads, and occupations of campus buildings, anti-Sem
The Atlantic7 min read
Turn Down the Streetlights
Years ago, I called the local electric and streetlight utility, Seattle City Light, to ask why the block around the corner was lit up like a sleep-deprivation torture cell. Then as now, seven high-powered LED lights, plus two on facing corners, blaze
The Atlantic4 min read
A Good-Enough Prime-Time Debut
Kamala Harris and Tim Walz have now completed their CNN interview. On social media and cable TV, the responses have broken down pretty much as one might expect. Democrats think it was a home run. Republicans are sour and churlish. The truth is that t

Related Books & Audiobooks