The Girl in Green
4/5
()
About this ebook
Finalist for the CWA Gold Dagger Award for Best Crime Novel of the Year
1991: One hundred miles from the Kuwaiti border, Thomas Benton meets Arwood Hobbes. Benton is a British journalist who reports from war zones in part to avoid his lackluster marriage and a daughter he loves but cannot connect with; Arwood is an American private who might be an insufferable ignoramus or might be a genuine lunatic with a death wish—it's hard to tell. Desert Storm is over, peace has been declared, but as they argue about whether it makes sense to cross the nearest border in search of an ice cream, they become embroiled in a horrific attack in which a young local girl in a green dress is killed as they are trying to protect her.
The two men walk away into their respective lives. But something has cracked for them both. Twenty-two years later, in another place, in another war, they meet again and are offered an unlikely opportunity to redeem themselves when that same girl in green is found alive and in need of salvation. Or is she?
“Swift, gripping, and mined with surprises…Arwood Hobbes is as intriguing an operative as Graham Greene's quiet American, but without the quiet.”—David Shafer, author of Whiskey Tango Foxtrot
“[A] stellar, electrifying story with a knockout ending.”—Publishers Weekly (starred review)
“A penetrating, poetic, and unexpectedly disarming book about the ageless conflict in the Middle East.”—Kirkus Reviews (starred review)
“A Catch-22 for the twenty-first century.”—Madison Smartt Bell, National Book Award finalist and author of All Souls' Rising
Derek B. Miller
Derek B. Miller is an American novelist, who worked in international affairs before turning to writing full-time. He is the author of five previous novels, all highly acclaimed: Norwegian by Night, The Girl in Green, American by Day, Radio Life and Quiet Time (an Audible Original). His work has been shortlisted for many awards, with Norwegian by Night winning the CWA John Creasey Dagger Award for best first crime novel, an eDunnit Award and the Goldsboro Last Laugh Award. How to Find Your Way in the Dark was a Finalist for the National Jewish Book Award and a New York Times best mystery of 2021. Derek B. Miller is a graduate of Sarah Lawrence College (BA), Georgetown (MA) and he earned his Ph.D. summa cum laude in international relations from The Graduate Institute in Geneva with post-graduate work at Oxford. He is currently connected to numerous peace and security research and policy centers in North America, Europe and Africa, and he worked with the United Nations for over a decade. He has lived abroad for over twenty-five years in Israel, the United Kingdom, Hungary, Switzerland, Norway and Spain.
Read more from Derek B. Miller
American By Day: A Novel Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5
Related to The Girl in Green
Related ebooks
Norwegian By Night Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Temple of Gold: A Novel Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Challenging the Pacific: The First Woman to Row the Kon-Tiki Route Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Selection Day: A Novel Rating: 3 out of 5 stars3/5Victim Without a Face: A Fabian Risk Novel Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Spill Simmer Falter Wither Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Lotus Eaters: A Novel Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Night Swimmer: A Novel Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Time It Takes to Fall: A Novel Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The King of Shanghai: An Ava Lee Novel: Book 7 Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Free: A Novel Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Seersucker Whipsaw Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsUnder the Wave at Waimea Rating: 3 out of 5 stars3/5The Feral Detective: A Novel Rating: 3 out of 5 stars3/5The History of Bees: A Novel Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Hungry Tide: A Novel Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Isabella Rating: 5 out of 5 stars5/5Nothing Short of Dying: A Clyde Barr Novel Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Three Lives of Tomomi Ishikawa Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Raft of Stars: A Novel Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Rabbit Factor Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Smilla's Sense of Snow: A Novel Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Summertime, All the Cats Are Bored Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Last Bookstore in America Rating: 5 out of 5 stars5/5Walking on Water Rating: 5 out of 5 stars5/5The Three-Legged Stool Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsThe Language of Solitude: A Novel Rating: 5 out of 5 stars5/5Finding Nouf: A Novel Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Accordion Crimes Rating: 3 out of 5 stars3/5In the Shadow of the Banyan: A Novel Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5
Satire For You
The Sisters Brothers Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Wonder Boys Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Clown Brigade Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Yellowface: A Novel Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Master & Margarita Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5As I Lay Dying Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Kill for Love Rating: 5 out of 5 stars5/5Women: A Novel Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Only Living Girl on Earth Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5It Was Just Another Day in America Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsThe Bonfire of the Vanities: A Novel Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Robot Who Looked Like Me: Stories Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5We: A Novel Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Crumbling of a Nation and other stories Rating: 5 out of 5 stars5/51900: Or; The Last President Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Mash: A Novel About Three Army Doctors Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Out of Oz: The Final Volume in the Wicked Years Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Dice Man: A Novel Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Going Postal Rating: 5 out of 5 stars5/5The Rise and Fall of D.O.D.O.: A Novel Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Bestseller Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Shriver: A Novel Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Five People You Meet in Hell: An Unauthorized Parody Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Utterly Uninteresting and Unadventurous Tales of Fred, the Vampire Accountant Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Florida Roadkill: A Novel Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Crimson Petal and the White: A Novel Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Little Old Lady Who Broke All the Rules: A Novel Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The White Boy Shuffle: A Novel Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Utopia Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5A Dog's Heart Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5
Related categories
Reviews for The Girl in Green
46 ratings6 reviews
- Rating: 5 out of 5 stars5/5Family saga set in Florida in a small town near St Augustine. I picked this up after reading Laura Lee Smith’s Ice House several years ago (which I loved), but this one is not in the same league. I found it long and dreary. The characters are an unlikeable bunch. It is mainly about life in a small town, where developers want to buy up the land and turn it into a tourist trap. I could not muster much enthusiasm for it.
- Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Witty dialogue and vivid scenery made this an interesting and fast read. The author has his Ph.D. in international relations, so there were some chapters that read more like an NPR investigative report. In general, this was an enjoyable read.
1 person found this helpful
- Rating: 5 out of 5 stars5/5I was fortunate enough to be sent a paper copy of this by the publisher some time back, and then a follower of my blog reminded me that I should read it.Can I say that I wouldn't really classify this as crime fiction, although crimes are certainly committed in their thousands.One reviewer has described it as a "moral thriller", and given recent efforts to free Mosul from ISIS, it is certainly a topical read. In 1991 Operation Desert Storm was declared a success and peace was thought to have been achieved. But now 25 years later, a whole generation has grown up in a war-torn landscape. 40 years ago I travelled through Iraq before the war began.THE GIRL IN GREEN puts the story of the last 25 years into human language, when Arwood Hobbes, an American soldier discharged at the end of Operation Desert Storm, and British journalist Thomas Benton, try to go back into the past. Hobbes in particular wants to wreak his own form of justice.The events of the book demonstrate in particular how difficult it will be to re-establish peace in the Middle East.
1 person found this helpful
- Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Exploring the many different agencies, the political nightmare of trying to understand the many different cultures and the religious beliefs of each, Miller has invented two very unique and quite likable characters, Arrowood and Benson. When they first meet the Gulf War has ended, at least ended as far as the United States is concerned, now turning to a peace keeping role, but as far as the infighting between the different tribes are concerned, there is no peace. Arrowood Hobbs, a young private in his early twenties, is guarding the northernmost end of the American Zone, Zulu, it is here he meets Benson, a journalist embedded with the army. Before the day is over a young boy will be saved and a young Iraqi girl in a green dress dead. This death will have serious effects on both of these men and their future lives. They will reunite twenty years later because of another girl in green. A ill advised quest for redemption. Written with a great deal of ironic humor, pop references abound, a book that highlights the absurdity of war. So much to understand in the Middle East, and this book shows how little is understood, despite many agencies and their efforts. It is at times an edge of your seat thriller, a political nightmare, an a PR challenge. What we see on television is only what they want us to see, not too surprising. I loved these characters, all of them, well except for the bad guys of course, they are unique, well intentioned and just trying to save as many as they can. We also see how the first event, led these two memo to the lives they led.A wonderful, well written story that has once again reiterated how little we know about the various cultures, tribes, affiliations in the Middle East. Meddling in things in which we never should have gotten involve. At times reading this book, this was confusing, but I loved the main story and on that is what I focused. The author is well qualified, and has a unique understanding of this region as one can see if they read his bio. Fascinating, informative and another great offering from this author.ARC from publisher.
