Marx at the Arcade: Consoles, Controllers, and Class Struggle
3.5/5
()
About this ebook
More people are playing video games than ever before, and yet much of the work of their production remains obscured to us.
Deploying a Marxist approach, Jamie Woodcock delves into the hidden abode of the gaming industry, unravelling the vast networks of artists, software developers, and factory and logistics workers whose material and immaterial labor flows into the products we consume on a gargantuan scale. Beyond this, the book analyzes the increasingly important role the gaming industry plays in contemporary capitalism, and the broader transformations of work and economy that it embodies. Woodcock also presents game-play itself not as a deviant activity, as it is often understood, but as a commentary of estrangement from contemporary forms of work. In so doing, it offers a fresh and much needed analysis of a sector which has for too long been neglected by scholars and labor activists alike.
Jamie Woodcock
Jamie Woodcock is a researcher based in London. He is the author of The Gig Economy (Polity Press, 2019), Marx at the Arcade (Haymarket, 2019), and Working The Phones (Pluto, 2016). His research focuses on labour, work, the gig economy, platforms, resistance, organising, and videogames.
Related to Marx at the Arcade
Related ebooks
Power Play: How Video Games Can Save the World Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Power-Up: How Japanese Video Games Gave the World an Extra Life Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Video Games and the Global South Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsBefore the Crash: Early Video Game History Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Game Work: Language, Power, and Computer Game Culture Rating: 5 out of 5 stars5/5Imaginary Games Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsExperimental Games: Critique, Play, and Design in the Age of Gamification Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsStarflight: How the PC and DOS Exploded Computer Gaming 1987-1994 Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsLudopolitics: Videogames against Control Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsIndie Games: The Complete Introduction to Indie Gaming Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Service Games: The Rise and Fall of SEGA Rating: 3 out of 5 stars3/5Game On!: Video Game History from Pong and Pac-Man to Mario, Minecraft, and More Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Videogames and Art Rating: 3 out of 5 stars3/5Attract Mode: The Rise and Fall of Coin-Op Arcade Games Rating: 5 out of 5 stars5/5The History of Video Games Rating: 5 out of 5 stars5/5A Brief History Of The Video Game Industry: The First Generation: 1, #1 Rating: 3 out of 5 stars3/5A Game In The Life Rating: 5 out of 5 stars5/5Gaming the System: Deconstructing Video Games, Games Studies, and Virtual Worlds Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsA Precarious Game: The Illusion of Dream Jobs in the Video Game Industry Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsThe Pac-Man Principle: A User's Guide To Capitalism Rating: 3 out of 5 stars3/5Ideology and the Virtual City: Videogames, Power Fantasies And Neoliberalism Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsBastards of Utopia: Living Radical Politics After Socialism Rating: 5 out of 5 stars5/5The Greatest Art Form: Video Games and the Evolution of Artistic Expression Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsIt Did Happen Here: An Antifascist People’s History Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsNarrative Mechanics: Strategies and Meanings in Games and Real Life Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsGame Time: Understanding Temporality in Video Games Rating: 5 out of 5 stars5/5Lost in a Good Game: Why we play video games and what they can do for us Rating: 5 out of 5 stars5/5The Claremont Run: Subverting Gender in the X-Men Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Resilience & Melancholy: Pop Music, Feminism, Neoliberalism Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Excommunication: Three Inquiries in Media and Mediation Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratings
Video Games For You
Live to Tell the Tale: Combat Tactics for Player Characters Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The NES Encyclopedia: Every Game Released for the Nintendo Entertainment System Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Dark Souls : Beyond the Grave - Volume 1: Demons Souls - Dark Souls - Dark Souls II Rating: 5 out of 5 stars5/5Pojo's Unofficial Advanced Pokemon Go: The Best Tips and Strategies for the World's Hottest Game! Rating: 5 out of 5 stars5/5The Monsters Know What They're Doing: Combat Tactics for Dungeon Masters Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5101 Awesome Builds: Minecraft® Secrets from the World's Greatest Crafters Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Big Book of Zelda: The Unofficial Guide to Breath of the Wild and The Legend of Zelda Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Fallout: A Tale of Mutation Rating: 5 out of 5 stars5/5Ultimate Guide to Mastering Command Blocks!: Minecraft Keys to Unlocking Secret Commands Rating: 5 out of 5 stars5/5The BIG Book of Animal Crossing: New Horizons: Everything you need to know to create your island paradise! Rating: 5 out of 5 stars5/5Pojo's Unofficial Ultimate Guide to Pokemon GO: How to Catch 'Em All! Rating: 