Imperfect Presidents: Tales of Presidential Misadventure and Triumph
By Jim Cullen
3/5
()
About this ebook
When people make bad decisions, odd remarks, and just plain silly mistakes, the results are sure to haunt them. But when these things happen to the president of the United States, they can change the course of history. In this clever portrait of the American presidency, Jim Cullen takes ten presidents down from their pedestals by examining key missteps in their careers--and how they transcended them. Examples include Abraham Lincoln smearing a preacher and rediscovering his religious vision in emancipating slaves; Lyndon Johnson's electoral fraud in his 1948 Senate race and his role in the signing of the Voting Rights Act; and Ronald Reagan's subversion of the Constitution in the Iran-Contra affair and affirmation of world peace in helping bring about the end of the Cold War. Targeting Republicans and Democrats alike, Cullen's insights are surprisingly timely and hugely entertaining.
Read more from Jim Cullen
Imperfect Presidents: Tales of Misadventure and Triumph Rating: 3 out of 5 stars3/5Historians on Hamilton: How a Blockbuster Musical Is Restaging America's Past Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Case for Long-Term Value Investing: A guide to the data and strategies that drive stock market success Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsBridge and Tunnel Boys: Bruce Springsteen, Billy Joel, and the Metropolitan Sound of the American Century Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsLong Walk Home: Reflections on Bruce Springsteen Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Martin Scorsese and the American Dream Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Best Class You Never Had: A Novel Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratings1980: America's Pivotal Year Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5From Memory to History: Television Versions of the Twentieth Century Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsBorn in the U.S.A.: Bruce Springsteen in American Life, 3rd edition, Revised and Expanded Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsThose Were the Days: Why All in the Family Still Matters Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratings
Related to Imperfect Presidents
Related ebooks
White Guilt: How Blacks and Whites Together Destroyed the Promise of the Civil Rights Era Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Scandal: How "Gotcha" Politics Is Destroying America Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5White House Confidential: The Little Book of Weird Presidential History Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5THE SORROWS OF YOUNG WERTHER (Literary Classics Series): Historical Romance Novel Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5New Orleans Boom & Blackout: One Hundred Days in America's Coolest Hot Spot Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsCocaine Nation Rating: 3 out of 5 stars3/5Lies, Half-Truths, and More Lies: The Truth Behind 250 "Facts" You Learned in School (and Elsewhere) Rating: 1 out of 5 stars1/5Fight Back: Tackling Terrorism, Liddy Style Rating: 3 out of 5 stars3/5Hottest Heads of State: Volume One: The American Presidents Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsFinding George Washington Rating: 5 out of 5 stars5/5Hitler, Stalin and I: An Oral History Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsIron Rose: The Story of Rose Fitzgerald Kennedy and Her Dynasty Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsThe Best American Crime Writing 2006 Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsKing of the World Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsMob Boss: The Life of Little Al D'Arco, the Man Who Brought Down the Mafia Rating: 5 out of 5 stars5/5The Whistleblower's Dilemma: Snowden, Silkwood and Their Quest for the Truth Rating: 5 out of 5 stars5/5The Real Life Taxi Driver: A Biography of Arthur Herman Bremer (The Real Inspiration of Travis Bickle) Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsBorn to Kill: The Rise and Fall of America's Bloodiest Asian Gang Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Worst Person In the World: And 202 Strong Contenders Rating: 3 out of 5 stars3/5Breaking And Entering: The Extraordinary Story of a Hacker Called “Alien” Rating: 3 out of 5 stars3/5The Monkey Handlers Rating: 3 out of 5 stars3/5Unlikely Heroes: Franklin Roosevelt, His Four Lieutenants, and the World They Made Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Hindsight: The Unraveling Effects of Addiction Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsThe Little Quiz Book of Big Political Sex Scandals Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsI'm Hosting as Fast as I Can!: Zen and the Art of Staying Sane in Hollywood Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Flynn & Miranda: Your Right to Remain Silent Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsBrainless: The Lies and Lunacy of Ann Coulter Rating: 3 out of 5 stars3/5Anything for a Vote: Dirty Tricks, Cheap Shots, and October Surprises in U.S. Presidential Campaigns Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5American Gangster: And Other Tales of New York Rating: 3 out of 5 stars3/5
Political Biographies For You
Fear: Trump in the White House Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Devil's Chessboard: Allen Dulles, the CIA, and the Rise of America's Secret Government Rating: 5 out of 5 stars5/5Benjamin Franklin: An American Life Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Our Kind of People: Inside America's Black Upper Class Rating: 3 out of 5 stars3/5The Indifferent Stars Above: The Harrowing Saga of the Donner Party Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Disloyal: A Memoir: The True Story of the Former Personal Attorney to President Donald J. Trump Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Manhunt: The 12-Day Chase for Lincoln's Killer Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Fire and Fury: Inside the Trump White House Rating: 3 out of 5 stars3/5The First Conspiracy: The Secret Plot to Kill George Washington Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Profiles in Courage: Deluxe Modern Classic Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Too Much and Never Enough: How My Family Created the World's Most Dangerous Man Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Dear America: Notes of an Undocumented Citizen Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Enough Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Mein Kampf Rating: 3 out of 5 stars3/5Freezing Order: A True Story of Money Laundering, Murder, and Surviving Vladimir Putin's Wrath Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Finding Freedom: Harry and Meghan and the Making of a Modern Royal Family Rating: 3 out of 5 stars3/5The Bully Pulpit: Theodore Roosevelt, William Howard Taft, and the Golden Age of Journalism Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Room Where It Happened: A White House Memoir Rating: 3 out of 5 stars3/5The Man Who Killed Kennedy: The Case Against LBJ Rating: 3 out of 5 stars3/5Summary of John Adams: by David McCullough | Includes Analysis Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Washington: The Indispensable Man Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5American Values: Lessons I Learned from My Family Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Lincoln's Melancholy: How Depression Challenged a President and Fueled His Greatness Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Art of Community: Seven Principles for Belonging Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Just as I Am: A Memoir Rating: 5 out of 5 stars5/5Putin's People: How the KGB Took Back Russia and Then Took On the West Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Truth & Beauty: A Friendship Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Watergate: A New History Rating: 5 out of 5 stars5/5
Reviews for Imperfect Presidents
2 ratings0 reviews
Book preview
Imperfect Presidents - Jim Cullen
IMPERFECT PRESIDENTS
OTHER BOOKS BY JIM CULLEN
The Civil War in Popular Culture: A Reusable Past
The Art of Democracy:
A Concise History of Popular Culture in the United States
Born in the U.S.A.:
Bruce Springsteen and the American Tradition
Popular Culture in American History (editor)
Restless in the Promised Land:
Catholics and the American Dream
The American Dream:
A Short History of an Idea that Shaped a Nation
The Civil War Era (editor, with Lyde Cullen Sizer)
The Fieldston Guide to American History for Cynical Beginners
IMPERFECT PRESIDENTS
Tales of
Misadventure and Triumph
JIM CULLEN
The author and publisher have provided this e-book to you for your personal use only. You may not make this e-book publicly available in any way. Copyright infringement is against the law. If you believe the copy of this e-book you are reading infringes on the author’s copyright, please notify the publisher at: us.macmillanusa.com/piracy.
This one is for Lyde.
The law will never make men free; it is men who have got to make the law free.
