White Guys: A Novel
3.5/5
()
About this ebook
Inspired by actual events, Giardina has created a masterful and explosive social novel about the price of the American dream.
After graduating from high school, in the early 1970s, Billy Mogavero is the only one of a tight-knit group of five friends who didn't make it out of Winship, a hardscrabble town outside of Boston. Twenty years later, the other four--who have made their way, to varying degrees--decide to return to Winship to visit Billy, once their galvanizing alpha male and now a paint salesman who lives at home with his mentally handicapped brother. Their reunion sparks a rapid-fire chain of events as Billy finally makes the social leap his friends have spent their lives making--to suburban respectability and conformity.
Enthralled by the rapidity of Billy's climb--his marriage to an equally ambitious and tough Irishwoman, Maureen, included--his best friend, Timmy O'Kane, sees in Billy's protean character and masterful adoption of middle-class norms a vital and necessary critique of his cozy existence--paid for by his wealthy wife--in a privileged Boston suburb. But when Billy, Maureen, and their unborn child are victims of a drive-by shooting in which only Billy survives, Timmy is ensnared in a series of events that threaten to spin entirely out of his control. His complicity in the aftermath of the tragedy threatens the hardwon security of his leafy, suburban idyll--but is also strangely and seductively liberating.
Anthony Giardina
Anthony Giardina is the author of novels including White Guys and one collection of stories. His short fiction and essays have appeared in Harper’s Magazine, Esquire, GQ, and The New York Times Magazine, and his plays have been widely produced. He is a regular visiting professor at the Michener Center of the University of Texas. He lives in Northampton, Massachusetts.
Related to White Guys
Related ebooks
The Road to Catoctin Mountain: A 20Th Century Journey Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsThe Death of the Grown-Up: How America's Arrested Development Is Bringing Down Western Civilization Rating: 5 out of 5 stars5/5High Yella: A Modern Family Memoir Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5My Fathers' Houses: Memoir of a Family Rating: 2 out of 5 stars2/5Gold Coast: Stories From A Suburban Shangri-La Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsThe Great Gatsby Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsThe Edge of Whiteness Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Let Me Finish Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5American Legacy Collection Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratings681⁄2: Movies, Manson & Me Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsComing of Age in New Milford Rating: 5 out of 5 stars5/5Remembering Mountain City Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsGhost Towns Rating: 5 out of 5 stars5/5City Boy: My Life in New York During the 1960s and '70s Rating: 3 out of 5 stars3/5Hank Hung the Moon and Warmed Our Cold, Cold Hearts Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsThe Great Gatsby - Unabridged Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsI See Lincoln's Underpants: The Surprising Times Underwear (And the People Wearing Them) made History Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsThe Great Gatsby: Original 1925 Edition: A Timeless Tale of Love, Wealth, and the American Dream Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsThe Great Gatsby: Original 1925 Edition: Dive into the Jazz Age - A Timeless Classic Reimagined! Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsThe Great Gatsby by F. Scott Fitzgerald Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsThe Great Gatsby: Original 1925 Edition Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsTen Thousand and One Nights: A Piano Man’S Odyssey Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsSpaceships and Liquor: Venus and Mars Are All Right Tonight Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsNote Found in a Bottle Rating: 3 out of 5 stars3/5The Ballad of Little River: A Tale of Race and Restless Youth in the Rural Sou Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsThe Hockey Sweater and Other Stories Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Solid Ivory: Memoirs Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsLetter from Brooklyn Rating: 5 out of 5 stars5/5The Great Gatsby (Musaicum Must Classics) Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsCircus Girl: A Novel Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratings
Literary Fiction For You
Prophet Song: A Novel (Booker Prize Winner) Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Piranesi Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5A Confederacy of Dunces Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The 7 1/2 Deaths of Evelyn Hardcastle Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Catch-22: 50th Anniversary Edition Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Covenant of Water (Oprah's Book Club) Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5A Man Called Ove: A Novel Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Demon Copperhead: A Novel Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Leave the World Behind: A Novel Rating: 3 out of 5 stars3/5Pride and Prejudice: Bestsellers and famous Books Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Silmarillion Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Only Woman in the Room: A Novel Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Handmaid's