3 out of 5 stars3/5Think Like A Game Designer Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Pojo's Unofficial Big Book of Pokemon Rating: 3 out of 5 stars3/5The Super World of Mario: The Ultimate Unofficial Guide to Super Mario® Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Legendary World of Zelda Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Ultimate Guide to The Legend of Zelda A Link to the Past Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsQuest for the Golden Apple: An Unofficial Graphic Novel for Minecrafters Rating: 5 out of 5 stars5/5The Fortnite Guide to Staying Alive: Tips and Tricks for Every Kind of Player Rating: 5 out of 5 stars5/5The Gamer's Bucket List: The 50 Video Games to Play Before You Die Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Master Builder Roblox: The Essential Guide Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Big Book of Five Nights at Freddy's: The Deluxe Unofficial Survival Guide Rating: 5 out of 5 stars5/5Phil Gordon's Little Gold Book: Advanced Lessons for Mastering Poker 2.0 Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5World of Warcraft: The Official Cookbook Rating: 5 out of 5 stars5/5The Sega Mega Drive & Genesis Encyclopedia: Every Game Released for Sega's 16-bit Console Rating: 5 out of 5 stars5/5Diablo: The Official Cookbook: Recipes and Tales from the Inns of Sanctuary Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratings
Reviews for Marx at the Arcade
7 ratings1 review
- Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Gaming the CodersMarx and Engels had nothing to say about videogames. Jamie Woodcock tries to connect them in Marx at the Arcade. The links are tenuous, but Woodcock’s knowledge of the industry is intense.The first videogame launched in 1940, and ever since, bored engineers have been tinkering with computers to make them playable. Today, at the other extreme, videogames are universally available. Woodcock quotes Forbes magazine as finding 69% of Pokémon Go players playing it at work. New games can be on the screens of 200 million people. In the UK, 51% of entertainment spending is on videogames, almost three times what is spent on music. It is a new institution in global culture.The book divides into three: the history, the industry and the games. Of the three, the industry section is by far the most interesting.The gaming industry is living irony. In the early days of videogaming, hackers ruled. Game developers came from a “Refusal to work. They were all about leisure, hedonism, irresponsibility against clock-punching, discipline and productivity,” Woodcock says. It was all about sharing, recognition, and joy at creation. Today, capitalism rules. No one works in gaming without signing an NDA – a nondisclosure agreement – before the job interview can take place. News from the workforce is therefore sparse. But what we do know it is a total throwback to sweatshops and no rights. There are now thousands of companies developing games, and they all seem to have the same playbook. They hire developers at apparently decent salaries, but then make them work 90 hour weeks with no extra pay, effectively cutting their pay to less than half. There is zero loyalty or job security. When the “crunch” period is done and the game has launched, the developers are simply fired. They come back when a new game is under development. Thanks to Gamergate, we also know the industry is filled with racism and sexism. Women are disdained, and paid 15% less. Everyone works in a microscopic area, so that no one can take pride or credit in the game, and may not even know what the final product will look like. It’s an assembly line where the model of car is none of your business. You just perform your little task, endlessly. Layers of management put the pieces together but have no creative say. Job satisfaction is nil. Motivation is nil. Frustration is total.During crunch, developers must work from 9am to 10:30pm, with just enough time to sleep some. And this is seven days a week. When they clock out, their work is handed off to another bureau in a different time zone, so the job can continue, with no one taking ownership of anything. The result is exhaustion, little follow through and lots of errors.These are conditions labor fought tooth and nail to break up 120 years ago, and enlightened high tech has simply reimposed them, for the greater profit of silicon billionaires. About the only delight in the book is that the workers are waking up and organizing. While the major unions ignore them, niche unions are teaching them the ropes, showing them they are not alone, that they have the power to stop this madness, and that they need to be actively promoting change for their own self preservation and the good of everyone. All this is total news to millennials.That history has to repeat itself so soon is discouraging. That solutions at least, are also repeating is reassuring. The race to the bottom may finally be ending. The real game in gaming is labor. Marx would understand.David Wineberg
Book preview
Marx at the Arcade - Jamie Woodcock
© 2019 Jamie Woodcock
Published in 2019 by
Haymarket Books
P.O. Box 180165
Chicago, IL 60618
773-583-7884
www.haymarketbooks.org
ISBN: 978-1-60846-867-6
Distributed to the trade in the US through Consortium Book Sales and Distribution (www.cbsd.com) and internationally through Ingram Publisher Services International (www.ingramcontent.com).
This book was published with the generous support of Lannan Foundation and Wallace Action Fund.