—Henry David Thoreau,
Slavery in Massachusetts,
1854
CONTENTS
Acknowledgments
Foreword: The President We Want
Prologue: General Washington Fumbles His Glasses
In which we see a winter soldier demonstrate the
limits of power, the power of limits, and a new
kind of leadership for a new kind of nation
Chapter One: Vice President-Elect Jefferson Stabs a Friend in the Back
In which we see a hypocritical ideologue
apprehend the value of pragmatism
Chapter Two: Former President Adams Can't Stop Gagging
In which we see that a privileged upbringing
need not handicap a (very) senior citizen
Chapter Three: Representative Lincoln Smears a Preacher
In which we see an ambitious politico achieve the
moral—and spiritual—clarity of a great emancipator
Chapter Four: Gentleman Boss
Arthur Bites the Hand that Feeds Him
In which we see a political hack discover
the virtues of good governance
Chapter Five: Dude T.R. Enters the Arena
In which we see an imperial democrat
reveal that impatience can be a virtue
Chapter Six: F.D.R. Courts Disaster
In which we see a handicapped man learn he must not
be a bully if he wants to save the world from despotism
Chapter Seven: Landslide Lyndon
Takes a Position
In which we see an amoral opportunist
commit an act of courage
Chapter Eight: Vice President Ford Stumbles at the Gate
In which we see a naïve man pardon a crook—
and heal a nation
Chapter Nine: The Gipper
Loses One
In which we see a saber-rattler break some rules,
get caught, and go on to win an important contest—
in good faith
Chapter Ten: Slick Willie
Slips and Falls
In which we see an offensive player
master a defensive strategy
Epilogue: President Bush Fumbles an Invasion
In which we see why this book was written
Afterword: The President We Need
Notes
Source Notes
Index
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
Alice Martell: My first words of thanks. Every writer has the fantasy of the unexpected benefactor, a highly credible figure who emerges from the mists and tells you you're good (as good as you sometimes believe you are, better than the fraud you know yourself to be). More than that: This person actually makes things happen, things you could never do for yourself. Alice swept into my life in the spring of 2005, made me presentable, shopped me around, sold my work, checked up on me periodically to see how I was doing, forgave my missteps, and—given some of my previous experience with agents, I still can't quite get over this—returned my phone calls. The word that describes my dazed gratitude is marvel.
I don't really deserve such treatment. The Puritans called it irresistible grace. The Lord works in mysterious ways, and I'm here to tell you that one of those ways is Alice.
She didn't do it alone. Another agent of my good fortune is my editor, Alessandra Bastagli. This was not supposed to be a book on the presidency. Actually, it began as a website on flawed but admirable Americans called American History for Cynical Beginners.* But Alessandra had the vision and the skill to help me focus it into a more svelte narrative form, and much of any merit this project has is attributable to her. I'd also like to thank other members of the Palgrave team: copyeditor Rick Delaney, who read the manuscript with skill and care; associate production editor Yasmin Mathew, who shepherded me through the production process,
* You can see it for yourself: www.ecfs.org/projects/jcullen
and Letra Libre, who designed the book. Special thanks as well to marketing manager Amy Tiedemann, Lauren Dwyer, and the editorial director of Palgrave, Airié Stuart.
Since coming to the Ethical Culture Fieldston School in 2001, I have benefited from the company and counsel of a cherished array of students and colleagues, some of whom allowed me to run road tests of this material by them. I am also thankful to the librarians of the Tate Library at Fieldston—Nelie Locher, Mandy Colgan, and Carol Oreskovic—who chased down leads, ordered books, and provided the kind of cheerful competence that is the special province of their breed. The Venture Grant board at ECFS provided crucial seeding in funding the website, and Associate Head of School Beth Beckmann channeled some institutional largesse in my direction as well. I am grateful to these people as well as to the head of the school, Joe Healey, for their administrative support and goodwill.
This book was wedged into an everyday life that I think could be legitimately regarded as busy. My four children accepted their father's distraction without entirely understanding it. My wife, to whom this book is dedicated, tolerated her husband's distraction despite understanding it all too well. It is a strange conceit to think that anything one might say to a stranger could be as valuable as that which one does with a loved one. I have indulged what sometimes seemed like a literal itch to write by scratching a metaphorical pen. I hope none of us—and that includes you, dear reader—are worse for it.
