Subway to California
()
About this ebook
Joe didn’t seem called to a life of crime, but evidence is mixed. Once he was Brother Joseph in a Catholic novitiate, but later he was named prime suspect in a racketeering investigation. During Vietnam he seized his college administration building, and then played blackjack around the world, staked by big-money backers. He managed Italian restaurants with laughable ineptitude, but also did graduate study and taught for twenty years. Eventually Joe buries his unstable, manipulative, and beautiful mother and his brothers, including his heroin-addicted younger brother. Later, he cares for his father with Alzheimer’s. By turns heartbreaking and hilarious, Subway to California recounts Joe’s battles with personal demons, bargains struck with angels, and truces with family in this richly colorful tale that reads like great fiction.
Joseph Di Prisco
Joseph Di Prisco is the acclaimed author of prize-winning poetry (Wit’s End, Poems in Which, and Sightlines from the Cheap Seats), bestselling memoirs (Subway to California and The Pope of Brooklyn), nonfiction, and novels (Confessions of Brother Eli, Sun City, All for Now, The Alzhammer, Sibella & Sibella, and The Good Family Fitzgerald). He taught for many years and has served as chair of not-for-profits dedicated to the arts, theater, children’s mental health, and schools. In 2015, he founded New Literary Project, a not-for-profit driving social change and unleashing artistic power, investing in writers across generations from neglected, overlooked communities. He also directs NewLit’s annual Joyce Carol Oates Prize, awarded to mid-career authors of fiction, and is Series Editor of the annual anthology Simpsonistas: Tales from New Literary Project. Born in Brooklyn, he grew up in Greenpoint and then in Berkeley. He and his family now live in Lafayette, California.
Read more from Joseph Di Prisco
All For Now: A Novel Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsThe Pope of Brooklyn Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Sightlines from the Cheap Seats: Poems Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsSibella & Sibella: A Novel Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsMy Last Resume: New & Collected Poems (1971–1980 | 1999–2023) Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratings
Related to Subway to California
Related ebooks
Summer of Deliverance: A Memoir of Father and Son Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The End of All Our Exploring: Stories Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsThe Storyteller Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Corpus Christi Writers 2023: Corpus Christi Writers Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsBeheld Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Cat's Pajamas: Stories Rating: 3 out of 5 stars3/5Going On Nine: A Novel Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsThis Tender Land: A Novel Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/51001 First Lines Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Greetings from Below Rating: 3 out of 5 stars3/5Without a Net: Stories of Our Risky Flights Towards Love, Loss, and Home Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsAfter You've Gone Rating: 3 out of 5 stars3/5The Strangeness of Men Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsThe Tenth Circle: A Novel Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Summer My Sister Was Cleopatra Moon Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsCity of Night Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Anything Is Good Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsGirl Talk Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Like Every Form of Love: a memoir of friendship and true crime Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsGreat Short Stories by Contemporary Native American Writers Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Boundless: An Anthology of Prose Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsMiss Dreamsville and the Lost Heiress of Collier County: A Novel Rating: 3 out of 5 stars3/5Going All the Way: A Novel Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Night Swim Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5South Toward Home: Adventures and Misadventures in My Native Land Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5History of a Suicide: My Sister's Unfinished Life Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Wreckage of Eden Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Evolution of Love Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsVacation Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Sabbath Night in the Church of the Piranha Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratings
Personal Memoirs For You
I'm Glad My Mom Died Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Bad Mormon: A Memoir Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Becoming Free Indeed: My Story of Disentangling Faith from Fear Rating: 5 out of 5 stars5/5A Child Called It: One Child's Courage to Survive Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5A Stolen Life: A Memoir Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Glass Castle: A Memoir Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Zen and the Art of Motorcycle Maintenance: An Inquiry Into Values Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Maybe You Should Talk to Someone: A Therapist, HER Therapist, and Our Lives Revealed Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Just Mercy: a story of justice and redemption Rating: 5 out of 5 stars5/5Lost Connections: Uncovering the Real Causes of Depression – and the Unexpected Solutions Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5I'll Be Gone in the Dark: One Woman's Obsessive Search for the Golden State Killer Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Maybe You Should Talk to Someone: the heartfelt, funny memoir by a New York Times bestselling therapist Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Dry: A Memoir Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Stash: My Life in Hiding Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5A Man of Two Faces: A Memoir, A History, A Memorial Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5You Could Make This Place Beautiful: A Memoir Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5How to Stay Married: The Most Insane Love Story Ever Told Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Everything I Know About Love: A Memoir Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5How to Be Alone: If You Want To, and Even If You Don't Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Solutions and Other Problems Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Becoming Sister Wives: The Story of an Unconventional Marriage Rating: 3 out of 5 stars3/5Too Much and Never Enough: How My Family Created the World's Most Dangerous Man Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Down the Rabbit Hole: Curious Adventures and Cautionary Tales of a Former Playboy Bunny Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5I Hope They Serve Beer In Hell Rating: 3 out of 5 stars3/5Son of Hamas: A Gripping Account of Terror, Betrayal, Political Intrigue, and Unthinkable Choices Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Pity the Reader: On Writing with Style Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Why Fish Don't Exist: A Story of Loss, Love, and the Hidden Order of Life Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Choice: Embrace the Possible Rating: 5 out of 5 stars5/5
Related categories
Reviews for Subway to California
0 ratings0 reviews
Book preview
Subway to California - Joseph Di Prisco
Praise for Joseph Di Prisco
The author can break your heart recalling the most romantic memory of his life or make you laugh out loud.
