Mario the lone bookwolf's Reviews > Carrion Comfort

Carrion Comfort by Dan Simmons
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
78485297
's review

it was amazing
bookshelves: simmons-dan

Mind penetrating psi vampires haunt humankind in the same year Simmons´ ingenious sci-fi fantasy milestone Hyperion was published and revolutionize the horror genre in the same way.

King said that Simmons writes like a God and that he is a bit envious and what could exceed this quote? There is a handful of authors who unite the lucky combination of hard, lifelong perfecting their writing and talent and Simmons is in a league I find just some are coming close to. There may be authors just playing in one league that are as good or, regarding the worldbuilding but not characterization, better, but nobody writes works of such quality in different genres. Sci-Fi is totally my thing and I could name very few names of the same greatness as Hyperion, the same for horror and this one.

It´s especially how it immediately blows one away, how it never gets boring for just a second, how it´s complexity is never confusing, the characters´ motivations logical, everything slowly escalating to amazing plot points,… And most of his novels are bricks, often with more than just 2 or 3 perspectives, time- and plotlines.

There is often so less action, few cliffhangers, nothing one is used to in modern writing to pimp, accelerate, and distract from characterization, plotting, and logical flaws and errors, Simmons is using pure characterization and a complex, interwoven net of protagonists and antagonists to lead the long novel to a culmination of epic proportion.

It´s a shame that I am too lazy to investigate which classic elements and tales inspired Simmons in and to his works, because his epic sci-fi novels are both filled with innuendos and connotations to famous ancient works or interpretations of these. Reader of the classics, mythologies, and history might find goldmines I am blind to see because of a lack of special knowledge.

One of the cases where I absolutely don´t understand why people don´t like it. In other cases, there are elements that make it completely understandable that one can´t deal with too sciency, too charactery, too world buildy, too whatever elements, but this has everything, it´s the beginning of the career of one of the most talented and underrated writers of the 20th century.
So amazingly many pictures of this and Simmons´ other horror novel, Summer of night, that feels like a reinterpretation of Stephen Kings´ It, stay in mind, always a sure sign that the quality of the stuff is so high that it permanently blows ones´mind away and leaves one, wasted, but very happy, afterward.

Tropes show how literature is conceptualized and created and which mixture of elements makes works and genres unique:
https://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.ph...
201 likes · flag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Carrion Comfort.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

Finished Reading
May 25, 2018 – Shelved

Comments Showing 1-14 of 14 (14 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Andreas (new)

Andreas It’s very simple: I despise horror. So, I wouldn’t like it.


Mario the lone bookwolf Andreas wrote: "It’s very simple: I despise horror. So, I wouldn’t like it."

It´s far away from stereotypical psycho or splatter horror with paranormal effects, one of the main plots is about a holocaust survivor hunting his torturer, another with a psi billionaire, etc, it are these amazing characters, not the rare horror scenes, that make it so great.


message 3: by Andreas (new)

Andreas Imagine a wonderful hike. Every there and then, you hit a dog turd and can’t get rid of the stink. That’s what „rare horror scenes“ mean for me.


Mario the lone bookwolf Andreas wrote: "Imagine a wonderful hike. Every there and then, you hit a dog turd and can’t get rid of the stink. That’s what „rare horror scenes“ mean for me."

Lovely metaphor, but you should possibly consider an anti aversion therapy, because some of the greatest books I´ve read are fantasy or sci fi horror hybrids or psychological horror stories, often unique in ideas and writing style. Would be a mess if you miss them all.


message 5: by [deleted user] (new)

Great review, Mario! I can't understand why more people don't like this one as well.


message 6: by Andreas (new)

Andreas There is soooooo much to read that I can choose. No need to step into the turd 💩. I also miss out all of the classics and don’t look back.
I stopped reading or watching any kind of horror some 30 years ago when I found out that I get nightmares from them. Here and there I stumble into a crossover (mostly with anthologies) and it didn’t change.


Mario the lone bookwolf Andreas wrote: "There is soooooo much to read that I can choose. No need to step into the turd 💩. I also miss out all of the classics and don’t look back.
I stopped reading or watching any kind of horror some 30 ..."


Wow, that´s heavy stuff, but completely understandable. I´ve the opposite problem of hardly finding something that can really thrill me.

Classics are another thing, there are authors like Twain, Austen, London, Swift,... that are not boring drivel, but great writing or comedic social criticism and analysis. But most of it, just as Nobel Prize garbage, is to run away from really fast.


Mario the lone bookwolf J.K. wrote: "Great review, Mario! I can't understand why more people don't like this one as well."

Thanks!
I had the absolutely same thinking going on, especially as there are so many overhyped average horror novels and I read this one without great expectations because I adore Simmons, but didn´t expect to find such a jewel.


message 9: by [deleted user] (new)

Mario the lone bookwolf wrote: "J.K. wrote: "Great review, Mario! I can't understand why more people don't like this one as well."

Thanks!
I had the absolutely same thinking going on, especially as there are so many overhyped av..."


Exactly, Mario! I just thought this book was so original and so well done. Simmons will always be one of my favorites


message 10: by Luvtoread (new) - added it

Luvtoread Wonderful review, Mario! I just bought this book and am really looking forward to reading a well-written horror story by an accomplished author!!


message 11: by Zain (new)

Zain I love the review! But I’ve read soooo many books, fiction and non-fiction, memoirs and all, about the holocaust! I don’t think I could read another one. Though I do love horror.


Mario the lone bookwolf J.K. wrote: "Mario the lone bookwolf wrote: "J.K. wrote: "Great review, Mario! I can't understand why more people don't like this one as well."

Thanks!
I had the absolutely same thinking going on, especially a..."


I can´t put my finger on how he does it, but just as King, Irving, Pratchett, Twain, and a few others, he has the amazing ability of keeping it always suspenseful and entertaining.


Mario the lone bookwolf Luvtoread wrote: "Wonderful review, Mario! I just bought this book and am really looking forward to reading a well-written horror story by an accomplished author!!"

Thanks!
Enjoy and, by the way, read most of his other books too if you haven´t, its ultimate quality over quantity, I couldn´t name a similar crossover author who accomplished writing such works.


Mario the lone bookwolf Zain wrote: "I love the review! But I’ve read soooo many books, fiction and non-fiction, memoirs and all, about the holocaust! I don’t think I could read another one. Though I do love horror."

Thanks!
I completely understand it, but the retrospective concentration camp scenes are very short and can easily be skipped without losing context. It would be a mess to miss it because of this.


back to top