Reynje's Reviews > Froi of the Exiles
Froi of the Exiles (Lumatere Chronicles, #2)
by
by
(Scroll down if you'd prefer the tl;dr version)
If Finnikin of the Rock was a story about a divided and displaced nation’s journey towards healing their collective psyche, Froi of the Exiles is about a people broken apart by hatred, the wound in their history left to fester, and seep suspicion and fear into the cracks between them. A faceless, malevolent presence in Finnikin of the Rock, this is Charyn’s unveiling as more than simply “the enemy” of Lumatere. It’s an insight into a land burdened by suffering and grief, and the darker side of human nature.
While Finnikin of the Rock covered more ground in one sense of the word, with a quest that lead its characters into the far corners of Skuldenore, Froi of the Exiles is a novel on a vaster scale in several ways. This story is more complex, with an intricate web of a plot, and it unfolds new dimensions to Marchetta’s fantasy world and the resident characters. Froi of the Exiles plumbs depths of the world only hinted at in Finnikin of the Rock: the detail is richer, each small element is vital and serves a larger purpose in the whole. The themes are pushed further, and by extension the characters are more nuanced, forced to develop in often unexpected, yet organic, ways.
Given the serpentine nature of the plot and the level of intrigue present, at times this is a difficult story to keep hold of. It twists sharply, resists being pinned down, turns in surprising directions. Yet it never feels loose or uncontrolled. There was always a sense, as I read, that Marchetta was driving this story exactly where it needed to go, regardless of how difficult a course she charted. The entire story is characterised by a sense of weight and momentum, that it’s being inexorably drawn to some powerful, inevitable conclusion.
This is an extraordinarily strong book, and probably one I’ll have to read again to fully appreciate the intricacies of the plot, but I believe that its greatest power lies (as with Finnikin) in the characterisation and relationships. Marchetta does not go easy on her characters, providing them with convenient justifications for their actions or plot developments that open up handy loopholes. Instead, she forces them to wrestle their inner demons, with all the brutality and desperation that hand to hand combat entails.
Which brings me to Froi. (Froi!) For those who have read Finnikin of the Rock, you’ll be aware of the fact that Froi attempts something abhorrent in the first book. So it speaks to Marchetta’s skill as a writer that she is able to develop this character - his shame, his humanity, his convictions - in such a way that makes him deeply compelling. There are plenty of easy roads Marchetta could have taken in bringing Froi back as a main character, effectively glossing over his backstory. But I think that would have taken away from the thematic power of the novel, and been disingenuous to the character himself. Instead, by exploring the darker side of Froi’s nature, she creates a character so conflicted, and so authentic, it actually makes me ache.
”Although a voice inside had chanted to stop that night, Froi would never know if he would have. And he wanted to know. He wanted to say the words, ‘I would not have gone through with it.’ But he’d never know and that was his punishment.”
That passage punches me in the gut every time, and it’s small moments of crystallised thought such as this that make Froi’s growth throughout the novel, redefining the terms on which he lives his life, so real and heartbreaking.
But it’s not only Froi that Marchetta is unafraid of putting into morally ambiguous and unsympathetic positions, flaws exposed. Almost every character in the novel has to fight for something, has some excruciating internal journey to travel. Lucian, Beatriss, Trevanion, Lirah, Gargarin, amongst others – all carry with them some kind of pain, and have been or must go through something that will alter them irrevocably. While not always (if at all) providing tidy resolutions, there’s something rewarding about accompanying these characters on their journeys. There is a redemptive nature to their growth, and an acknowledgement that people are rarely all good or all evil, and all are capable of both inflicting pain.
And then, Quintana. Oh, Quintana. I’m not sure there is a character I’ve felt so fiercely about recently. She is my spirit animal. Neither clichéd fantasy princess or “kickass heroine” in a physical sense, Quintana is an alloy of contradictions: vulnerability, humour, grief, rage, intelligence, insanity. She’s tenacious and a little bit feral. She’s passionate and cold. And though this is largely Froi’s story, the chemistry of these two characters, the way they crash together on the page, is pretty captivating.
