The Good Years: From 1900 to the First World War
By Walter Lord
5/5
()
About this ebook
Though remarkable in their own right, the first fifteen years of the 1900s had the misfortune of being sandwiched between—and overshadowed by—the Gilded Age and the First World War. In The Good Years, Walter Lord remedies this neglect, bringing to vivid life the events of 1900 to 1914, when industrialization made staggering advances, and the Wright brothers captured the world’s imagination. Lord writes of Newport and Fifth Avenue, where the rich lived gaily and without much worry beyond the occasional economic panic. He also delves into the sweatshops of the second industrial revolution, where impoverished laborers and children suffered under unimaginable conditions. From the assassination of President McKinley to the hot and lazy “last summer” before the outbreak of war, Lord writes with insight and humor about the uniquely American energy and enthusiasm of those years before the Great War would forever change the world.
From the #1 New York Times–bestselling author of Incredible Victory and Day of Infamy, this is an “informative and entertaining” journey through an often-overlooked period of history at the beginning of the twentieth century (The New York Times).
Walter Lord
Walter Lord (1917–2002) was an acclaimed and bestselling author of literary nonfiction best known for his gripping and meticulously researched accounts of watershed historical events. His first book was The Fremantle Diary (1954), a volume of Civil War diaries that became a surprising success. But it was Lord’s next book, A Night to Remember (1955), that made him famous. Lord went on to use the book’s interview-heavy format as a template for most of his following works, which included detailed reconstructions of the Pearl Harbor attack in Day of Infamy (1957), the battle of Midway in Incredible Victory (1967), and the integration of the University of Mississippi in The Past That Would Not Die (1965).
Read more from Walter Lord
The Miracle of Dunkirk: The True Story of Operation Dynamo Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5A Time to Stand: The Epic of the Alamo Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Incredible Victory: The Battle of Midway Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsDay of Infamy: The Bombing of Pearl Harbor Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The World War II Collection: The Miracle of Dunkirk, Day of Infamy, and Incredible Victory Rating: 5 out of 5 stars5/5The Dawn's Early Light: The War of 1812 and the Battle That Inspired Francis Scott Key to Write "The Star-Spangled Banner" Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsThe Past That Would Not Die Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsPeary to the Pole Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5World in Crisis: Classic Accounts of World War II Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsThe Good Years: From 1900 To The First World War [Illustrated Edition] Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratings
Related to The Good Years
Related ebooks
Last Call: The Rise and Fall of Prohibition Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Five Points: The Nineteenth-Century New York City Neighborhood Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Good Years: From 1900 To The First World War [Illustrated Edition] Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsHymns of the Republic: The Story of the Final Year of the American Civil War Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5City of the Century: The Epic of Chicago and the Making of America Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Fifties Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Bubble in the Sun: The Florida Boom of the 1920s and How It Brought on the Great Depression Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Buck Stops Here: The 28 Toughest Presidential Decisions and How They Changed History Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsJohnstown Flood Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Oregon Trail: A New American Journey Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Nothing Like It In the World: The Men Who Built the Transcontinental Railroad 1863-1869 Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Fraud of the Century: Rutherford B. Hayes, Samuel Tilden, and the Stolen Election of 1876 Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Men Who Lost America: British Leadership, the American Revolution and the Fate of the Empire Rating: 5 out of 5 stars5/5Storm Over the Land: A Profile of the Civil War Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Rising Tide: The Great Mississippi Flood of 1927 and How It Changed America Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/51948: Harry Truman's Improbable Victory and the Year that Transformed America Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Butch Cassidy: The True Story of an American Outlaw Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Hear That Lonesome Whistle Blow: The Epic Story of the Transcontinental Railroads Rating: 3 out of 5 stars3/5Henry Adams and the Making of America Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Accidental Presidents: Eight Men Who Changed America Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5American Midnight: The Great War, a Violent Peace, and Democracy's Forgotten Crisis Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/51944: FDR and the Year That Changed History Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Next Century Rating: 5 out of 5 stars5/5Only Yesterday: An Informal History of the 1920s Rating: 5 out of 5 stars5/5The Definitive FDR: Roosevelt: The Lion and the Fox (1882–1940) and Roosevelt: The Soldier of Freedom (1940–1945) Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsCountdown to Pearl Harbor: The Twelve Days to the Attack Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Year Of The Hawk: America's Descent into Vietnam, 1965 Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Band of Giants: The Amateur Soldiers Who Won America's Independence Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5
United States History For You
