The Eternity Key
By Bree Despain
4/5
()
About this ebook
Fan-favorite author Bree Despain continues her modern-day romance trilogy inspired by the Greek myth of Persephone and Hades with this second book in her Into the Dark series.
Haden Lord, the disgraced Prince of the Underrealm, has chosen love over honor and will do everything in his power to protect Daphne Raines, the human girl he was supposed to bring to the Underrealm. Haden's choice is put to the test as the Skylords and a figure from his past arrive in Olympus Hills with a plan that could destroy all of the realms.
Embracing her destiny as the Cypher, Daphne begins to understand the immense power of her musical ability to control the elements, but she must come to terms with her feelings for Haden and what she must sacrifice in order to protect him and her friends.
Believing the Key of Hades is the only thing that can stop the Underrealm Court from releasing the monstrous Keres on the mortal world, Haden, Daphne, and their friends set out to find the Key before Persephone's Gate opens again on the spring equinox.
Bree Despain
Bree Despain is the author of The Dark Divine trilogy and the Into the Dark trilogy. She currently lives in Salt Lake City, Utah, with her husband and two sons. Visit her online at www.breedespain.com.
Read more from Bree Despain
The Shadow Prince Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Immortal Throne Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5
Related to The Eternity Key
YA Romance For You
Caraval Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Summer I Turned Pretty Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Red Queen Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Legendary: A Caraval Novel Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5It's Not Summer Without You Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Better Than the Movies Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Shatter Me Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Cinderella Is Dead Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Heartless Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5We'll Always Have Summer Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Unravel Me Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Out of Darkness Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Finale: A Caraval Novel Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Legendborn Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5These Violent Delights Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5They Both Die at the End Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Selection Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Forever . . . Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Ace of Spades Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Giver Quartet Omnibus Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5To All the Boys I've Loved Before Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Ignite Me Rating: 5 out of 5 stars5/5Sabriel Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5This Woven Kingdom Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Wuthering Heights Complete Text with Extras Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Destroy Me Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5My Lady Jane Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Foul Lady Fortune Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Poet X Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Do-Over Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5
Reviews for The Eternity Key
4 ratings1 review
- Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5A fun book two for the series. I usually enjoy Despain's novels, and I did with this one. It took me a bit to remember what was happening in the storyline, but Despain did a great job at bringing everything back to the reader without a big info dump at the beginning.It's fun to read a retold Greek myth with a modern-day twist. It will be interesting what happens in now that they are in the underworld and how their story will be resolved.
Book preview
The Eternity Key - Bree Despain
chapter one
HADEN
Lord Haden, prince of the Underrealm, has ceased to exist.
I have ceased to exist.
Since I was a nursling, I’d been taught that life is nothing but a thin golden string. It’s spun and entwined in a grand tapestry of the gods’ design, then pulled and severed at a predetermined length. Nothing can be done to change this, nothing can be said, and no bargain can be made. Once your thread has been measured—that’s it. No choice. It’s the will of the Fates.
I’d believed this myth every second of my existence, and yet, as I’d learned all too recently, if you clawed at the design hard enough, the tapestry would unravel just enough that you could grab on to another string. Follow another path.
Since that realization, I have burned the connection between myself and my realm, ruined what little standing I had reclaimed as a Champion chosen by the Oracle of Elysium, and destroyed all hope of becoming my father’s heir. I brought this upon myself with a single decision.
And I would do it all over again.
Because this is a fate of my own choosing.
I am rewriting my destiny.
Something I didn’t even know was an option until I met her.
Daphne Raines—the girl who was supposed to grant me the chance to win back my honor. I had been Chosen for a quest to the mortal realm to convince her to come back with me to the underworld. It quickly became clear that there was something special about her. She wasn’t a mere Boon to fill the harem of the Court.
Daphne is the fated Cypher—the only one who can find and retrieve the lost Kronolithe of my long-dead god: the Key of Hades.
I knew it was up to me to ensure that the Kronolithe was found, and use it to stop the Court of the Underrealm from breaking through the walls of the Pits and freeing the Keres. There would be terrible consequences if they were to take this action: all hell would break loose on the mortal world, spilling out from the schism created between the realms, and war with the Skylords would inevitably follow, not to mention the death toll and havoc the Keres would leave in their wake.