—Kirkus Reviews
"Di Prisco delivers thoughtful contemplation of the human condition and plenty of self-examination that reveals how he made it to where he is, and why he survived when others didn’t. His sharp wit and hard-won wisdom make Subway to California a story that anyone who’s risen out of a hard-scrabble life with the odds stacked against them will love and learn from."
—Diane Prokop, Foreword
Di Prisco’s latest is part Mafia thriller, part comic farce, part lament about the anguish of dementia—and all hyperkinetic…fast-paced and often charming.
—Kirkus Reviews
Though Di Prisco takes a heartbreaking look at the scars left by pedophilia, and some readers will surely feel anger at the sins, the tale unfolds, bravely [and] with much humor, thanks to Brother Stephen’s bemused narration.
—Publishers Weekly
The novel’s surreal tone, Brother Stephen’s drily acidic worldview, and the enigmatic portait of a pedophile all combine to deepen this thoughtful look at the heartbreak left in the wake of child sexual abuse.
—Booklist
"Along with Joe Di Prisco, I rode that same sweaty Subway to California. But somehow, his was a local, with every stop an adventure: crime, passion, gambling, drugs, all the tantalizing stuff we goody-goodies missed."
—Leah Garchik, columnist, San Francisco Chronicle
"Joseph Di Prisco writes with humor and a great sense of character, poking fun at things that would leave a lesser author cringing. Think Cuckoo’s Nest meets The Godfather. He interweaves all these elements with the skill of a master writer."
—Anne Hillerman, New York Times bestselling
author of Spider Woman’s Daughter
"Great funny lines on every page. Am I recommending The Alzhammer? As the protagonist Mikey might say, ‘Eggs ackly.’"
— Jack Handey, author of Deep Thoughts
A brilliant portrayal of a wise guy who faces his biggest arch enemies…time and Alzheimer’s. The last tango of power, fear, loyalty, and love is beautifully danced for us right to the very end.
—Vickie Sciacca, Lafayette Library
A beautiful, heartfelt, sometimes funny, occasionally harrowing story of a man making his way through the minefield of his own family history. Di Prisco has lived more lives than most of us, and managed to get it all down in this riveting book.
—Jerry Stahl, author of Permanent Midnight and OG Dad
"Brimming with humor, heartbreak, and at times the feel an old-time Catholic confessional, Subway to California is a one-of-a-kind read."
—Kathleen Caldwell, A Great Good Place For Books
A book replete with all the rich unfolding and poetic reflection of a novel, and all the focused research and unsparing truth-seeking of biography.
—Laura Cogan, Editor in Chief of ZYZZYVA
"What Di Prisco has written here is likely to become the standard-bearer for all future memoirs. This Subway ride is the real deal."
—Steven Gillis, author of The Consequence of Skating
An attention-capturing cliffhanger.
—Judith M. Gallman, Oakland Magazine
Told with enough tenderness and humor to elevate his pain-filled recollections to poetry at times, pure fun at others, Di Prisco brings us home—grateful our family is less volatile, or feeling less alone if we, too, survived a wild childhood.