1 person found this helpful
- Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5THE GIRL IN GREEN works well as a pretty good thriller, but better as a commentary on how the good intentions of the West in the Middle East were subverted by incompetence. Following the Gulf War, soldiers were forced to sit around and watch Saddam Hussein’s soldiers massacre thousands of Kurds and Shia Muslims. The cold blooded execution of the girl in green by a Baathist colonel serves both as a striking metaphor for the West’s passivity in the face of this atrocity and as a source of guilt for the two protagonists of the novel— Thomas Benton and Arwood Hobbes.This murder was only one of several images highlighting a level of incompetence reminiscent of Joseph Heller’s iconic anti war novel “Catch 22.” Indeed there is no shortage of other images of ineptitude. We are treated to an hilarious scene depicting an Air Force airdrop of frozen chickens onto starving Iraqi refugees and aid workers; Arwood’s inability to receive much needed psychological counseling because that benefit was reserved for those “not really needing it;” an incompetent junior officer berating Arwood for daring to get involved in local matters following his heroic rescue of Benton and attempt to save the girl in green; and soldiers helplessly standing around while a child is trapped in a minefield. Innocent children seem to be Miller’s most compelling image.The true heroes of this novel are the humanitarian relief workers, primarily represented by Märta Strom, a Swedish Red Cross agent who has been stoically working to salvage shreds of humanity under the most adverse and dangerous of conditions for the two decades covered by the novel. She also plays a key role in rescuing the two protagonists when they embark on a risky and quixotic mission to rescue another girl in green 22 years following the original execution. Miller’s choice to set the main action of his novel 22 years following the original murder is inspired for three reasons. First, it highlights how the original Middle Eastern intervention by the West never resolved anything. In fact, it exacerbated the terror, giving rise of ISIS, accompanied by threats of torture, intimidation, ransoming, roadblocks and random executions. Second, the protagonists have evolved. Hobbes is now a gunrunner, still located in the Middle East, and Benton is a 63-year-old burnout in a failing marriage and unable to connect with his adult daughter. Third, a 22 year hiatus congers images of the famous “Catch 22.”Both Benton and Hobbes are fully realized and nuanced characters that travel arcs. In 1991, Benton is ambitious and curious about ferreting out the truth of events in Hussein’s Iraq following the Gulf War. In 2013, he is reluctant to get involved in Hobbes’ harebrained adventure to rescue a girl in green he saw on a video and believes is the same one they could not save in 1991. Hobbes is aptly named for Thomas Hobbes, the political philosopher who maintained that government was the main bulwark between society and chaos. In “Leviathan,” Thomas Hobbes described what he called man’s “natural state” that would evolve in the absence of political structure with words that are eerily evocative of the Middle East today (“…continual fear, and danger of violent death; and the life of man, solitary, poor, nasty, brutish, and short.”). Arwood Hobbes starts as a naive private from the American heartland who evinces a strong sense of honesty and honor. He may be quite brave, or just reckless and a little insane. These latter traits lead to a general discharge from the Army and, following some floundering, a career as a gunrunner. Miller taps into his experience in Iraq to give us a thriller that is both darkly humorous and iconoclastic. Obviously he feels strongly about the mistakes that were made in the Middle East and occasionally becomes a little too didactic. Yet he provides a thrilling story and refrains from providing facile answers.
1 person found this helpful
- Rating: 5 out of 5 stars5/5I loved Norwegian by Night, still think about Sheldon Horowitz on some days, and I loved this book too. It is a totally different story and done just as well. The location of Iraq, during two different periods of our involvement in the country, meshed well together. Even if some of the situations and actions of the two protagonists are a little unbelievable, it is a novel of fiction with a satisfying story line that you are drawn into in the first chapter.The first two reviewers have given a detailed synopsis of the book so no need to reiterate the plot line. However, the character of Arwood is every bit the unlikely hero that Sheldon was in Norwegian by Night. Derek Miller is an exceptional novelist and I look forward to his next book as well as his next subject for that book.
1 person found this helpful
Book preview
The Girl in Green - Derek B. Miller
Contents
Title Page
Contents
Copyright
Dedication
Author’s Note
An Early Spring
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
The Long, Cold, Hard, and Dark of It
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
Other Than Honorable
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
Acknowledgments
Reading Group Guide
Q&A with Derek B. Miller
Sample Chapter from NORWEGIAN BY NIGHT
Buy the Book
About the Author
Connect with HMH
First Mariner Books edition 2018
Copyright © 2016 by Derek B. Miller
Reading Group Guide © 2018 by Derek B. Miller
Q&A with Author © 2016 by Corey Valhos
All rights reserved
For information about permission to reproduce selections from this book, write to [email protected] or to Permissions, Houghton Mifflin Harcourt Publishing Company, 3 Park Avenue, 19th Floor, New York, New York 10016.
First published in Australia and New Zealand by Scribe in 2016
www.hmhco.com
Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data
Names: Miller, Derek (Derek B.), author.
Title: The girl in green / Derek B. Miller.
Description: First U.S. edition. | Boston : Houghton Mifflin Harcourt, 2017.
Identifiers: LCCN 2016005409 (print) | LCCN 2016008840 (ebook) | ISBN 9780544706255 (hardcover) | ISBN 9780544706279 (ebook)
ISBN 9781328745507 (pbk.)
Subjects: LCSH: Life change events—Fiction. | Journalists—Fiction. | Soldiers—Fiction. | BISAC: FICTION / General. | FICTION / War & Military. | FICTION / Literary.
Classification: LCC PS3613.I5337 G57 2017 (print) | LCC PS3613.I5337 (ebook) | DDC 813/.6—dc23
LC record available at http://lccn.loc.gov/2016005409
Cover design by Brian Moore
Cover image © Zmicier Kavabata / Shutterstock
v2.0118
For my wife
Inspired by many actual events
PART I
An Early Spring
1991
1
Arwood Hobbes was bored. Not regular bored. Not your casual, rainy-day, Cat in the Hat–style bored that arrives with the wet, leaving you with nothing to do. It wasn’t post-fun or pre-excitement bored, either. It was, somehow, different. It felt rare and deliberate, entire and complete, industrial and inescapable. It was the kind of bored that had you backstroking in the green mist of eternity wondering about the big questions without searching for answers. And it wasn’t in short supply, either, because it was being dispensed like candy on Halloween to Arwood and others like him at Checkpoint Zulu at the rim of the Euphrates Valley, in the heart of Iraq, by the world’s largest contractor of boredom: the United States Army.
