A Girl of the Limberlost
4/5
()
About this ebook
Gene Stratton-Porter
Gene Stratton-Porter (1863-1924) was an American author, photographer, and naturalist. Born in Indiana, she was raised in a family of eleven children. In 1874, she moved with her parents to Wabash, Indiana, where her mother would die in 1875. When she wasn’t studying literature, music, and art at school and with tutors, Stratton-Porter developed her interest in nature by spending much of her time outdoors. In 1885, after a year-long courtship, she became engaged to druggist Charles Dorwin Porter, with whom she would have a daughter. She soon grew tired of traditional family life, however, and dedicated herself to writing by 1895. At their cabin in Indiana, she conducted lengthy studies of the natural world, focusing on birds and ecology. She published her stories, essays, and photographs in Outing, Metropolitan, and Good Housekeeping before embarking on a career as a novelist. Freckles (1904) and A Girl of the Limberlost (1909) were both immediate bestsellers, entertaining countless readers with their stories of youth, romance, and survival. Much of her works, fiction and nonfiction, are set in Indiana’s Limberlost Swamp, a vital wetland connected to the Wabash River. As the twentieth century progressed, the swamp was drained and cultivated as farmland, making Stratton-Porter’s depictions a vital resource for remembering and celebrating the region. Over the past several decades, however, thousands of acres of the wetland have been restored, marking the return of countless species to the Limberlost, which for Stratton-Porter was always “a word with which to conjure; a spot wherein to revel.”
Read more from Gene Stratton Porter
Gene Stratton-Porter Collection: A Girl of the Limberlost, Freckles, Laddie, The Harvester, A Daughter of the Land, At the Foot of the Rainbow, Her Fatther's Daughter, Michale O'Halloran Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsLaddie: Family Novel: A True Blue Story Rating: 5 out of 5 stars5/5A Girl of the Limberlost: Romance Novel Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratings
Related to A Girl of the Limberlost
Related ebooks
A Girl of the Limberlost Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5A Tangled Web Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5A Little Princess Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The blue castle Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsThe Harvester Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Anne of Windy Poplars Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Laddie: A True Blue Story Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Wives and Daughters Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Emily of New Moon Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Anne of Avonlea Rating: 5 out of 5 stars5/5Cranford Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Rebecca of Sunnybrook Farm Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Emily's Quest Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Anne of the Island Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Far from the Madding Crowd Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsA Daughter of the Land Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Anne’s House of Dreams Rating: 5 out of 5 stars5/5I Capture the Castle Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Princess and the Goblin: Classic Children's Fiction Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsJo's Boys Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Five Little Peppers Grown Up Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsThe Wind in the Willows Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Many Reflections of Miss Jane Deming Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5An Old-Fashioned Girl Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Persuasion Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Little Men Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Freckles Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5FAR FROM THE MADDING CROWD (British Classics Series): Historical Romance Novel Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Five Children and It Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratings
Children's Classics For You
Sideways Stories from Wayside School Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Alice in Wonderland: Down the Rabbit Hole Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Phantom Tollbooth Rating: 5 out of 5 stars5/5We Have Always Lived in the Castle Rating: 5 out of 5 stars5/5Mr. Popper's Penguins Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Graveyard Book Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Alice In Wonderland: The Original 1865 Unabridged and Complete Edition (Lewis Carroll Classics) Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsCoraline Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Bridge to Terabithia Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Secret Garden: The 100th Anniversary Edition with Tasha Tudor Art and Bonus Materials Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Little House in the Big Woods Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Stuart Little Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Baby Bear, Baby Bear, What Do You See? Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Baron Trump's Marvelous Underground Journey Rating: 3 out of 5 stars3/5The Last Battle: The Chronicles of Narnia Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Voyage of the Dawn Treader: The Chronicles of Narnia Rating: 5 out of 5 stars5/5From the Mixed-Up Files of Mrs. Basil E. Frankweiler Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Grimm's Fairy Tales Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Horse and His Boy: The Chronicles of Narnia Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Prince Caspian: The Return to Narnia Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Silver Chair: The Chronicles of Narnia Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Winnie the Pooh: The Classic Edition Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Sarah, Plain and Tall: A Newbery Award Winner Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Peter Pan Complete Text Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Wayside School Is Falling Down Rating: 5 out of 5 stars5/5On the Banks of Plum Creek Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Pete the Kitty and the Unicorn's Missing Colors Rating: 5 out of 5 stars5/5The Velveteen Rabbit Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5
Reviews for A Girl of the Limberlost
379 ratings19 reviews
- Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Elnora Comstock is a young woman who lives with her mother at the edge of the Limberlost swamp in Indiana around the turn of the century. Though naturally gifted and intelligent, Elnora is resented by her mother who blames her pregnancy for her inability to pull her husband from a mire of quicksand, where he died. Elnora has grown up never knowing her father or even her mother's love, but she is determined to make something of herself. Though straitened by her mother's refusal to sell land or cut trees, Elnora finds a way to pay her way through the city high school and get the education that will change her future. Along the way, old secrets about her father come to light and Elnora's mother must face the truth she never knew. I loved A Girl of the Limberlost so much growing up. I wanted to be Elnora and lose myself in the Limberlost as she did. (It's also easy for a teenage reader having conflict with her parents to admire the much-persecuted heroine of this tale.) I have been afraid to reread it because I felt it could not hold up to my older and wiser scrutiny, but I finally did. My hesitation was for good reason; I could see the weaknesses and sentimentality of the story a bit more clearly now. But there were other things that still rang true and moved me. This will always be an important novel to me and one I will share with my children. Sometimes it's the moment of life when you read a book that matters more than the literary merits of the work itself. A Girl of the Limberlost is that for me.
