Praveen's Reviews > Secondhand Time: The Last of the Soviets

Secondhand Time by Svetlana Alexievich
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
19760612
's review

it was amazing

“There were new rules: if you have money you count- no money you are nothing. Who cares if you have read all Hegel?”

I made a rule one day that every time, whenever I get time to visit any book fair, I’ll purchase at least one non-fiction and that non-fiction must fulfill three criteria. First, its cover should be extremely charming, second, it should be bulky, and third, it must be historical. A world book fair was organized in my city last month, I rigorously followed the rule and the book that got qualified for me this year was this one. :)

Last time my choice was Mao: The Unknown Story by Jung Chang and prior to that it was India After Gandhi: The History of the World's Largest Democracy by Ramchandra Guha. Coincidently I found a great amount of similarity in the writing of these three writers. All three have written their historical accounts in a very alluring and captivating manner, these writers are able to give you a sort of beguiling feel of reading a non-fiction, very much like a fiction, and at the same time they perfect your understanding of history.

Coming back to this book of Svetlana Alexivitch, This book unleashed the knots of my mind. My understanding about the real life of Soviet people increased multi-fold and I felt a peculiar sort of connectivity with the people there. We all are same in our desires and limitations; it does not matter which part of globe, we reside in, and which kind of political system we are inflicted upon, by the authorities.

Our country was suddenly covered in banks and billboards. A new breed of goods appeared. Instead of crummy boots and frumpy dresses, we finally got the stuff we’d always dreamed of: blue jeans, winter coats, lingerie, and descent crockery…everything bright and beautiful. Our old soviet stuff was grey, ascetic, and looked as if it had been manufactured in war time.

This book is written in hybrid style by the author; mixture of a kind of reportage and a kind of documentary on paper. She is a lifelong journalist and her writing has all those flavors of journalism. Reports.. Records …Interviews…Facts...Quest for truth!

She has recorded the voices of housewives, common men, Gulag survivors and ex- communist post holders. Though she has not put forward her own opinion for the sake of conveying a message of a writer in this book, still she has her writerly craft giving voice to the unknown and lost sentiments.

It is said that Alexivitch is anything but a simple recorder of found voices. She has a writerly voice of her own with great style and authority.

Alexievich strongly believes that people who were born in the USSR and those born after its fall in 1991 come “from different planets”. She has recorded some very agonizing and torturous accounts and stories of people in their own words from these periods.

Russian novels don’t teach you how to become successful. How to get rich…Oblomov lies on his couch, Chekov’s protagonists drink tea and complain about their lives… [She falls silent]. There is a famous Chinese curse: ‘May you live in interesting time’. Few of us remained unchanged. Descent people seem to have disappeared. Now its teeth and elbow everywhere….

I am very happy that I read this book. This is an awesome and phenomenal work by this Nobel Laureate!
82 likes · flag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Secondhand Time.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

October 13, 2016 – Shelved
October 13, 2016 – Shelved as: to-read
January 29, 2017 – Started Reading
February 7, 2017 –
page 344
69.35%
February 9, 2017 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-21 of 21 (21 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Dolors (new)

Dolors Thanks for reminding me that I need to read this book, which has been on my radar for a while. Well crafted, sensitive review, Praveen.


Praveen Dolors wrote: "Thanks for reminding me that I need to read this book, which has been on my radar for a while. Well crafted, sensitive review, Praveen."
Thanks Dolors ! its a unique one... multiple stories within .. each giving you a new perspective and understanding .. !


message 3: by Fran (new) - added it

Fran Excellent review Praveen!


Praveen Fran wrote: "Excellent review Praveen!"

Thank you very much Fran :)


message 5: by Supratim (new)

Supratim Nice review, Praveen!


Praveen Supratim wrote: "Nice review, Praveen!"

Thanks Supratim !


message 7: by Deanna (new)

Deanna Wonderful review, Praveen!


Praveen Deanna wrote: "Wonderful review, Praveen!"

Thanks Deanna !


Nick Nice review, Praveen. I plan to read this for insight into post-communist Russia.


Praveen Nick wrote: "Nice review, Praveen. I plan to read this for insight into post-communist Russia."
Thanks Nick ! I hope you enjoy it :)


message 11: by Nick (new) - rated it 4 stars

Nick I have read her work on Chernobyl, and that makes for some chilling reading. I would recommend it if you have not read it -"Voices from Chernobyl ".


Praveen Nick wrote: "I have read her work on Chernobyl, and that makes for some chilling reading. I would recommend it if you have not read it -"Voices from Chernobyl "." Thats n my radar Nick ! thanks for the suggestion.. I will try it for sure ! :)


message 13: by Ilse (new) - rated it 5 stars

Ilse Splendid review of this poignant book, Praveen.


Praveen Ilse wrote: "Splendid review of this poignant book, Praveen."

Elyse wrote: "Great review and I love the quotes too!!! Wonderful!"
Thank you very much for your comment... Ilse :)... I wish to tell you that your review of this book was one of the reasons of my purchasing this book under non- fiction category this year ! thanks a lot for that !


Praveen Elyse wrote: "Great review and I love the quotes too!!! Wonderful!"
Thanks Elyse ! for taking time to have a look on my opinion on this book. :)


Margitte I'm so thrilled to see that we have this book in common, Praveen. My apologies for missing out on your wonderful review.

We share Mao: The Unknown Story by Jung Chang as well. Have you read her first book Wild Swans, Three daughters of China - a compelling book, if you ever consider a non-fiction book at a book fair again. What a great idea, so by the way! :-) IMHO Wild Swans was her better book of the two.

I haven't read India After Gandhi: The History of the World's Largest Democracy by Ramchandra Guha, and appreciate this recommendation. I've read A Suitable Boy Vikram Seth - what a whopper, but so worth it!

This book is indeed a documentary on paper. Her rendition of history was perfect. The more human side. She opened those locked up doors behind which people were hiding from the soldiers crushing down their streets with heavy armory on their way into civil war. She allowed the residents to tell the story from their side.


Praveen Margitte wrote: "I'm so thrilled to see that we have this book in common, Praveen. My apologies for missing out on your wonderful review.

We share Mao: The Unknown Story by Jung Chang as well. Have you read her fi..."

Thanks for stopping by Margitte!
Wild Swans, Three daughters of China, I have not read but I am sure it would be a great book, as I witness the amazing writing of the author in Mao,
India After Gandhi is again a history of India retold by the author in his unique style. I would definitely recommend it.


message 18: by mwana (new)

mwana Great review Praveen. Are you still following the rule? How many more nonfictions have you read since


Praveen Margitte wrote: "I'm so thrilled to see that we have this book in common, Praveen. My apologies for missing out on your wonderful review.

We share Mao: The Unknown Story by Jung Chang as well. Have you read her fi..."


'A Suitable Boy' by Vikram Seth is such a big book, I have only read the first few chapters perhaps, not complete, but I will definitely read it.


Praveen Elyse wrote: "Reading Margitte's review -- yours again --and Ilsa --there is a lot of support around here -- it I get stuck --
Thanks again -- I want to give it a go --
In our area -- where we live -- we have so..."


This is an enlightening book Elyse, I hope you enjoy it, We'll wait to see your thoughts on it.


Praveen mwana wrote: "Great review Praveen. Are you still following the rule? How many more nonfictions have you read since"

Thanks, Mwana! I am reading many nonfictions in between, but I failed in purchasing books from the book fair as I am living far away from the city, but will try to buy a few bulky ones if I get a chance.


back to top