With the fate of the five realms hanging in the balance, I’d chosen to leave the safe haven we’d found in Ellis Fields in order to return to Olympus Hills to search for the Key.
Much to my surprise—and admittedly distress—Daphne and the others had chosen to go with me. Even if you find it,
she’d said, "you can’t get the Kronolithe without me, so suck it." I’d known she was right, even though I had wanted her to be wrong. Because of our choices, our new destinies were now irrevocably entwined. If the realms can be saved, salvation will happen only if we do it united.
And so we’d escaped into the dark, together.…
Rain pounds on the hood of my car now as I sit outside Daphne’s home in Olympus Hills. I realize I am gripping my steering wheel tight, as if I were once again silently maneuvering the Tesla Model X down an unlit canyon road in a torrential rainstorm without headlights. It had been a slow, tense, and quiet escape during the darkness of midnight. No one said a word for almost an hour, as if even a whisper might alert the Skylords of our presence or break my concentration on the wet, black road in front of us.
In our favor, Underlords see far better in the dark than Skylords do, and the Tesla, with its silent electric motor, had provided us the stealth we needed to make our exit. The Skylords, who can control rain as well as lightning and thunder, had intended the storm to prevent us from escaping, but instead it had provided the cover we needed to pass through the unlit canyon unseen. However, the mere memory of that storm is enough to raise the hairs on the back of my neck. I had never been so terrified in all my life—not even when facing the imminent destruction of my soul at my father’s hands. Because, this time, the lives of Daphne, Joe, Tobin, Lexie, Garrick, and Dax—the only people left in all the realms who still believed in me—were in my hands as we crept along the cliffside road.
It may have been two weeks since that harrowing experience, but sitting in the rain now not only served as an unwelcome reminder of that long drive, but it also felt like a warning as to what is still to come.
I will one of my hands to release its death grip on the steering wheel and use it to take a swig from the coffee cup that’s been my only company tonight. I gag, almost choking on the cold swill. I don’t know how Simon could have loved this stuff. I take another sip, not because I want to taste it again, but because I need to stay awake. I’ve barely slept a scant few hours in the days since our return from Ellis. I may require less sleep than a human, but even I have my limits.
As if Dax can read my thoughts—which I am not entirely sure he can’t sometimes—my phone lights up with a text from him.
Dax: You’re there again, aren’t you? Come home.
I stare at the screen, not sure I am going to reply, when another message comes through.
Dax: You’ve barely slept in weeks. You can’t keep up this pace of looking for the Key all day and guarding Daphne’s house all night.
I pry my other hand from the steering wheel to answer.
Me: I’m not at Daphne’s. I am merely getting a bite to eat.
Typing it feels easier than saying it to his face. I’ve never been good at lying to Dax. I drop my phone in an empty compartment in the dash, hoping that will be the last of the conversation, and pinch my nose between my eyes. Sleep pulls at me, but I won’t let my eyelids shut.
I grip my coffee cup with both hands, sending a small pulse of electric heat from my palms into it, hoping to warm it up enough to make it palatable again. An abrupt knock sounds against the passenger-side window. I jump in my seat, and a surge of electricity escapes my hands, nearly incinerating the cardboard cup before I drop it in my lap. I hold my hand out, blue light crackling between my fingers, toward the car door as it swings open.
A tiny gray cat jumps through the dark opening, landing on the passenger seat. She yowls at me.
Hello to you, too, Brim,
I say, knowing I’ve been caught.
I extinguish the lightning in my hand and pick up the cup from my coffee-stained lap, wishing I hadn’t warmed the contents quite so much. Brim jumps over the center console onto my shoulder as Dax follows her into the car. He settles himself into the passenger seat and pulls the door shut. His hair is damp, and rain has soaked the shoulders of his jacket.
Liar,
he says, not looking at me as he digs into a paper sack that he’s brought with him.
You used Brim to track me?