I won’t brush off the fact that this isn’t a light book, in terms of the content. Be warned that there’s all manner of brutality in this story: rape, torture, infanticide – Marchetta takes Froi of the Exiles to some very dark places. Reader thresholds for this type of subject matter will vary, naturally, but I feel it’s worth mentioning that it didn’t read gratuitously to me. The inclusion felt purposeful, important to the story being told.
On the other hand, it would remiss of me not to note that this book worthwhile things to say on the issues of religious tolerance, racism and cultural prejudice. Just as she does not flinch from showing both the repugnant and the admirable in her characters, Marchetta also shows the cruelty humans are capable of, along with their capacity for forgiveness and absolution.
Underpinning this very involved and intense novel, however, is the very human desire to belong somewhere. To have a sense of home, of family, and connection. And that this can sometimes be found in the most unlikely of places.
tl;dr: This book is a beautifully complex, emotional wrecking ball. It’s brilliant.
P.S. Thank goodness I held off from reading this until now. I think a year long wait for Quintana of Charyn might have completely cracked me.
* * * * *
I can't even, people. I just finished and everything hurts.
::SHOULDERS::
Readalong with the delightful Emily :)
If Finnikin of the Rock was a story about a divided and displaced nation’s journey towards healing their collective psyche, Froi of the Exiles is about a people broken apart by hatred, the wound in their history left to fester, and seep suspicion and fear into the cracks between them. A faceless, malevolent presence in Finnikin of the Rock, this is Charyn’s unveiling as more than simply “the enemy” of Lumatere. It’s an insight into a land burdened by suffering and grief, and the darker side of human nature.
While Finnikin of the Rock covered more ground in one sense of the word, with a quest that lead its characters into the far corners of Skuldenore, Froi of the Exiles is a novel on a vaster scale in several ways. This story is more complex, with an intricate web of a plot, and it unfolds new dimensions to Marchetta’s fantasy world and the resident characters. Froi of the Exiles plumbs depths of the world only hinted at in Finnikin of the Rock: the detail is richer, each small element is vital and serves a larger purpose in the whole. The themes are pushed further, and by extension the characters are more nuanced, forced to develop in often unexpected, yet organic, ways.
Given the serpentine nature of the plot and the level of intrigue present, at times this is a difficult story to keep hold of. It twists sharply, resists being pinned down, turns in surprising directions. Yet it never feels loose or uncontrolled. There was always a sense, as I read, that Marchetta was driving this story exactly where it needed to go, regardless of how difficult a course she charted. The entire story is characterised by a sense of weight and momentum, that it’s being inexorably drawn to some powerful, inevitable conclusion.
This is an extraordinarily strong book, and probably one I’ll have to read again to fully appreciate the intricacies of the plot, but I believe that its greatest power lies (as with Finnikin) in the characterisation and relationships. Marchetta does not go easy on her characters, providing them with convenient justifications for their actions or plot developments that open up handy loopholes. Instead, she forces them to wrestle their inner demons, with all the brutality and desperation that hand to hand combat entails.
Which brings me to Froi. (Froi!) For those who have read Finnikin of the Rock, you’ll be aware of the fact that Froi attempts something abhorrent in the first book. So it speaks to Marchetta’s skill as a writer that she is able to develop this character - his shame, his humanity, his convictions - in such a way that makes him deeply compelling. There are plenty of easy roads Marchetta could have taken in bringing Froi back as a main character, effectively glossing over his backstory. But I think that would have taken away from the thematic power of the novel, and been disingenuous to the character himself. Instead, by exploring the darker side of Froi’s nature, she creates a character so conflicted, and so authentic, it actually makes me ache.
”Although a voice inside had chanted to stop that night, Froi would never know if he would have. And he wanted to know. He wanted to say the words, ‘I would not have gone through with it.’ But he’d never know and that was his punishment.”
That passage punches me in the gut every time, and it’s small moments of crystallised thought such as this that make Froi’s growth throughout the novel, redefining the terms on which he lives his life, so real and heartbreaking.
But it’s not only Froi that Marchetta is unafraid of putting into morally ambiguous and unsympathetic positions, flaws exposed. Almost every character in the novel has to fight for something, has some excruciating internal journey to travel. Lucian, Beatriss, Trevanion, Lirah, Gargarin, amongst others – all carry with them some kind of pain, and have been or must go through something that will alter them irrevocably. While not always (if at all) providing tidy resolutions, there’s something rewarding about accompanying these characters on their journeys. There is a redemptive nature to their growth, and an acknowledgement that people are rarely all good or all evil, and all are capable of both inflicting pain.