Master Slave Husband Wife: An Epic Journey from Slavery to Freedom Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/51776 Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Book of Charlie: Wisdom from the Remarkable American Life of a 109-Year-Old Man Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Killing the Guys Who Killed the Guy Who Killed Lincoln: A Nutty Story About Edwin Booth and Boston Corbett Rating: 5 out of 5 stars5/5A People's History of the United States Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Lies My Teacher Told Me: Everything Your American History Textbook Got Wrong Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Bury My Heart at Wounded Knee: An Indian History of the American West Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Fourth Turning Is Here: What the Seasons of History Tell Us about How and When This Crisis Will End Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5How to Hide an Empire: A History of the Greater United States Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Fifties Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Devil's Chessboard: Allen Dulles, the CIA, and the Rise of America's Secret Government Rating: 5 out of 5 stars5/5Benjamin Franklin: An American Life Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Incidents in the Life of a Slave Girl Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Vanderbilt: The Rise and Fall of an American Dynasty Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Masters of the Air: America's Bomber Boys Who Fought the Air War Against Nazi Germany Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Indifferent Stars Above: The Harrowing Saga of the Donner Party Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Great Awakening: Defeating the Globalists and Launching the Next Great Renaissance Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Devil in the Grove: Thurgood Marshall, the Groveland Boys, and the Dawn of a New America Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Library Book Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Pioneers: The Heroic Story of the Settlers Who Brought the American Ideal West Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5White Too Long: The Legacy of White Supremacy in American Christianity Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Electric Kool-Aid Acid Test Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5We Had a Little Real Estate Problem: The Unheralded Story of Native Americans & Comedy Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Angels in America: A Gay Fantasia on National Themes: Revised and Complete Edition Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5American Carnage: On the Front Lines of the Republican Civil War and the Rise of President Trump Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Great Reset: And the War for the World Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Killing England: The Brutal Struggle for American Independence Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5
Reviews for The Good Years
4 ratings1 review
- Rating: 5 out of 5 stars5/5This has been on my shelf for ages, avoided because it was big. That was a really bad idea. I thoroughly enjoyed it. One may remember [[Walter Lord]] from [A Night to Remember] about the Titanic. What he has done in this book is to take the years from 1900 until the start of the First World War, and tell one great story about a major event that occurred during that year (some years get 2 events). For instance, 1906 is the San Francisco earthquake. 1912 focuses on the Democratic National Convention (with a very short mention of the Titanic; only to show what kind of affect it had on the country). The great thing is that this book was published in 1960, so a majority of his references were interviews with people who were actually there! I just found it a fascinating book, and if you can find a copy, you should read it.
Book preview
The Good Years - Walter Lord
The Good Years
From 1900 to the First World War
Walter Lord
For
MARGIE HORNBLOWER
Contents
These were the Good Years …
1900 A New Year
1900 The Fumbling Imperialists
1901 A Good Man’s Death
1902 Big Stick, Big Business
1903 The Whopper Flying Machine
1905 The Golden Circus
1906 The Town That Refused to Die
1907 Trial of a Union Man
1907 Panic
1908-9 The Great White Fleet
1909 The Dash to the Pole
1910-12 The Cosmopolites
1912 Women Triumphant
1912 Big Man off Campus
1913 Children at Work
1914 The Last Summer
Published Material
Index
Acknowledgments
Illustrations
These were the Good Years …
GOOD, NOT BECAUSE RICH men rode in private railroad cars and Society gave magnificent parties. Most people rarely traveled, and many went to no parties at all.
Good, not just because the world was at peace. Millions of so-called little brown brothers
took violent exception to America’s fumbling (if well-intentioned) imperialism.
Good, not even because a shirt cost only 23 cents. The child who often made the shirt got only $3.54 a week.
These years were good because, whatever the trouble, people were sure they could fix it. The solutions differed of course—Theodore Roosevelt had his Square Deal, Carry Nation her hatchet—but everyone at least had a bold plan and could hardly wait to try it.
In this sense, the period could be called the Confident Years, the Buoyant Years, the Spirited Years … or perhaps named after some bright, hopeful color, like the Golden Years.
It could be done, but such tags are the invention of pundits, social historians, and professional name coiners. To the many varied people who lived through the era—the men and women who wistfully recall marching for suffrage, rebuilding San Francisco, or cheering wildly for Woodrow Wilson—these were, and still are, the Good Years.
1900
A New Year
There is not a man here who does not feel 400 per cent bigger in 1900 than he did in 1896, bigger intellectually, bigger hopefully, bigger patriotically, bigger in the breast from the fact that he is a citizen of a country that has become a world power for peace, for civilization and for the expansion of its industries and the products of its labor!
—SENATOR CHAUNCEY DEPEW
A FINE, DRY SNOW powdered the sidewalk as William J. Witt and Anna Waddilove, two young German-Americans, entered Liederkranz Hall in Jersey City and stood before the Reverend Rufus Johnson of Trinity Baptist Church. Dr. Johnson eyed his watch for a few moments, then began reading, and pronounced the Witts man and wife at 12:01 A.M., January 1, 1900. The time was important, for the Witts wanted to be the first couple married in the twentieth century.
They were a year too soon. Actually the new century would not begin until 1901. As the newspapers patiently explained, the first century obviously ended with the year 100, so the nineteenth had to end with the year 1900.
Still the Witts weren’t convinced, nor were many other sentimental German-Americans. After all, the Kaiser himself said this was the day, and in Berlin at this very minute thirty-three guns were saluting the new era. Addressing his officers, Wilhelm promised the rebirth of my Navy,
so that in the coming century Germany might win the place which it has not yet attained.