I ask, not realizing that is still a sore spot until I say it. Brim and I share a special bond, and because of it, she can find me anywhere. Simon exploited that fact to follow Daphne and me to the Oracle in Las Vegas, and that unfortunate choice had resulted in both Simon’s and the Oracle’s deaths. Brim might look like a harmless puff of fur, but Simon had made the mistake of ignoring one of the most steadfast rules of the Underrealm: never get a hellcat angry.
I scratch Brim under her chin to let her know there are no hard feelings about her being used to find me once again. Brim purrs next to my ear.
I used my common sense to find you,
Dax says. Brim came along for the ride. We brought you something.
He fishes in the paper sack.
If that’s another taco, Hades help me …
Since Simon is gone, Dax has taken over most of our meals, which means I’ve had more Mexican takeout in the last two weeks than I’d ever care to have in a lifetime.
It’s chamomile tea,
he says, handing me a capped cup, and pulls out a second for himself. It smells sweeter than the coffee I’ve been nursing all evening, like flowers and honey. I’m about to take a tentative sip when he says, It’ll help you sleep.
I put the tea in a cup holder. I don’t need help sleeping.
Those dark circles under your eyes tell a different story.
What I mean is that I’m not going to sleep. Not when it’s raining.
"You need sleep. Go home."
Brim meows as if agreeing with Dax. Furry little traitor.
"Maybe you didn’t hear me: it’s raining. I can’t leave."
Yeah, Haden, I can see that,
he says, gesturing out the windshield. And it’s just rain. There’s no lightning. No thunder. Rain doesn’t always mean Skylords are about to swoop down on us. Relax. We’re safe.
You can’t know that.
It’s been two weeks.
I don’t like being reminded how much time has passed since we returned to Olympus Hills. I don’t know why I really expected anything different, but part of me had thought we would have found the Key by now. Despite all our searching, we haven’t made any progress. It’s like I can feel every second that ticks by without the Key.
It’s not just the rain that keeps me up at night. It’s the nightmares. The visions of Keres ripping through the realms, devouring everything—and everyone …
I know if I tell Dax about my dreams, he will say that they were just that, dreams, but part of me worries they’re a premonition of what is to come if we don’t find the Key. Just like the rain feels like an omen now.
As if something else were coming …
If the Skylords were coming for us, they would have come by now,
Dax says, and I know my thoughts are painted on my face. All my life, I’ve practiced hiding myself behind an expressionless mask—a necessary skill for someone from a place where emotion and affection are considered weaknesses—but I seem to have lost my knack for it of late. Ever since I let Daphne see the real me …
Deal with it, fearless leader; we got away,
Dax says, and lifts his tea as if proposing a toast in my honor.
A sick feeling washes over me, and I know it’s not from my steady diet of fast-food tacos and coffee. I hit the lever for the windshield wipers, wiping away a thick coat of rainwater. In the distance, I watch one of the lights go out in Daphne’s house. It isn’t her window that goes dark, but I wonder if she was the one who turned out the light. Can she see me out here now?
Her bedroom is in the back of Joe’s mansion. I’d contemplated climbing the fence and camping out under her window, but I’d barely gotten past the point in which Daphne was referring to me as a creep and a stalker, so I didn’t want to push my luck. Instead, I sit in my car like a sentinel. Making sure there’s no sign of trouble.
Making sure she’s safe.
You should tell her.
Dax’s voice is so quiet when he says it, I almost wonder if he said anything at all. No, wait, scratch that,
he says, bolder now. "You need to tell her."
I raise an eyebrow with a noncommittal Huh?
That you’re in love with her, you idiot.
Panic rises up my throat, burning like vomit. Admitting to myself that I am in love with Daphne had been hard enough—and it had taken the imminent threat of my death to get me to do it.
I can’t,
I say.
Affection is weakness, I hear my father’s voice echoing in my head. My jaw aches as I remember his ringed hand slamming into my face when I was a small child. I’d been punished, disowned, stripped of my honor because I’d shown affection for my mother when she died. My love for her had caused me to take a stand against my father, and I’d lost just about everything because of it.
Dax shifts in his seat. Despite what your father and Master Crue and all the other Heirs may have taught you, loving someone isn’t a sin. It isn’t a crime, either.
