Dolors's Reviews > The Lover

The Lover by Marguerite Duras
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
18383778
's review

it was amazing
bookshelves: read-in-2015

Who is “L’amant”(*)? The characters in this story are nameless. A puzzle of personal pronouns draws an anonymous canvas that perspires with alienation and the dense humidity of a foreign land, that mourns the loss of youth and innocence, that invokes the image of photographs never taken, the sound of words never uttered and the mirage of a future that never existed. Only the condensed ardour that clouds up the windows of a small hotel room, where two slippery bodies abandon themselves to contorting passion, defies reality and the passage of time.

But who is “The Lover”?
Is “The Lover” the fifteen-years-old tomboy standing in front to the ferry hiding her prematurely wrinkled face under the shadow of a man’s fedora hat?
She never expected to fall in love with him. She was only worn out with desire. And her dysfunctional family of European colonizers needed the money.
Is “The Lover” the wealthy Chinese man of twenty-seven years of age from Cholen who adores the girl from the distance, concealed behind the tainted windows of his father’s black limousine?
He undresses her with trembling fingers and weeps in the exile of his illegitimate love. He is ashamed of his weakness. She kisses his fragility and ruins the rest of his life.

At first I thought “The Lover” was she.
Then I realized it was he.
And finally I understood it was much more.

“The Lover” is a movable portrait of a first person narrator who is visiting a succession of her younger selves. Memories are her brushstrokes and life-consuming longing the color in which she paints her pictorial story. The awakening of first love and the discovery of erotic pleasure arrive hand in hand with the heartbreak of a certain separation, the sentence to life imprisonment by familial duty and the ruthlessness of intransigent tradition. The cultural distance between the local people and the colonizers in French Indochina become the backdrop of a love story that is condemned by history before it even started and the detached irony that drips from the narrator’s voice can’t disguise the desolation that is eating her alive underneath a carefully studied, impassive poise.

“The Lover” is a cascade of musical notes delivered in fluid movements, a whirlwind of words repeated like a mantra in breathless cadence and staccatto punctuation . “The Lover” is more than a semi autobiographical memoir and less than an interior monologue. It is the rawness of impressionistic paragraphs capturing in Polaroid snapshots the obsession of a crazed mother, the chauvinistic abuse of an elder brother and the alternating urgency and resigned languidness that leaves a permanent scar on the features of a young woman.

Yes. The tale has been told countless times before.
But never like this.
Never the vessel set sail in the Mekong River amidst deafening heat, chirping jungles and melting sky annihilatating all color.
Never the salty tears drowned the sob in torrents of silence and immobility while Chopin’s notes tinted the breath of the wind onboard.
Never the throbbing heartbreak was replaced by incandescent prose that palpitated to the rhythm of the distant voice of China.
Never the fate of two lovers who never spoke to each other, would be sealed with only two words.

(*) I read Marguerite Duras’ novella in Catalan translated from the French by Marta Pessarrodona.
175 likes · flag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read The Lover.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

March 8, 2015 – Shelved
March 9, 2015 – Started Reading
March 9, 2015 –
page 117
100.0% ""“When it's in a book I don't think it'll hurt any more ...exist any more. One of the things writing does is wipe things out. Replace them.” Utterly speechless."
March 10, 2015 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-50 of 57 (57 new)


message 1: by Warwick (new)

Warwick Only the condensed ardour that clouds up the windows of a small hotel room, where two slippery bodies abandon themselves to contorting passion, defies reality and the passage of time.

What a beautiful review!


message 2: by Seemita (last edited May 10, 2015 09:29AM) (new) - rated it 3 stars

Seemita Isn't every lover redeemed of her sin under the legitimate waters of untamed passion and flaming desire?

In your searing words, you transcend many worlds and stand a confidante to a love that was worthy of emulation by virtue of its audacity to love against love, Dolors. This reminds of "The Memoirs of a Geisha" where too, the love sustained amid sensual hallucinations and aching awaiting. Thank you for this flowing sea of emotions.