Tale Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Life of Pi: A Novel Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Cloud Cuckoo Land: A Novel Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Little Birds: Erotica Rating: 3 out of 5 stars3/5Flowers for Algernon Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Alchemist Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Lagos Wife: A Novel Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5I Who Have Never Known Men Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Old Man and the Sea: The Hemingway Library Edition Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Tender Is the Flesh Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Poisonwood Bible: A Novel Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Queen's Gambit Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Invisible Hour: A Novel Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Sympathizer: A Novel (Pulitzer Prize for Fiction) Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5I'm Thinking of Ending Things: A Novel Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Master & Margarita Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Babel: Or the Necessity of Violence: An Arcane History of the Oxford Translators' Revolution Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5All the Ugly and Wonderful Things: A Novel Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5
Related categories
Reviews for White Guys
12 ratings2 reviews
- Rating: 3 out of 5 stars3/5The book opens in the 1970s in Winship, Massachusetts, a middle-class suburb of Boston. The narrarator is Timmy O'Kane. The book follows Timmy and his friends through the last year of high school, college, and then work and family life. The friend who is the center of the book and Tim's life is Billy Mogavero, who deviates drastically from the life path that his friends have chosen. The character development was excellent with lots of nuances, and the story has some shocking twists. Midway through the book, though, the story begins to deteriorate, and Timmy turns into a whiner with no backbone, and the reader is questioning what Tim is getting out of his relationship with Billy. But this reader kept on going, hoping for a big payoff at the end, which never comes. So overall, a disappointing read.
- Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Engaging story of five childhood friends growing up in an Italian neighborhood. Story revolves around one of the gorup--an on again-off again hoodlum. Really a story about what makes people happy and whether a middle-class lifestyle does the trick.
Book preview
White Guys - Anthony Giardina
part one
one
Billy Mogavero was my friend from the age of about eight, or whatever age it is that boys separate from their mothers, begin their forays outside the tight circle of skirts and family gatherings, and form their own, even tighter circles on playgrounds, or, in our case, on the long, broken strip of beach stretching from Boston Harbor all the way up to Gloucester. We were located in Winship, somewhere in the middle of those two points. There are boys who, at eight or ten, are more than normally handsome, well built, instinctive leaders, and I have noticed such boys nearly always have a streak of meanness in them. That was true of Billy, but we followed him anyway, because we had no innate leadership qualities ourselves, not Johnny Lombardi or Freddie Tortolla or Kenny DiGiovanni, or me, the only Irish kid in the group, the ethnic runt.
We all followed Billy, but Billy followed just one person, and that person only sometimes. That was his father. Mr. Mogavero was a tall, skinny man who had married late. He wore glasses, and he was the butcher for the Star Market. When we went there to meet him—when Billy needed money for the movies or to get a cut of meat his mother had asked him to bring home—his father would come out the door that led into the frosty inner harbor of the Star Market meat department and wipe his hands slowly and carefully on the blood-smeared apron he wore and look us all over. With the glasses on, he might have been a schoolteacher. He said our names carefully, one by one, as if he owed us all the respect he would give to men who had come on business.
It is odd that it begins this way, this story I have to tell, with us following Mr. Mogavero on the boardwalk on a series of warm summer evenings in the late sixties. There was, at that time, along the boardwalk, the three-quarters-empty shell of a once-great amusement park, Fantasia. Its memory still hovered over the town of Winship. The park had been built in the 1920s, a huge pleasure dome, a city by the sea
imposed on the marshland that spread back and fanned outward from the beach. It had put us on the map. A train had once carried immigrant workers out of Boston on Sundays (The Fantasia Special, it was called) to pay their ten cents and ride the flume cars into the Great Lagoon, or to sit coupled in the scooped boats of Love’s Journey and emerge, after a trip through the tunnel, under a shower of confetti. Or else to visit Dark Town, where Negroes played Dixieland music and staged mock alligator hunts. All that was left by the time we were kids were the roller coaster and the kiddie rides, the Dodge ‘Em cars and the Caterpillar, and a sometimes-working Wild Mouse. Mr. Mogavero used to take us boys Sunday nights into what was left of the park, to dispense quarters so that we could play Skee-Ball, to stand and watch us on the Dodge ’Ems. He did not participate. He stood and watched, and when we were tired, he made us follow him in a direction opposite to home.
