Steven Godin's Reviews > Jude the Obscure

Jude the Obscure by Thomas Hardy
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
26706841
's review

liked it
bookshelves: great-britain, classic-literature

3.5/5

To read of Tess or Jude? I was completely undecided, so took the action of a coin toss to decide for me.
Problem, had not a penny in my pocket, so whisked out a visa card and launched it across the room.

Frontside up - Tess
Backside up - Jude

Jude it was then...
(Don't worry Tess, you will have your day!)

He might have won my card toss but there is no winning in Hardy's final novel. A novel of such bleak and devastating intensity it's little wonder he finally called it a day.
Stirring up a feeling of failure and disappointment in life, the protagonist Jude Fawley is a scholarly chap who aspires from an early age to study in the university town of Christminster, situated in Hardy's fictional county of Wessex, become a clergyman, and distinguish himself in the world.

But two women would enter his life, Arabella and cousin Sue, to ruin everything.....

His tragic story moved me in such a way that was almost unbearable, too painful to comprehend, the light at the end of the tunnel didn't even exist.

Jude is brought up by his old Aunt and is devoted to a local schoolmaster, Phillotson, and dreams of following in his footsteps after he moves to the Oxford-like town of Christminster. He builds a fantasy life for himself, and believes this is based on his entire destiny, well, that is until the selfish Arabella Donn enters the frame, followed by unhappy Sue Bridehead. What happens next?, we have murder-suicide, failed marriage, a miscarriage, deathly illness and loss of faith, could a novel be more depressing.Hardy skewers the cruelty and hypocrisy of the way society works. He shows how, even in moments when men attempt to do something about the injustice of it all, they end up merely papering over the problem so that they don’t have to see what’s amiss.

I have to say it's very well written, and clearly see why Hardy is regarded so highly, you take all three central characters to heart, it's impossible not to, and his portrayal of the villages and countryside evokes such feelings within, however, I am unconvinced that Hardy’s critiques of Christianity and marriage are altogether just and reasonable, but do recognize the truth for love in the hearts of Sue and Jude, through their anguish and hopelessness, their anxiety and grief.
Of the other earthy characters in it, dare I say they actually made me laugh at times, but generally any cheerfulness is on a very small level to say the least.

As for Hardy’s career as a novelist, it’s a shame that he ended it so soon, he here proves himself to be one of the great creators of complex characters with emotionally devastating problems, grabbing the readers attention in a very short period of time, I didn't think it was the masterpiece some might see it as, but did leave a very strong impression on me....I even felt sorry for the Pig.
104 likes · flag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Jude the Obscure.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

June 3, 2017 – Shelved
June 6, 2017 – Started Reading
June 6, 2017 –
page 58
11.98%
June 8, 2017 –
page 102
21.07%
June 9, 2017 –
page 159
32.85%
June 11, 2017 –
page 202
41.74%
June 13, 2017 –
page 319
65.91%
June 14, 2017 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-17 of 17 (17 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

Ilse Talking by devastating novels, for me this still comes first in a possible list of them, Steven -after turning the last page, I wasn't able to start a new book for a week, entirely smothered. Those children, so horrible.


message 2: by Steven (last edited Jun 14, 2017 02:18PM) (new) - rated it 3 stars

Steven Godin Ilse wrote: "Talking by devastating novels, for me this still comes first in a possible list of them, Steven -after turning the last page, I wasn't able to start a new book for a week, entirely smothered. Those..."

Yes, indeed so tragic, there were parts where I simply wanted to turn away.


message 3: by Julie (new)

Julie G I love Hardy, and I love Tess, so you need to read her next! (But maybe Anne of Green Gables in between??)


Steven Godin Julie wrote: "I love Hardy, and I love Tess, so you need to read her next! (But maybe Anne of Green Gables in between??)"

His characters are so well drawn, you really feel for them, just wish he gave them some respite from all the misery!


Dolors Heh, quite a refreshing novel considering the strong vibes of endless tragedy that overcrowd this novel. I also re-read the book recently and was struck at how much I had neglected Sue in my pity for Jude in my first reading. Calamities befall on both characters, but Sue's attitude seems to be presented as a catalyst for all drama to unfold, and in this second read I shifted perspective and tried to focus more on the female characters, with quite unexpected results...


message 6: by Tim (new)

Tim Your visa card let you down! I much prefer Tess to Jude. Nice review.


Adina (way behind) I read the same kind of reviews about Tess, about how tragic it is. So, you might want to take a break between the 2 of them. I never tried tossing a Visa before, I might do it the next time I can't decide on something.


Steven Godin Tim wrote: "Your visa card let you down! I much prefer Tess to Jude. Nice review."

Thanks for the friend request Tim!, Tess will have to wait in the wings for a while.


Steven Godin Adina wrote: "I read the same kind of reviews about Tess, about how tragic it is. So, you might want to take a break between the 2 of them. I never tried tossing a Visa before, I might do it the next time I can'..."

Thanks Adina, I will certainly leave reading Tess for another time.


message 10: by Steven (last edited Jun 15, 2017 08:25AM) (new) - rated it 3 stars

Steven Godin Dolors wrote: "Heh, quite a refreshing novel considering the strong vibes of endless tragedy that overcrowd this novel. I also re-read the book recently and was struck at how much I had neglected Sue in my pity f..."

I can see where your coming from Dolors, I struggled to like Arabella and felt more for poor Jude than Sue, however, both women still suffered great emotional turmoil, Sue maybe even more so than Jude.


message 11: by Jennifer (new)

Jennifer Masterson Hahaha! That's hysterical about the Visa card! 😂. Improve skills! You have them! Great review, Steven!


message 12: by Jennifer (new)

Jennifer Masterson Improv. Darn Autocorrect!


message 13: by Cheryl (new)

Cheryl Complex characters, a middle finger up to society's hypocrisy, the grittiness of stories that rush up to meet you unexpectedly - yes, I'll have to agree that those things make Hardy's work unique and jolting. Nice review, Steven.


Steven Godin Cheryl wrote: "Complex characters, a middle finger up to society's hypocrisy, the grittiness of stories that rush up to meet you unexpectedly - yes, I'll have to agree that those things make Hardy's work unique a..."

Thanks Cheryl, I look forward to reading of Tess next...


Steven Godin Jennifer wrote: "Hahaha! That's hysterical about the Visa card! 😂. Improve skills! You have them! Great review, Steven!"

Ha!, thanks. I just hope it still works when next thrust into an ATM!


Marcia Letaw The good news is that of Hardy's 5 great novels, Jude is the most negative reflecting his own increasing cynicism. If you read them in backwards chronological order it will be like watching the sun rise instead of the sun setting.


Steven Godin Marcia wrote: "The good news is that of Hardy's 5 great novels, Jude is the most negative reflecting his own increasing cynicism. If you read them in backwards chronological order it will be like watching the sun..."

What a great last line!, thank you Marcia.


back to top