Special discounts are available for bulk purchases by organizations and institutions. Please call 773-583-7884 or email [email protected] for more information.
Cover design by Rachel Cohen.
Text design by Jamie Kerry.
Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication data is available.
AUTHOR’S NOTE
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
Introduction
Part I: Making Videogames
A History of Videogames and Play
The Videogames Industry
The Work of Videogames
Organizing in the Videogames Industry
Part II: Playing Videogames
Analyzing Culture
First-Person Shooters
Role-Playing, Simulations, and Strategy
Political Videogames
Online Play
Conclusion: Why Videogames Matter
NOTES
INDEX
The ideas for this book began as an article in the Journal of Gaming and Virtual Worlds.¹ It has been rewritten, expanded, and developed into the present form here.
I would like to start by thanking John McDonald at Haymarket for encouraging me to turn my ideas about Marxism and videogames into a book. That conversation over the stall at the New York Historical Materialism conference was the start of a great collaboration, and I would also like to thank Nisha Bolsey and the rest of the team at Haymarket for their support, as well as Brian Baughan for copy editing the book.
This book could not have been written without the support of Lydia Hughes—not only her encouragement throughout the entire process, convincing me that the book was worth doing, and finishing, but also her help with the crunch
points during the process. The irony is not missed that I crunched while writing about how bad such a practice is at work.
I would like to thank my parents for their support, as well as for letting me play videogames—who would have thought that those experiences would turn into a book later? My dad encouraged me and introduced me to my first videogames. Many of these came through his friend Jim, so thanks for all those floppy disks.
The book owes a huge debt to my comrade Solvi Goard, who not only played videogames with me but also talked through—at length—many of the ideas that I’ve put forward here.
Working with Mike Cook and Mark Johnson proved an invaluable experience for understanding how videogames are actually made, with thanks to both for their (often very patient) explanations. Thanks also to Mike for letting me test out some of the ideas (well, at least the slide of Marx’s face on a robot) at the hugely inspiring PROCJAM conference.
An earlier version of the argument in this book was published in a special issue of the Journal of Gaming and Virtual Worlds, and I would like to thank both Lars and Graeme for all their feedback. I was also greatly inspired by Nick Dyer-Witheford and Greig de Peuter’s Games of Empire, a book I returned to regularly while writing. It has also been great talking with both Nick and Greig during trips to Canada, as well as Daniel Joseph, whose work too has been really useful.
The politics of this book have been deeply shaped by my editorial comrades Lydia Hughes, Seth Wheeler, Callum Cant, Achille Marotta, and Wendy Liu at Notes from Below. The special issue on technology by Wendy and Marijam (as well as Left Left Up) helped me to think through many of the issues for the book. Sai Englert provided invaluable pun support (I’m sorry none of them made it into the title!).
Finally, I would like to thank Game Workers Unite (GWU) and particularly its UK branch. Sitting in your meetings and talking through what organizing should look like today has been hugely inspiring (and also a bit difficult to write about—in a good way—as things are moving so fast!). I would like to thank Dec, Beck, Karn, and Austin (among many others). You have all shown that there is clearly no such thing as unorganizable workers. This book is dedicated to all of you.
Popular culture is one of the sites where this struggle for and against a culture of the powerful is engaged: it is also the stake to be won or lost in that struggle. It is the arena of consent and resistance. It is partly where hegemony arises, and where it is secured. It is not a sphere where socialism, a socialist culture—already fully formed—might be simply expressed.
But it is one of the places where socialism might be constituted. That is why popular culture
matters. Otherwise, to tell you the truth, I don’t give a damn about it.
—Stuart Hall, Notes on Deconstructing ‘the Popular’
One of my earliest memories of videogames is sitting in front of a computer, trying to figure out how to work the MS-DOS operating system. A friend of my dad’s gave him games, loaded onto floppy disks, to pass along to me. Sometimes they came in plain paper packaging, other times in larger cardboard boxes, filled with paper manuals and other ephemera. I would write down the instructions for playing different games on Post-it notes, which became scattered around the screen. I remember thinking that the games required some expertise, that you had to learn to play them.
Those early games, pixelated and colorful, were a route into another world for me. I directed Lemmings, using different commands to try and stop any from falling off cliffs. I ventured out from the crashed spaceship of Commander Keen, eagerly investigating the game’s world. I also, for reasons I never quite understood, explored the Fantasy World of that anthropomorphized egg with a hat, Dizzy. Then there were the videogames like the platformer Duke Nukem, in which I shot my way through levels. All of these games were passed along by someone who programmed computers for a living.