- Rating: 3 out of 5 stars3/5I wish I had read this as a child. Back then Little House on the Prairie books were still cool and I dreamed of being an innocent outdoors-woman. Now... not so much. I found Elnora to be a little too perfect, I would have killed for a fault or two. She always obeys her mother, does, what it right, always helps her neighbors, never encourages young men. She's too good! I wanted some excitement. Her tempestuous mother I could at least relate to even though she was a bitch. This book is the second in the Limberlost series although you needn't have read it. This story follows Elnora as she enters high school, enters society, and starts to earn money by collecting moths, butterflies, and other swamp specimen. She grows from a naive little country bumpkin to a refined little lady who is yards smarter and kinder than anyone else. Slow reading, but not bad. It's written well but would do best for younger readers.
- Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5A must read classic for girls
- Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5A classic american children's story about a very creative and charming girl who decides to pay her way through high-school collecting moth's in the Limberlost swamp. Elnora's father is dead and her mother lost in grief and refuses to support her in any way, blaming Elnora for the death of the father.This cannot quench Elnora's spirit. She has an incredible determination, and the transformation of this girl into a young woman captivates us. She's unspoiled, curious, self-taught and with a disarming simplicity and love of nature. The second half of the book is more of a love story between Elnora and a rich kind city-boy, Philip. however he's already entangled with a conceited girl that does whatever she can to stop the blossoming love.Stratton-Porter is a naturalist and we get a lot of knowledge of the nature life in the swamp. It also takes on some serious issues about loss, grief and reconciliation. If you love Anne of Green Gables there's a good chance you will love this one.It's in 1001 Children's Books You Must Read Before You Grow Up.
- Rating: 5 out of 5 stars5/5I expected to learn about a forgotten time, a time when people worked the land, and girls wore dresses, and life was simple. But I seemed to be consumed with reflecting on the relationships in the story, and how even today, we suffer unnecessarily because of a lack of communication. Pride is a terrible thing, so is keeping secrets.So many life lessons are learned while reading this story. All the characters have something to teach us. Gene Stratton-Porter was a great author.Enjoyed learning about moths as well. Mrs. Comstock was my favorite character.
- Rating: 5 out of 5 stars5/5This book was first published in 1909; the story is fiction, but the setting is real. The Limberlost Swamp, parts of which were also known as the Loblolly Marsh, originally covered 13,000 acres in eastern Indiana. The wetlands had mixed vegetation and supported a rich biodiversity, significant for local and migrating birds and insects, as well as other animals and life.As the story opens, Elnora is 16 and living with her mother in a cabin in the Limberlost. Her father died when she was born, and her mother, Katharine, blames Elnora for that. She is very harsh with her daughter, and when Elnora wants to start high school, she refuses to help her. Elnora is ostracized on her first day of school, for her outdated and dowdy clothing, and is embarrassed when she finds out that instead of the school providing the books for the students, she must pay for them herself. Elnora returns home that day with a broken heart, but determined to get an education. When her mother refuses to provide the money, Elnora collects moths native to the Limberlost area to sell to collectors. With perseverance and determination, Elnora works at securing a future for herself, and finds a way to mend her relationship with her mother.I really enjoyed this story, so much so that I stayed up way too late on a couple of evenings reading because it was just too hard to put down. Elnora is a very kind person, but with just enough feisty-ness and a touch of temper to keep her from being too syrupy sweet, (like Pollyanna.) She reminds me a lot of the fictional character Anne Shirley, from Anne of Green Gables, and I think readers of that series would enjoy this book too.I enjoyed reading the descriptions of moths, and they make the reader see why Elnora appreciated them so much. I had no idea before reading this book of the wide variety of moths and how beautiful some of them are. I have a new appreciation of them now, though I still don't want them in my house, lol! The author was an amateur naturalist and wildlife photographer, and her knowledge and love for nature really shows through her writing. In fact, she used the proceeds from her book for conservation of the Limberlost swamp and other wetlands in Indiana.I also liked that a small part of the story was set in Mackinac Island, Michigan. As a girl born and bred and still living in Michigan, I always think it's cool when it's used as a setting in a story.
- Rating: 3 out of 5 stars3/5When I visited my grandmother I would climb into the old walnut tree and sit with a book or two and a pocket full of apples, in case I got hungry and didn't want to climb down and smash walnuts with a rock and eat them. This was one of her books, and she gave it to me when I was a bit older, to keep. I loved it dearly and uncritically; I loved the heroine, the drama with her hard and bitter mother, the story of the woods and swampland.
Recently I reread it, in my own woodlands, as an environmentalist, and I thought "oh, by golly, her mom was right not to sell the land to be logged off and destroyed". And I took less kindly to the plundering of the swamps for moths to sell to collectors. (though I still loved the dress Eleanor designs)
And such is the perspective of time. - Rating: 5 out of 5 stars5/5This book was my mother's favorite. A tale of a girl who collects moths in a wonderful large woods, sells the moths, to get money for school. I will read it with my daughter this year, and I look forward to seeing how well my memories hold up.