Samadrita This review is pure poetry! I have no other words.


Dolors Warwick wrote: "Only the condensed ardour that clouds up the windows of a small hotel room, where two slippery bodies abandon themselves to contorting passion, defies reality and the passage of time.

What a beaut..."


Thanks Warwick, I really loved this slim novella and I am glad it shows in this review!


Dolors Seemita wrote: "Isn't every lover redeemed of her sin under the legitimate waters of untamed passion and flaming desire?

In your searing words, you transcend many worlds and stand a confidante to a love that was ..."


Your perceptiveness is palpable in every comment you post, Seemita. This is indeed a painful journey that blends eroticism with an irredeemable sense of loss. Your comparison to "The Memoirs of a Geisha" is fitting in more senses than one, although Duras paints a surrealistic version of the "classic" love story and packs it all in a slim novella that can be read in one sitting. Thanks as always for making me beam with your wonderful comments and for highlighting the key points of every book I try to review with keen eye and otherworldly prose.


Dolors Samadrita wrote: "This review is pure poetry! I have no other words."

No more words are needed, Samadrita. Thank you for reading and for giving me wings to fly.


message 7: by Abubakar (new)

Abubakar Mehdi It would be injustice to humanity if you don't write a book. You are gifted with the craft of constructing and as you like you say 'deconstructing' everything right upto perfection. Brilliant review !


Dolors Abubakar wrote: "It would be injustice to humanity if you don't write a book. You are gifted with the craft of constructing and as you like you say 'deconstructing' everything right upto perfection. Brilliant review !"

Can you imagine a huge smile from ear to ear, conquering cheeks, eyes and even forehead? Well, my smile is even bigger than that. Thanks for your generous, inspiring comment Abubakar.


Cheryl Beautiful review, Dolors. I had a mentor who tried to convince me to read this book because of the way she handles memory, as you've put it. I never did get around to it (except for a few excerpts) but hopefully I do soon.


message 10: by Jibran (new) - added it

Jibran As I went through the review I had a faint impression of having read this before but couldn't think when and where. But very strong images came to mind. And then I understood I had seen a film perhaps of the same name but did not realise that it was a cinematic adaptation of this novel. That said, nothing compares to reading your silken prose that smooths out the wrinkly edges of raw thought to give it a serenity of a still-flowing river, hiding angry floods beneath the quiet surface. I am in awe of your tremendous skill to give voice to the voiceless, to those two lovers who could not speak two words between themselves. A brilliant piece of writing, Dolors. Accept my congratulations and appreciation. Book added.


message 11: by Fionnuala (new)

Fionnuala Glad to see you enjoying Duras, Dolors!


message 12: by [deleted user] (last edited May 10, 2015 08:11PM) (new)

Những người yêu? 情人? L'amante? L'Amant? The Lover? Regardless of tongue, "the lover" feels the "truth" of Love--with a capital letter--even if he or she can't know it or explain it. Yet, despite the language, Love is a truth that is spoken, shouted, or whispered many different ways with different meanings (conveyed so well in your sparkling review). But sometimes, Love’s many truths elude us, and they become swallowed or transformed in our multitude of fears and memories (past, present, and future), which are as muddy as the currents of the Mekong. Thus, Truth (like love) is a many splendored and, alternatively, dark thing. Dolors, whatever the language, you have brilliantly described Love’s pull between the twin tensions of languor and of urgency in the presence of a chorus of insects and Chopin in a land that knows only one season. I am particularly impressed with your insight that the narrator is visiting a succession of her younger selves, each of which is like a photograph frozen in time but it's not really frozen because the color of her memory subsumes the real event. The narrator, as an older woman, can view each Polaroid of herself at 15 with impressionistic subjectivity that may blend with the haze alcohol and the weight of 50 years of defeat in love. I marvel in appreciation at your sui generis review that perfectly blends your own incandescent language and impressions with those of Duras. Dolors-Duras. Thank you for painting this review.


message 13: by Henry (new)

Henry Avila Terrific review,Dolors, saw the great film of this.