—Lou Fancher, Contra Costa Times
A heartwarming and hilarious sharing of his dysfunctional family adventures, Joe said it best when he wrote: ‘Stories happen…to people who can tell them.’
—Ginny Prior, Oakland Tribune
A very fine novelist and poet who has now written a moving and actually quite funny memoir about life with two parents who should never have married, and once they did, should never have had children. But then we wouldn’t have Joe to tell us their story.
—A. R. Taylor, author of Sex, Rain, and Cold Fusion
People struggling to find their place in the world often search for answers in a psychiatrist’s office, in love affairs, religion, illegal drugs, gambling, social activism, academia, work, and vicariously, through their children. Di Prisco visited all those places, and then, coming up short, found himself by writing a memoir.
—Mercury News
It’s rare to encounter a book so heartfelt and compassionate and yet so incisively hilarious at the same time.
—Heather Mackey, author of Dreamwood
"Throughout Subway, Di Prisco evokes the past with vivid, often hilarious, prose, describing his Italian-Polish upbringing in Brooklyn, the flight to a strange world called California, his doomed and dramatic love affairs, and his colorful parents—the kind of parents you enjoy reading about and are grateful they were not yours!"
—Anara Guard, author of Remedies for Hunger
"What makes Di Prisco’s novel work is its narrative voice—poignant, rueful, and wise-crackingly sardonic…Readers of J. F. Powers’ Morte d’Urban and Alice McDermott’s Charming Billy should find their way to All for Now."
—P. F. Kluge, author of A Call from Jersey and Gone Tomorrow
It is especially moving to read a book that looks so broadly at the ubiquitous issue of Roman Catholicism and pedophilia…Di Prisco has given us a brave, bumbling, soul-searching hero whose wry humor only enhances his honesty.
—Jan Weissmiller, Prairie Lights Books
"Catholic or not, religious or not, All for Now is accessible to everyone because mistakes and forgiveness are universal."
—Seattle Post Intelligencer
"Confessions of Brother Eli fairly sparkles with humor that ranges from sophisticated to slapstick, in what some believe to be the most difficult writing to carry off."
—Tucson Weekly
With dry, sardonic wit, Brother Eli questions his faith and vocation, while recounting adventures that take place at his school…The writing and narrative voice in this book is some of the best I’ve come across.
—Akron Beacon Journal
"With a wit that questions as it embraces, Poems in Which provides us with a strong, original voice."
—Carl Dennis, author of Practical Gods
and winner of the Pulitzer Prize
This is a Genuine Vireo Book
A Vireo Book | Rare Bird Books
453 South Spring Street, Suite 302
Los Angeles, CA 90013
rarebirdbooks.com
Copyright © 2017 by Joseph Di Prisco
All rights reserved, including the right to reproduce this book or portions thereof in any form whatsoever, including but not limited to print, audio, and electronic.
For more information, address: A Vireo Book | Rare Bird Books Subsidiary Rights Department, 453 South Spring Street, Suite 302,
Los Angeles, CA 90013.
epub isbn
: 9781940207537
A part of Subway to California appeared in an essay by the author, Head Fakes in Ho Chi Minh City,
published in The Threepenny Review.
The author has changed names and altered details where appropriate in his memoir, to safeguard the privacy of some whose lives intersected with his.
Publisher’s Cataloging-in-Publication data
Di Prisco, Joseph, 1950—Subway to California : a memoir / by Joseph Di Prisco. p. cm.
ISBN 9781940207353
1. Di Prisco, Joseph, 1950–. 2. Di Prisco family. 3. California—Biography. 4. Brooklyn (New York, N.Y.)—Biography. 5. Gambling and crime —Biography. 6. Addictions. I. Title.CT275.D481 S8 2014
979.4/092—dc23
For my son, Mario
Also by Joseph Di Prisco
Memoir
The Pope of Brooklyn
Novels
Confessions of Brother Eli
Sun City
All for Now
The Alzhammer
Poetry
Wit’s End
Poems in Which
Sightlines from the Cheap Seats
Nonfiction
Field Guide to the American Teenager
(with Michael Riera)
Right from Wrong: Instilling a Sense of Integrity in Your Child
(with Michael Riera)
Contents
Part One
Brooklyn Transfer
February 4, 2010
Joy of my Youth
625 Humboldt Street
Dirty
Snow in the Mountains
Part Two
Brother Joseph
Liberal Education
Stinson Beach and the Great Whites
Sailing to Las Vegas
The Modern Language Assocation
and Other Nightmares
High School Redux
Part Three
This Is As Far As We Go: 2010
Epilogue
Acknowledgments
Part One
I too lived, Brooklyn of ample hills was mine,
I too walk’d the streets of Manhattan island, and bathed in the waters around it,
I too felt the curious abrupt questionings stir within me.
