chai (thelibrairie on tiktok!) ♡'s Reviews > The Bear and the Nightingale
The Bear and the Nightingale (Winternight Trilogy, #1)
by
by
chai (thelibrairie on tiktok!) ♡'s review
bookshelves: favorites, fiction, read-in-2018, read-in-2022
Jul 24, 2018
bookshelves: favorites, fiction, read-in-2018, read-in-2022
Read 2 times. Last read January 2, 2022 to January 3, 2022.
A large pleasure in re-reading a favorite book is to experience that sense of almost-newness: to recognize and relive everything again exactly as it was, page by page, and yet to submit, completely, to the promise of discovery.
I read The Bear and the Nightingale for the first time in 2018. I finished the whole trilogy in 2019. It was bittersweet: for a year, I had filled my life with this world, these characters, and it was like breathing. When I said goodbye, I was not so much saying goodbye to these books as to the person I was when I read them. The person who is now two cities, three apartments, one bachelor’s degree, several heartbreaks away from me. Most days I don’t miss that person, but I missed this series with a longing so sharp it drew me right back to the first page, as though by some invisible string.
Everything about The Bear and the Nightingale was the same, and it was different, and there was something so utterly intoxicating about that.
So vivid and fierce in my memory was Arden’s beautiful evocation of interminable winter nights and stories told by the hearth, of restless flights into the woods and an insatiable hunger for the unknown, of fire made out of fear and innocence meeting its fate, of encounters fraught with chance and a white mare, standing like a faint, far beacon in the darkness. The feeling, too, that I was reading a centuries-old fairytale, something timeless, beyond age. These images, which have been etched for years into the soft flesh behind my eyes, fell on my heart with a burst of recognition. Yet, when I returned to The Bear and the Nightingale, I saw even more.
I saw how the book casts visceral lights upon the ways in which faith can be both a balm and a blight, how fear can rule our bodies like the hand of a hidden puppeteer, and how faith and fear, when held intertwined in our hearts, can be sharpened into weapons. I also saw what it means to be hungry down to your delicate bones without realizing it, a hunger to seek, to be seen, to surrender on your own terms. And when I turned that thought around, I realized, with a start, that in this at least, the monstrous and the downtrodden in this book were not dissimilar at all. And I understood why, at nineteen, I fell so helplessly in love with Vasya Petrovna, and so thoroughly sickened by my flashing sympathy for Konstantin Nikonovich.
With every page, the book kept blooming and blooming inside me until there was absolutely no room left for anything else. I remembered the ferocious, sacrificial love of a parent, of a sibling, and it knocked at my heart, this newly invigorated appreciation for all the invisible ribbons of familiarity and love that are woven through our lives, like a net to break our fall. At the same time, I understood that putting yourself first, after a lifetime of loving fiercely, of giving until you’re hollow, can sometimes be an act of radical resistance. I will be free, and I will not count the cost.
I'm always going to be struck, I think, by how much a book can yield upon revisiting it. How a story can be endless in that way, inexhaustible and beckoning. I'm glad I took the hand offered by The Bear and the Nightingale and stepped back into its world. I'm already looking forward to the next time.
I read The Bear and the Nightingale for the first time in 2018. I finished the whole trilogy in 2019. It was bittersweet: for a year, I had filled my life with this world, these characters, and it was like breathing. When I said goodbye, I was not so much saying goodbye to these books as to the person I was when I read them. The person who is now two cities, three apartments, one bachelor’s degree, several heartbreaks away from me. Most days I don’t miss that person, but I missed this series with a longing so sharp it drew me right back to the first page, as though by some invisible string.
Everything about The Bear and the Nightingale was the same, and it was different, and there was something so utterly intoxicating about that.
So vivid and fierce in my memory was Arden’s beautiful evocation of interminable winter nights and stories told by the hearth, of restless flights into the woods and an insatiable hunger for the unknown, of fire made out of fear and innocence meeting its fate, of encounters fraught with chance and a white mare, standing like a faint, far beacon in the darkness. The feeling, too, that I was reading a centuries-old fairytale, something timeless, beyond age. These images, which have been etched for years into the soft flesh behind my eyes, fell on my heart with a burst of recognition. Yet, when I returned to The Bear and the Nightingale, I saw even more.
I saw how the book casts visceral lights upon the ways in which faith can be both a balm and a blight, how fear can rule our bodies like the hand of a hidden puppeteer, and how faith and fear, when held intertwined in our hearts, can be sharpened into weapons. I also saw what it means to be hungry down to your delicate bones without realizing it, a hunger to seek, to be seen, to surrender on your own terms. And when I turned that thought around, I realized, with a start, that in this at least, the monstrous and the downtrodden in this book were not dissimilar at all. And I understood why, at nineteen, I fell so helplessly in love with Vasya Petrovna, and so thoroughly sickened by my flashing sympathy for Konstantin Nikonovich.