How long had he been bored? How long was he destined to be bored? Arwood couldn’t even muster the motivation to care as he melted over his machine gun under the hot, hot sun that was pressing down on the sandy sand around him without a raindrop in sight and no one offering to cheer him up.
The M60 machine gun was the perfect height for leaning on. It was probably the perfect height for firing, too, but Arwood had no proof of that because he hadn’t fired the gun since qualifying on it, and there was nothing to aim at because everything was far away, apart from a camel; and while he did point the gun at the camel for a while, it ultimately seemed a mean thing to do, so he stopped. That was eons ago. Nothing fun like that had happened since. Even the camel had gone away.
It wasn’t that Arwood was unfamiliar with being bored and that his resistance was low. After all, Operation Desert Storm—now over—had really been just a month-long air campaign on exposed Iraqi troops followed by a four-day ground war, which meant there wasn’t a lot of ground war for him or his buddies, or much for people on the ground to actually do. For Arwood, the Gulf War primarily involved him doing a lot of nothing for three months in the sand, jogging expectantly beside an APC with his gun for a few days, only to be told it was over.
But at least back then there had been a sense that something might happen. There was a sense of possibility.
Not anymore.
Possibility was but a popped balloon for Arwood.
And at the very moment they were all expected to go home, his company drew the shortest of short straws and they’d been deployed here to Checkpoint Zulu, 240 kilometers from the Kuwaiti border. He had no idea why. This time there was nothing to look forward to but peace. Endless, tedious, nondescript, fluffy-white peace.
You could eat a grenade, you really could.
It was into this stagnant vortex of quietude and forenothingness that a form approached Arwood from across the desert.
Like everything else in Iraq, it came at him sideways.
Arwood didn’t look. He sort of liked not knowing. Perhaps it was a guy wearing sandals who had a beard like Jesus. Or maybe it wasn’t a man at all. Maybe it was the Ghost of Christmas Yet to Come who was doing his rounds and was there to let Arwood know that—on account of global warming, acid rain, and El Niño, not to mention the global shortage of decent people and the high price of coal—Christmas was going to be canceled.
Whatever it was was getting bigger, which probably meant it was getting closer. It probably wasn’t something dangerous, though; it was approaching from this side of the ceasefire line. But it wasn’t going to be anything good, either. It wasn’t going to be one of Charlie’s Angels. It wasn’t going to be Daisy Duke. It wasn’t going to be Kelly LeBrock in her blue-and-white panties appearing out of red mist from a doorway. No, it was probably going to be orders.
A different mind, a different person, might have welcomed orders because it would have ushered in change.
Not Arwood. The only thing worse than boredom was labor, and he didn’t want to wash anything, dig anything, move anything, stack anything, fill anything, load anything, unload anything, peel anything, or—and this was critical—smell anything awful. Given that he was twenty-two and a private, rather than, say, fifty and a nuclear physicist, all these things were on the shortlist of the possible.
No, he wasn’t going to look up. He would cherish the uncertainty for as long as he could.
Which fate had decided would end right . . . about . . . now.
Want a cigarette?
asked a man who was now man-sized and to his right.
The man stood next to Arwood’s sandbags. Arwood considered them his sandbags, not so much because he was manning a machine gun behind them as because he was the one who had filled them.
Arwood accepted the cigarette by opening his mouth. The man placed it in and lit it. Arwood inhaled, grateful only that it gave him a pretext to keep breathing.
I’m Thomas Benton,
the man said.
Uh-huh.
What’s your name?
Arwood Hobbes.
Hobbes. Interesting name to take into a war zone.
Why?
No reason. Where are you from?
America.
Yes, I figured, given the uniform. Any place special?
Never felt like it.
I’m from a village in Cornwall,
Benton offered.
I don’t know where that is.
Cornwall is in England.
That’s overseas, right?
Yes.
Thomas Benton squatted down behind Arwood’s sandbags because it was cool and shady there. Benton looked across the desert to the still town a kilometer and a half away.
You’re a journalist?
"Yes. The Times."
Arwood did not move from his resting position. When is this war gonna end?
What?
The war.
It did. The war is over. This is the peace. Now the lawyers are drafting the UN permanent-ceasefire resolution.
We’re waiting for paperwork?
It’s the Western way of war. Even Hitler filed his paperwork. Without it we become confused. What’s your job?
I’m maintaining a vigilant perimeter.
Safwan,
Benton said, if you’re curious, is way back there. That’s where your general, Stormin’ Norman, met the Iraqi high command. It is also where he made the mistake of letting them fly helicopters, which is what they are using to kill everyone connected to the uprisings down south and up north. It’s a bloodbath.