—Crossing Brooklyn Ferry,
Walt Whitman
Brooklyn Transfer
When my father ran away, he said, Go back to Grandma’s house and don’t take no shit from nobody.
If I’d had a camera that Sunday afternoon, I might have snapped a picture of his backside when he made a mad dash for the tree line, plunged into the thickets, and disappeared. I was ten years old the day he left my younger brother and me on that Long Island country road. Not that I knew it at the time, but that was only the beginning of a long journey for him—and for me.
Soon after, my mother rounded up my brother and me and we hauled out of Brooklyn.
We weren’t the first family to skip town and we wouldn’t be the last. Nothing awaited us elsewhere, but elsewhere did have one big advantage: It was not Brooklyn. Brooklyn, however, was not the problem. As I would one day find out, the FBI was on my father’s trail. Who wouldn’t call that a problem?
*
His flight began one peaceful day in the late spring or early summer of 1961, while my family was visiting my grandparents’ farm in sleepy, suburban East Islip. Though I loved the farm, I didn’t appreciate missing Mass that Sunday. I was a pious child.
A tiny train station stood within walking distance of the farm, but it was more convenient to drive, despite the bumper-to-bumper weekend expressway traffic, and that is how we traveled to spend occasional Sundays. Nowadays, where my grandparents once lived, tract homes stretch as far as the glaucomaed eye fails to distinguish. Back then, there were trees and dirt roads, wild pigs plowing the brush, hawks soaring, wild turkeys gobbling. Frayed signs were nailed up in the forests we roamed, warning No Hunting No Trespassing. Shots rang out from time to time in the distance. I had no idea what anybody could be hunting. Maybe wolf, maybe fox? That depended on the movie or the fairy tale disturbing my dreams. My father and uncle took me out into the woods a few times, armed with shotguns and .22s so we could take aim at the quarry of soda cans and wine jugs.
Before the old man scooted off, he blurted out those parting instructions: Go back to Grandma’s house and don’t take no shit from nobody.
Old man? Old man? He was in his thirties. Still, he spoke his piece and didn’t stick around for discussion and explanation—neither of which he was big on under any circumstances, including those apparently less urgent than the present.
Not that the man was auditioning for street mime. He had his opinions. We never had a question as to where he stood on the subject of shit-taking. He was anti. We didn’t fully understand what he meant by that bromide, but we knew it was his all-purpose take on life.
My father invoked memorable counsel on other subjects as well: Don’t count your money in front of no windows.
Seems there once was a rash fellow in Brooklyn who did such a foolish thing and lived to regret it. My father didn’t say how or why somebody was conducting surveillance on said man, but he also didn’t say he was a disinterested party. And he didn’t exactly admit that he stole the guy’s money or that anybody he knew stole the guy’s money. The guy had it coming, though, because he was stupid enough to count his money in front of a window, which, in case there was a question, nobody should do. For the record, my brother and I didn’t have in our possession any rolls of cash to count in front of a window or anywhere else. Still, the notion was weaponized and loaded into the memory chamber for later discharge.
I watch my father vanish that Sunday, quickly enveloped by the trees. I turn to look down the road, and I instantly understand what has clipped wings onto his shoes. My grandparents’ house is surrounded by black and white police cars and other official-looking vehicles unmarked yet easily detectible as chariots of law enforcement. Lights flash on top of the cruisers parked in ominous, threatening diagonals.
John and I wander back to the house. I do not recall being frightened for myself, though there must have been some element of fear. Wouldn’t any child have been afraid to see his father run for his life? At the same time, I also do not recall being intimidated by the spectacle of the great blue line. My childhood fantasies failed to run toward a career in the well-compensated and respected field of criminal justice. More than anything, what I recall is that it all felt normal—or at least not particularly strange. It’s the sort of thing I intuited my father was capable of doing. He would run into the woods and would flee into the wind.