Love gave you strength. That’s what Daphne had told me when I related the story of my mother’s death to her. Deep down, I’d known she was right. And I know that my love for Daphne was what gave me the strength to stand up to Ren once more—to try to weave my own destiny. But the idea of telling her terrifies me more than the threat of the Skylords and the wrath of the Court combined—because I turned my back on the Underrealm, my father, my chance to be his heir, gave up being a prince, and possibly endangered all the realms, because of my love for Daphne.
That love is all I have left.
It’s the only thing that gives me hope.
And if I confess to her and learn that she does not reciprocate my feelings—then I will have truly lost everything.
My fingers shake as I reach for what remains of my coffee cup instead of the chamomile tea. I can’t,
I say again. Even if I wanted to tell Daphne, I wouldn’t be able to find the words.
Against my will, my thoughts flit to Rowan—my twin brother, the one my father and the Court would have chosen as the Champion to collect Daphne if the Oracle of Elysium had not intervened. Rowan was the one who had a gift for words. He was the smart one. The cunning one.
A small smile plays on my lips because I like to think that even Rowan, with all his manipulative skills, wouldn’t have been able to trick Daphne into falling in love with him enough to return with him to the Underrealm. She’d have seen right through his lies. As far as I know, my brother is incapable of loving anyone other than himself. All he cares about are power and pride.
Then again, only four months ago, before I was sent to the mortal world, before I met Daphne, before I refused to hand her over to my father, all anyone would have said I cared about was getting my honor back.
But I proved I wouldn’t sacrifice her to do it. Rowan would have handed Daphne over without blinking, if he were in my place. He would have done anything necessary to succeed where I had failed.
Dax clears his throat, pulling my thoughts away from Rowan.
So are you hoping that, by sitting outside her house every night, she’ll figure it out on her own?
I don’t sit out here every night. Only when it’s raining.
It’s January in California. It’s rained every night.
It didn’t rain yesterday.
And yet you still found a reason to stay here half the night.
There was rain in the forecast. I needed to know she was safe.
Harpies, Haden. Sometimes rain is just rain. Come home. Unless you know something I don’t know?
I hesitate for a moment. There was something—something I saw when we stopped for breakfast at that diner outside Vegas. The same one where Daphne, Garrick, and I had stopped for lunch on our way to find Sarah, the Oracle, and ended up meeting up with Tobin and Lexie. Thinking we were in the clear after we escaped the rain, we’d stopped for sustenance and to retrieve Lexie’s car. I hadn’t thought anything of the trucker who had been in the diner when we stopped there the first time—just a man in a hat with a scruffy beard who seemed to like pink, creamy looking drinks—but when I saw him there again, at four in the morning no less, I’d started to worry.
I watched him down two of those pink drinks while the others ate piles of what Daphne had referred to as buttermilk pancakes,
then he threw a few bills on the counter and left without giving us a second glance. I’d let myself relax then, even grunted in response when Daphne dared me to try bacon dipped in maple syrup, thinking I’d been a complete lunatic for being anxious about the man—but then I could have sworn that, through the diner’s dirty windows, I saw the man’s truck rumble to life before he even got inside it. As if he’d started it with the brush of his hand over the hood. Like the way I could start my Tesla with my lightning powers.
Much to the others’ protests, I’d insisted we leave as soon as the trucker pulled out of the parking lot. I didn’t mention what I saw because I didn’t see the man or his truck on the road. He wasn’t following us, and he wasn’t up ahead. I’d convinced myself that having my soul fried less than twenty-four hours before, followed by the tense drive out of the canyon, was making my mind play tricks on me. (For all I knew, there had been someone else in the truck to begin with.) And I didn’t feel like contradicting my passengers, who were treating me like I was some kind of Hercules for successfully executing our daring escape from Ellis.
My pride had gotten the better of me then, but the more days that passed and the more rain that fell, I had started to wonder if we had really escaped at all.
No … It’s just a feeling,
I say, my pride getting to me once again. You know. As if I’m still being followed.
They didn’t follow us.
You’re the one who is always telling me to trust my instincts.