—Jim Cullen
Hastings-on-Hudson, New York
November, 2006
IMPERFECT PRESIDENTS
FOREWORD
THE PRESIDENT WE WANT
For most of us, for most of the time, it doesn't really matter who the President of the United States is. We get up in the morning, go to school or work, see our friends and families, balance our checkbooks (or try to, anyway), eat our meals, sleep in our beds. We have our passions, our struggles, our aspirations. And every once in a while, we may stop to realize that the very fact of it not mattering is part of what makes us lucky to be Americans. It's one of the forms our freedom takes: the freedom not to care.
Even for most of the people who work for the federal government, it doesn't matter who the President of the United States is. Members of the U.S. Congress and Supreme Court have responsibilities and concerns completely separate from those of the executive branch, as do state and local government officers. Moreover, a vast army of appointed officials watch politicians come and go, their own work largely invisible—and stubbornly resistant to change—no matter who happens to live at 1600 Pennsylvania Avenue.
Yet however irrelevant he may be—and we have been invariably talking about a he
so far—the President of the United States is also an inescapable presence in our daily lives. Whether we want to or not, we see him in the morning when we watch TV, surf the web, or open a newspaper, and we hear about him over dinner or in the employee lounge. We're told endless details about his friends, his family, his foibles, and we hear jokes about him. Every four years we have a presidential election, and long before most of us would care to think about it, we're bombarded with ads, and with armchair speculating and strategizing over scenarios that never come to pass.
Presidents also sometimes become a kind of social shorthand for measuring and characterizing a time. The Age of Eisenhower,
for example, conjures up a series of time-specific images: new suburban homes and highways; television shows like The Adventures of Ozzie and Harriet and I Love Lucy; highballs and martinis; men in gray flannel suits and women in poodle skirts; and so on. Of course that very moment was also one of anxieties over juvenile delinquency, the emergence of the Civil Rights movement, and a problem with no name
that launched the modern feminist movement—all of which were largely tangential to the Eisenhower administration. And yet the very significance, even intensity, of these latter phenomena were defined against a mainstream that Eisenhower—the twice-elected, highly popular, and reassuringly conventional president—represented.
Indeed, the perceived personality of a president is almost always more important than specific policies he advocates. True, most chief executives are representatives of political parties that seek to advance a general political philosophy (one usually related, in one form or another, to a belief in the proper scope of the federal government). But the reception of specific decisions a president makes are usually filtered through a more durable, and usually decisive, lens of personality. Franklin Delano Roosevelt's popularity was not directly correlated with his policies—it could not have been, because his actions in office directly contradicted promises he made (like balancing the federal budget during the 1932 presidential campaign, or keeping the United States out of World War II in 1940) without any negative impact on his political effectiveness. Instead, it is generally agreed, it was Roosevelt's indomitable spirit of optimism that voters responded to, a mood he projected that proved far more important than logically curious assertions (like we have nothing to fear but fear itself
) or policies that were in fact deeply unpopular (like trying to pack the Supreme Court with pliable appointees). Insofar as specific actions matter—like those of Richard Nixon between the Watergate break-in of June 1972 and his resignation a little over two years later—it's because such actions lead Americans to revise their overall perception of a president's character. Nixon felt compelled to say I am not a crook
in 1973 precisely because that's what most Americans concluded he was, even before all the corroborating evidence was in.
The correlation between a president's character and the situations in which he finds himself can be complicated to untangle. Andrew Jackson seemed to place his imprint on his era by sheer force of personality; Jimmy Carter seemed buffeted by events beyond his control—and was viewed as ineffectual for precisely this reason. Though presidents are in office for a tiny fraction of their lives, it's that fraction that permanently defines their public personae, even when they had substantial lives before entering and after leaving office.
