Mayim de Vries's Reviews > City of Stairs
City of Stairs (The Divine Cities, #1)
by
by
"Any miracle, no matter how subtle, always feels tremendously unsettling." And what is a good book if not a miracle of a prime quality? City of Stairs proves this theory. It is one of those books you need to digest before writing a review that will not consist of banalities. And one of those that have you inwardly screaming for more the moment you finish the last sentence.
The world is less about tsarist Russia meeting the opulence of an Indian continent (although it undeniably is quite a clash), the world Mr Bennett has created is all about history. The way it is created, the way it is remembered and recreated, the way it is forgotten, the way it is missed or hated. It is also about history that is forbidden.
The city knows. It remembers. Its past is written in its bones, though the past now speaks in silences."
Welcome to the city of Bulikov, once a seat of the world, presently under the yoke of occupation by its former colony - Saypur. Bulikov is a crumbling memory of itself, poor, damaged and bursting with bitterness. Saypur is at the firm apex of its power and maintains a careful imbalance of power where Saypur rules while the Continent remains at the very bottom of worldly affairs. Preferably even below the bottom. They have only one thing in common, that is hatred.
Saypur and the Continent hate one another, completely oblivious that each is now the product of the other."
Into this hate-ridden, history-oriented city comes an inconspicuous woman, one Shara Thivani, cultural ambassador of Saypur. In reality, she is Ashara Komayd, one of Saypur's best intelligence officers with a mission of solving a mystery behind the murder of a Saypuri historian, Dr. Efrem Panguyi. She is accompanied by a killing machine posing as her secretary, Sigurd.
Who is Shara really? An agent. A scholar. A brokenhearted woman. A niece to the Minister of Foreign Affairs. A descendant of the very person who overthrew continental hegemony by killing their divinities. This event constituted a starting point of the new era, and the Worldly Regulations, a set of laws forbidding to even mention any emanation of the divine, stands firmly as a guardian of this point of no return. But the past is still there.
"Behind this crumbling city is a hidden, mythic paradise, and one only has to scrape at a reality with ones fingernail to find it." And Shara pokes the reality with more than one finger in what is a superb blend of urban fantasy (those of you who showered The Gathering of Shadows with milky way of stars can see how misguided they were), heroic epos, and a mystery thriller. It is a great story, a tale with many beginnings, numerous versions, built on the current of events, back-stories of a colourful array of characters that morph and develop (and sometimes shed their skins) frequently flipping the tale upside down with breathtakingly paced twists.
In addition to the dazzling plot and the overwhelming richness of the Bulikov city-verse, I have to say that for a long time I have not been able to identify with the main protagonist the way I did with Shara. I smiled with her, and plotted with her, I was scared with her and felt her indignation. My heart was broken in the very same places that her broke to pieces. I kept reading until the small hours of the night and then I dreamt on about all of it.
City of Stairs is provocative, disturbing and unsettling and undoubtedly one of my best reads this year. I quaffed it like a sailor drinking whiskey and have the most pleasant case of a book hangover. Highly recommended.
Other Divine Cities:
2. City of Blades
3. City of Miracles
The world is less about tsarist Russia meeting the opulence of an Indian continent (although it undeniably is quite a clash), the world Mr Bennett has created is all about history. The way it is created, the way it is remembered and recreated, the way it is forgotten, the way it is missed or hated. It is also about history that is forbidden.
The city knows. It remembers. Its past is written in its bones, though the past now speaks in silences."
Welcome to the city of Bulikov, once a seat of the world, presently under the yoke of occupation by its former colony - Saypur. Bulikov is a crumbling memory of itself, poor, damaged and bursting with bitterness. Saypur is at the firm apex of its power and maintains a careful imbalance of power where Saypur rules while the Continent remains at the very bottom of worldly affairs. Preferably even below the bottom. They have only one thing in common, that is hatred.
Saypur and the Continent hate one another, completely oblivious that each is now the product of the other."
Into this hate-ridden, history-oriented city comes an inconspicuous woman, one Shara Thivani, cultural ambassador of Saypur. In reality, she is Ashara Komayd, one of Saypur's best intelligence officers with a mission of solving a mystery behind the murder of a Saypuri historian, Dr. Efrem Panguyi. She is accompanied by a killing machine posing as her secretary, Sigurd.
Who is Shara really? An agent. A scholar. A brokenhearted woman. A niece to the Minister of Foreign Affairs. A descendant of the very person who overthrew continental hegemony by killing their divinities. This event constituted a starting point of the new era, and the Worldly Regulations, a set of laws forbidding to even mention any emanation of the divine, stands firmly as a guardian of this point of no return. But the past is still there.