I thought that was Safwan,
Arwood said, not bothering to motion to the town at the end of his machine gun.
That’s Samawah.
When do I get to go home?
The Americans are the ones sticking around the longest, though some of you shipped out on the seventeenth. It could be a while.
Arwood finally moved his head by shaking it. It’s not fair that we have to sit around here like the Breakfast Club.
Benton shrugged and wiped his face with a red bandanna. He was not smoking. He had eaten something in the morning that disagreed with him, and he’d opted not to push his luck further with a cigarette.
It might not be calm for long. You should try and enjoy it.
Arwood perked up. What do you mean?
Doesn’t your commanding officer explain all this to you?
You mean Harvey?
I don’t know his name.
Lieutenant Harvey Morgan. No, he doesn’t explain anything. He’s full of shit, and never makes sense because he keeps reading quotes from the government, and they speak in riddles. What do you mean it won’t be calm for long?
The Iraqi civil war. It’ll have to get here eventually. You see that green flag over there? On top of that onion-shaped water tower?
Benton pointed to a tower in the middle of the town.
Yeah. If you watch it really, really closely for hours, it sometimes moves,
Arwood said.
It’s a Shiite flag. That means they’ve overthrown the Sunni government in the city. It’s only a matter of time before Saddam sends troops here to change that back.
Uh-huh.
You’re actually in the eye of a storm. You are the American soldier deepest in Iraqi territory. Did you know that?
Why are you here?
Arwood asked. At my post?
The view, mainly. It’s as close as I can get without crossing the demarcation line. I’m embedded in your company. I’ve been reporting on what’s been happening with your fellows.
Which is nothing.
Well, there was the mass surrender.
Yeah. That was fun.
Arwood had enjoyed the mass surrender. Once the war reached its tipping point, all the Iraqi soldiers gave up. A French journalist had reported that Saddam had forbidden his soldiers to wear white underwear lest they use it to surrender. Arwood had wondered about the mechanics of that. Usually you surrender in really dire circumstances, which is not when you want to be taking your pants off.
Arwood had become chatty with the POWs when they flowed to his location in late February. That was much farther south, and before they were deployed here. There was a certain affability to the Iraqi conscripts. Sure, they were the enemy and all that, but their accent was endearing, every one of them had a Groucho Marx mustache, and they were incredibly sincere about their desire to give up. There was very little not to like about them once they stopped shooting at you.
There’s nothing happening now, though,
Arwood said.
Not here. But there is over there. And the world would like to know what it is. Or at least I’d like to think they would.
Is being English the same as being British?
Arwood asked.
No. England is part of Britain. Which is also made up of Wales and—
So who banned all that music?
It didn’t connect until now, because Arwood had never met anyone British before, but word had gotten down to the troops that their allies—the British—were banning antiwar music back home, and so a good deal of time was spent ragging on them about it in their absence. On the BBC’s blackout list were
We Gotta Get Out of This Place,
by the Animals;
Walk Like an Egyptian,
by the Bangles;
Killing Me Softly,
by Roberta Flack;
Two Tribes,
by Frankie Goes to Hollywood;
War,
by Edwin Starr; and
Everybody Wants to Rule the World,
by Tears for Fears.
That was you, right?
Arwood said.
It was the BBC.
They really thought a bunch of straight dudes were gonna sing Roberta Flack in the desert?
What you have to understand about the BBC—
So you’re sitting here with me because you want this civil war thing to get started, and you want a front-row seat?
Well, no. That’s not fair,
Benton said. I do have questions, though. The kind that can only be answered over there,
he said, pointing to Samawah. Right now, no one knows anything. We’re getting our news from radio broadcasts coming out of Iran and Syria. It’s all ignorance, rumor, and frustration. I’d like to ask them some questions of my own.
Like what?
Like what? Really? Well, like . . . Did you plan this revolution? Are you getting support from Iran? Who is in charge? What are your aspirations? Do you want to see a whole and stable Iraq, or do you want a new state and to see it carved up along religious and ethnic lines? Or no state at all? Is this the return of the Islamic umma? Can you work with the Sunni after the way you were treated by Saddam? Are you prepared to cooperate with the West? Under what conditions? Are you coordinating with the Kurdish resistance up north? If so, how? Is there a unified command structure? Do you see yourself forming one? How well armed are you? What kind of training—
Yeah, OK, political stuff. I got it.
It’s the future of the Middle East. In fact, it’s the future of the post–Cold War order. In that village, in the ideas of those people, are the first clues about whether this brave new world of ours will maintain the colonially imposed and Cold War–sustained state system, or—
Do Arabs eat ice cream?
That’s the question burning a hole in your mind?
I have a follow-up.
Yes. They do.
What kind of ice cream?
The usual stuff. Why?
I want one.
OK,
said Benton.
And I’ve got an idea that I was thinking up while you were talking. You want to report on all that political stuff from that village, right?