What were the odds that my father would be taking a walk with his sons when the cops showed up to not find him? A long shot. My father has been a gambler forever and he would have said the odds were too steep to take. What an amazing piece of luck. Luck isn’t the word.
We come in through the back door, go down the steps into the cellar past the canned sweet tomatoes and the jarred red and green peppers and the half-gallons of reedy red wine, which we had to sip on during Sunday supper for no other reason than to validate our boyhood. Everybody is standing around, only now their standing around has a solemn function. They are seriously smoking cigarettes, looking highly pissed off. This condition applies to everybody, from my grandparents to my mother to my uncles to the guys in the suits whose jackets flare open, revealing weaponry. If they are saying anything, they aren’t sharing recipes, and they are all talking in English, not Italian.
*
In the 1920s my grandparents arrived in America, passing through Ellis Island like many Italian immigrants. They had left Fontanarosa, a lovely hillside town of diminishing economic prospects famous for its high-quality stone, in the region of Campania, forty minutes these days by car outside Avellino, more than an hour away (by horse cart, who knows?) from Napoli. Giovannina Ruzza was born on May 5, 1896. Pasquale Di Prisco, September 18, 1897. They were married on November 27, 1919, in their home town. She was twenty-three, he was twenty-two. Pasquale became a naturalized citizen of the United States of America in July 1929. Their four children, three boys and a girl, were born in Brooklyn.
Giuseppe Luigi Di Prisco was the second child, and he was born on March 18, 1925, about thirty-five years before scooting into those woods. He was usually called Joe, but his street name was Popey. That was Pope-y, not as in Popeye, but as in of the Pope, or Pope-like or -ish. So it was pronounced Pope-ee.
Popey’s wife, my mom, was a Polish girl from the neighborhood, and she used to say they called him Popey because, in her words, he never shut the fuck up.
That was a difficult for me to understand, because my father never expatiated at length, preferring the aphoristic, like about not counting your money or taking shit. Then again, if my mom was in attendance, she commanded the floor. As for the street name, my dad testified they called him Popey because his crew caught him coming out of a church one time. How he lived down the embarrassment he never did explain, and what he was doing in a pew he never said, either. Truth is, I had only few faint recollections of his ever being inside a sanctuary.
My uncles normally speak to their parents in their Napolitano tongue, because the immigrants speak hardly any English. This dialect is rough, considered low-class in Italy, and easy to pick out. It’s reminiscent of the Italian
in ’50s pop songs that people who don’t speak Italian believe sounds Italian. At every opportunity, closing vowels are severed. Ricotta becomes ricott’, spaghetti spaghett’, manicotti manicott’. The English ch
sounds in Italian become sh.
Diciamo,
let’s talk—di-CHA-mo
—sounds like di-SHA-mo.
Scopa,
the delightful Italian card game, SHH-copa.
And so on.
Meanwhile, on this farm in New York, the grandchildren are on the monorail to cultural assimilation. None of us grandchildren spoke Italian at the time, and it would take decades for that misjudgment to be corrected. Nobody wanted to be outed by speaking Italian and being labeled a wop. Everybody assumed Italians were mobsters who preferred wife-beater T-shirts—that day being a case in point.
*
The cellar was where my grandparents lived, with stove and sink and fridge and lots of cupboards for canned tomatoes and peppers, tools and weaponry and so on, the usual comestibles and combustibles. That’s where they rolled out the pasta, made the family dinners, did the TV-watching, the yelling, the drinking of their homemade red wine, the crying, the chestnut-roasting, the anisette-pouring, the card-playing, and still more of the crying and yelling. The bathroom was upstairs, though my grandfather preferred the outdoor sink for his morning toilet and the water pump by the garage and the outhouse on the farthest edge of the property. If he was out there at six a.m., he had overslept. I loved the water that came out of that pump. It always tasted sweet and cold.
The stairs leading to the upper floor obeyed no rational twentieth-century building code, constructed at about a sixty-degree angle, just this side of a ladder. Upstairs, there were bedrooms and a living room and another kitchen—a more conventional domestic arrangement. They never cooked or ate up there. Up there, genteel codes prevailed. Furniture had plastic covering and walls were painted dusky brown and lime green. The halls reeked of mothballs, amazingly, considering that twenty, thirty feet downstairs no garlic bulb was safe from the olive oil in a spattering hot pan. The real living went on downstairs, in what they called the cellar.