With every page, the book kept blooming and blooming inside me until there was absolutely no room left for anything else. I remembered the ferocious, sacrificial love of a parent, of a sibling, and it knocked at my heart, this newly invigorated appreciation for all the invisible ribbons of familiarity and love that are woven through our lives, like a net to break our fall. At the same time, I understood that putting yourself first, after a lifetime of loving fiercely, of giving until you’re hollow, can sometimes be an act of radical resistance. I will be free, and I will not count the cost.
I'm always going to be struck, I think, by how much a book can yield upon revisiting it. How a story can be endless in that way, inexhaustible and beckoning. I'm glad I took the hand offered by The Bear and the Nightingale and stepped back into its world. I'm already looking forward to the next time.
1999 likes · Like
∙
flag
Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read
The Bear and the Nightingale.
Sign In »
Reading Progress
April 30, 2017
– Shelved
November 30, 2018
–
Started Reading
December 7, 2018
–
Finished Reading
January 2, 2022
–
Started Reading
January 3, 2022
–
Finished Reading
Comments Showing 1-50 of 74 (74 new)
message 1:
by
Bhavik (Semi Hiatus)
(new)
-
added it
Jul 24, 2018 04:33AM
I doubt its the same but atb
reply
|
flag
I've read neither of those, but I really really enjoyed this one! If you like atmospheric books that lean on cool mythology, you're in luck!
I really love this book! There's so much magic and Russian folklore, it honestly made me wish I was a forest witch with flowers in my hair, communing with ancient creatures somewhere in medieval Russia
i wouldn't say they're like.../that/ similar, esp the night circus.
for what it's worth, though, i've read all three of those books and liked/loved them. and in any case, i hope you enjoy this!!
for what it's worth, though, i've read all three of those books and liked/loved them. and in any case, i hope you enjoy this!!
oohhhhh I highly rec this one!! slow but tbh I didn't really see it as slow because it's just that well-written and overall amazing
I’ve read this and Uprooted. Uprooted is definitely more of a magical fantasy, while The Bear and the Nightingale is a very pastoral faery tale.
It’s an amazing book. Very slow at times, but the writing is beautiful and Vasya, the main heroine, is one of the best I’ve come across! Definitely worth the wait.
Benjamin wrote: "They're not wrong - and I'd include Catherynne Valente's Deathless on that list as well."
oohh I’ve wanted to read that book for so long!! I might pick it up sooner if I liked this book!!
oohh I’ve wanted to read that book for so long!! I might pick it up sooner if I liked this book!!
Claudia ✨ wrote: "In my humble opinion this one is the best of the three though so PREPARE"
IM PUMPED OMG
IM PUMPED OMG
Kaylin wrote: "I've read neither of those, but I really really enjoyed this one! If you like atmospheric books that lean on cool mythology, you're in luck!"
first of all I screamed when I saw your comment I MISS SEEING YOU AROUND!!!! also please read the night circus it’s one of my favs ever!! lastly, everything you stated sounds right up my alley I’m so excited!!
first of all I screamed when I saw your comment I MISS SEEING YOU AROUND!!!! also please read the night circus it’s one of my favs ever!! lastly, everything you stated sounds right up my alley I’m so excited!!
Tara ☽ wrote: "I really love this book! There's so much magic and Russian folklore, it honestly made me wish I was a forest witch with flowers in my hair, communing with ancient creatures somewhere in medieval Ru..."
now I really can’t wait to read it omg
now I really can’t wait to read it omg
mo wrote: "i wouldn't say they're like.../that/ similar, esp the night circus.
for what it's worth, though, i've read all three of those books and liked/loved them. and in any case, i hope you enjoy this!!"
aahh thank you so much <3
for what it's worth, though, i've read all three of those books and liked/loved them. and in any case, i hope you enjoy this!!"
aahh thank you so much <3
T♠️bi wrote: "oohhhhh I highly rec this one!! slow but tbh I didn't really see it as slow because it's just that well-written and overall amazing"
ohh I get that, so far, it’s so atmospheric and the writing is so marvelous that the plot flows easily!!
ohh I get that, so far, it’s so atmospheric and the writing is so marvelous that the plot flows easily!!
Em wrote: "Kaylin wrote: "I've read neither of those, but I really really enjoyed this one! If you like atmospheric books that lean on cool mythology, you're in luck!"
first of all I screamed when I saw your..."
