Top Fantasy Authors Recommend Books for You
When looking for good book recommendations in the fantasy genre, it’s always a solid idea to start at the source: authors of good fantasy books.
In honor of the new dark fantasy short story collection Into Shadow—dropping November 15 in ebook and audiobook formats—we asked several of the contributing authors to recommend four fantasy books. We also asked the writers to give their thoughts on what makes a great fantasy read.
You’ll find some compelling ideas in the passages below—ideas about dream logic and mirrors, alternate worlds and perfect metaphors. Genre veteran Garth Nix even provides some free verse.
Feel free to continue the discussion in the comments section, and add any tempting recommendations to your Want to Read shelf.
In honor of the new dark fantasy short story collection Into Shadow—dropping November 15 in ebook and audiobook formats—we asked several of the contributing authors to recommend four fantasy books. We also asked the writers to give their thoughts on what makes a great fantasy read.
You’ll find some compelling ideas in the passages below—ideas about dream logic and mirrors, alternate worlds and perfect metaphors. Genre veteran Garth Nix even provides some free verse.
Feel free to continue the discussion in the comments section, and add any tempting recommendations to your Want to Read shelf.
"Obviously, most fantasy novels tend to opt out of the idea that fiction should play by the same rules as the real world. And that’s all well and good. But the thing about reality is that it has a lot of integrity to it. It has hard rules, and it tends to keep to them. For me, great fantasy has to have its own, separate integrity, its own rules and logic and grammar, and it has to stick to them just as much as realism sticks to reality. Because when we read fantasy, we should recognize those new rules, that new logic, and not from external reality but from somewhere inside us. After all, when people dream, they don’t dream in realism; they dream in fantasy. And when we write fantasy, we’re using that same dream logic. We're trying to speak back to that deep place where dreams come from, in its own native tongue. And when we succeed, it listens."
"Like unhappy families, every good book is good in its own way. A book is good for its daring structure or its adherence to classic beats, for its spare elegance or its extravagance. I have loved books for a single perfect metaphor and hated them for even less. When I think of all my favorite fantasy books, the only thing they really have in common is an emotion: a lifting in my chest, a wind at my back, as if I'm standing on the shore looking out at a wide green sea."
"A great fantasy novel is not only a transporting experience but a transformative one. When you’ve finished a great fantasy novel, you realize that you’ve been offered two new worlds: the one found in its pages and the one that you are now looking at with new eyes."
"Use your imagination. This well-worn edict strikes at the heart of what a fantasy novel is. To me, the best fantasy uses reality as a springboard to create alternate pasts, presents, and futures that make us question not only who we are but why we are. That at any time, we can imagine ourselves into something infinitely better or horrifically worse. Ultimately, the best fantasy novels are mirrors reflecting our ability to effect change."
"Three spoons of adventure. No, two, and one of magic
Add a dash of mythic resonance
And characters, human or not
That is, of human interest
Because readers are human
Though characters can be
Anything, from sentient statue to
Anthropomorphic dog
Any story is better with dogs
And cats, particularly if they talk
Likewise owls, and naturally
Monsters add spice to the mix
You can swap any of the above
For other ingredients
If the book feels real
In every aspect
Setting, character, plot
If the author believes
So will the reader"
Add a dash of mythic resonance
And characters, human or not
That is, of human interest
Because readers are human
Though characters can be
Anything, from sentient statue to
Anthropomorphic dog
Any story is better with dogs
And cats, particularly if they talk
Likewise owls, and naturally
Monsters add spice to the mix
You can swap any of the above
For other ingredients
If the book feels real
In every aspect
Setting, character, plot
If the author believes
So will the reader"
Have a great fantasy recommendation? Let's talk books in the comments!
And be sure to check out more recent articles.
And be sure to check out more recent articles.
Comments Showing 1-21 of 21 (21 new)
date
newest »
Thierry wrote: "Recommended for ME ???? I hate fantasy...
What is it with people that can't make the difference between fantasy and scifi?
The more I get recommendations from Goodreads, the less useful they get..."
You realize this is just an article presented to everyone sitewide, right? Like it's not just not curated just for you.
What is it with people that can't make the difference between fantasy and scifi?
The more I get recommendations from Goodreads, the less useful they get..."
You realize this is just an article presented to everyone sitewide, right? Like it's not just not curated just for you.
Thierry wrote: "Recommended for ME ???? I hate fantasy...
What is it with people that can't make the difference between fantasy and scifi?
The more I get recommendations from Goodreads, the less useful they get..."
Oh bless your heart for thinking the "you" actually meant you, personally. :) Maybe you have a problem understanding what a generalization is? Don't want Goodreads recommendations? Don't click on the links. Simple.
What is it with people that can't make the difference between fantasy and scifi?
The more I get recommendations from Goodreads, the less useful they get..."
Oh bless your heart for thinking the "you" actually meant you, personally. :) Maybe you have a problem understanding what a generalization is? Don't want Goodreads recommendations? Don't click on the links. Simple.