Right … But, you know, if someone were watching us, you sitting outside her house every night is pretty much the same as erecting a huge, Vegas-style THE CYPHER LIVES HERE neon sign, right?
I hadn’t thought of that.
And if you kill yourself via sleep deprivation, then you’ll truly be no use to anyone.
Dax places his hand on my shoulder, next to a now-sleeping Brim. How about you let me take up the watch tonight so you can go home and sleep? There is that school thing tomorrow and all.
I try to take a sip of my coffee but all I find are the scalded dregs in my charred cup. Brim’s purring snores next to my ear seem particularly hypnotic. My eyelids feel heavy as I look up at Daphne’s house. All the lights are out now. I’m not going to be much use at school if I fall asleep in class. With Simon gone and Daphne knowing the truth, I normally wouldn’t see the point in continuing with the school charade—except I don’t like the idea of leaving Daphne unprotected all day long. Besides, I welcome the excuse to actually be close to her, instead of sitting outside her house at night.
I look out over the lake across the street from Daphne’s quiet home and notice that the rain is finally starting to let up. I contemplate going home to sleep so I’ll be prepared for tomorrow. My fingers are on the ignition button, ready to start the car, when a bolt of lightning rips the sky above the lake. Rolling thunder explodes with it, causing me to flinch at the nearness. But in the half second before my eyes clamp shut, I think I see someone standing on the lakeshore. Staring at me. When my eyes open another half second later, no one is there.
I jump out of my car and run toward the lake. The wet sand on the shore grips at my shoes, slowing my pace. Dax follows, calling, What are you doing, Haden?
as if he hadn’t seen anything. Brim yowls in protest over having been awoken so abruptly, sinking her claws into my shoulder.
I cast about in the rain, but I don’t see anyone. I start to think I’d imagined seeing someone—perhaps I’d drifted momentarily asleep—but I make out what looks like a pair of boot prints in the sand before the lapping water of the lake washes them away.
There,
I say, pointing to the now-gone prints. Didn’t you see him?
Him?
Dax shakes his head. I saw lightning, but nothing else.
I stand on the beach, frantically searching the shoreline with my eyes, that creeping feeling that I am being watched plaguing me. The rain, lighter than before but still a steady downpour, soaks through my thin shirt. Brim jumps from my shoulder and bounds back to the car, seeking shelter from the rain.
Come on,
Dax says. It was just lightning. You don’t want to be standing in the water if it strikes again.
I cross my arms for warmth and turn back toward Daphne’s house, watching for any signs of trouble. Any thoughts of leaving, and any sleepiness, have vanished. I don’t care if I have to stand in the rain all night; I’ll do whatever it takes to keep Daphne safe.
chapter two
DAPHNE
I ask the raindrops on the windowsill to dance, and they listen. Four little drops pucker and roll along the painted wood to form a circle of dots just below my fingertips. They twist and twirl, like they’re performing a miniature ballet to the tune I hum. I raise my fingertip, along with my pitch, and one of the drops lifts off the sill and quivers and swirls in midair, following my command. I concentrate harder as I sing a high note, and the other three drops follow the first, leaping up into the air at my will.
I’ve always been able to hear the tones and melodies that every living thing puts off—like the world is a symphony that only I can hear—but learning that I can use those tones to influence the elements is a new and exhilarating feeling. A warm, pulsating sensation encircles me, and I feel calm, in control, for the first time since I was awoken by a crash of thunder in the middle of the night.
It’s even more reassuring than knowing that Haden was standing guard outside during the night. I’d seen him sitting below my bedroom window, settled into one of the deck chairs beside the pool, when I’d gotten up to get a glass of water about an hour after the lightning crash had woken me. Only a few weeks ago, I would have called him on it—but the almost constant evening rain since we escaped the Skylords has me on edge.
Which is why being able to manipulate these raindrops makes me feel more in control. Like if I practice this newfound power enough, I’ll be able to protect myself.
It’s not that I don’t appreciate Haden’s efforts—the boy sleeps in the rain for me, after all. It’s not that I doubt his abilities. And it’s certainly not that his mere nearness doesn’t make me acutely aware of his … prowess.