Elsewhere, mathematics prevailed, and the big celebration was postponed for another year. Except for the Witts, Jersey City had an uneventful New Year’s Eve. The Metropolitan Wheelmen of Boston bicycled quietly to Newburyport. In St. Louis Mr. and Mrs. Thomas Lawler held a candy pull. In New York financier J. Pierpont Morgan played solitaire in his library. Downtown some merrymakers roamed Wall Street, drowning the Trinity chimes with fishhorns, but most people were satisfied with less. At the 28th District Republican Club, the members sipped hot punch while President Charlie Hecht rendered When the Swallows Homeward Fly.
Yet the idea would not die that there was something special about moving into 1900. That irrepressible brigade who write letters to the London Times fired salvo after salvo, arguing that this was indeed the turn of the century. If,
explained the Reverend Grimley, Rector of Norton, a bride in her hundredth year were to pass from the altar of my church to the vestry, she would give as her age to be entered in the register 99. Her hundredth year would be labeled 99 until its very close.
In New Orleans, a city endowed with a keen sense of romance, people also felt that 1900 marked a fresh start. A boisterous crowd swarmed along Canal Street, gaily saluting an open carriage of girls at the corner of St. Charles. The girls opened up on them with Roman candles. If this wasn’t launching a new century, the police shuddered to think what next year would be like.
The New York Tribune sensed it too. No new century began yesterday. Avoid all delusions on that head,
intoned the editor, but those who had to date anything found that there was a queer sensation in writing ‘1900,’ and they felt that something momentous had happened to the calendar.
So in the end the Kaiser, with his flair for the dramatic, was right. A new century is something that’s not measured but felt. And nearly everybody felt that New Year’s 1900 was a milestone—a time to relish past accomplishments, a time to thrill to the promise of the future.
The newspapers did plenty of both. The New York Times on December 31, 1899, devoted nearly four editorial columns to a review of the Nineteenth Century. It proudly paraded the list of inventions—steam engines, railroads, telegraph, ocean liners, telephones, electric lights, even the cash register. They would pave the way for even greater advances. We step upon the threshold of 1900 which leads to the new century,
concluded the editorial, facing a still brighter dawn of civilization.
Sunday sermons struck the same note. The Reverend Newell Dwight Hillis could scarcely contain himself: Laws are becoming more just, rulers humane; music is becoming sweeter and books wiser; homes are happier, and the individual heart becoming at once more just and more gentle.
No wonder hopes were high. From coast to coast, the country had never seen such good times. The Portland Oregonian called 1899 the most prosperous year Oregon has ever known.
The Cheyenne Sun-Leader agreed: Never has a year been ushered in with more promise.
The Louisville Courier-Journal: Business in Louisville was never better, if as good.
The Boston Herald perhaps summed it up best with an interesting thought: If one could not have made money this past year, his case is hopeless.
For a man with a little talent, there seemed no limit. Andrew Carnegie, the gnomelike Scotch steelmaster, saw his annual profits double. Coal operators had the best anthracite year in history. The slump of 1893-95 was all but forgotten—since those dreary days Southern cotton goods were up 92 per cent, manufactured exports 88 per cent, glass output 52 per cent. No one noticed that the glass production record was achieved with the help of a ten-year-old child who had to tie stoppers on three hundred dozen bottles a day.
Even the usually discontented farmers were happy. Kansas barns bulged with a bumper corn crop. The cities and towns of the Midwest enjoyed a fantastic Christmas season. A Minneapolis jeweler figured that on one day during the holiday rush his diamond sales ran at the rate of $2,400 an hour.
Sales were high, but prices were low—just the way the system was meant to work. A Chicago couple furnishing a home could easily get a mahogany parlor table for $3.95 … a sofa for $9.98 … a brass-trimmed bed for $3. Food wasn’t much of a problem with corned beef selling at 8 cents a pound. Clothes were equally reasonable—in Denver turtleneck sweaters were eight cents apiece, felt hats 89 cents, top-quality suits $10.65. Wages might be modest by later standards, but a man from Birmingham, Alabama, could still celebrate New Year’s respectably, when six-year-old whiskey cost $3.20—for four quarts.
In Washington President William McKinley contentedly faced his annual New Year’s reception, when the whole public could file by for the handshake the President so enjoyed. It was another election year, but there were no worries this time. The informal partnership between business and the Administration had proved itself. William Jennings Bryan, the young Democrat who made Wall Street shiver in ’96, seemed as remote as his discredited platform of free silver. McKinley could stand with perfect confidence on the brief, irrefutable slogan The Full Dinner Pail.
But prosperity was only part of the story. An endless stream of exciting discoveries offered concrete evidence of the abundant life ahead. The new X-ray was revolutionizing surgery. Walter Reed’s experiments might end yellow fever. The caterpillar tractor would lighten farm work. The gramophone and Pianola would bring joy to the home. Electricity promised untold wonders—not just light but help on all sorts of household chores; some man had even invented a toaster.
Best of all was the motorcar. Its growth had been phenomenal. On April 1, 1898, an adventuresome soul bought the first American machine ever made specifically for sale. By 1900 some eight thousand cars sputtered about the country. Over one hundred taxis graced the streets of New York; Chicago even had a motor ambulance.