I suppose I do, yes.
I want an ice cream, and you said they probably have one there.
You think it’s a good idea for me to go to the town and get you an ice cream?
You sort of implied you might be going.
Benton sat in the sand. He dug grooves in the earth with the heels of his boots. He’d been in the region since February 28, the day President Bush declared this a victory for the United Nations, for all mankind, for the rule of law, and for what is right.
Benton’s wife, Vanessa, had argued it was not a good day to leave her or their ten-year-old daughter, Charlotte, behind. Given that the war was over, she’d said, there was no good reason to be there, and it was dangerous. He’d said questions remained that no one was asking, because victory is always exciting and therefore wasn’t when people probed for details. He’d said he’d be back in a few weeks. A visit into a rebel-held city—even for a few hours—could justify the cost.
Benton looked across the windless landscape to the listless Shiite flag. Something significant had already happened there, and something else was going to. He was sure of it. Saddam had forbidden journalists to enter the country, but so what? He was shy of his fortieth birthday and hadn’t won any prizes. It was impressive to be at the Times, but he was among the rank and file and he’d never distinguished himself. A visit to Samawah could change all that.
It was an interesting idea.
There was a downside to the plan, though, and being almost forty rather than in his early twenties, like Arwood, Benton still had some reverence for the wider systems of authority and power that made his journalism possible. You fall out with those and you’re out. He was talking to Arwood to manipulate the situation, yes, but he was still on the edge about whether to walk the literal mile.
I was told not to wander off-base or I’d lose my press credentials,
he said.
Arwood field-stripped his spent cigarette and flicked the pieces into what should have been wind.
If you follow the rules all the time, you don’t really have any press credentials, do you?
Huh,
said Benton.
It is my experience—and I learned this the hard way, believe me—that the trick to getting what you want without getting caught—and this is the important part—is not getting caught.
And how do you do that?
Benton asked.
I just told you. Don’t get caught.
That feels a bit circular.
Arwood never took his eyes off the distant buildings and the absolute nothing that was happening over in the town. Now that he had the idea of an ice cream firmly planted in his mind—which was seeping down into his very soul and filling it with strawberries—he could picture swarms of ten-year-olds suddenly bursting into the corner store and tearing open every remaining Popsicle, leaving nothing for him but sticky wrappers. It was a dark image.
I have this theory that everything you truly need to know,
Arwood said, "I mean, deep down and for the duration, can be learned from Ferris Bueller’s Day Off. The fact that there was no sequel only proves that there was nothing left to say. To me, the army is Principal Ed Rooney, and you need to be Ferris."
If I go, you won’t tell anyone?
I’m not paid to keep you in. I’m paid to keep them out.
They don’t have Ben and Jerry’s. Mostly Popsicles. Also they might not have any. There were economic sanctions after Kuwait was invaded, and there’s been a war since. And it could melt by the time I’m back.
I’m prepared for you to take that risk.
Are you sure you’ll be there when I return? I don’t want to get shot as I approach the checkpoint. How’s your eyesight?
Come back the way you came. I’ll be here all day. Same bat time, same bat channel.
I don’t have any money,
Benton said.
No charge, dude.
No, for the ice cream. I need to buy it. I’m not going to steal an ice cream, am I?
I . . . hadn’t considered that,
said Arwood. You don’t think he’ll be friendly and give you one?
He might, but it’s presumptuous. I think it’s inappropriate to ask, and if he gives me a gift, it’s customary practice that I return the gesture with a gift of my own.
It really is like a whole different place over here, isn’t it?
Arwood was no longer leaning on the gun. He had perked up like a flower exposed to sunlight at the thought of an ice cream. I don’t have any money either. What kind of gift?
Something of the same value and significance as an ice cream, otherwise he’ll feel further in my debt and want to even things out, which is not what we want here,
Benton said.
OK . . .
Arwood bent down and pulled a comic book from his rucksack. How about this Amazing Spider-Man #312, Green Goblin versus the Hobgoblin? It’s from 1989, and I paid a buck. It isn’t current, but the trade is only for an ice cream, so I think it’s fair. There’s got to be some kid over there who hasn’t read it yet.
I don’t know if they read comic books.
Jesus. How foreign are they?
Fine, give it to me,
said Benton, who stood up, dusted himself off, and put the comic book in his own rucksack, beside his camera and incidentals.
So you’re going?
It’s half-twelve now . . .
Huh?
It’s twelve-thirty now,
Benton translated, and I figure I can walk there in half an hour, spend about three hours or so interviewing, and be back by four o’clock, which is well before dark. You’re sure you’ll still be here?
I’m on until eighteen hundred.
I really don’t want to get shot coming back.
I will not let anything happen to you. I promise.
"All right then. Audaces fortuna iuvat, right?" said Benton.
I don’t know about that, but Ferris got Mia Sara.