Maybe it’s because of what happened with Joe. Maybe it’s because I still don’t understand the why of it all—why Haden would chose me over his father. Or maybe it’s because I still have a hard time accepting the concept of fate. Even though Sarah had said that Haden’s and my destinies were irrevocably intertwined, I don’t want to rely on the idea that someone will always be there for me.
Even if part of me wants him to be.
The water droplets’ dance slows with my lack of concentration. Returning my focus to them, I lift my voice in a few high, staccato notes, and raindrops jump along to the sound, almost as if I’ve given them life. A smile spreads across my face.
Yeah, I could get used to this.
Oi, Daphne?
Joe says in his British accent from behind me.
I startle. The water droplets splat onto the sill, lifeless once more. I spin around, afraid I’ve been caught, and try to come up with an explanation for what he may have just witnessed. Whatever this new power is, whatever it means, I’m not ready to share it yet. Especially with someone I don’t know how to trust anymore.
But Joe doesn’t seem to have seen anything out of the ordinary. Instead, he’s standing half in and half out of my bedroom doorway, looking down at the large package in his arms.
I called up the stairs but you didn’t hear me,
he says, as if he’s apologizing for invading my wing of the mansion. We’ve pretty much been keeping to our own parts of the house since we returned from Ellis. My courier just dropped this off. It’s the package from your mother. I thought you’d want it right away.
Oh yeah, of course,
I say, pulling the window shut, like I’m afraid the raindrops are going to start spontaneously dancing again behind me. Bring it in.
Joe takes a few apprehensive steps into my bedroom and sets the hefty box on my bed. He backs away, wringing his hands as I approach, and stands again in that noncommittal fashion in my doorway. He acts like he isn’t watching as I open the box.
Inside are two presents wrapped in red paper—the Christmas gifts from my mother that I never got to open—and a third present in sparkling silver paper, done up with more ribbons than should be legal (a gift from Jonathan, I know without even looking at the card). Tears prick at the backs of my eyes, and I set those aside, waiting to have my own private belated Christmas when Joe isn’t watching.
The rest of the box is filled with stacks of papers and a few books and a small, carved wood figurine of a rose. They’re all things that my Ellis Fields best friend, CeCe—who, it turns out, is really my Olympus Hills best friend, Tobin’s long-lost sister, Abbie—left behind in her apartment before disappearing from Ellis. It makes me shudder as I think that the five years of her life she’d spent in Ellis Fields could all be fit inside this box.
I’d left Ellis with Haden and the others in such a hurry, I hadn’t thought to look through CeCe’s things, so when I got home and started kicking myself for the oversight, I convinced Jonathan to send whatever he could find of hers. I was grateful that he agreed, especially since my mom hadn’t been responding to any of my texts or messages since she’d returned from Salt Lake City with Jonathan to learn from her shopgirl, Indie, that I had returned to Ellis with some friends for only a few hours and then taken off again before even seeing her, and that I wasn’t going to be there for Christmas break, after all.
That had been one of the two promises I had made to her when I chose to move to Olympus Hills with Joe: that I would be home for Christmas—the other promise being that I cross my heart and hope to die, I won’t go running off with some guy.
And now after fleeing Ellis with Haden to go looking for the Key, I felt I’d broken both of those promises to her.
At the time, it had seemed vitally important that we leave Ellis immediately. The fate of the whole world seemed to rest on our quest to find the Key. But two weeks later, with nothing but raw fingers from flipping page after page in the town archives; newly healing blisters on my palms from digging up the grove—the place we had all thought to be the most likely candidate for where Orpheus had stashed the Key of Hades—and aching feet from walking every inch of Olympus Hills, searching out alternative possible hiding places; I was beginning to think I had broken those promises for nothing.
At least Joe had taken the bullet for me over the Christmas thing. When my mom found out I was skipping out on the holidays with her, the phone call that followed can only be described as epic. Luckily, Joe had taken the phone from me and informed her he’d become lonely without his only child around the house and ordered me back to California on the next flight out of Utah, or else he was