He led us to deserted places, places where the marsh had broken through the territory of the old park, other places where stores and warehouses had taken up residence. Some nights Mr. Mogavero would make a halfhearted attempt to explain what had once been here, what a ride like Tragic Honeymoon had looked like in its heyday, and how it had worked. The couple would stand up there, and there was a mechanical illusion, made them look like skeletons.
His hands would go up to describe the scene in the air, but he would give up halfway, as though exact communication was less important than pure suggestion. What we were left with was how strangely beautiful and spectral the old park remained for this quiet man.
There is nothing more to say about those nights except for the anger with which Billy endured his father’s wanderings. No boy wants to see his father as in any way out of the ordinary. The rest of us were lucky: the Italian boys’ fathers were big, hairy, energetic lugs, deliverers of oil, night watchmen in factories, bus drivers. My own father was a teller in a bank. They listened to baseball games on transistor radios; they sat on the stoops of their small, packed-together beach-town houses on summer nights and drank beer; they put down Negroes and insulted hippies and fags and asserted an American regularity we all deeply prized. We knew how to throw baseballs and catch footballs, they took the time to make sure of that, though it was not like now: they rarely came to the organized games we played in Little League or Babe Ruth. They took us to church and afterward scoffed a little at what the priest had said, so that we should know certain sins were not to be taken seriously. It was an easy life, without large expectations, and it probably surprised these guys to see the incomes their sons managed to achieve when, in the nineties, the economy picked us up on that high, curling wave we miraculously knew how to ride. One by one, Mr. Mogavero would return us to these waiting fathers, and they always exchanged words, but you knew right away from the way they looked at Billy’s father that he was not a member of their club.
On those nights, I’m convinced, something started in Billy, an attitude toward the world essentially hard, as though his father’s dreaminess were a strop he was sharpening his blade on. For me, it had another effect. I’d lie in bed after those walks and look out my window, which had a view beyond the houses and the TV antennas and the row of stores on the next block to the marsh where the great, dormant Fantasia now lay. Nobody wants to believe that there had once been a world better than the one you were born into, but if that is the information fed into your young consciousness, it tends to stay there.
One of the ways I have learned to accommodate the past—or maybe it’s truer to say, one of the ways I have learned to fight its pull—is in the work I do now. I am a salesman for the textbook division of Endicott Press. Endicott has branched out in the last couple of decades to include historical survey books, and three years ago we launched a foreign languages division, which shows signs of doing very well. Our reputation, however, was made on the literary anthologies we began publishing in the early 1960s, when the market for literature began to boom on American campuses, and we have remained a leader ever since. We now publish anthologies of African American and Native American and Asian American literature; our selection of Chicano writings, published just two years ago, has done spectacularly well, particularly in the West, and a gay-and-lesbian anthology has just been published. Our bread and butter, though, is and always has been the book we refer to in-house as White Guys.
White Guys
sells in the hundreds of thousands annually. It is the text of choice at community colleges and for the less-imaginative graduate assistants at the big state universities. It begins with an excerpt from Charles Brockden Brown and his eighteenth-century religious maniacs and ends with a story about a lovesick football coach in late-twentieth-century Albuquerque. Though it is not, of course, literally comprised of stories written only by white males, the bulk is still there: it is a testicular view of America, unquestionably.
Never a reader in high school or college, and having fallen into this job by benign accident (the father of a college buddy set me up), I took to the road as a very young man with a briefcase full of books and, finding time and a little energy on my hands, began to read from beginning to end the stories in our cash cow. I thought I was probably the only one of the young salesmen doing this, that it might give me some sort of leg up. Mostly what I felt, though, reading these stories in motel rooms in Utica or Wilkes-Barre, was how depressing most of them were, Henry James and Willa Cather and Sherwood Anderson chronicling lives that started out hopeful and then fell into some hole. After reading one of these stories, I would put the book down, go to the window of whatever motel I happened to be staying in, and, looking outside, feel something begin to shift for me; an easy and basically innocent take on the world that had served me well up to this point began to seem too weak an instrument of defense.