Thierry wrote: "Recommended for ME ???? I hate fantasy...
What is it with people that can't make the difference between fantasy and scifi?
The more I get recommendations from Goodreads, the less useful they get..."
What the hell,dude?
This is not an algorithm thing for "you" it's a goodread's general news
What is it with people that can't make the difference between fantasy and scifi?
The more I get recommendations from Goodreads, the less useful they get..."
What the hell,dude?
This is not an algorithm thing for "you" it's a goodread's general news
Thierry Recommended for ME ???? I hate fantasy...
What is it with people that can't make the difference between fantasy and scifi?
The more I get recommendations from Goodreads, the less useful they get...
🥺
What is it with people that can't make the difference between fantasy and scifi?
The more I get recommendations from Goodreads, the less useful they get...
🥺
Thierry wrote: "Recommended for ME ???? I hate fantasy...
What is it with people that can't make the difference between fantasy and scifi?
The more I get recommendations from Goodreads, the less useful they get..."
sweet summer child...............
What is it with people that can't make the difference between fantasy and scifi?
The more I get recommendations from Goodreads, the less useful they get..."
sweet summer child...............
Thierry wrote: "Recommended for ME ???? I hate fantasy...
What is it with people that can't make the difference between fantasy and scifi?
The more I get recommendations from Goodreads, the less useful they get..."
......
what's wrong with you and who hurt you? if you don't like fantasy, simple. just don't click the link. so many people love fantasy genre other than YOU ONLY; INCLUDING ME. I LOVE FANTASY SOOO MUCH. YOU here is in general not just for one person. smh.
What is it with people that can't make the difference between fantasy and scifi?
The more I get recommendations from Goodreads, the less useful they get..."
......
what's wrong with you and who hurt you? if you don't like fantasy, simple. just don't click the link. so many people love fantasy genre other than YOU ONLY; INCLUDING ME. I LOVE FANTASY SOOO MUCH. YOU here is in general not just for one person. smh.
Hey! The Scholomance trilogy by Naomi Novik, starting with A Deadly Education. The Graceling books by Kristin Cashore. Nettle & Bone by T. Kingfisher. Alphabet of Thorn and many others by Patricia A. McKillip.
Stven wrote: "Hey! The Scholomance trilogy by Naomi Novik, starting with A Deadly Education. The Graceling books by Kristin Cashore. Nettle & Bone by T. Kingfisher...."
Ooh, I have never heard of "Alphabet of Thorn" before. I sounds good! Thanks for sharing!
Ooh, I have never heard of "Alphabet of Thorn" before. I sounds good! Thanks for sharing!
I was looking for something that moves from fantasy to sci-fi, but not in the sense that magic was science all along, I have enough of these...
Synek wrote: "I was looking for something that moves from fantasy to sci-fi, but not in the sense that magic was science all along, I have enough of these..."
You can try this one:
It certainly exceeded my expectations and it has the transition you're looking for.
You can try this one:
It certainly exceeded my expectations and it has the transition you're looking for.
I've greatly enjoyed the Mennik Thorn series by Patrick Samphire. Renegade mage does detective noir. Book 1 was a SPFBO finalist
Good to see Swords and Deviltry by Fritz Leiber mentioned. He's not as well known, I think, as he once was, and that's a shame.
And The Bone Key: The Necromantic Mysteries of Kyle Murchison Booth by Sarah Monette (a.k.a. Katherine Addison) is a favorite story collection of mine.
And The Bone Key: The Necromantic Mysteries of Kyle Murchison Booth by Sarah Monette (a.k.a. Katherine Addison) is a favorite story collection of mine.
Synek wrote: "I was looking for something that moves from fantasy to sci-fi, but not in the sense that magic was science all along, I have enough of these..."
oh, that is new to me, do you mind recommending some?
thanks in advance!
oh, that is new to me, do you mind recommending some?
thanks in advance!
Stven wrote: "Hey! The Scholomance trilogy by Naomi Novik, starting with A Deadly Education. The Graceling books by Kristin Cashore. Nettle & Bone by T. Kingfisher...."
I absolutely love the Graceling books by Kristin Cashore and just got her new one "Seasparrow" a Graceling Realm book to read. I will try the others you mentioned. Thanks!
I absolutely love the Graceling books by Kristin Cashore and just got her new one "Seasparrow" a Graceling Realm book to read. I will try the others you mentioned. Thanks!
ᴛɪᴀ wrote: "Alright, now which of these has the best romance as a sub plot. 🧐"
You might like The Conductors. I would describe it as more of a blooming of a relationship than a traditional romance, but it was beautifully done.
You might like The Conductors. I would describe it as more of a blooming of a relationship than a traditional romance, but it was beautifully done.
What is it with people that can't make the difference between fantasy and scifi?
The more I get recommendations from Goodreads, the less useful they get...