- Rating: 5 out of 5 stars5/5a great read for fans of Anne of Green Gables-a destitute young girl discovers a way to pay her own way through high school and falls in love.
- Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5A coming of age book, exploring both the beauty hidden in a northern Indiana swamp, and the beauty submerged in the heart of a girl whose life is filled with bitterness and hardship.
- Rating: 5 out of 5 stars5/5This was one of my grandmothers favorite books. I love the way that Statton-Porter describes the wetlands, and her ability to write a realistic character that does not come off as a goody two shoes is incredible.
- Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5A great coming of age story, mixed with strong characters! This book will transport you to another time, and you won't want to leave! Definitely worth reading!!
- Rating: 3 out of 5 stars3/5An elderly friend gave this book to me when I was in my early teens. It's a classic story of a girl who doesn't quite fit in--and if you were that kind of girl, as was I, it's well worth the read.
- Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Gene Stratton Porter was my mother's favorite author as a girl, and whe wanted me to read her books when I was young, too. I hated them, and never even finished one. When I found this free on the Kindle, I thought I would give it another try, and this time I like it! The writing is dated, but the concerns of the author are still relevant: destruction of the wetlands, preservation of species, getting alond with your mother :)I'm glad I finally read it, and may try another of her books.
- Rating: 5 out of 5 stars5/5Wow. That's really rich. It started out an interesting story - rather Horatio Alger, with the way she suffered for lack of money and found a way to earn it. But richer than Alger, with strong emotions driving realistic characters with reasonable motivations. Then it expanded into a romance - just as rich, just as complicated emotions, just as real characters. I was seriously crying by the end. In Freckles I felt that the solutions were more than a little contrived - long-lost heir and all - in this one everything truly flowed. Magnificent. And - what was it I read at the B&B last year? Wasn't this, wasn't Freckles because after reading it I wanted Freckles...There must be another Limberlost story - yay! Something to look forward to.
- Rating: 5 out of 5 stars5/5It was great fun to finally read this book I had heard about through my childhood and growing up---from my mother---but somehow I never read it. It has a fairy-tale like quality to it but so many things have changed since 1909, when this was first published. Elnora was written as a girl/woman ahead of her times in terms of interests and ambition and even the ending presents her as a person who will equal her husband at the same time she performs the wifely duties required of the time. Too bad there isn't a sequel, written after children arrive---will she be just like Freddie and Angel? Fascinating to see how many mothers and grandmothers of reviewers introduced this book to their offspring.
- Rating: 5 out of 5 stars5/5How did I miss this book when I was younger? It’s like a slighter darker version of Anne of Green Gables, and I loved every second of it. Published in 1909, the story is about a young girl named Elnora who lives in the country. She is going to high school for the first time, but her lack of social skills and money makes the way difficult. Her whole life has been spent on her farm with her cold, unloving mother. Her father died in the Limberlost swamp the day she was born and her mother has resented her ever since. Elnora is such a unique character. She is stubborn and driven to succeed. She's fiercely intelligent but incredibly compassionate. She is patient, giving her mother the benefit of the doubt for years. She's a hard worker, willing to make money to achieve her dreams. She has self-respect and is willing to sacrifice in order to find true happiness. She reminded me a little bit of Jane Austen’s Lizzy Bennet, particularly in a scene where one woman comes to talk to her about her possible engagement. There is so much I loved about this book. There's a fantastic female lead who isn't just trying to win a man. The plot focuses on relationships with her family and friends and pursuing her dreams. She stands up for herself even when she doesn't fit in. She's a problem solver and isn't overwhelmed when a slight obstacle gets in her path. **SPOILERS**Kate Comstock, Elnora's mother, is a fascinating character. She’s so oblivious to the pain she causes her daughter because she’s trapped in a prison of grief. She has one of the most drastic changes in attitude and overall character development that I've ever read. The way it's done it's completely believable, but it's still a 180 and it was so satisfying to see her relationship with Elnora change throughout the book.I love how the romantic aspect of the story played out too. Elnora protects her own feelings and isn’t swayed the moment Philip gave her a second glance. She waited until she was sure he didn't want anyone else and she was not just a consolation prize. That’s so unusual to find in a novel, especially one written more than 100 years ago. She wanted someone who loved her deeply, not someone who settled for her in a moment of passion.**SPOILERS OVER**BOTTOM LINE: I fell hard for this novel. Elnora is so determined and intelligent, she’s definitely become one of my new favorites. The book is chocked full of wonderful characters, including her Uncle Wesley, the young ruffian Billy and even her selfish, detached mother becomes a character you care about.
- Rating: 5 out of 5 stars5/5It's a little cheesy in places, but overall this book is great for it's love of the outdoors and the complicated emotions experienced by the adults.
- Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5My grandmother's favorite book. When I told her I had begun collecting, she asked me if I knew of it. I am so grateful that she introduced me to this author and to this era of our history. The science angle gave added intelligence to a tale full of depth and insight.