You have to understand who I was then: a young guy who had done little in the past four years except get drunk and half sleep through his classes, party, and watch a criminal amount of sports on TV. Nothing at all had happened to me except for one thing, and I had basically swept that under the rug. Nothing existed to stand in my way except that old affinity of mine for getting caught up in the dregs and eddies of the past. But now, gazing out into the light of the motel’s commercial surround, I began to detect another light at the edge of my vision. It seemed the light of the stories I’d been reading. As old as many of those stories were, it felt like it was still out there, exerting a familiar pull—the light in which people failed.
I remember one such night in particular. It was early November in western Pennsylvania, and I’d been sitting in my motel room before dinner, reading a story by John Cheever called The Country Husband.
By the time I went out for dinner, the story’s effect hadn’t really gotten to me. But I found as I sat in this family restaurant, empty at this late hour except for a couple of solitary guys like me, other salesmen or divorced guys, and a couple who sat in morose silence in a booth near mine, that whatever it was I’d been pushing away in my first months on the road, whatever mood of fear and trepidation had been nursed through my reading of the stories in White Guys,
that mood was now squarely, frighteningly in front of me. I can’t say it was The Country Husband
alone that did it to me. But Cheever’s story, with its emphatic suggestion of the emptiness of suburban marriage, of lives like my own hanging by a thread of misplaced hope, had reached me at a point where my ducks were all in a row. Cheever’s well-chosen words had knocked them all down.
When do boys decide who they’re going to be? I don’t have the answer to that one, but I know I had decided by that point. I wanted something soft and ever-present in the life I saw around me. I wanted husbandhood and fatherhood and a certain kind of woman who attached to those concepts in my mind. I wanted, in a very basic, unashamed way, the life I saw in the movies, in advertisements, in which a couple, still young, sit in a car full of kids. I wanted the whole package that went along with that image: sofas and largescreen TVs, and a small boat, a Boston Whaler. It had not yet occurred to me that those dreams might be in any way insufficient.
I had little appetite that night. Things I had hardly noticed before suddenly seemed inescapable. Who were the lonely guys sitting in this restaurant with me tonight, and how had their loneliness been arrived at? Why weren’t the couple in the next booth speaking?
I paid quickly and went back to the motel and lay under the covers, and here is what happened to me: I knew then that I did not merely want the Life—the wife and kids and dog and boat—I wanted it fiercely. I wanted this dream so badly it did not even require individuals to fulfill it: a specific wife, specific kids. I wanted to cling to forms. Almost anyone would do, as long as I could prove John Cheever wrong. Give me those beautiful forms, I promised myself in the way of young men, and I will love them to death.
The next day, I found myself wandering down the hallway of a small private college in western Pennsylvania. There is a light to the hallways of such third-tier institutions that is like the color of food that’s been poorly wrapped. There is old dust and, always, a discarded book left outside a professor’s office, a book that the professor in question has left there on purpose, secretly hoping someone will take it.
I had determined to make several cold calls, calls to men who had received sample copies of the newest revised White Guys.
But as soon as I found myself in that hallway, I began to wonder if it was possible anymore for me to do this job, never mind generate new revenue from it. I knocked on the door of a man to whom I had sent the book, a man named Professor Bill Adamcik, and listened to his gruff voice, inside, say, Come in.
I took a seat in Professor Adamcik’s office before I was invited to. He started to lift a hand in protest, then thought better of it. He told me he was busy before I’d even gotten a chance to tell him I was from Endicott. I asked if he’d had an opportunity to look over the sample copy. He scowled. No, he hadn’t had time. Then, after a pause, he said, Besides, that volume is too stodgy. I haven’t used it in years.
I knew then that I had two choices: leave the room or go for broke. I chose the latter. I asked him the simplest, most naked question I could think to ask: Had he ever read The Country Husband
?