"Behind this crumbling city is a hidden, mythic paradise, and one only has to scrape at a reality with ones fingernail to find it." And Shara pokes the reality with more than one finger in what is a superb blend of urban fantasy (those of you who showered The Gathering of Shadows with milky way of stars can see how misguided they were), heroic epos, and a mystery thriller. It is a great story, a tale with many beginnings, numerous versions, built on the current of events, back-stories of a colourful array of characters that morph and develop (and sometimes shed their skins) frequently flipping the tale upside down with breathtakingly paced twists.
In addition to the dazzling plot and the overwhelming richness of the Bulikov city-verse, I have to say that for a long time I have not been able to identify with the main protagonist the way I did with Shara. I smiled with her, and plotted with her, I was scared with her and felt her indignation. My heart was broken in the very same places that her broke to pieces. I kept reading until the small hours of the night and then I dreamt on about all of it.
City of Stairs is provocative, disturbing and unsettling and undoubtedly one of my best reads this year. I quaffed it like a sailor drinking whiskey and have the most pleasant case of a book hangover. Highly recommended.
Other Divine Cities:
2. City of Blades
3. City of Miracles
Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read
City of Stairs.
Sign In »
Reading Progress
December 26, 2015
– Shelved
December 26, 2015
– Shelved as:
to-read
May 21, 2017
–
Started Reading
May 28, 2017
–
Finished Reading
Comments Showing 1-31 of 31 (31 new)
date
newest »
message 1:
by
Sasha
(new)
May 28, 2017 02:14PM
Great review
reply
|
flag
Sasha wrote: "I wish my boyfriend who just broke up with me would take me back. That would be a great mirical."
Thank you Sasha. Fingers crossed he will see what treasure he has lost and will come to retrieve it. Sometimes miracles need time.
Thank you Sasha. Fingers crossed he will see what treasure he has lost and will come to retrieve it. Sometimes miracles need time.
Celeste wrote: "This series sounds fabulous. Great review!"
Thank you Celeste! It was tantalising really. I am still high on this prose. Quite a drug.
Thank you Celeste! It was tantalising really. I am still high on this prose. Quite a drug.
Yeah you've absolutely sold me on this. Glad to hear that someone is a prose-nerd–there's nothing I love more, so this sounds like nirvana for me :)
Lovely review. Like you you considered the historical approach and the interaction between the two cities.
FanboyBen wrote: "Yeah you've absolutely sold me on this. Glad to hear that someone is a prose-nerd–there's nothing I love more, so this sounds like nirvana for me :)"
Oh that makes me giddy with joy! I look forward to hear what you think of the book!
Oh that makes me giddy with joy! I look forward to hear what you think of the book!
Carol. wrote: "Lovely review. Like you you considered the historical approach and the interaction between the two cities."
I am a sucker for politics and religion. Bennett played and I danced to his tuned like a mesmerised cobra.
I am a sucker for politics and religion. Bennett played and I danced to his tuned like a mesmerised cobra.
☽Luna☾ wrote: "Fantastic review May !!"
Thanks Luna. Make sure to read the book though! Right now I am fiercely proselytising :)
Thanks Luna. Make sure to read the book though! Right now I am fiercely proselytising :)
☽Luna☾ wrote: "Well I've got it on my tbr! I'll definitely get to it this year 😊"
I know what it's like to have a monstrous TBR. It's just for me it's one of those "I-wish-I-got-to-you-earlier" books.
I know what it's like to have a monstrous TBR. It's just for me it's one of those "I-wish-I-got-to-you-earlier" books.
Haïfoun wrote: "Terrific review May !! You definitely piqued my curiosity !!"
Yay! I am SO happy I did. This book is definitely worth trying sooner rather than later.
Yay! I am SO happy I did. This book is definitely worth trying sooner rather than later.
Petrik wrote: "Great review Mayim! I'm going to read this one too within this year! :)"
I'm glad to hear Petrik. It's a superb blend of genres and excellent worldbuilding. Also, while it touches upon the transcendent, it does so in a way different from, say, Staveley, so I hope you will love it as much as I did.
I'm glad to hear Petrik. It's a superb blend of genres and excellent worldbuilding. Also, while it touches upon the transcendent, it does so in a way different from, say, Staveley, so I hope you will love it as much as I did.
Jordan wrote: "Wow, I got a lot out of this review. Loved your quotes and take on the book!"
Thank you, I'm glad you liked it. And I'm happy you enjoyed the book too!
Thank you, I'm glad you liked it. And I'm happy you enjoyed the book too!
This book has been on my TBR for almost four years, and it keeps slipping further and further down the list. Your review has now persuaded me to push it back up into my top 20 so I should get to it at some point this year. 😃
Ian, I applaud your decision. The whole series is truly exceptional and Mr Bennett proved to be a fantastic writer. You will not regret.
This makes me want to read it sooooo muuuuuch. I live stories about forgotten/lost civilizations (historian here, so...)
Laura wrote: "Oh my I'd been meaning to read this, now I definitely will!"
Please do and let me know if you liked it!
Please do and let me know if you liked it!