Himanshu This is an achingly mesmerizing review, Dolors! For those who haven't read this book (including me), this review is like a tease which blocks out all other thoughts but one i.e. to run and get a copy. You sail higher with each of your reviews, Dolors.


Dolors Cheryl wrote: "Beautiful review, Dolors. I had a mentor who tried to convince me to read this book because of the way she handles memory, as you've put it. I never did get around to it (except for a few excerpts)..."

It's a fast read Cheryl, a slim book, short paragraphs and straight-forward language which in turn results strangely poetic. Duras' style reminded me of Clarice Lispector, even the story itself because they both involve two older women looking back in time to their younger selves introspectively and analyzing a turbulent love affair. I hope you find Duras' worth of your time if you finally get to read her, thanks for your kind words!


Dolors Jibran wrote: "As I went through the review I had a faint impression of having read this before but couldn't think when and where. But very strong images came to mind. And then I understood I had seen a film perh..."

Yes! There's a film adaptation of this book which I haven't seen but I browsed through the pictures and I was amazed at how much the actors in the movie resembled the characters I had drawn in my imagination. The mixture of ache, longing and melancholy is tremendous in this emotionally packed novella and I bet you would find amazing literary connections to other writers as you so naturally do. And as for one giving words to the voiceless, your overly generous comments left me speechless and quite inarticulate, so I will just offer a humbled and very heart-felt "thank you" for your inspiring comment. Thank you Jibran! :)


Dolors Fionnuala wrote: "Glad to see you enjoying Duras, Dolors!"

I had a fantastic time reading Duras and then much fun writing this review, Fio. Thanks for noticing! :)


Dolors Steve wrote: "Những người yêu? 情人? L'amante? L'Amant? The Lover? Regardless of tongue, "the lover" feels the "truth" of Love--with a capital letter--even if he or she can't know it or explain it. Yet, desp..."

You can put it in a thousand different languages, Steve. You got it. Precisely. Love, like memory and truth, are elusive, tricky concepts and prone to blur reason or logic. We have seen these ideas before in other works, Banville and Barnes come to my mind as apt examples, but the language and the structure of this short book is what will remain with me after many years. The prose was lyrical, deceptively simple, the images, clearly drawn, with many punctuation marks and sentences composed in staccato style and yet there was such an inner force in the text that it was hardly impossible to remain impassive in front of a narrator baring her soul in retrospection. Memory works in flashes though, don't you think? A frozen moment in a particular place, the shape of a face, some inconsequential words. I think Duras captured that essence brilliantly with this book. And the fact that the jagged pieces fit all together in a vivid, pulsating puzzle is all the more fascinating. Thank you as always for your in-depth comment, which could have been written by Banville himself! And so Dolors-Duras sends kudos to Steve-Banville! ;)


Dolors Marita wrote: "A beautiful review, Dolors. You certainly have a way with words yourself; thank you for sharing them."

Beaming here because of your words Marita! This was my first Duras but I loved every sentence in it and I am glad something of that transpired in this review. Thanks to you for such a nice comment.


Dolors Henry wrote: "Terrific review,Dolors, saw the great film of this."

I want to watch the movie myself Henry. I just commented above that I was shocked to see how much the actors in the film adaptation resembled the characters that I envisioned in my imagination. Thanks as per usual for stopping by and dropping some words of encouragement.


Dolors Himanshu wrote: "This is an achingly mesmerizing review, Dolors! For those who haven't read this book (including me), this review is like a tease which blocks out all other thoughts but one i.e. to run and get a co..."