For a long moment he gazed at me with a reluctant sense of curiosity. I have, yes,
he said, and shifted in his chair. Why do you ask?
"Well, when you call this volume stodgy, I don’t know. I shook my head.
I’m going to take a guess I’m a lot like your students. I mean, we’re all just trying to figure it out. I let out a very small laugh, to show him I could poke a little fun at myself while remaining, in essence, deadly earnest.
These stories, especially this one—I’m not ashamed to say they get to me."
Professor Adamcik’s eyes narrowed slightly. Beyond him, outside his oversize windows, at the edge of the brown and yellow November grounds of the college, lay the athletic fields. Boys in maroon and black soccer uniforms stood in clumps. He saw me looking at them and settled lower in his chair.
"What—got to you?" he asked, and I could tell that he was testing me, to see if I’d really read it.
Well, like I say, I’m a young guy, with it all sort of in front of me. And here’s a story about a guy who’s got it all, everything I want—
I leaned forward slightly. "Wife, kids, great house. And then he nearly dies in a plane crash, and he can’t get his wife to listen to him. It’s like the things in his life have taken over."
I shook my head, aware now that I was doing everything for effect, and marveling at my own newfound ability to lampoon, for the sake of a sale, things that had kept me awake the night before. So what’s Cheever saying?
I asked in the same breathless, highly charged mode. "That it’s all meaningless?"
Professor Adamcik smiled at that. But then, after smiling, he turned and faced out his window. Beyond him, at the edge of our vision, the soccer players spread into formation. I considered his days on this patch of Pennsylvania devoted to sports, this man with his sparse dark hair and trimmed gray beard and eyes that seemed to have begun a steady retreat into that place where things mattered to him less and less.
I know there are fancier volumes,
I said. I think we’re aware—at Endicott—that what we put out isn’t exactly cutting edge, but—
It’s just one view,
Professor Adamcik said, turning to me. Cheever’s. It’s just one view of marriage, of … the life you want.
I didn’t respond immediately. I sat and waited, watching him as he looked me over. In my training in sales, I had been taught always to maintain dominance, to never let the buyer get ahead of me. It occurred to me now that that strategy might work with the dumb, but not with the smart, and professors were, of course, among the smartest. But what they also were was lonely.
So I allowed him to talk. I did no more than listen. He seemed reluctant to say too much, aware that I might be laying some subtle trap for him. But when I made no move toward bringing him to the point of sale, when the whole notion of my wanting anything at all from him (save to listen) seemed to have evaporated, I saw something begin to happen to him that I have since seen happen in a hundred other academic offices. I watched him fall into his need for me.
Things are never so simple that I can say Professor Adamcik ordered White Guys
from me that time, or the next. But I kept coming, and eventually he did. For my freshmen,
he said, as if to excuse this lapse in his judgment. But really it was to keep me coming, to know that once or twice a year I would arrive and sit in his office and engage him with an idea or ask a question to which I believed he might offer some illumination. This is my life now. This is what I do: knock on doors and offer my stirred-up soul to men who have stopped believing that people like me exist—thinking men, questing men, readers. I am not really any of those things, of course, at least not in the way these men assume. What I am is something much simpler: a man who had a momentary perception of one of the ways the past wants to pull you under, and until very recently, at least, managed to stay afloat.
By the time this incident happened, Billy was no longer really a part of my life. I believed at that time that his effect on me had been a function of adolescence and was slowly evaporating. If asked, I might even have said I barely remembered the night Billy’s power got to me in a new way, a way that was more difficult to outgrow, on the night of our senior prom, in 1978.
Disco reigned that year. We were desperate to escape all that—Kenny, Johnny, Freddie, Billy, and I. We were cooler, or at least considered ourselves to be (Devo was our band of choice), so as soon as we could cut out from the prom, we took our dates down to the beach and Freddie brought out some of the dope he bought regularly from a cousin who worked in Boston. Freddie was already full of himself, with an oversize head and an air of knowing all the angles. He loved to rub whatever connections he had in our faces.
The girls who were with us that night were girls we’d each been with for a while, but there was nothing serious going on. The one exception was Billy’s date, Carol Casella.