The two parts of that equation—the numerator
of holding office and denominator
that marks the rest of a president's life—form the key quotient of a presidential character. Typically those two pieces point toward a whole; voters pretty much knew what they were getting when they elected Calvin Coolidge president in 1924 (a terse, minimalist leadership style, epitomized by the way he broke a police strike as the governor of Massachusetts), and he pretty much fulfilled those expectations in the Oval Office. Occasionally, there was a big divergence. Ulysses S. Grant saved the Union as a decisive military leader during the Civil War, but in his eight years as president between 1869 and 1877 he passively condoned widespread corruption and marred his stellar reputation. The element of unpredictability is what makes presidential politics both intriguing and frustrating.
All presidents make mistakes. They're human. We all know that, and yet many of us have trouble fully accepting this truth. In part, that's a function of the presidency itself, which fuses the head of the government and the head of the state into a single person. The British feel free to jeer at the prime minister right to his face in the House of Commons; jeering at the Queen is another matter. From the moment he is elected, the president is endowed with an otherworldly aura, even by friends on a first-name basis who now refer to him as Mr. President.
And from the moment he is elected he becomes fodder for late-night comedians, and begins the inevitable process of disappointing at least some of the people all of the time. Meanwhile, there are those who think of politics as a four-letter word; election to the presidency is in itself proof that a candidate has cut a deal with the devil. No president has been immune from such carping and suspicion.
There is much to be gained from an attempt to see presidents whole, to appreciate their strengths as well as their weaknesses—and, perhaps more importantly, to appreciate those strengths in light of their weaknesses. Given the sheer scope of the challenges involved in becoming president, it is safe to say that anyone who has ever held the job exhibits traits that would be worth emulating. And given the fallibility of human beings generally, and the kinds of vices to which a president is particularly susceptible, it also seems reasonable that every president offers a cautionary tale. The lessons these people afford are illuminating in the context of American politics, to be sure. But in embodying tendencies of Americans in a particular time and place, they open a window on the American character generally—who we are, who we're not, and who we may yet be.
The stories that comprise this book all begin the same way: A man in a moment of weakness or confusion, acting in ways few of us would regard as appropriate. John Quincy Adams refusing to attend his successor's inauguration. Theodore Roosevelt making an absurdly pretentious entrance into the New York State Assembly. Gerald Ford attending a meeting of questionable propriety about Richard Nixon. Far from random miscalculation, however, the actions of these people reflect important aspects of their characters—they represent a kind of honesty. Moreover, the same character traits that get them into trouble are also manifestations of an inner strength that ultimately serves the country well. So, for example, Chester Alan Arthur violated a cardinal rule of politics by forsaking loyalty to his cronies, but when he unexpectedly landed in the White House he realized he had a higher loyalty to the American people. It is also true, however, that the presidential triumph in each of these cases has sometimes come from a decision (typically temporary) to consciously act against type. Thomas Jefferson, for instance, was able to consummate the most successful act of his presidency only by actively resisting powerful philosophical inclinations. At other times, success is simultaneously an affirmation and a refutation of a particular trait. Ronald Reagan's behavior toward the Soviet Union in his second term was both a reversal of his career-long hostility to that nation as well as the fulfillment of an overriding desire—one that had gotten him into some serious trouble—to bring the Cold War to a decisive close.
Some of the figures examined here are widely considered great, like Lincoln and the two Roosevelts. Others, like Arthur and Adams, are obscure to most Americans today. Still others, like Lyndon Johnson and Bill Clinton, remain deeply controversial. Five of the subjects here are Republicans, three are Democrats, and two were president before the advent of the modern party system. Many of the misadventures described here take place before the man in question became president, followed by a particular success in office. But sometimes both halves of the story occur in the White House, and in one case (Adams) both occur afterward. Even old men make foolish mistakes—and transcend them.
The core conviction animating this book is a belief that, like choosing a spouse, choosing the president we want is an affair of the heart no less than one of the head. To understand your president, however imperfectly, is, however imperfectly, to understand yourself.