Entering the cellar, you had to pass a pole. This pole was painted that very same lime green as the walls upstairs, a color signaling an alert—perhaps to prevent grandchildren from running into it after sipping on that Sunday supper wine. It must have functioned as a sort of structural support, because the aesthetic enhancement was dubious. Whenever I saw this pole I remembered something my mother said a hundred times: When your father was a boy, your grandfather used to tie him to a post in the cellar, beat the shit out of him with a belt, and leave him crying in the dark. They’re all fucking barbarians, these Italians.
My mother also had iron-clad culinary views that clashed with Italian traditions and my father’s native-born food preferences. Herbs and spices were practically banished from her board. Salt and pepper were tantalizing rumors. Cinnamon was around, for toast or to garnish rice pudding, and of course all types of sugar, granulated, brown, or powdered. Sure, she used plenty of sour cream and whipping cream, but for her, everything tasted better with one special ingredient. Later on, when my father was getting word on his elevated cholesterol count, he often could be heard shouting about it: he accused his wife of killing him—with butter.
She hated garlic. She hated garlic almost as much as she hated the Italians, and for obviously related reasons. It seems perhaps incomprehensible and almost insanely impressive that she waged a one-woman crusade against garlic her whole life, but it is true. I don’t know what she could eat on Sunday at my grandparents’ given that position, and now that I think about it, I have no recollection of her eating anything on Long Island. Her indictment of garlic was absolute. I couldn’t buy her contention that garlic made her physically ill, a claim underscored with grotesque facial contortions and nauseating sound effects. I would not have had the vocabulary to articulate that her argument was symbolic or passive-aggressive, but that was my take. How could anybody not like garlic? Whenever we went to restaurants, she would interrogate the waiter about every item on the menu: Any gah-lick?
A naked swinging light bulb over the waiter’s head couldn’t have added to her efforts of intimidation. If the waiter swore, No garlic, lady,
she would size him up to see if he was fucking with her. I can imagine her proposing to snoop in the kitchen, to check if any garlic bulbs were lying suspiciously around. Despite her vigilance, dishes with supposed garlic were dangerously served up to her. I lost count of how many times she sent back her plate. The garlic phobia was not rooted in sensory reality.
Mom,
my brother Eddie would say to her, you can’t eat garlic?
Makes me want to puke.
Eddie would lift up a bottle of kosher pickles. She loved her dills.
Says here, right on the label, there’s garlic in these pickles. Want one?
When she did not have a leg to stand on, she strutted: Never mind.
Despite the fact that her previous husband—with whom she had three children—and her current husband—with whom she had two boys, me and my brother John—were both Italian, or maybe because of it, she never relented on her garlic antipathy or on her position that Italians were all fucking barbarians. She often reminded everybody of her anti-Italian worldview when she was angry with my father, as if she were clearing up doubts as to why he was a fucking barbarian, and why he couldn’t help it, the motherfucker. Sometimes, rarely, she said this in a sympathetic tone of voice, as if to convey how much adversity he’d overcome, or would have overcome if he were capable of overcoming adversity, which so far the fucking barbarian had not managed to do.
My mother’s frightening accounts of cellar beatings made for an indelible image: my father prostrate on the cold cement floor, shivering in the darkness, welts all over him from the belt buckle. My mother was doubtless relaying what she believed to be accurate information—she must have gotten the details from her husband. My father, for his part, never once mentioned this ordeal, but he was never less than deferential to his father, fearful even.
More than anything, perhaps, what my mother had to say about my father and the fucking barbarian Italians showed that she was continuing the pattern of abuse my father had experienced since childhood—not that I ever made that connection at the time. Maybe my father found in my mother the perfect mate to abuse and love him. She wasn’t tying him to a pole in the cellar and leaving him in the dark. She was tying him to herself and leaving him in the dark.