Carol had transferred from a parochial school to Winship High in her junior year, a blond girl with a face of that extraordinary peach-fuzz quality that made every boy in the high school want to touch her, while knowing instinctively that it was more than we deserved. This modesty she’d brought out in all of us resulted in her going dateless for most of junior year, until Billy walked up to her one day in the cafeteria and asked her out.
They were legendary in the world of Winship High School. Billy had already come fully into his looks. His big, pouty, roundish face had matured without passing through any of the debilitating stages of adolescence. He had the look of sexual readiness before any of the rest of us. I was more than half in love with the sight of them together, his dark frame against the soft blondness of her, and on this night, as on many others, I found myself staring at them.
It was not something Billy ever failed to notice, my staring. In a way, he could be said to have thrived on it. What was strange was that the first thing I noticed as I stared at Billy that night was a hint of uncertainty in his eyes. He covered it with a big, mouthy smile, as if it were him, not me, who’d caught the other at something. I knew by that smile that a change was coming.
Billy stood up. He dusted off the seat of his tuxedo pants, which were wet from the sand. Carol helped him, her gesture spontaneous enough to make it seem like they were attached to the same set of impulses. Then Billy started walking away from us, toward the boardwalk, where our cars were parked, Carol following at a distance.
We all decided to get up and go after him. Johnny was the only one of us to balk; there was a prematurely aged part of him that always kicked in at such moments and tried to hold us back from our wilder impulses. Billy’s car was gone, so we all got into our own and for ten or fifteen minutes searched the streets of Winship, streets quiet on this May night before the beach season had officially started. If any of us were annoyed at Billy’s disappearance, we sat on it. It was unthinkable that the evening should continue without him.
Finally we spotted Billy’s car parked alongside the alley behind the train station. The trunk was open and Billy was leaning into it, removing something. Carol was in the front seat.
What’s going on, Billy?
someone shouted.
He didn’t answer us. Billy’s earlier uncertainty had given way to a darker mood. Changes in him always happened quickly; we were never quite prepared for them. It might have been disgust written across his face now as he hoisted a gas can out of the trunk.
I thought I could guess what had sparked his new mood: the four of us in our cars, with our ties still in place, and our air of placid acceptance of whatever tepid pleasures the night ahead of us might bring, the parties and the drinking and the bonfire on the beach, and afterward the sacking of the layers of taffeta. He turned away from us, started down the alley, carrying the heavy gas can. We could follow him or not, it was all the same to him.
I knew where he was headed. The alley was bordered on one side by a chain-link fence protecting the train tracks; the T stopped here on its way into Boston. On the other side was a large wooden wall with the words FANTASIA BALLROOM—DANCING NITELY barely decipherable. The wall had faded over time, gone from white to gray, and in certain places the paint had completely worn off and the wooden planks had taken on a sickly green tinge. It had been left up long after its time because the urge still existed in our town— Mr. Mogavero was not the only one to feel it—to honor what we had once been.
We watched Billy carry the gas can to the place where the sign’s wording was, and then we all got out of our cars, though none of us—not even Carol—came close.
I told you you didn’t have to come,
Billy said, and he splashed gas liberally onto the sign, stepping back when some came back against him. He took out a box of matches, and he might have gone ahead and set fire to the gas if a car hadn’t pulled up just then.
It was a Winship police car. Billy lit a match and thought a second, then blew it out.
We all recognized the cop inside. He was Charlie Porto, a cop in his early sixties, round, and with one of those genial, sad faces of older men who want to be liked. We’d known him for years. He’d even coached some of us in Little League. The patience we all remembered was there in the way he sat in the car, just making us aware of his presence, as if that should be enough to temper or even halt whatever marginally illegal thing we might be up to.
But we were not so far from him, and the scent must have reached him.
Is that gasoline I smell, Billy?
He had never coached Billy, but he couldn’t help knowing him. There were previous small brushes with the law, and there was also the football team Billy had played on, prominently but unspectacularly, for three years.
Billy’s response was to sniff hard. I don’t know, Officer Charlie. Is it?