The new invention did pose some problems. The operator,
explained one writer, must combine the intelligence of the driver with that of the horse.
Tires cost $40 apiece. In New York cars had to stay out of Central Park, carry a gong, and keep under nine miles an hour.
More fundamental, according to McClure’s magazine, was the difficulty of finding suitable terminology: The French, with characteristic readiness in getting settled names for things, have formally adopted the word ‘automobile’ for the vehicle and ‘chauffeur’ (stoker) for the driver. But we of the English tongue are slower.
All this only added to the intrigue. Still a rich man’s toy, anyone could see that the motorcar would someday belong to everybody. Already eighty firms, capitalized at more than $380 million, were banking on it.
Countless miracles, boundless prosperity—they would go on and on—it was that simple. And perhaps this feeling that everything was so simple contributed most of all to the optimism and confidence that greeted the twentieth century. Wealth was simple—small boys grew up on Horatio Alger: if you were good and worked hard, someday you would be rich. Rules were simple—nice people didn’t mention sex, and even smoking was questionable. President McKinley once cautioned a photographer, We must not let the young men of the country see their President smoking.
Pleasures too were simple. New Yorkers might rave about the Floradora sextet, but most people made their own amusement. Seymour, Connecticut—a typical small town—had its own orchestra, drama group, German band, and Gilbert and Sullivan troupe.
Government especially was happily simple. In 1900 the Navy Department’s budget was $55 million. Sixty years later, a single atomic submarine cost as much. Washington offices were pleasantly informal—one administrative clerk liked to keep a hen by his desk. Kind, portly President McKinley was the most accessible of men. It is not always necessary, though better, to make an engagement to see the President,
wrote White House correspondent Albert Halstead. In launching an abortive drive for the 1900 Democratic nomination, Admiral Dewey blandly explained, Since studying the subject, I am convinced that the office of the President is not such a very difficult one to fill. …
By the same token the future was simple. The rewards would go to the virtuous. A certain manly quality in our people,
observed commentator John Bates Clark, gives assurance that we have the personal material out of which a millennium will grow.
And what would this millennium be like? As the new century dawned, wise men gave their prophecies and predictions. Perhaps inspired by Mr. and Mrs. Witt’s marital enterprise, Mayor Lawrence Fagan of Hoboken saw a Greater Jersey City
which would eclipse New York across the Hudson. Professor John Trowbridge of Harvard envisaged a nation-wide network of trolley car lines, binding the country together. Edward Everett Hale thought that by 1975 people might be shot through a tube from Texas to Georgia. Russell Sage thought millionaires were safe, for they are the guardians of the public welfare.
John Jacob Astor predicted a pedestrian’s paradise—transparent sidewalks high above the traffic. Ray Stannard Baker, a crack reporter of the day, saw the traffic problem itself nearing solution: It is hardly possible to conceive the appearance of a crowded wholesale street in the day of the automotive vehicle. In the first place, it will be almost as quiet as a country lane—all the crash of horses’ hoofs and the rumble of steel tires will be gone. And since vehicles will be fewer and shorter than the present truck and span, streets will appear less crowded.
Only a few great men refused to peer into the crystal ball. Thomas Edison explained, I don’t care to play prophet to the twentieth century: it’s too large an undertaking.
When asked about the mission of the dramatist of the future, George Bernard Shaw acidly replied, To write plays.
The New York World regretted that the young Irishman didn’t take himself more seriously.
No such reticence from H. G. Wells, who was easily the most prolific prophet around. For six consecutive issues the North American Review carried his lively Anticipations.
Later events showed some to be a little visionary: for instance, the Anglo-American republic centered east of Chicago. Others were somewhat myopic: Probably before 1950 a successful aeroplane will have soared and come home safe and sound.
Others were just plain wrong: I must confess that my imagination, in spite of spurring, refuses to see any sort of submarine doing anything but suffocate its crew and founder at sea.
But many of Wells’ predictions proved amazingly accurate. He didn’t guess the words, but he certainly saw air-conditioned houses … detergents … suburbia … thruways… togetherness
… do-it-yourself … and that idea breathlessly voiced by market researchers some fifty years later, the vast stretch of country from Washington to Albany will be one big urban area.
Unlike some of the seers, Wells thought there would still be wars. On land, victory would depend on balloon power; on the sea, a light ironclad equipped with a murderous ram. Unless I know nothing of my own blood,
he explained, the English and Americans will fight to ram.
Here was a revealing observation. It unconsciously gave away the one belief above all others that obsessed many minds as the twentieth century began. This was the conviction that the British and American people were bolder, braver, truer, nobler, brighter, and certainly better than anyone else in the world. As the New York Evening Post pointed out in its New Year’s Day editorial on the Boer War, Englishmen have, on the whole, taken their unexpected disasters in South Africa in manly fashion. One can imagine what would have happened in France under similar circumstances… .
It naturally followed that the future belonged to the Anglo-American race.
Together with the Germans, explained Professor John W. Davis, they were particularly endowed with the capacity for establishing national states, and are especially called to that work; and therefore they are intrusted, in the general economy of history, with the mission of conducting the political civilization of the modern world.