Book preview
A Girl of the Limberlost - Gene Stratton-Porter
Chapter I
Wherein elnora goes to high school and learns many lessons not found in her books
Elnora Comstock, have you lost your senses?
demanded the angry voice of Katharine Comstock while she glared at her daughter.
Why mother!
faltered the girl.
Don’t you ‘why mother’ me!
cried Mrs. Comstock. You know very well what I mean. You’ve given me no peace until you’ve had your way about this going to school business; I’ve fixed you good enough, and you’re ready to start. But no child of mine walks the streets of Onabasha looking like a play-actress woman. You wet your hair and comb it down modest and decent and then be off, or you’ll have no time to find where you belong.
Elnora gave one despairing glance at the white face, framed in a most becoming riot of reddish-brown hair, which she saw in the little kitchen mirror. Then she untied the narrow black ribbon, wet the comb and plastered the waving curls close to her head, bound them fast, pinned on the skimpy black hat and opened the back door.
You’ve gone so plumb daffy you are forgetting your dinner,
jeered her mother.
I don’t want anything to eat,
replied Elnora.
You’ll take your dinner or you’ll not go one step. Are you crazy? Walk almost three miles and no food from six in the morning until six at night. A pretty figure you’d cut if you had your way! And after I’ve gone and bought you this nice new pail and filled it especial to start on!
Elnora came back with a face still whiter and picked up the lunch. Thank you, mother! Good-bye!
she said. Mrs. Comstock did not reply. She watched the girl follow the long walk to the gate and go from sight on the road, in the bright sunshine of the first Monday of September.
I bet a dollar she gets enough of it by night!
commented Mrs. Comstock.
Elnora walked by instinct, for her eyes were blinded with tears. She left the road where it turned south, at the corner of the Limberlost, climbed a snake fence and entered a path worn by her own feet. Dodging under willow and scrub oak branches she came at last to the faint outline of an old trail made in the days when the precious timber of the swamp was guarded by armed men. This path she followed until she reached a thick clump of bushes. From the debris in the end of a hollow log she took a key that unlocked the padlock of a large weatherbeaten old box, inside of which lay several books, a butterfly apparatus, and a small cracked mirror. The walls were lined thickly with gaudy butterflies, dragonflies, and moths. She set up the mirror and once more pulling the ribbon from her hair, she shook the bright mass over her shoulders, tossing it dry in the sunshine. Then she straightened it, bound it loosely, and replaced her hat. She tugged vainly at the low brown calico collar and gazed despairingly at the generous length of the narrow skirt. She lifted it as she would have cut it if possible. That disclosed the heavy high leather shoes, at sight of which she seemed positively ill, and hastily dropped the skirt. She opened the pail, removed the lunch, wrapped it in the napkin, and placed it in a small pasteboard box. Locking the case again she hid the key and hurried down the trail.
She followed it around the north end of the swamp and then entered a footpath crossing a farm leading in the direction of the spires of the city to the northeast. Again she climbed a fence and was on the open road. For an instant she leaned against the fence staring before her, then turned and looked back. Behind her lay the land on which she had been born to drudgery and a mother who made no pretence of loving her; before her lay the city through whose schools she hoped to find means of escape and the way to reach the things for which she cared. When she thought of how she appeared she leaned more heavily against the fence and groaned; when she thought of turning back and wearing such clothing in ignorance all the days of her life she set her teeth firmly and went hastily toward Onabasha.
On the bridge crossing a deep culvert at the suburbs she glanced around, and then kneeling she thrust the lunch box between the foundation and the flooring. This left her empty-handed as she approached the big stone high school building. She entered bravely and inquired her way to the office of the superintendent. There she learned that she should have come the previous week and arranged about her classes. There were many things incident to the opening of school, and one man unable to cope with all of them.
Where have you been attending school?
he asked, while he advised the teacher of Domestic Science not to telephone for groceries until she knew how many she would have in her classes; wrote an order for chemicals for the students of science; and advised the leader of the orchestra to hire a professional to take the place of the bass violist, reported suddenly ill.
I finished last spring at Brushwood school, district number nine,
said Elnora. I have been studying all summer. I am quite sure I can do the first year work, if I have a few days to get started.
Of course, of course,
assented the superintendent. Almost invariably country pupils do good work. You may enter first year, and if it is too difficult, we will find it out speedily. Your teachers will tell you the list of books you must have, and if you will come with me I will show you the way to the auditorium. It is now time for opening exercises. Take any seat you find vacant.
Elnora stood before the entrance and stared into the largest room she ever had seen. The floor sloped to a yawning stage on which a band of musicians, grouped around a grand piano, were tuning their instruments. She had two fleeting impressions. That it was all a mistake; this was no school, but a grand display of enormous ribbon bows; and the second, that she was sinking, and had forgotten how to walk. Then a burst from the orchestra nerved her while a bevy of daintily clad, sweet-smelling things that might have been birds, or flowers, or possibly gaily dressed, happy young girls, pushed her forward. She found herself plodding across the back of the auditorium, praying for guidance, to an empty seat.
As the girls passed her, vacancies seemed to open to meet them. Their friends were moving over, beckoning and whispering invitations. Every one else was seated, but no one paid any attention to the white-faced girl stumbling half-blindly down the aisle next the farthest wall. So she went on to the very end facing the stage. No one moved, and she could not summon courage to crowd past others to several empty seats she saw. At the end of the aisle she paused in desperation, while she stared back at the whole forest of faces most of which were now turned upon her.