I find it curious that her observation about Italian parenting customs never really did the trick of making me feel intimidated by my grandfather, which was, I assume, at least one strategic aspect. He was difficult enough on his own terms, so I kept my measured distance, in case he got any ideas of tying me up and leaving me in the cellar. I didn’t believe he would do that to me, his prized oldest grandson—yet how was I to know for sure after taking into account my mother’s vast wisdom on the barbarian subject? But when his face turned tomato red and he wanted to show affection, he would nuzzle my cheek, and his grizzled face would amusingly scratch my face and the scent of the wine would please and terrify me. My grandfather yelled at my younger brother a lot, which, to tell the truth, just about everybody did. But he never yelled at me, not even after the time we were searching around in some cupboards—for what, I cannot recall—and I came across, fifteen feet from the dinner table, three or four loaded rifles and shotguns along with plenty of rounds and buckshot. When the breach of security was analyzed, the guns were moved and never stumbled upon again.
My grandfather’s eyes crossed, so sometimes it was hard for me to face him. Which eye to look at? Left or right? Maybe focus on the nose, a target prominent as a Roma tomato? When I was very young, my parents noticed my own eyes would drift when I got tired, a gift from the family genes. My eyes would still be crossing if at age twelve I hadn’t started wearing glasses with prisms in the prescription, as I still do.
Thick, broad-chested, florid of complexion, and squat, my grandfather resembled a blushing turnip. On a good day he was five feet tall. He was comically bow-legged. This last observation seemed connected to another of my mother’s choice observations: Pasquale was a cavalier.
She enjoyed enunciating the word cavalier.
The truth was, he was a Cavaliere dell’Ordine di Vittorio Veneto, and served in Ethiopia in the cavalry. My mother found worthy of mockery this family military history, especially the part about Ethiopia. She would say he should go back to Ethiopia, because he was a fucking barbarian, and I was forced to conclude Ethiopia was another country full of barbarians, like Italy. At which point my father would counter by saying something inscrutably laudatory about somebody named Haile Selassie, whoever he was.
I remember going to church one Sunday with everybody in East Islip. The priest’s homily was delivered in Italian. My grandfather was wearing his brown work shoes that had never been afflicted by a coat of polish and a blue suit, topped with a grey fedora that was too small, so he looked like a cartoon character bloated into a Pez dispenser. He had put on a starched white shirt stiff as cardboard with a tie wide as a flag, a tie whose knot, from the look on his red face, was constricting his oxygen supply, the shirt collar flipped up as if he had a set of wings under his chin. If he were a horse in that church, he could not have appeared more skittish.
When he was in high spirits, and his nose turned beet red from the wine he had been drinking all day, he used to beam and warn he was about to break into the tarantella. He would strike a pose like some Sicilian dancer, hands over his head, snapping his fingers, kicking his heels, threatening some imitation of the flamenco. But as much as his grandson wished for this star turn to take place, my Nonno never did break into the tarantula dance. That would have been something to see.
By the way, how did we know what they were saying though we did not speak their dialect, or any Italian? I don’t know, but we did. Somehow I inherited a good Italian accent, which I discovered when I learned to speak the language many years later.
As for my grandmother, like every Italian boy of literature and lore, I adored her. She must have been a ravishing beauty in her youth, for she had that gorgeous mocha Southern skin and high cheekbones and a ready sparkle in her eyes. My mother wanted me to dislike her because, according to my mother, Giovannina was pitting my father against his siblings and his own father, while she elected to play the role of martyr and saintly matriarch. It was implicit, from my mother’s point of view, that my grandmother was devious. I am not saying my mother did not have a point. She may well have, for my mother could have received a graduate degree in deviousness. Still, my grandmother trumped every argument made against her by being herself. She wept for joy a lot—joy is my guess—when she and I chatted at the table, though I never knew why she wept, or what the joy, if it was joy, was about. She had big feelings and she showed them. Then she would pat my hand and slip me a twenty-dollar bill. The money smelled nutty and woodsy, a lot like shaved Parmigiano cheese, which should have been a clue as to where she secreted her cash.
Don’t tell your father about the money, she would communicate in broken English. I got the message and squirreled away the loot. What nobody needed to know nobody needed to know. Acqua in bocca, as they say in Italian. Water in the mouth—which makes it hard to talk, you see, and which amounts to Mum’s the word.
Well, if it was important to her that nobody needed to know, okay. Anything for Nonna—anything.
*
When my dad ran off, he didn’t bother to say: If anybody asks you something, especially a cop, don’t open your mouth.