Kipling was less pontifical:
Take up the White Man’s burden—Send forth the best ye breed …
In taking up the burden this New Year’s Day, both Britain and the United States had more than they bargained for. The British were getting nowhere with the Boers in South Africa. The Americans were having little better luck in the Philippines, that trying legacy from the Spanish-American War. And in each nation many people smirked at the other’s embarrassment. Sober minds tried to put things in proper perspective. Harper’s Weekly urged Americans to mourn the British defeats, if we have a proper pride of race.
Good Englishmen gave an older brother’s advice on the Philippines. I think,
Colonel The O’Gorman told young Senator Albert Beveridge during a fact-finding trip to the Far East, you must do nothing but fight them. When we are in a row with Orientals, that is the way we do. They do not understand anything else.
Senator Beveridge returned convinced. By now he was intrigued by the opportunities offered by the whole Orient. Here was the market America needed when she could no longer absorb her own production. And just beyond the Philippines,
he reminded the Senate, are China’s illimitable markets. We will not retreat from either.
Secretary of State John Hay had his eyes on China too. This very New Year’s morning the papers happily announced that Hay had won all the great foreign powers to his Open Door policy. Under its terms each country gave the others equal trading rights in any sphere of influence
it enjoyed in China. A happy solution for everybody and especially for America—the last power on the scene and the only one without a sphere of influence.
But more than trade was involved. Entirely apart from the commercial aspect, there was something exciting about the Open Door idea … something that caught the nation’s imagination. Suddenly expansion was no longer a matter of grabbing territory; it was part of the duty of guarding the weak.
It would be difficult to do a greater wrong to the people of China than to leave the nation to itself,
declared D. Z. Sheffield in the January, 1900, Atlantic Monthly. Here is the substance of the matter: China needs protection and guidance even to the point of wise compulsion.
And there was no doubt who had the responsibility. As Senator Beveridge explained, God has not been preparing the English-speaking and Teutonic peoples for a thousand years for nothing but vain and idle self-contemplation and self-admiration. No! He has made us the master organizers of the world to establish system where chaos reigned. … He has made us adepts in government that we may administer government among savages and senile peoples.
So the American traders, diplomats, soldiers, and missionaries marched off to the Orient—parvenu imperialists but with a sense of lofty mission. And even as they went, success seemed in the air. There are many signs of times,
concluded D. Z. Sheffield, which assure us that the day is not distant when China will be delivered from its effete civilization and will come under the power of those motives which have their source in the vital truths of the Christian revelation.
1900
The Fumbling Imperialists
A new day has dawned. Civilization will never loose its hold on Shanghai … the gates of Peking will never again be closed against the methods of modern man.
—SENATOR ALBERT J. BEVERIDGE
ON THE MORNING OF April 1, 1900, six of the Americans to whom civilization was committed lay fogbound on the China Sea. Mrs. Edwin H. Conger, wife of the American minister at Peking, was returning from a visit to the States; with her she brought her daughter Laura and four other ladies whom she wanted to show the wonderful things being done for China.
Naturally the fog was exasperating. The more so since Mrs. Conger—by now rather used to diplomatic prerogatives—could do nothing to hurry along the little Japanese steamer Negato. I have to watch myself,
she confided to her diary. The Captain is running this ship and I must hands off.
Her patience was rewarded. The fog lifted, and on April 3 the Negato dropped anchor off Tientsin. Handkerchiefs fluttered as an official launch bobbed alongside. Aboard was Minister Conger himself—GOP wheelhorse … Civil War veteran … close friend of President McKinley.
Ashore the ladies were whisked to the legation’s special train, and then ninety miles inland to Machiapu, the rambling station just outside the walls of Peking. A waiting caravan of carts and sedan chairs carried them through the Yungting gate, and now they were in the crowded outer city, with its bustling shops and markets. Continuing on, they passed through another massive wall and into the newer Tartar City. Within its walls and just ahead lay the mysterious Imperial City, and within that the even more mysterious Forbidden City. It was all like a nest of boxes, but the caravan didn’t go any deeper. Just before the Imperial City, it turned into the foreign quarter on Legation Street and drew up at the American compound. Fireworks popped and crackled, celebrating the return of the minister’s lady.
In no time Mrs. Conger was back in the daily routine—picnics … formal calls … stiff dinners at the British Legation, where Queen Victoria’s portrait seemed to chaperon the proceedings. Far gayer were Sir Robert Hart’s lawn parties. The old gentleman was Chief Inspector of the Imperial Chinese Customs; he had been in China forever and by now had accumulated a private brass band. On a more modest scale were Mrs. Conger’s own Wednesday afternoons,
when the Continental set tried to adjust to homelike Iowa hospitality.
It was a compact little world completely isolated from the Chinese. Concentrated in the small area between the Imperial Palace on the north and the great Tartar Wall on the south, the diplomatic community visited back and forth, strolled Legation Street, shopped at Imbeck’s, and watched each other endlessly. Was Baron de Pokotilov about to wring another concession for his Russo-Chinese Bank? Were the Germans planning to extend their new sphere of influence beyond Shantung Province? Arriving last on the scene, the Americans played a minor role in this political game, but they lived the same way and were equally interested in the latest mysterious visitors stopping at the Hôtel de Pékin.