In a flash came the full realization of her scanty dress, her pitiful little hat and ribbon, her big, heavy shoes, her ignorance of where to go or what to do; and from a sickening wave which crept over her, she felt she was going to become very ill. Then out of the mass she saw a pair of big, brown boy eyes, three seats from her, and there was a message in them. Without moving his body he reached forward and with a pencil touched the back of the seat before him. Instantly Elnora took another step which brought her to a row of vacant front seats.
She heard laughter behind her; the knowledge that she wore the only hat in the room burned her; every matter of moment, and some of none at all, cut and stung. She had no books. Where should she go when this was over? What would she give to be on the trail going home! She was shaking with a nervous chill when the music ceased, and the superintendent arose, and coming down to the front of the flower-decked platform, opened a Bible and began to read. Elnora did not know what he was reading, and she felt that she did not care. Wildly she was racking her brain to decide whether she should sit still when the others left the room or follow, and ask some one where the Freshmen went first.
In the midst of the struggle one sentence fell on her ear. Hide me under the shadow of Thy wings.
Elnora began to pray frantically. Hide me, O God, hide me, under the shadow of Thy wings.
Again and again she implored that prayer, and before she realized what was coming, every one had arisen and the room was emptying rapidly. Elnora hurried after the nearest girl and in the press at the door touched her sleeve timidly.
Will you please tell me where the Freshmen go?
she asked huskily.
The girl gave her one surprised glance, and drew away.
Same place as the fresh women,
she answered, and those nearest her laughed.
Elnora stopped praying suddenly and the colour crept into her face. I’ll wager you are the first person I meet when I find it,
she said and stopped short. Not that! Oh, I must not do that!
she thought in dismay. Make an enemy the first thing I do. Oh, not that!
She followed with her eyes as the young people separated in the hall, some climbing stairs, some disappearing down side halls, some entering adjoining doors. She saw the girl overtake the brown-eyed boy and speak to him. He glanced back at Elnora with a scowl on his face. Then she stood alone in the hall.
Presently a door opened and a young woman came out and entered another room. Elnora waited until she returned, and hurried to her. Would you tell me where the Freshmen are?
she panted.
Straight down the hall, three doors to your left,
was the answer, as the girl passed.
One minute please, oh please,
begged Elnora: Should I knock or just open the door?
Go in and take a seat,
replied the teacher.
What if there aren’t any seats?
gasped Elnora.
Classrooms are never half-filled, there will be plenty,
was the answer.
Elnora removed her hat. There was no place to put it, so she carried it in her hand. She looked infinitely better without it. After several efforts she at last opened the door and stepping inside faced a smaller and more concentrated battery of eyes.
The superintendent sent me. He thinks I belong here,
she said to the professor in charge of the class, but she never before heard the voice with which she spoke. As she stood waiting, the girl of the hall passed on her way to the blackboard, and suppressed laughter told Elnora that her thrust had been repeated.
Be seated,
said the professor, and then because he saw Elnora was desperately embarrassed he proceeded to lend her a book and to ask her if she had studied algebra. She said she had a little, but not the same book they were using. He asked her if she felt that she could do the work they were beginning, and she said she did.
That was how it happened, that three minutes after entering the room she was told to take her place beside the girl who had gone last to the board, and whose flushed face and angry eyes avoided meeting Elnora’s. Being compelled to concentrate on her proposition she forgot herself. When the professor asked that all pupils sign their work she firmly wrote Elnora Comstock
under her demonstration. Then she took her seat and waited with white lips and trembling limbs, as one after another professor called the names on the board, while their owners arose and explained their propositions, or flunked
if they had not found a correct solution. She was so eager to catch their forms of expression and prepare herself for her recitation, that she never looked from the work on the board, until clearly and distinctly, Elnora Comstock,
called the professor.
The dazed girl stared at the board. One tiny curl added to the top of the first curve of the m in her name, had transformed it from a good old English patronymic that any girl might bear proudly, to Cornstock. Elnora sat speechless. When and how did it happen? She could feel the wave of smothered laughter in the air around her. A rush of anger turned her face scarlet and her soul sick. The voice of the professor addressed her directly.
This proposition seems to be beautifully demonstrated, Miss Cornstalk,
he said. Surely, you can tell us how you did it.
That word of praise saved her. She could do good work. They might wear their pretty clothes, have their friends and make life a greater misery than it ever before had been for her, but not one of them should do better work or be more womanly. That lay with her. She was tall, straight, and handsome as she arose.
Of course I can explain my work,
she said in natural tones. What I can’t explain is how I happened to be so stupid as to make a mistake in writing my own name. I must have been a little nervous. Please excuse me.
She went to the board, swept off the signature with one stroke, then rewrote it plainly. My name is Comstock,
she said distinctly. She returned to her seat and following the formula used by the others made her first high school recitation.
As Elnora resumed her seat Professor Henley looked at her steadily. It puzzles me,
he said deliberately, how you can write as beautiful a demonstration, and explain it as clearly as ever has been done in any of my classes and still be so disturbed as to make a mistake in your own name. Are you very sure you did that yourself, Miss Comstock?