I was taught to play Tetris on a Nintendo Game Boy while sitting on the staircase of a family friend’s home. Another friend taught me to play console games, introducing me to Sonic, Mario, and others. I remember sitting on the floor, poring over the paper manuals while Civilization installed, wondering whether the installer had crashed or if the loading bar could really take so long. I felt at the time that Civilization was not just a game but that it had educational value—another reason for just one more turn.
My paper manual for Street Fighter Alpha 2 had all the pages torn out, so I had to try and learn the moves with friends while we battled it out in front of the TV. I built sprawling metropolises in SimCity, astonished that I could then fly a helicopter through them in SimCopter. Baldur’s Gate was the closest I ever got to Dungeons & Dragons: I would meet with friends to compare notes on how the characters and story developed. Moving on from those games, I explored postapocalyptic wastelands in Fallout and played for the evil side in Dungeon Keeper.
The first console I ever owned was a PlayStation. I still vividly remember the sound effect and exclamation mark flashing on the screen upon a player being discovered in the stealth game Metal Gear Solid, along with the Snake? Snaaaaake!
at game over, and the shock of the boss fight that broke the fourth wall, making it seem like the TV channel had accidently changed. At the time broadband internet first became widely available, I built my own PC. That need for expertise was there again, brought on by the fear that static electricity would damage the components, along with the ongoing debate with my friends about the best way to apply thermal paste to a CPU. The first online videogame I played was Counter-Strike version 1.4, and I have played that series on and off since. I played World of Warcraft on that custom PC too.
Many of these videogames from my childhood have aged badly, while others have been transformed as the game series evolved. I have no doubt forgotten many that I played, but I can place these older games within periods of my life, which brings back much-broader memories. Videogames have been with me almost my entire life, and the continuing pace of their development is dizzying. Over this time, videogames have also become a form of mass culture. Last year nearly 70 percent of Americans played videogames, while the global industry generated revenues of $108.4 billion.¹ Videogames no longer feel like a pursuit that requires niche expertise to access—they are everywhere now.
Now that I am older, videogames are something I have to make time for—whether unwinding after work or carving out the time to dive into a new title. I have a Steam collection with more un-played games than I would care to admit, but I still do find the time to play videogames and talk about them. In a way, the process of researching for and writing Marx at the Arcade was also an excuse to play some more videogames. It also provided the opportunity to combine videogames with another of my interests: Marxism.
As I think back to those earlier times, who would have thought that twenty years later Karl Marx would actually have relevance to the world of videogames? It is a rare combination that might seem like quite a jump to conceive. But then again, the Old Moor did recently make his digital debut in Assassin’s Creed Syndicate.
Syndicate, part of the long-running Ubisoft series Assassin’s Creed and released in 2015, is set in London in 1868. The plot covers convoluted time travel, battles between Assassins and the Knights Templar, bizarre technology, and everything else that players have come to love and expect throughout the series. The main character, Desmond Miles, is trapped within a sinister corporation and made to relive the genetic memories of his ancestors. This provides the backdrop for the player to visit key moments of history, including the Third Crusade, the French Revolution, and the golden age of piracy, among others.
Despite this complicated plot, the game also provides the backdrop for this book. It highlights some of the key dynamics of contemporary videogames and draws attention to themes that will be explored throughout the book as well as providing an example of Marx in an actual game, in a way that deftly introduces him into the analysis. Upon loading Assassin’s Creed Syndicate, a statement flashes on the screen: Inspired by historical events and characters, this work of fiction was designed, developed, and produced by a multicultural team of various beliefs, sexual orientations and gender identities.
Unsurprisingly, nothing more is said about how workers at Ubisoft made the game. There are no details about how many people were involved, what the work was like, or any disagreements in the process. This gives way to a title screen decorated with turning cogs and indeterminate pieces of metal machinery in motion, with steam drifting over the screen. This is an Assassin’s Creed set after the Industrial Revolution, in a London filled with factories, dense housing, smokestacks, and railway tracks.
The game revolves around Desmond’s assassin ancestors, the twins Jacob and Evie Frye, who are trying to regain London from Templar control and find some sort of artifact. The twins are armed with hidden wrist blades for stabbing people, can free-run up and down buildings, and have grappling hooks for soaring through the air. With these abilities, they make the city their dangerous playground. Their focus is the chief villain, Crawford Starrick, a Templar who is responsible for the current state of London. As one character describes him, There is no aspect of society he does not control. No industry that escapes his grim touch.