Completely engrossed in themselves, no one saw much of the Chinese—just the harassed officials of the Tsungli Yamen, as the Imperial Foreign Office was called. Here the diplomats went to complain, or demand some new concession. Beyond that there was little contact. The legation community shared nothing with the rest of teeming, crowded Peking except the heat, the dust, and the endless stray dogs that all seemed to bite.
This April everything was the same as always—only not quite. Visitors to the trading quarter noticed that the price of knives was soaring. Signs appeared in doorways announcing Swords made here.
People’s gardeners and houseboys began to disappear. Soon the legation colony noted a new rudeness on the streets—often the unmistakable phrase foreign devil
snarled by some passerby. Around the end of April posters blossomed on the walls, partly religious mumbo-jumbo but partly very clear indeed: The will of Heaven is that the telegraph wires be first cut, then the railways torn up, and then shall the foreign devils be decapitated.
The old China hands understood. The native patriotic society colloquially called Boxers—literally Fists of Righteous Harmony
—was spreading to Peking from the south, preaching its anti-foreign gospel. And it had fertile soil to grow on. Foreign governments had exacted humiliating territorial concessions. Foreign railroads had thrown thousands of boatmen out of work. Foreign missionaries were interfering with local courts when native Christians were involved. The foreigner also proved a convenient scapegoat to blame for flood, famine, and now the drought that parched the country. Nor did it help when a boy arrested for suspicious behavior confessed that he had been paid by foreigners to poison the wells.
It made no difference that the Americans had no sphere of influence, or that the American missionaries were mostly mild men and women innocuously engaged in teaching school. To the Boxers all foreigners were alike; all were to blame for China’s troubles.
And to this the Boxers had an easy answer—kill the foreign devils. For those who feared foreign guns and bullets, they had another answer—the Boxers couldn’t be hit. Wear the Boxers sash, carry the yellow paper talisman, learn the cant, follow the ritual, and the true believer would be protected. High priests of the movement were happy to demonstrate; bravely they faced firing squads,
and the doubters were quickly convinced … unaware that the shots were blank.
Patriotic Chinese flocked to the Boxer banners, and others not so idealistic joined in the lively hope of plunder. The Chinese imperial government looked on passively, and under the circumstances, this amounted to approval.
Here and there, a few Chinese warned their foreign friends. Around the middle of May Dr. Robert Colter, an American physician in Peking for eighteen years, got the word from a grateful native patient. He passed the news along to the U. S. Legation, but made little impression. Writing the folks at home a few days later, Minister Conger assured them there was no danger. Outside on Legation Street, long carts full of swords and spears began coming in from the outer city.
About the same time, Bishop Favier of the French Cathedral heard from his native converts (secondary devils
), who were also scheduled for slaughter. On May 19, he urged Minister Pichon to send for troops: Peking is surrounded on all sides and I beg you will be assured I am well informed.
Sir Claude MacDonald, the British minister, was told about the bishop’s appeal but he didn’t worry. He had been with the Army in Egypt before turning diplomat, and he knew that these colonial storms blew over. A few blocks away a new Boxer poster proclaimed An admirable way to destroy foreign buildings.
On May 24, the legation district suddenly stirred. Sedan chairs hurried through the streets converging on the British compound. It was Queen Victoria’s birthday, and Sir Claude was celebrating with a state dinner. Afterward, by the light of weird colored lanterns the sixty carefully selected guests sipped champagne on the lawn and danced to the music of Sir Robert Hart’s brass band. In the servants’ quarters red and black cards mysteriously appeared, warning that those who waited on the foreign devils were also doomed.
By the end of the month the diplomatic families were starting as usual for their summer homes in the nearby western hills. Among the early arrivals were the wife of the American first secretary, Mrs. Herbert Squiers, her three children, two governesses, and an attractive house guest from home, Polly Condit Smith. They had barely settled on the 28th, when they saw huge clouds of smoke rolling up from the Fengtai railway junction just below.
In Peking a breathless, dusty messenger clattered up Legation Street, shouting that the Boxers were burning Fengtai station and its sheds. Worse still, they were besieging the Belgian engineers and their families at Chang Hsin Tien some sixteen miles away. The ministers frantically compared notes, not knowing what to do.
Others moved faster. M. Auguste Chamot, Swiss proprietor of the Hôtel de Pékin, recruited a rescue team that saved the Belgians. Dr. George Ernest Morrison, resourceful correspondent of the London Times, forgot about his deadline … rushed to the hills where he knew the Squiers family were stranded. An hour later Squiers himself borrowed a Cossack from the Russian Legation and dashed off to join them. The little group huddled all night in the flickering light of the Fengtai flames, then slipped back to Peking in the morning.
But it was no longer safe anywhere. In Peking itself, the Boxers were now burning the little trolleys that creaked along the foot of the outer wall. Again Dr. Morrison set out for the scene. He was an incurable wanderer—once he was even court physician to the Sultan of Wazar—but he had never seen anything like this. A howling mob tried to tear him apart. He turned and ran back to the Legation District.