(previous page) TIME OF TRIAL: The Prayer at Valley Forge, painted by H. Brueckner; engraved by John C. McRae, 1866. Most portraits of Washington depict him with Olympian detachment. But there were crucial moments in the Revolution—Valley Forge was one; the Newburgh Conspiracy was another—where the cause was in doubt and Washington's leadership in question. (Presidential Portraits, Library of Congress)
CHAPTER ONE
VICE PRESIDENT–ELECT JEFFERSON STABS A FRIEND IN THE BACK
In which we see a hypocritical ideologue apprehend the value of pragmatism
Sometime during the month of January 1797, Thomas Jefferson made a fateful decision that would betray a friendship and destabilize a nation. Elected Vice President of the United States the previous November, he secretly resolved to decline an invitation to collaborate closely in the new government of President John Adams. Instead, he would keep his distance and quietly aid the opposition. The Adams administration would in effect be doomed before it got underway. Even worse, Jefferson's decision would mean that the nation's first foreign policy crisis would spill over into domestic politics, rocking the country to its foundations.
The chief reason for Jefferson's decision to betray his friend was ideological. Adams, part of the so-called Federalist faction in the new political regime, favored a stronger central government and a foreign policy aligned with England. Jefferson, who belonged to the so-called Democratic-Republican faction, favored stronger state governments and a foreign policy aligned with France. Amid the tumult of the French Revolution, which careened between anarchy and authoritarianism, U.S.-French relations, so crucial to the success of the American Revolution, had deteriorated to the point where the two nations were at virtual war. President-elect Adams thought he could heal the breach, at home and abroad, by sending Jefferson—who had once been U.S. ambassador to France—to negotiate with the Revolutionary government. Even if Jefferson himself could not go, perhaps one of his allies, like Congressman James Madison, could. Adams would no doubt be excoriated by his Anglophile allies for such a move, but it was a risk he was willing to take—a bold act of solidarity in a fragile country that could ill afford internal squabbling.
Jefferson's first instinct was to accept the offer, discreetly extended through mutual friends.¹ Jefferson had known Adams for almost a quarter century; they had met in Philadelphia during the Second Continental Congress in 1775, collaborated on the Declaration of Independence the following year, and served together as diplomats in Europe during and after the American Revolution. In the years that followed they had drifted apart politically,² yet remained friendly amid increasingly obvious philosophical differences and their respective unhappiness with their roles in the Washington administration—Adams as vice president and Jefferson as secretary of state. (Jefferson, disgusted with Washington's bias toward Treasury Secretary Alexander Hamilton, left the nation's capitol in Philadelphia for his Virginia estate, Monticello, after the first term.) When Washington stepped down after his second term, Adams and Jefferson were widely considered the leading candidates from their respective factions to run for president. Adams won and became president, and as per the recently ratified Constitution, Jefferson, who came in second, became vice president.³
Not that Jefferson himself minded the outcome. In December 1796, Madison wrote Jefferson that since Adams was the likely winner, you must prepare yourself therefore to be summoned to the place Mr. Adams now fills.
Jefferson wrote back on New Year's Day of 1797 to say that was just fine with him: I am his junior in life [Jefferson was nine years younger than Adams], was his junior in Congress, his junior in the diplomatic line, his junior lately in our civil government.
Besides, as he had noted in a December 27 letter to his South Carolinian friend Edward Rutledge, this is certainly not the time to covet the helm.
Given the difficulty any man would face in filling Washington's shoes, and the severity of the nation's foreign policy challenges, Jefferson was shrewd as well as gracious.⁴
The very next day, Jefferson went a step further, writing a warm letter to Adams himself, expressing satisfaction with the pending outcome. No one then will congratulate you with purer disinterestedness than myself,
he told his longtime collaborator. Indeed, he expressed relief. The share indeed which I may have had in the late vote, I shall still value highly, as an evidence of the share I have in the esteem of my fellow citizens. . . . [But] I have no desire to govern men. It is a painful and thankless office.
Jefferson went on to express the hope that Adams would be able to steer the nation away from a looming war with France. "If you are, the glory will be all your own; and that your administration may be filled with glory and happiness to yourself and advantage to