It is impossible that any one else should have done it,
answered Elnora.
I am very glad you think so,
said the professor. Being Freshmen, all of you are strangers to me. I should dislike to begin the year with you feeling there was one among you small enough to do a trick like that. The next proposition, please.
When the hour had gone the class filed back to the study room and Elnora followed in desperation, because she did not know where else to go. She could not study as she had no books, and when the class again left the room to go to another professor for the next recitation, she went also. At least they could put her out if she did not belong there. Noon came at last, and she kept with the others until they dispersed on the sidewalk. She was so abnormally self-conscious she fancied all the hundreds of that laughing, throng saw and jested at her. When she passed the brown-eyed boy walking with the girl of her encounter, she knew, for she heard him say: Did you really let that gawky piece of calico get ahead of you?
The answer was indistinct.
Elnora hurried from the city. She intended to get her lunch, eat it in the shade of the first tree, and then decide whether she would go back or go home. She knelt on the bridge and reached for her box, but it was so very light that she was prepared for the fact that it was empty, before opening it. There was one thing for which to be thankful. The boy or tramp who had seen her hide it, had left the napkin. She would not have to face her mother and account for its loss. She put it in her pocket, and threw the box into the ditch. Then she sat on the bridge and tried to think, but her brain was confused.
Perhaps the worst is over,
she said at last. I will go back. What would mother say to me if I came home now?
So she returned to the high school, followed some other pupils to the coat room, hung her hat, and found her way to the study where she had been in the morning. Twice that afternoon, with aching head and empty stomach, she faced strange professors, in different branches. Once she escaped notice; the second time the worst happened. She was asked a question she could not answer.
Have you not decided on your course, and secured your books?
inquired the professor.
I have decided on my course,
replied Elnora, I do not know where to ask for my books.
Ask?
the professor was bewildered.
I understood the books were furnished,
faltered Elnora.
Only to those bringing an order from the township trustee,
replied the Professor.
No! Oh no!
cried Elnora. I will have them to-morrow,
and gripped her desk for support for she knew that was not true. Four books, ranging perhaps at a dollar and a half apiece; would her mother buy them? Of course she would not–could not.
Did not Elnora know the story of old. There was enough land, but no one to do clearing and farm. Tax on all those acres, recently the new gravel road tax added, the expense of living and only the work of two women to meet all of it. She was insane to think she could come to the city to school. Her mother had been right. The girl decided that if only she lived to reach home, she would stay there and lead any sort of life to avoid more of this torture. Bad as what she wished to escape had been, it was nothing like this. She never could live down the movement that went through the class when she inadvertently revealed the fact that she had expected books to be furnished. Her mother would not secure them; that settled the question.
But the end of misery is never in a hurry to come; before the day was over the superintendent entered the room and explained that pupils from the country were charged a tuition of twenty dollars a year. That really was the end. Previously Elnora had canvassed a dozen methods for securing the money for books, ranging all the way from offering to wash the superintendent’s dishes to breaking into the bank. This additional expense made her plans so wildly impossible, there was nothing to do but hold up her head until she was from sight.
Down the long corridor alone among hundreds, down the long street alone among thousands, out into the country she came at last. Across the fence and field, along the old trail once trodden by a boy’s bitter agony, now stumbled a white-faced girl, sick at heart. She sat on a log and began to sob in spite of her efforts at self-control. At first it was physical breakdown, later, thought came crowding.
Oh the shame, the mortification! Why had she not known of the tuition? How did she happen to think that in the city books were furnished? Perhaps it was because she had read they were in several states. But why did she not know? Why did not her mother go with her? Other mothers–but when had her mother ever been or done anything at all like other mothers? Because she never had been it was useless to blame her now. Elnora realized she should have gone to town the week before, called on some one and learned all these things herself. She should have remembered how her clothing would look, before she wore it in public places. Now she knew, and her dreams were over. She must go home to feed chickens, calves, and pigs, wear calico and coarse shoes, and with averted head, pass a library all her life. She sobbed again.
For pity’s sake, honey, what’s the matter?
asked the voice of the nearest neighbour, Wesley Sinton, as he seated himself beside Elnora. There, there,
he continued, smearing tears all over her face in an effort to dry them. Was it as bad as that, now? Maggie has been just wild over you all day. She’s got nervouser every minute. She said we were foolish to let you go. She said your clothes were not right, you ought not to carry that tin pail, and that they would laugh at you. By gum, I see they did!
Oh, Uncle Wesley,
sobbed the girl, why didn’t she tell me?
Well, you see, Elnora, she didn’t like to. You got such a way of holding up your head, and going through with things. She thought some way that you’d make it, till you got started, and then she begun to see a hundred things we should have done. I reckon you hadn’t reached that building before she remembered that your skirt should have been pleated instead of gathered, your shoes been low, and lighter for hot September weather, and a new hat. Were your clothes right, Elnora?
The girl broke into hysterical laughter. Right!
she cried. "Right! Uncle Wesley, you should have seen me among them! I was a picture! They’ll never forget me. No, they won’t get the chance, for they’ll see me again to-morrow!