2
Benton drank from a bottle of water as he walked toward Samawah under the blue dome of heaven. His feet were hot. He wore cheap socks that were woven with nylon and polyester. He knew better, but had still done nothing about it when it came time to pack. They couldn’t breathe as he stepped from rock to rock across the broken earth toward the squat city and its muted people. This always put him in a mood.
Closer, he found the small city unremarkable. He might have been in Jordan, or the West Bank, or Bahrain as he looked at the flat roofs and the canopy of satellite dishes made dirty from the sand and the winds and the absence of rain or the social pressure to clean them. Around the city was its litter—the discarded refrigerators and tires, the bed frames and canvas bags. There was no topsoil. There was surely a proper reason for this, but Benton imagined that too many feet had walked here for too long in search of too much.
He approached a derelict oil truck in a wide and unused parking zone. Someone had painted, in giant white letters, We want Fredum. Bleads help Iraq peple.
Benton put the empty bottle of water back into his satchel, intending to throw it in a bin later.
He checked his watch. Dhuhr prayer was around 11:30, and Asr prayer shouldn’t be until around three-ish. He figured he had a workable window to get oriented and at least conduct a few discussions.
Towns have eyes in the Middle East. This one, however, felt blind—as though it were resting in the midday sun in preparation for a long stretch of work in the cooling night yet to come.
A boy appeared. He was thin, twelve years old, and carrying a platter of glasses of tea over his shoulder like a French waiter. The boy wore sandals and had thick black hair. He was unhurried, and focused on his task of delivering tea and lunch to the shopkeepers.
When the boy saw Benton, he stopped and fixed himself to the earth, paralyzed. Eyes wide, he was motionless until an inner force shot into his limbs, making him jerk erratically. He twitched his head right and left and back to Benton, as though Benton might issue instructions that would end his indecision.
Benton could hear the glasses rattle on the thin silver platter as they amplified the boy’s vibrations and started dancing to the arrhythmia of his heart. Soon enough the cups could not keep up. One by one the cups fell, smashing themselves on the hard earth, and the sweet water poured from the platter onto the boy’s feet, scalding his exposed toes and forcing the boy to join in the dance he had inadvertently started.
Hopping in pain, the boy dropped the platter, and he turned and ran as fast as he could, back the way he had come.
Not loudly enough, not by a long shot, Benton called out, I’m not going to hurt you. I promise.
But the promise never reached the boy’s ears, and in a moment he was gone.
Alone again, Benton trudged toward the first buildings and into a narrow alley between them. It was shadier between the buildings, and cooler. He paused to scratch one foot with the other through his leather boots. It was unsatisfying. He’d have to take the boot off, and perhaps the sock as well.
Kneeling with his shoe untied, Benton heard a rumbling ahead of him, through the mouth of the light and narrow alley. It sounded like water. It was an impossible notion, but he half expected a tidal wave to come bursting into the passageway, a crest of salty white foam gushing around him to his waist, to flood his boots and cool his feet.
It was only when they were almost upon him that he understood the sound as a wave of human voices, foreign and excited.
His shoe tied, he stood and looked back, unconvinced by either choice of staying or going. The choice was made for him as he deliberated. They poured in as a flood to a wadi. They were silhouetted by the bright light of the Iraqi sun, and in that moment they overtook him and drowned him. Hands gripped him, and he shielded his face as people started pulling him, surrounding him, and pushing him out into the city. They called and yelled in Arabic. His bag was pulled from his shoulder, and he was no longer sure of anything at all.
He shouted for them to wait, but his voice failed him for the second time in Samawah. There were too many people, too much emotion. When his head struck something hard, he fell to the ground.
Benton did not pass out. He was, however, bloodied and incapacitated. Two men were holding him up. They smelled bad. Their shirts were made of cotton and were sweaty. He couldn’t see their faces. There was blood in his eyes. It came from his head. He raised a hand to find the source. He was pulled into a building and then pushed into a chair. There was a voice.
American?
Benton couldn’t see who’d asked the question. The man was standing too close. The smell of all the people was overpowering. The sunlight was poking through the spaces around the man’s face and through the shoulders of those around him.
American?
the man said.
I’m British,
Benton said.
American?
British, for Christ’s sake.
English?
Yes, yes. I can’t breathe.
The dark face in front of him yelled something in Arabic and then stood up, pushing the other people back. He shushed the people around him, bringing silence, order, and calm.
He handed Benton a cloth and a bottle of water.
Thank you,
Benton said.
Who are you?
"I’m Thomas Benton. I’m a journalist with the Times. I’m here to understand what’s happened and to learn what you’re all going to do next. I’m . . . I’m hurt. I don’t want to upset anyone or get anyone else hurt. Can we talk?"
There was mumbling and then Benton said, Do you speak English?
Yes, yes. Everyone speaks English. Everyone-everyone. You are not American? You are not here to help us?
No. I’m a journalist.