Thanks is not enough anymore to depict the way your invigorating comments send me flying high with satisfaction, Himanshu. I went through the reviews of some of GR friends and I encountered reactions for all tastes. This is a classical "tragic love story" in all senses of the expression, but I fell in love with Duras' way of telling it. I hope you think the same if you finally decide to buy it. Needless to say, I am honored beyond words that you would want to get the book based solely on this review. That makes me insanely happy, my friend. Thanks again for your validating presence.


message 22: by Fionnuala (new)

Fionnuala Dolors wrote: "I had a fantastic time reading Duras and then much fun writing this review, Fio...."

I've more time to write this morning - what surprised me last night was that I was expecting your review of Carr's book since we'd been talking about it and here you give us a Duras instead (hope I haven't missed the Carr). But I understand the problem - books line up to be reviewed faster thanwecantype, and especially faster than it takes to assemble wordfests such as yours! Anyway great account of Duras' Lover story, a story she seems to have revolved around continuously in all of her work, both writing and film - I haven't read this one but I feel as if I have - the story is so familiar.


Agnieszka Lovely review , Dolors ! And with your writing here you made me to revisit that novel . Read it eons ago , barely remember the plot . And my feelings … well , reading The lover left me rather detached .


message 24: by Aditi (new)

Aditi Alluring review :-)


message 25: by Vipassana (new) - added it

Vipassana Your poetic prose has me enraptured, Dolors. By not naming the characters, Duras has allowed us all to be enthralled by your penetrating gaze.


message 26: by Praj (new) - rated it 5 stars

Praj To say that I “loved” this review would be a palpable understatement. But then a higher superlative for ‘love’ would be ‘obsession’ and my current sentiment swirls between my ardent love for Duras and my unwavering affinity to your poetic words. Duras was the voice that spoke to a pre-adolescent girl (me) the meaning of the utmost baffling human emotion-love. It goes beyond the fantasies of a fairytale, the fictional notion of the innate perfection disseminating into the filth of societal chaotic mores birthing an array of vivid sentiments and yet preserving its pristine qualities. Duras taught me the whimsicality and obstinacy of ‘love’, walking through the narrow alleys of a dystopian panorama, blossoming in the abundance of a lover’s sexuality and embracing the perfection within its screaming imperfections. The idea of ‘love’ becoming human. And the obvious question that lingers –“ Who is the real lover?” . The heart, the body or the person on the whole, the probability of drowning in its nostalgia of a familiar dawn.

The book and the inspired(namesake) movie has always been a faithful to my literary sojourn and I, an enthusiastic learner. I love Ms. Duras as much as I love this book. So, thank you as ever for penning this skilfully lyrical and spectacular review.


Dolors Fionnuala wrote: "Dolors wrote: "I had a fantastic time reading Duras and then much fun writing this review, Fio...."

I've more time to write this morning - what surprised me last night was that I was expecting you..."


I have a huge backlog of books that I want to review, some even from last year but free time is scarce, particularly when I spent most of it reading books or other reviews and commenting on them! I hope to write something about Carr's novella because I truly loved it, but I read this one in a buddy read with Steve and he wrote such a complete review that I felt I had nothing new to add... I will let the book rest for some weeks though and perhaps when I revisit my notes I will write something in two months time! :)
Thanks for coming back this morning Fio. This was my first Duras and I agree that the story has been told many times before in films and other books, but I liked the structure and writing style of the novel, it felt different, maybe because I read it in Catalan. I do want to read more by her, do you have any suggestion as to what title I could tackle next?


Dolors Agnieszka wrote: "Lovely review , Dolors ! And with your writing here you made me to revisit that novel . Read it eons ago , barely remember the plot . And my feelings … well , reading The lover left me rather ..."

I can see why the book would not resonate with some readers and I have seen very disparate reactions among my GR friends. The narrator certainly made efforts to sound stand-offish and disconnected, but I detected a hidden yearning and regret in her facade. I think this is a very intimate book that seems written on an impulse, and so it either reaches to you or it doesn't. It's almost like a song. Sometimes you don't know the reason why certain melodies move you and why similar ones pass by unnoticed without much ado. Thanks for stopping by to read and to post such a thoughtful comment anyway, Agna!:)


Dolors Aditi wrote: "Alluring review :-)"

Thanks for reading Aditi, super glad that you liked it! :)


Dolors Vipassana wrote: "Your poetic prose has me enraptured, Dolors. By not naming the characters, Duras has allowed us all to be enthralled by your penetrating gaze."