In the first mission, the player takes control of Jacob after breaking into a factory. He watches as a child is crushed, screaming in pain. Rupert Ferris, the industrialist,
complains, How long does he intend to go on like this? He’s disrupting the other workers. Shut his trap and get the machine fixed! And send me some laudanum for my head.
Jacob replies, out of earshot, Coming right up.
The player can then free-run across the factory to try to reach Ferris, but will find the door locked. After engaging in some good old-fashioned sabotage of the factory, Jacob can then be directed to drop from the rafters to air assassinate
Ferris with those hidden blades.
From the killing of Ferris, the story develops into a series of core missions, which involve taking over London boroughs, and many, many side missions. After causing some trouble, Starrick gives the following monologue:
Gentlemen! This tea was brought to me from India by a ship, then up from the harbor to a factory, where it was packaged and ferried by carriage to my door, unpacked in the larder and brought upstairs to me. All by men and women who work for me. Who are indebted to me, Crawford Starrick, for their jobs, their time, the very lives they lead. They will work in my factories, and so too shall their children. And you come to me with talk of this Jacob Frye? This insignificant blemish who calls himself Assassin? You disrespect the very city that works day and night so that we may drink this. This miracle. This tea.
As I played through this stage of the game, it brought to mind all the different workers and processes that must have come together across the world to allow the player to enjoy this miracle.
The videogame, like the cup of tea, requires complex global supply chains and different kinds of labor to ensure the final object can be consumed by the player. Uncovering these supply chains today will take more than just studying the lines of an evil monologue.
The first encounter with Karl Marx in Assassin’s Creed Syndicate takes place in the packed Whitechapel train station, somewhere I used to pass through daily in modern, real-life London. Moving through the crowds, Marx can be spotted arguing with a policeman. In his German accent he shouts: You cannot frighten me! I insist on being heard!
Once the player reaches Marx, a pop-up notes that the player can start the mission titled Karl Marx Memories: Cat and Mouse
and that they will need to help Marx avoid the London Police.
In a cutscene (a short expository clip in a videogame), the twins approach Marx, who introduces himself: Much like you, I am an activist of sorts.
He explains that the twins "have done more for London’s citizens lately than any endeavor has accomplished in a decade. But those citizens were already well provided for. I challenge you both to help those who really need your assistance. The working people. Before Jacob can say anything, Evie replies,
An interesting challenge. We accept. Marx explains that he is
organizing a discreet meeting with some like-minded friends to discuss trades unions. The player is directed to
follow Marx." A good start to the mission!
The first mission involves the twins protecting Marx by killing spies. The next encounter starts with Marx standing outside a factory. A pop-up announces the mission: Find proof that a factory is abusing its work force.
Marx explains:
Corruption reigns here, I am sure of it. The number of people injured by their machinery cannot be calculated, and yet the company continues to prosper. They must be stopped for the sake of the poor workers they abuse. If only we had some form of proof. There must be records of the accidents somewhere inside which would surely prove their malfeasance. I should think you would need to find the foreman, but how you’d convince him to give you the reports…Perhaps…if they think the factory is on fire, you might bluff your way past.
The player is directed to find and ignite the cotton bales
along with the optional air assassinate a guard.
The player can then break into the factory, jumping in through a window. While the machinery whirls around them, the player sets fire to cotton bales, and the factory fills with smoke. The next step is hijacking a fire truck, bringing it back to the factory. The foreman comes out thinking they are being saved, but the player’s character replies to them, Saved, are you daft? What about the reports? Your masters won’t be happy.
The foreman, followed by the player, goes to retrieve the reports. Once back outside the factory, the player picks the foreman’s pocket, securing the reports for Marx.
Videogames, it may be no surprise to hear, often take quite a lot of artistic license with historical details. Marx did not employ twin assassins to kill spies with hidden gauntlet blades. Nor did he convince them to break into factories and steal reports. The historical account is, at least as far as we know, much less exciting. The reality is that Marx drew on the publicly available factory inspectors’ reports. He would later also experiment with the use of surveys as method of workers’ inquiry
to interrogate and understand workers’ conditions.² This moment of inquiry in Assassin’s Creed, albeit far removed from Marx’s actual methods, is one favorable to being turned outward and used to examine the industry that produced it. It suggests a way to unpack the type of relationships that Starrick identifies in his tea monologue, and it poses a critical question: Where does a game like Assassin’s Creed come from? What does the game’s creation entail—from the workers who developed it to the supply chains that make it playable at home, easily appearing as a modern miracle,
much like Starrick’s tea. Instead of convincing assassins to break into the workplaces of the videogame industry, this book will explore what we can learn when applying Marx’s methods of inquiry in the present day.