Fortunately, help was coming. The ministers had finally demanded more guards, and the relief train arrived from Tientsin in the last fading daylight of May 31. It unloaded detachments of American, British, Russian, French, Italian, and Japanese marines—340 men altogether. (Some Germans and Austrians would come later.) They had been scraped together on the spur of the moment—so hastily that the Americans came in winter uniform and the Russians forgot their cannon. But they were there. And as they marched toward the Legation District, the Chinese mobs fell back silent. The British consular students knew it was just what the beggars needed; they rushed to greet their men, singing Soldiers of the Queen.
That was all it took. In a day or so life was normal again. At the Peking Club, the members once more sipped their ices, or complained about Count von Soden, the young German military attaché who played vile tennis and worse billiards.
While Peking relaxed, the provinces blazed in violence. At Yungching two young English missionaries, Harry Norman and Charles Robinson, were seized and beheaded on June 1. At Paoting-fu, thirty-two more missionaries were trapped. The Reverend Horace Tracy Pitkin—a stern, lantern-jawed man of God from Philadelphia—sold his life dearly, firing at the Boxers until his ammunition ran out. More often the doomed missionaries were gentle to the end. Thank heaven we drove them off without killing any,
was one of the last entries in the Reverend Herbert Dixon’s diary. When Mrs. Arnold Lovitt of the American Baptist Mission was seized at Taiyuan-fu, she told her captor, We have done you no harm, but only sought you good, why do you treat us so?
The Boxer carefully removed her glasses before beheading her.
Minister Conger seemed paralyzed. When asked for a military escort to help rescue the American Board Mission at nearby Tungchow, he regretfully explained that he must not risk his marines. The Reverend W. S. Ament sighed, went to Tungchow alone and saved the people himself. In their exasperation, the American missionaries cabled President McKinley direct on June 8. It was a courteous message, appealing for help and pointing out that the Chinese government’s policy was double-faced.
Would the Imperial Telegraph Service forward such an outspoken message? Certainly. Only one change was required: the hyphen must be erased and double faced
charged as two words.
In a way the incident symbolized the whole struggle. The simple gullibility of the West; the polite, impenetrable ambiguity of Peking officialdom. To the foreigners, this sort of behavior was one more example of Chinese hypocrisy. Actually it was often indecision. The aged, rouge-smeared Empress Dowager sat isolated in her pink palace, pulled this way and that. The court intrigue was incredibly complex—there was even a false eunuch. The vain old woman was generally influenced by the last person who saw her, and Prince Tuan—father of the heir apparent and foe of everything foreign—usually managed to be that. But not always. Sometimes it was pleasant Prince Ching, who thought railways might even help China; sometimes it was crusty General Jung Lu, who knew what a Krupp gun could do. It was all so difficult for an ex-Iowa congressman to fathom.
Then on June 9 the drift became crystal clear. The Boxers burned the grandstand at the race course—the foreign colony’s own center of social intrigue. Four young British consular students could hardly believe such villainy was possible. Riding out to investigate, they were mobbed by swarms of Boxers chanting, Kill! Kill! Kill!
They barely made it back to safety.
Chinese government troops watched with interest from the walls. They took no active part, but their banners bore the legend Exterminate the foreigner.
Rumor spread that soldiers and Boxers together would turn on the legations that night. Nothing happened, but Sir Claude MacDonald had now seen enough. He wired Tientsin for heavy reinforcements. The reply was encouraging—Admiral Seymour would leave at once with nine hundred men.
All next day the legations waited. No one knew that the railway was destroyed. Nor could anyone check; the wires were now out. On June 11 the Japanese Chancellor Sugiyama set out for the station, hoping to pick up some news. He had just passed Yungting gate when some Chinese soldiers appeared, yanked him from his cart, and hacked him to pieces.
Back at the American Legation Minister Conger sat at his roll-top desk, pondering what to do. In the drawing room—a wonderful hodgepodge of Ming vases, Morris chairs and calendars pasted on lacquered walls—Mrs. Conger filled in her diary: If men think he should do more for them and say unkind things, he does not let it hurt him, and replies kindly but firmly.
Baron von Ketteler, the German minister, believed in action. Years before, when he was military attaché, his blue eyes and handsome mustache made him quite the most dashing blade in Peking. Since then he had served in Washington, married an American heiress, and generally settled down. But he still had a low boiling point, and he reached it on the morning of June 13. Down Legation Street, before his very eyes, came a pony cart carrying a Boxer in full regalia—ribbons, white tunic, red sash, everything. None had ventured so close before, and this man was even sharpening his sword on his boots. The baron personally yanked him off the cart and thrashed him with the heavy cane he liked to carry.
The example was ignored. That afternoon bands of Boxers broke into the outer city and began burning churches. The diplomats did nothing, but once again the Swiss hotelkeeper Auguste Chamot rose to the occasion. He and his young American wife (a McCarthy from San Francisco) rushed to the blazing South Cathedral, brought back a padre and twenty-five nuns.