Glad you liked the review Vipassana. I was lost with the personal pronouns half of the time because the characters were referred as "he" or "she" and I seem to recall that only the narrator's mother was given a name. Still, the confusion only added to the poetic voice and I was in turn enticed by the prose that came in waves of varying intensity. Thanks for stopping by to read and for posting such a beautiful comment!


Dolors Praj wrote: "To say that I “loved” this review would be a palpable understatement. But then a higher superlative for ‘love’ would be ‘obsession’ and my current sentiment swirls between my ardent love for Duras..."

I am still reeling from the blow of your magnificent post, Praj. This is my first Duras and so I haven't contrasted my reaction with her other novels, but I felt many of the conflicting emotions that you describe with your insightful prose in this slim book. The shackles of colonialism, the racial bigotry, the latent tragedy of a dysfunctional family and the burning passion of a young girl who doesn't grasp the true extent of her feelings... all these complex themes develop in unison at the background but it was the intimate voice that speaks from the gut, not minding punctuation, grammar or repetition, that made the hair stand on end at the back of my neck. This book was sheer, unadulterated emotion and more than the story it was the style in which it was delivered that enthralled me. How can I thank you for this comment, my dear friend? Your reviews are an inexhaustible source of inspiration and this comment guarantees that I will read more by this author. I also asked Fio, but I would love to hear your personal recommendations as well. Thanks for everything, Praj! :)


message 32: by Praj (new) - rated it 5 stars

Praj Hey D, I have Duras' The Ravishing of Lol Stein on my reading list which I'll get to soon. I have nothing but praise for Duras's other works. Also, on my radar ( if the book is in stock) -The North China Lover. It's a sort of follow up or a more mature take on the "The Lover". And thanks again, sweetie:)


Garima The kind of writing I needed to add some colors to my otherwise dull day. Thanks a lot for refreshing the magic of this lovely book and adding your own astute insights to this unconventional love story which struck a chord with me along with the movie which you mentioned had characters which were faithful to the descriptions of the book.

Yes. The tale has been told countless times before.
But never like this.


Precisely. Lovely, soothing review, Dearest.


Dolors Praj wrote: "Hey D, I have Duras' The Ravishing of Lol Stein on my reading list which I'll get to soon. I have nothing but praise for Duras's other works. Also, on my radar ( if the book is in stock)..."

Indebted to you Praj! I just added the follow up to "The Lover" in my to-buy list. Now I will surf the web to find a copy of it...grazie mille XXX


Dolors Garima wrote: "The kind of writing I needed to add some colors to my otherwise dull day. Thanks a lot for refreshing the magic of this lovely book and adding your own astute insights to this unconventional love s..."

A thousand thanks for your motivating comment Garima! Gratified to hear you found the movie faithful to the novella because I am planning on watching it soon (I just stole a few glimpses of pictures on the website when I was searching for it). This book is a perfect example to prove the importance of writing style because it can alter the way in which the reader perceives the "same old story". I hope to read more by Duras now that I have added some titles thanks to some GR friends' recommendations. Now this discussion thread has all the palette of colors that infuses me with energy to continue reading and writing, now that you have stopped by to say hello! :)


message 36: by Deea (last edited May 11, 2015 09:13AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Deea The love that you describe seems to pertain to the sensitivity and innocence of young lovers. It seems to be profound and fragile, yet full of passion and personality in the meantime...and then I get to the end of your review and I read "Never the fate of two lovers who never spoke to each other, would be sealed with only two words." This made me wonder: can two people who never exchange ideas fall in love for real, other than in literature? Did they fall in love with their physical traits? With their gestures, their grimaces and other facial expressions? Your review is simply exquisite and I really loved how you explained your understanding of the title.