Every child borough-wide is hard-wired. You don’t talk. You don’t answer questions. Answer a question with a question, buy some time. And volunteering information? That was something that could get you smacked. You take every opportunity to shut the fuck up.
Still, the uniform might be asking questions—but then again, I had an overactive imagination and a bustling fantasy life. Probably the cop didn’t ask me anything, but his disapproving scrutiny amounted to something like this:
Where’s your old man?
Where?
So it’s gonna be like that.
Like what?
Where. Is. Your. Old. Man?
My old man?
That’s the greaseball I’m axing about, chubby.
My mutha says I am stout.
You’re a punk, orange ya, like your old man. Stout means fat, did your pretty Polack mutha tell you that, too?
She takes me shopping for clothes in the husky section.
You know, husky is another word for…
Also she says I have big bones.
Yeah, you got lotsa big bones all right. In your freakin’ head.
*
When my family is finally reunited, it’s a long time from now and a long, long way from here, in an airport on the other side of the country. It would take longer, much longer, for me to have a clue as to what the FBI wanted with my father and what it was that drove us far from home.
Brooklyn in my past, as a boy I would come to discover I had arrived in a place where oranges grew on the trees and shiny convertibles glided along the expressway, which they called a freeway, and a different ocean—and also the Brooklyn Dodgers, only they weren’t the Brooklyn Dodgers anymore. This was a strange and beautiful place. There were redwood trees and brown hills. The food was different, too, including the pizza, which barely qualified. They didn’t know from chicken parm, either. The rain was not the New York rain, rain that gave off attitude: You want a taste of this? I got your rain right here. And the snow…what snow?
I would soon find out the people who lived here talked weird. They would snicker when you said didjuh and shoulda, wautah and fawk. They would correct you and say did you and should have, water and fork. Your mudda, fadda, and brudda were a source of amusement as well. At the movies, everybody waited in line, and not on line, as they shoulda. Yes, they thought they wuz pretty smaht, only they said smart. It was enough to put the kibosh on the whole friggin ding. The only sport I had played was stickball in the middle of Humboldt Street in Greenpoint, when we yelled fuck you at the drivers whose cars interrupted us. Here they had gorgeous green fields for baseball, and perfect black asphalt courts for a game known as basketball. I had never touched a basketball before. The whole landscape was sad and dazzling, lit up by the unyielding, bleaching sun. Over time, I might get used to it all, maybe, but I doubted it.
The place was called California.
February 4, 2010
Ch illy, chilly, chilly night here in Greenpoint, which is in Brooklyn and which is where I was born. I don’t often come back to Greenpoint, except for weddings and funerals.
So far, no weddings.
Tonight’s forecast is a blizzard.
Bring it on, I say, even as the sparkling black sky makes me doubt the meteorologist’s crystal ball. I like the toasty, tinny taste in the air. Maybe that means the flu is coming on.
I’m here in Greenpoint to see my mother. It has been almost two years. A lot has happened. But first, I am going to walk. And walk. And walk some more. Though it is freezing, I need to prepare. Fortunately, the sidewalks are mostly empty, the way I have preferred my sidewalks and, for longer than I would care to admit, my romantic entanglements.
Greenpoint is toying with me. Brooklyn, my mother’s appearance, the imminent blizzard—the puzzle pieces of the past, my personal history, are shifting around on the board when who knew there was a game to be played? Bless me, Father, for I have obviously sinned, it has been a long, long time since my last confession, but if it please the court, there are two observations I would like to observe at this time: As far as I am concerned, nothing has changed in Greenpoint since I was ten years old and was transplanted in California, and everything looks completely different.
*
One day my wife had a routine medical appointment. This was many years before tonight and three thousand miles away.
I had never met Dr. Smith, though other relatives as well as friends were Dr. Smith’s patients. At the time I was traveling, and when my wife called, she sounded tentative, wary. She does not do tentative or wary. She is more like standing on the bridge in bungee-jumping school and then leaping: Wheee! This was the exchange she related:
Dr. Smith, she said to her healer, you and I have a mutual acquaintance.
Oh, really, her doctor asked, who would that be?
That would be Kay Di Prisco, your patient.
How do you know Catherine?
This was a legitimate query on the doctor’s part, because his patient did not take her spouse’s last name in holy wedlock.
She is my mother-in-law.
That means