In the quiet and uninterrupted moment that followed, Benton was able to look around and see where he was.
He wasn’t in a cave dwelling or an Iraqi torture chamber. He wasn’t even in a boxy apartment with barred windows and a dubbed Western television set playing in the background. He was in a pharmacy—a pharmacy that stocked L’Oréal hair products and Halls lozenges and was having a 20 percent off sale on reading glasses if you used 1.50 magnification and didn’t mind wearing orange.
The man who had been too close stood back and pulled a white plastic chair across the concrete floor. Sitting, he rubbed his face with a tissue and placed it in his jacket pocket.
What is going to happen to Saddam?
the man said.
I beg your pardon?
Benton said, wiping his own face with his red bandanna.
Saddam. We need to know what you are going to do with Saddam. What is our future?
I came here to ask you the same question.
The man shook his head. No. This made no sense to him.
You have an army. Big army. You drive Saddam out of Kuwait. OK. Now what? You take Saddam away?
Well . . . no.
Why not?
The international coalition was formed to restore Kuwait and secure the borders.
OK, OK, but the problem is Saddam. We fought a war with Iran, then Kuwait, then America. Always war because of Saddam. So . . . now it’s time to get rid of Saddam, yes?
Isn’t that what you’re doing?
Benton asked. He felt a cut on his head. Why did someone hit me?
No, no. Sorry, your head hit the wall. People were very excited to get news. You are a journalist. So . . . you have news.
No. I’m here to get the news from you, and report it in Britain.
They don’t need the news. We need the news. Are you going to get rid of Saddam?
It’s our understanding,
Benton tried to explain, that you’re having a revolution. That you’re getting rid of Saddam. I’m here to understand your plans. You’ve already taken the city. There’s a Shiite flag on the water tank. Are you being supported by Iran? Are you hoping—
Another man, wearing the white coat of a pharmacist, interjected. Benton didn’t understand what he said, but the crowd started to disperse, and the man he’d been speaking with nodded, stood up from his chair, tapped the arms of a few people, and then walked out.
The pharmacist looked at Benton’s wound. I told them we were not being good hosts, that you need some help first and we can discuss this all over some food and tea. Clearly you want to talk to us, and we want to talk to you. We should do it properly. Times are very delicate. Very delicate. I can tell you this, though: the answers to the questions you are asking don’t exist yet. I was educated as a chemist. In chemistry, the answers are out there, waiting to be found. But in life, in politics, in war, the answers aren’t there yet. Your whole profession has a very strange theory in the middle.
My head hurts,
said Benton, not only feeling a throbbing in his head but starting to hear it, too.
I’ll get you some aspirin, unless you’re allergic. The Republican Guard took most of it. We have a few left. I’d like to put a bandage on you, too.
Yes. Fine. Thank you.
The pharmacist shooed people out of the shop on his way to a small cabinet. He used a tiny key to unlock it and removed a white plastic bottle.
How are you?
Benton asked.
How am I?
he said.
Yes. How are you?
Worried. Very, very worried. But thank you for asking.
The pharmacist was pressing down on the childproof cap when he stopped and looked at Benton. They could both hear it. It was as if the air were being sucked from the room and pushed back in, quickly and repeatedly.
What is that?
Benton asked.
3
Arwood had always liked helicopters. When he was a little boy, he’d make them in Legos with his uncle, who would come over sometimes when his father was out
and his mother was indisposed. It has always been one of his fondest and quietest memories from childhood.
When Arwood was ten, they moved on to models with glue and paint. Models worked for them as a shared activity, because it set them on a common task and didn’t require much talk about why they were together instead of Arwood being with his parents. The less they talked, the more helicopters and other machines they would build. They liked to look up the specifications of the aircraft from a dated copy of Jane’s World Air Forces that Uncle Maxwell had bought at a library sale.
Now he was twenty-two years old, and from this distance it actually looked like a model. It was about the same size. He felt a thrill at first as the massive gunship floated over the ridge and approached the city. The Mi-24 was a primary component of Iraq’s order of battle and had been used to devastating effect only three years earlier in the war against Iran. It was a Soviet-built brute of a vehicle, with all the charmless industrial hostility that the Cold War could create. It had twin cockpits, one above and behind the other, both encased in glass. To the sides were two massive wings with a twenty-one-foot wingspan. At the front was a 12.7mm Gatling gun with a payload of some 1,500 rounds of ammunition. Under the wings were rocket launchers and mine-dispenser pods. And backing it up, at its six o’clock, was an Aérospatiale Gazelle helicopter, built in France. Together they formed a hunter-killer team.
Just like his models.
However, the angle of attack proved to Arwood that, unlike in Iran or in his basement, this team was not going to be used for war. It was going to kill people—regular, everyday, soft people.
Even at the pinnacle of his earlier boredom, Arwood hadn’t been more than a quarter mile away from the base and had had a radio. Looking back across the