He had a little smile on his face.
Charlie Porto looked at the rest of us, his way of gauging the seriousness of what was going on, of deciding whether he needed to step out of the car. Our faces must have been blank—at least unhelpful—because he did get out. He walked up to us in that rolling movement of an unhurried fat man.
Tell you what,
he said as he got closer to Billy. You just bring me that gas can and those matches in your hand, and we’ll forget this. You can go on to your parties, or whatever.
He turned around and glanced at the rest of us, and there was something mildly heartbreaking in the way that glance asked us to remember the diamonds of certain municipal parks. He was calling to an old agreement, one he couldn’t see had been superceded.
When he turned back to Billy, it was to see him kick the can a few inches toward him.
Charlie Porto didn’t know what to say then. For a moment or two he simply rocked back and forth on his hips.
Come on, Billy, before this gets serious, it’s time to cut it out.
Billy turned away from him and looked up at the sign. I caught the look of offense on his face at being referred to so intimately, so familiarly. With a quick motion he lit a match.
We all stepped away immediately, and when the match hit the pool of gas, everyone made a run for it, the girls making disgusted noises and Johnny leading the way back to the cars. I’d had the same reaction at first, but I turned around after a few steps to see Charlie Porto making a broken run toward the burning pool at Billy’s feet. Billy was waiting for him. Even from a distance I could see the savagery with which Billy hit the policeman. He laid him on the ground too quickly, in a way that seemed unfair, as if they’d been poorly matched. Charlie Porto kept trying to get up, and Billy kept hitting him until the older man lay there motionless. It was over sickeningly fast. I ignored my girlfriend’s halfhearted beckoning and stayed after the others were gone.
What the hell are you doing, Billy?
I shouted.
He ignored me; I doubt he even heard me. He was in another place.
Carol, all this time, had said nothing. But I was aware of her stillness there, almost her expectation of this kind of behavior coming from Billy. An unconscious police officer lay at her feet, she was wearing an expensive gown whose pale tangerine folds scraped against the dirty alley he had brought her to, and this was the night of nights, her senior prom. Yet all this she took in some sort of stride.
Billy hoisted Charlie Porto under the arms, but the man’s weight was too much even for him. It was then that he looked up and acknowledged me.
Come on, Tim. Let’s move this guy.
At first I didn’t respond. Billy hoisted Charlie Porto under the arms and started dragging him. To save the man this indignity, I went forward and took his legs. I was relieved to see that he was alive. He was still hard to move, though. All the time we were carrying Charlie Porto to his car, I made noises to let Billy know how disgusted I was, but he didn’t seem to hear them. He was still in his own quiet place.
We laid Charlie Porto out on the backseat of his car, his fatness making it hard to arrange the body properly. I decided I should stay there until he awoke, to do something at least to make up for Billy’s cruelty.
Billy unlatched Charlie’s holster and removed the gun.
Jesus, Billy,
I said, and started to reach for the gun to keep him from using it.
Oh, relax, Tim. I’m not going to shoot him. What do you think I am?
With surprising expertise Billy dropped the bullets out of the chamber, then jingled them in his hands and threw them as far as he could. He glanced back once at the toppled policeman and started moving toward Carol.
It was then that I realized how much I didn’t want to be there. In some domesticated part of me, I hungered for the night as it was supposed to have gone. The sign itself worked its way into my sudden nostalgia. I wanted things left as they were.
Billy was nearly at the sign, reaching into his pocket for the matches, when I shouted, Don’t do it!
Part of me hated him now.
He turned and looked at me, surprised that I had spoken, surprised maybe, in some deeper part of him, that I was still there.
Why?
he asked.
He’s right,
Carol said. Her head had been lowered up till now in patience. She lifted it and said, You don’t have to burn the goddamn sign.
No, I don’t have to,
he said, and splashed more gas over the wood, but I’m going to. Shit, yes. I’m going to.
He placed the lit match against the wood at the lowest point where the gasoline had spilled, and it went up.
Carol shielded her eyes. The flame, initially quite large and dramatic, died down so that only the gas was burning. The wood, soaked with water and salt for more than fifty years, wouldn’t take. Billy looked at it with curiosity now.