Dolors Deea wrote: "The love that you describe seems to pertain to the sensitivity and innocence of young lovers. It seems to be profound and fragile, yet full of passion and personality in the meantime...and then I g..."

Thanks for posting such a thoughtful comment, Deea. The lovers were indeed young, but their love was far from innocent. They spoke to each other only superficially and only the Chinese man tried to get through to the impassive wall, made of instinctive fear and lack of experience, that the girl built around her. I did wonder whether the simple tale could be understood as a broader metaphor to depict the festering relationship between colonizers and colonized. (view spoiler). Thanks as per usual for providing high quality food for thought with your discerning reflections, glad you liked the review! :))


message 38: by Margitte (new)

Margitte This sounds like a really interesting book indeed, Dolors. You really choose prose with body to read :-)


Dolors Margitte wrote: "This sounds like a really interesting book indeed, Dolors. You really choose prose with body to read :-)"

Prose with body indeed, but condensed in a fairly slim book! Sometimes less is more, right? :)
Thanks for your lovely comment, my friend!


message 40: by Debbie "DJ" (new)

Debbie "DJ" What an amazing review Dolors. Your writing is so just beautiful!


Dolors Debbie "DJ" wrote: "What an amazing review Dolors. Your writing is so just beautiful!"

Thanks so much Debbie, glad you liked it! I certainly had fun writing this one! ;P


message 42: by Lynne (new) - added it

Lynne King Well you've definitely excelled yourself here Dolors. This is sheer artistry.

I've always liked Marguerite Duras. She directed an incredible film "India Song" and I managed to get hold of the text of this. The music of the film is so haunting and I still remember it. Magical in fact.


message 43: by Dolors (last edited Jun 13, 2015 04:30AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Dolors Lynne wrote: "Well you've definitely excelled yourself here Dolors. This is sheer artistry.

I've always liked Marguerite Duras. She directed an incredible film "India Song" and I managed to get hold of the text..."


Thanks for reading and your generous words Lynne! I want to read more Duras and I might try to search for the film you brought to my attention. I imagine what reading one of his books while listening to that soundtrack might feel like... an all-consuming experience, that's for sure! :)


Taylor Another one that has sat on my shelves for too long. Even better than a great review is a review of a book I already have :) Have been enjoying your beautiful reviews and catching up on what you've been reading! Sounds like you've read some very good ones lately :)


Dolors Taylor wrote: "Another one that has sat on my shelves for too long. Even better than a great review is a review of a book I already have :) Have been enjoying your beautiful reviews and catching up on what you'v..."

Yes, I have been lucky of late...although I have learned to pick my books carefully and I am seldom wrong theses days (even more with the direct and indirect advice of my smart GR friends!). This one is a short read, it can be tackled in one sitting and the writing is powerful...I hope to read some reviews of your latest reads soon, Taylor! Thanks for spending so much time catching up with past reviews and for leaving such lovely comments, Taylor...you're making my night bright with your sparkling words! :)


Kelly I'm so sorry I missed this review before! What a lovely one!


Dolors Kelly wrote: "I'm so sorry I missed this review before! What a lovely one!"

Oh thanks Kelly for coming back with such a nice comment! Glad you liked the review.


message 48: by rahul (new) - added it

rahul I should have taken your autograph when I had the chance :)
Eecohonante.. hehe :)


Dolors rahul wrote: "I should have taken your autograph when I had the chance :)
Eecohonante.. hehe :)"


Heh, thanks a bunch for showering me with likes and lovely comments, Rahul! Just one remark...you should write "Acojonante" instead! ;P


message 50: by rahul (new) - added it

rahul Dolors wrote: "rahul wrote: "I should have taken your autograph when I had the chance :)
Eecohonante.. hehe :)"

Heh, thanks a bunch for showering me with likes and lovely comments, Rahul! Just one remark...you ..."


Nobody taught the spellings..hehe.. lo siento :P


« previous 1
back to top