Debra's Reviews > The Girls in the Garden
The Girls in the Garden
by
by
Well, I am going to be in the minority here. I had heard a lot of good things about this book. I anxiously awaited my copy to be available at the library. I waited and waited and waited. Then finally it was ready.
Yay! I was so excited to start it. Then it began with a fizzle. It was slow as in sloooooooooow. I hung in there. I found that this book took some time, but eventually it became more interesting. It is a mystery whodunit. At the end I found it to be good - not great. I wanted to know what the hell really happened but was still left feeling like, like well, that this book could have been more. I think this is a book one either loves or just finds to be okay. For me although the story did pick up, it still did not grab me, not entirely. I waned to see where it ended and I had heard so much hype that I kept going.
For starters, we know from the first couple of pages that something terrible has happened.
Clare and her 2 daughters move into a new home that shares a communal "garden" with other families. Things seem fine at first as they always do, but then things turn out to not be as fine as they seem. There are cliques, family secrets, jealousy, relationships changing upon the arrival of the new family, and a 15 year old murder mystery of another teenage girl.
Good not great. For me the highlight was pip and her letters to her father.
Yay! I was so excited to start it. Then it began with a fizzle. It was slow as in sloooooooooow. I hung in there. I found that this book took some time, but eventually it became more interesting. It is a mystery whodunit. At the end I found it to be good - not great. I wanted to know what the hell really happened but was still left feeling like, like well, that this book could have been more. I think this is a book one either loves or just finds to be okay. For me although the story did pick up, it still did not grab me, not entirely. I waned to see where it ended and I had heard so much hype that I kept going.
For starters, we know from the first couple of pages that something terrible has happened.
Clare and her 2 daughters move into a new home that shares a communal "garden" with other families. Things seem fine at first as they always do, but then things turn out to not be as fine as they seem. There are cliques, family secrets, jealousy, relationships changing upon the arrival of the new family, and a 15 year old murder mystery of another teenage girl.
Good not great. For me the highlight was pip and her letters to her father.
Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read
The Girls in the Garden.
Sign In »
Reading Progress
Comments Showing 1-9 of 9 (9 new)
date
newest »
message 1:
by
Mayada
(new)
-
rated it 3 stars
Aug 26, 2016 06:03PM
Oh! I loved pip's letters and drawings! ❤️
reply
|
flag
Great review Debra! I thought this book was missing something too and was exactly what you said, "good not great".
Katie wrote: "Great review Debra! I thought this book was missing something too and was exactly what you said, "good not great"."
Thank you Katie! It's frustrating when books feel as if they are missing something.
Thank you Katie! It's frustrating when books feel as if they are missing something.
I tried and and put it aside. There was something about the writing that bothered me. Great review, Debra
Tammy wrote: "I tried and and put it aside. There was something about the writing that bothered me. Great review, Debra"
Thank you Tammy! I believe a lot of people had our experience that something was missing!
Thank you Tammy! I believe a lot of people had our experience that something was missing!