Now that is what I call spunk, Elnora! Downright grit,
said Wesley Sinton. Don’t you let them laugh you out. You’ve helped Margaret and me for years at harvest and busy times, what you’ve earned must amount to quite a sum. You can get yourself a good many clothes with it.
Don’t mention clothes, Uncle Wesley,
sobbed Elnora, I don’t care now how I look. If I don’t go back all of them will know it’s because I am so poor I can’t buy my books.
Oh, I don’t know as you are so dratted poor,
said Sinton meditatively. There are three hundred acres of good land, with fine timber as ever grew on it.
It takes all we can earn to pay the tax, and mother wouldn’t cut a tree for her life.
Well then, maybe, I’ll be compelled to cut one for her,
suggested Sinton. Anyway, stop tearing yourself to pieces and tell me. If it isn’t clothes, what is it?
It’s books and tuition. Over twenty dollars in all.
Humph! First time I ever knew you to be stumped by twenty dollars, Elnora,
said Sinton, patting her hand.
It’s the first time you ever knew me to want money,
answered Elnora. This is different from anything that ever happened to me. Oh, how can I get it, Uncle Wesley?
Drive to town with me in the morning and I’ll draw it from the bank for you. I owe you every cent of it.
You know you don’t owe me a penny, and I wouldn’t touch one from you, unless I really could earn it. For anything that’s past I owe you and Aunt Margaret for all the home life and love I’ve ever known. I know how you work, and I’ll not take your money.
Just a loan, Elnora, just a loan for a little while until you can earn it. You can be proud with all the rest of the world, but there are no secrets between us, are there, Elnora?
No,
said Elnora, there are none. You and Aunt Margaret have given me all the love there has been in my life. That is the one reason above all others why you shall not give me charity. Hand me money because you find me crying for it! This isn’t the first time this old trail has known tears and heartache. All of us know that story. Freckles stuck to what he undertook and won out. I stick, too. When Duncan moved away he gave me all Freckles left in the swamp, and as I have inherited his property maybe his luck will come with it. I won’t touch your money, but I’ll win some way. First, I’m going home and try mother. It’s just possible I could find second-hand books, and perhaps all the tuition need not be paid at once. Maybe they would accept it quarterly. But oh, Uncle Wesley, you and Aunt Margaret keep on loving me! I’m so lonely, and no one else cares!
Wesley Sinton’s jaws met with a click. He swallowed hard on bitter words and changed what he would have liked to say three times before it became articulate.
Elnora,
he said at last, if it hadn’t been for one thing I’d have tried to take legal steps to make you ours when you were three years old. Maggie said then it wasn’t any use, but I’ve always held on. You see, I was the first man there, honey, and there are things you see, that you can’t ever make anybody else understand. She loved him Elnora, she just made an idol of him. There was that oozy green hole, with the thick scum broke, and two or three big bubbles slowly rising that were the breath of his body. There she was in spasms of agony, and beside her the great heavy log she’d tried to throw him. I can’t ever forgive her for turning against you, and spoiling your childhood as she has, but I couldn’t forgive anybody else for abusing her. Maggie has got no mercy on her, but Maggie didn’t see what I did, and I’ve never tried to make it very clear to her. It’s been a little too plain for me ever since. Whenever I look at your mother’s face, I see what she saw, so I hold my tongue and say, in my heart, ‘Give her a mite more time.’ Some day it will come. She does love you, Elnora. Everybody does, honey. It’s just that she’s feeling so much, she can’t express herself. You be a patient girl and wait a little longer. After all, she’s your mother, and you’re all she’s got, but a memory, and it might do her good to let her know that she was fooled in that.
It would kill her!
cried the girl swiftly. Uncle Wesley, it would kill her! What do you mean?
Nothing,
said Wesley Sinton soothingly. Nothing, honey. That was just one of them fool things a man says, when he is trying his best to be wise. You see, she loved him mightily, and they’d been married only a year, and what she was loving was what she thought he was. She hadn’t really got acquainted with the man yet. If it had been even one more year, she could have borne it, and you’d have got justice. Having been a teacher she was better educated and smarter than the rest of us, and so she was more sensitive like. She can’t understand she was loving a dream. So I say it might do her good if somebody that knew, could tell her, but I swear to gracious, I never could. I’ve heard her out at the edge of that quagmire calling in them wild spells of hers off and on for the last sixteen years, and imploring the swamp to give him back to her, and I’ve got out of bed when I was pretty tired, and come down to see she didn’t go in herself, or harm you. What she feels is too deep for me. I’ve got to respectin’ her grief, and I can’t get over it. Go home and tell your ma, honey, and ask her nice and kind to help you. If she won’t, then you got to swallow that little lump of pride in your neck, and come to Aunt Maggie, like you been a-coming all your life.
I’ll ask mother, but I can’t take your money, Uncle Wesley, indeed I can’t. I’ll wait a year, and earn some, and enter next year.
There’s one thing you don’t consider, Elnora,
said the man earnestly. And that’s what you are to Maggie. She’s a little like your ma. She hasn’t given up to it, and she’s struggling on brave, but when we buried our second little girl the light went out of Maggie’s eyes, and it’s not come back. The only time I ever see a hint of it is when she thinks she’s done something that makes you happy, Elnora. Now, you go easy about refusing her anything she wants to do for you. There’s times in this world when it’s our bounden duty to forget ourselves, and think what will help other people. Young woman, you owe me and Maggie all the comfort we can get out of you. There’s the two of our own we can’t ever do anything for. Don’t you get the idea into your head that a fool thing you call pride is going to cut us out of all the pleasure we have in life beside ourselves.