The fires continued: Asbury Church … the blind asylum … Sir Robert Hart’s customs buildings. When Watson’s drugstore went up on the 16th, explosive chemicals sprayed flames all over the trading quarter. Soon they spread to the huge pagoda atop the Chien gate, a famous Peking landmark. The foreign colony gasped to think that a people could do such a thing to their own most cherished possessions. In the Imperial City the Empress Dowager watched grimly from a little hill to the west of the Southern Lake.
The crisis came June 19. That afternoon the Tsungli Yamen delivered eleven red envelopes to the eleven legations. Inside each a polite letter on ruled rice paper explained that relations were broken; the ministers and their staffs must leave within twenty-four hours—specifically, by 4:00 P.M. the following day.
Minister Conger rushed from the American compound, joined his colleagues at the Spanish Legation. Here they sat around, excitedly arguing what to do. To leave would be perilous; to stay would violate all protocol. Finally, it was decided to leave, but to ask for more time. To work out the details, they urged the Yamen to receive them at 9:00 A.M. next morning.
News always spread fast in Peking, but never faster than now. At the American Legation, Polly Condit Smith debated how to fill the single small bag she would be allowed to take—a warm coat or six fresh blouses?
At the American Methodist compound a mile to the east, the missionaries faced a far grimmer problem. Some seven hundred native Christians had come to the place for protection. Evacuation would mean leaving them behind—to certain death. Nor would it help for the missionaries to stay with them; that would draw the Boxers’ attention all the more quickly.
In the small hours of the night the missionary leaders penned a desperate plea to Minister Conger: For the sake of these, your fellow Christians, we ask you to delay your departure by every pretext possible. … We appeal to you in the name of Humanity and Christianity not to abandon them. …
Conger was unimpressed. The Legation staff began rounding up ponies and carts for the flight. The missionaries assembled their frightened Chinese schoolgirls … broke the news … gave them money and told them to scatter when the time came to leave. It was as difficult to say as it must have been for the girls to understand. Men like the Reverend Frank Gamewell had devoted their lives to spreading the ideals of Christ. No matter how hard they tried to justify their departure, they couldn’t help wondering whether this was really the Christian thing to do.
On the morning of June 20 the ministers reassembled at 9:00 but the Yamen hadn’t answered their request for an audience. The consensus was to wait a little longer. Baron von Ketteler announced he would go anyhow. They said it was dangerous. He replied nothing would happen; he would go unarmed. They pointed out that the Yamen might not meet. He replied he could wait—he was taking along a book and a box of good cigars.
So he set out in his sedan chair, accompanied only by his secretary Heinrich Cordes and a few outriders to lend a little prestige. They had just passed the Arch of Honor on Hata Men Street when a Chinese soldier, with peacock feathers in his hat, stepped out from the curb. He pushed a rifle through the window of the Baron’s chair and pulled the trigger.
Minutes later Herr Cordes, wounded and exhausted, staggered into the Methodist compound, where the missionaries were still trying to prepare the schoolgirls to shift for themselves. He shouted that von Ketteler had been assassinated, then collapsed from loss of blood. Runners sped to the legation with the awful news.
Now flight was out of the question. It would simply lead to more massacres. All groups were ordered to the British compound to stand siege until help could come. Again the question arose about saving the Chinese Christians. Again Minister Conger said no: there simply wasn’t room. His colleagues seemed to agree. This was too much for Dr. Morrison, the stalwart Times correspondent: I should be ashamed to call myself a white man if I could not make a place for these Chinese Christians.
No answer. So Morrison did something about it himself. With the help of Professor Huberty James, a knowledgeable teacher at Peking University, he wangled the use of Prince Su’s palace, or fu, next to the British Legation. The prince wouldn’t be using it, and (who knew?) the loan might be a good investment if the allies held out. The argument worked, and now there was room for everyone. Come at once within the Legation lines,
Conger hastily wrote the Methodists; then the wonderful words they could hardly believe: And bring your Chinese with you.
The missionaries had only twenty minutes to get ready. Just enough to grab the first thing in sight—one lady settled on a hot-water bottle. Then off on the long trek to the Legation district—71 missionaries, wives and children … 124 native schoolgirls, strangely lamb-faced … 700 Chinese converts staggering under rolls of bedding … 4 stretcher bearers carrying the wounded Herr Cordes … 20 U.S. Marine guards, tramping along in the sleepless way of men who had seen too much duty.
Reaching the Legation district, the party split. The natives turned off into Prince Su’s fu, where 2,000 Catholic converts had already gathered. The missionaries halted briefly at the U.S. Legation; then continued on as arranged, to the British compound.
Here they would be comparatively safe, for Her Majesty’s Legation formed the heart of a good defensive position. To the north was the Hanlin Library; its walls were thick and no one thought the Chinese would wreck its centuries of culture. To the east (across the Imperial Drainage Canal that ran through the whole position) lay Prince Su’s fu—now strongly held by Japanese marines. The southern front was the great Tartar Wall, forty feet thick. American and German marines held a three-hundred-yard segment along the top; and the U.S.