I moved a little closer toward him. It means something to people,
I said.
Thank you, Tim, for your Rotary Club take on our little expedition here.
Carol turned to me then for the first time, as if she were just now distinguishing me from the pack. It was a look of approval I was receiving, and it made me beam.
Billy splashed more gas onto the sign. This time some got on Carol’s dress, she uttered a small cry and stepped back. Billy didn’t light the match, but looked at her a moment as if he was taking in her vulnerability, her girlness. It wasn’t exactly compassion on his face now, but something else. In dumb show, it looked as if she was pretending to be angry, maybe even was angry. She mimed pushing him away, hitting him, and all he did was touch her bare shoulder, look at it with what seemed a kind of wonder. She watched him looking at it.
I could see then, very suddenly, that a change had come over Billy and Carol. Billy placed his hand against her back, and in the next moment they were moving toward me, Carol gazing slightly downward, her hand bunching the spot where her gown had been soiled. I knew they didn’t even see me. Something had just been decided between them, and they were moving off as if all that was left for them to do was to obey it.
In the aftermath, everything that was tawdry about the scene—the alley itself, the abandoned gas can, the police car in which I could see the first signs of Charlie Porto stirring—came forward in a way that their being there had at least partially obscured. I was hit by the stupidity of my being there at all, the fall guy for Billy’s stunt. So I ran down the alley in the opposite direction from the police cruiser, crossed the street, and sat on the seawall, far enough away so that I knew no one could see me.
I sat there and wondered what the end of this might be. Was it too late to rejoin my friends, to make the evening yield up the simple high school pleasures it had promised earlier? I knew I should be worrying about Charlie Porto, but I wasn’t. Though I was trying to push it away, the thing that was still with me was the way Billy and Carol had looked as they passed me.
I was still waiting in my life then for the consummate fuck, the act that would take me out of myself and onto some higher plane. Sometimes you can know things exist without actually experiencing them, and tonight, in the look Billy and Carol had given each other, I knew I’d come close to some central, powerful source. In all his sordidness and violence, Billy was also a guardian of the world’s special rooms, the holder of the key. He seemed to need the violence sometimes just to tap into his own tenderness, but having reached it, it was like he was able to open that room to me. To say, Look, Tim, look what’s inside. I could see Charlie Porto stepping out of his car and calling for backup, but it was not the reality of this or even the possible danger that affected me now. It was Billy and Carol’s sex. I could taste it as I sat there. I could taste the way it would feel to bite Carol’s lips and hear her gasp against your ear and to watch her neck stretch as you pushed in a little farther. I could feel, too, what it would be like to do that pushing, to feel the wetness of her and her resistance, too, and the way that wetness would spread deliciously against your thighs.
Though the sign suffered no real damage that night, Billy would go to jail for his assault on Charlie Porto. The rest of us he would refuse to implicate, even going so far as to swear we’d tried to stop him. So we all went to college, while Billy did six months. Always, he gave the sense that whatever had happened between him and Carol that night had been worth it. My semester abroad,
he liked to call it afterward, and smiled.
two
We didn’t see Billy again until we came home for our Christmas breaks. We all knew he would be out by then, so we made sure to gather at his house.
Christmas night in an Italian house has a certain feeling. I don’t know what it is about these people, but it was always different in my friends’ houses from the way it was in the O‘Kane home, where my mother made sure to wrap up the uneaten turkey early and my father sat in front of the TV puffing on a cigarette with a kind of relief as soon as it was five o’clock and the day could be officially declared over.
I was glad when I was old enough to visit my friends’ houses on Christmas night. There were always uncles around in those houses, big guys with close-cropped hair and enormous cheeks, for whom, after they’d drunk enough, it ceased to matter that we boys had a perpetually stoned look. All that fell away, and they tried very hard to assert a brotherhood-of-man feeling by taking us aside and, with dark, deeply sincere eyes, asking, "Listen, if there’s ever anybody’s legs you need broken, I’m the guy to call, you hear me? I’m the