Uncle Wesley, you are a dear,
said Elnora. "Just a dear! If I can’t possibly get that money any way else on earth, I’ll come and borrow it of you, and then I’ll pay it back if I must dig ferns from the swamp and sell them from door to door in the city. I’ll even plant them, so that they will be sure to come up in the spring. I have been sort of panic stricken all day and couldn’t think. I can gather nuts and sell them. Freckles sold moths and butterflies, and I’ve a lot collected. Of course, I am going back to-morrow! I can find a way to get the books. Don’t you worry about me. I am all right!
Now, what do you think of that?
inquired Wesley Sinton of the swamp in general. Here’s our Elnora come back to stay. Head high and right as a trivet! You’ve named three ways in three minutes that you could earn ten dollars, which I figure would be enough, to start you. Let’s go to supper and stop worrying!
Elnora unlocked the case, took out the pail, put the napkin in it, pulled the ribbon from her hair, binding it down tightly again and followed to the road. From afar she could see her mother in the doorway. She blinked her eyes, and tried to smile as she answered Wesley Sinton, and indeed she did feel better. She knew now what she had to expect, where to go, and what to do. Get the books she must; when she had them, she would show those city girls and boys how to prepare and recite lessons, how to walk with a brave heart; and they could show her how to wear pretty clothes and have good times.
As she neared the door her mother reached for the pail. I forgot to tell you to bring home your scraps for the chickens,
she said.
Elnora entered. There weren’t any scraps, and I’m hungry again as I ever was in my life.
I thought likely you would be,
said Mrs. Comstock, and so I got supper ready. We can eat first, and do the work afterward. What kept you so? I expected you an hour ago.
Elnora looked into her mother’s face and smiled. It was a queer sort of a little smile, and would have reached the depths with any normal mother.
I see you’ve been bawling,
said Mrs. Comstock. I thought you’d get your fill in a hurry. That’s why I wouldn’t go to any expense. If we keep out of the poor-house we have to cut the corners close. It’s likely this Brushwood road tax will eat up all we’ve saved in years. Where the land tax is to come from I don’t know. It gets bigger every year. If they are going to dredge the swamp ditch again they’ll just have to take the land to pay for it. I can’t, that’s all! We’ll get up early in the morning and gather and hull the beans for winter, and put in the rest of the day hoeing the turnips.
Elnora again smiled that pitiful smile.
Do you think I didn’t know that I was funny and would be laughed at?
she asked.
Funny?
cried Mrs. Comstock hotly.
Yes, funny! A regular caricature,
answered Elnora. No one else wore calico, not even one other. No one else wore high heavy shoes, not even one. No one else had such a funny little old hat; my hair was not right, my ribbon invisible compared with the others, I did not know where to go, or what to do, and I had no books. What a spectacle I made for them!
Elnora laughed nervously at her own picture. But there are always two sides! The professor said in the algebra class that he never had a better solution and explanation than mine of the proposition he gave me, which scored one for me in spite of my clothes.
Well, I wouldn’t brag on myself!
That was poor taste,
admitted Elnora. But, you see, it is a case of whistling to keep up my courage. I honestly could see that I would have looked just as well as the rest of them if I had been dressed as they were. We can’t afford that, so I have to find something else to brace me. It was rather bad, mother!
Well, I’m glad you got enough of it!
Oh, but I haven’t,
hurried in Elnora. I just got a start. The hardest is over. To-morrow they won’t be surprised. They will know what to expect. I am sorry to hear about the dredge. Is it really going through?
Yes. I got my notification today. The tax will be something enormous. I don’t know as I can spare you, even if you are willing to be a laughing-stock for the town.
With every bite Elnora’s courage returned, for she was a healthy young thing.
You’ve heard about doing evil that good might come from it,
she said. Well, mother mine, it’s something like that with me. I’m willing to bear the hard part to pay for what I’ll learn. Already I have selected the ward building in which I shall teach in about four years. I am going to ask for a room with a south exposure so that the flowers and moths I take in from the swamp to show the children will do well.
You little idiot!
said Mrs. Comstock. How are you going to pay your expenses?
Now that is just what I was going to ask you!
said Elnora. You see, I have had two startling pieces of news to-day. I did not know I would need any money. I thought the city furnished the books, and there is an out-of-town tuition, also. I need ten dollars in the morning. Will you please let me have it?
Ten dollars!
cried Mrs. Comstock. Ten dollars! Why don’t you say a hundred and be done with it! I could get one as easy as the other. I told you! I told you I couldn’t raise a cent. Every year expenses grow bigger and bigger. I told you not to ask for money!
I never meant to,
replied Elnora. I thought clothes were all I needed and I could bear them. I never knew about buying books and tuition.
Well, I did!
said Mrs. Comstock. I knew what you would run into! But you are so bull-dog stubborn, and so set in your way, I thought I would just let you try the world a little and see how you liked it!
Elnora pushed