Ahhh!!! 💕 I HAVE MISSED BEING AROUNDD
I really need to read it because it sounds amazing?? (I think I actually read the first few chapters one a million years ago and then had to return it to the library? Clearly past Kaylin was a mess)
YAY! I hope you love itttt!
first of all I screamed when I saw your..."
Ahhh!!! 💕 I HAVE MISSED BEING AROUNDD
I really need to read it because it sounds amazing?? (I think I actually read the first few chapters one a million years ago and then had to return it to the library? Clearly past Kaylin was a mess)
YAY! I hope you love itttt!
message 21:
by
chai (thelibrairie on tiktok!) ♡
(last edited Jul 25, 2018 11:06PM)
(new)
-
rated it 5 stars
Helena wrote: "I’ve read this and Uprooted. Uprooted is definitely more of a magical fantasy, while The Bear and the Nightingale is a very pastoral faery tale."
oh I've read Spinning Silver and I thought it wouldn't live up to Uprooted's brilliance but I was pleasantly surprised so I'm intrigued to see how this book will fare in comparison!
oh I've read Spinning Silver and I thought it wouldn't live up to Uprooted's brilliance but I was pleasantly surprised so I'm intrigued to see how this book will fare in comparison!
BoMo wrote: "It’s an amazing book. Very slow at times, but the writing is beautiful and Vasya, the main heroine, is one of the best I’ve come across! Definitely worth the wait."
ohh I 'm loving so far aahh and the writing is so enchanting!!
ohh I 'm loving so far aahh and the writing is so enchanting!!
oh man, this book is beautiful, slow, and so so atmospheric and really just so....MUCH in the best of ways. i think it really does myths justice in a way i don't often see - no instalove or love triangles or making things less scary than they should be. it's also very feminist without feeling anachronistic. :')
Megan wrote: "I just finished Spinning Silver and it really reminded me of the Bear and the Nightingale!"
spinning silver was one of my favorite books of all time so this reassures me omg
spinning silver was one of my favorite books of all time so this reassures me omg
Sage wrote: "Oh i loved tbatn so fucking much em it's gonna be everything you're hoping for and so much more"
U WERE RIGHT
U WERE RIGHT
Kaylin wrote: "Em wrote: "Kaylin wrote: "I've read neither of those, but I really really enjoyed this one! If you like atmospheric books that lean on cool mythology, you're in luck!"
first of all I screamed when..."
it's sooo good i hope u love it whenever u pick it up again <33
first of all I screamed when..."
it's sooo good i hope u love it whenever u pick it up again <33
Alienor ✘ French Frowner ✘ wrote: "I'd add
*
No yeah you're right"
witch kin (which maybe not be very far-fetched now that I think about it)
*
No yeah you're right"
witch kin (which maybe not be very far-fetched now that I think about it)
Kelly wrote: "Sequel is just as good. Now the long wait for number 3."
oohh I’m excited to read it!!!!
oohh I’m excited to read it!!!!
Suzi wrote: "I'm so glad you like it! I really love this book and Vasya... One of my favorites characters!"
Thank you!! She’s definitely one of my favorites too!!
Thank you!! She’s definitely one of my favorites too!!
Raquel wrote: "I had a hard time with this book! It felt like there wasn’t enough and also too much at the same time? Haha, probably doesn’t make sense but alas, I finished feeling unsatisfied and not wanting mor..."
oh I’m sorry you didn’t enjoy it! I get exactly the feeling you’re describing, I definitely finished this book wanting more and was delighted to find out that it’s only the first book of a trilogy!
oh I’m sorry you didn’t enjoy it! I get exactly the feeling you’re describing, I definitely finished this book wanting more and was delighted to find out that it’s only the first book of a trilogy!
Nikki wrote: "When does the romance start though? 😫"
there are some implications by the end of the sequel but it doesn't really happen until the third book, which I'm currently reading, and let me tell you: IT'S SO FUCKING WORTH THE AGONIZING WAIT.
there are some implications by the end of the sequel but it doesn't really happen until the third book, which I'm currently reading, and let me tell you: IT'S SO FUCKING WORTH THE AGONIZING WAIT.
You actually pointed out the best reason for me to read this series... Two words... Naomi Novik. I love her books... Temeraire is one of my new favorite series, and her stand alone fairy tales well, stand alone. I am looking forward to reading this series with a new anticipation after reading your review.
I will add that I am reading Small Spaces and it is imaginative and well written. So far. Thanks for taking the time to write this review!
I will add that I am reading Small Spaces and it is imaginative and well written. So far. Thanks for taking the time to write this review!
I can relate so much to your emotional connection to this story and magical stories like it. I got lost in the fairytale and look forward to getting lost in its sequel.
What a beautiful review! I’ve been wanting to reread these books too, you’ve made me want to do it sooner rather than later.