And then, Quintana. Oh, Quintana. I’m not sure there is a character I’ve felt so fiercely about recently. She is my spirit animal. Neither clichéd fantasy princess or “kickass heroine” in a physical sense, Quintana is an alloy of contradictions: vulnerability, humour, grief, rage, intelligence, insanity. She’s tenacious and a little bit feral. She’s passionate and cold. And though this is largely Froi’s story, the chemistry of these two characters, the way they crash together on the page, is pretty captivating.
I won’t brush off the fact that this isn’t a light book, in terms of the content. Be warned that there’s all manner of brutality in this story: rape, torture, infanticide – Marchetta takes Froi of the Exiles to some very dark places. Reader thresholds for this type of subject matter will vary, naturally, but I feel it’s worth mentioning that it didn’t read gratuitously to me. The inclusion felt purposeful, important to the story being told.
On the other hand, it would remiss of me not to note that this book worthwhile things to say on the issues of religious tolerance, racism and cultural prejudice. Just as she does not flinch from showing both the repugnant and the admirable in her characters, Marchetta also shows the cruelty humans are capable of, along with their capacity for forgiveness and absolution.
Underpinning this very involved and intense novel, however, is the very human desire to belong somewhere. To have a sense of home, of family, and connection. And that this can sometimes be found in the most unlikely of places.
tl;dr: This book is a beautifully complex, emotional wrecking ball. It’s brilliant.
P.S. Thank goodness I held off from reading this until now. I think a year long wait for Quintana of Charyn might have completely cracked me.
* * * * *
I can't even, people. I just finished and everything hurts.
::SHOULDERS::
Readalong with the delightful Emily :)
Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read
Froi of the Exiles.
Sign In »
Reading Progress
March 8, 2012
– Shelved
September 3, 2012
–
14.5%
"Oh Froi. I'm pretty sure I would appreciate your tight trousers, even if you don't."
page
86
September 4, 2012
–
20.4%
"Lucian, I do love you, but right now I'd punch you in the face."
page
121
September 4, 2012
–
29.68%
"There's such a strong message/theme (?) about tolerance in these novels. I love it."
page
176
September 6, 2012
–
56.66%
"I wish real life would stop interrupting me and just let me read."
page
336
September 7, 2012
–
67.45%
"Progress report on Lucian's dickish behaviour: declining. Hurrah! In other news: this book is intense."
page
400
Started Reading
September 8, 2012
–
Finished Reading
Comments Showing 1-38 of 38 (38 new)
date
newest »
message 1:
by
Jo
(new)
-
rated it 5 stars
Mar 08, 2012 02:27AM
yeeeessss.
reply
|
flag
I actually can't believe you haven't read it yet.
YOU ARE A RIDICULOUS PERSON.
I think Froi is even better than Finnikin.
READ IT NOW.
YOU ARE A RIDICULOUS PERSON.
I think Froi is even better than Finnikin.
READ IT NOW.
......I might do that before Quintana comes out.
I actually read Froi (which is just over 400 pages) in one day. I don't think I ate.
It was like CW all over again.. o.O
I actually read Froi (which is just over 400 pages) in one day. I don't think I ate.
It was like CW all over again.. o.O
I agree I loved Froi more than Finnikin. NOW Rey! The time is now!
It is better that the first. A lot better in my opinion. But it's a chunky one so make sure you have some time when you get to it because you will not be able to put it down! :)
I know. She looks so good. I love her eyebrows. She looks so feral and awesome.
It's my desktop picture!
It's my desktop picture!
I am in! We should all taking selfies lookin fierce. Wait 2 of you are face shy...take a photo of someone else?
Yes! Mass global to hell with timezomes readalong!
Trin, perhaps I will wear a fierce mask :)
Jess! You need to rememdy that, soon!
Trin, perhaps I will wear a fierce mask :)
Jess! You need to rememdy that, soon!
Trinity wrote: "I am in! We should all taking selfies lookin fierce. Wait 2 of you are face shy...take a photo of someone else?"
dear Trinja
(view spoiler)
dear Trinja
(view spoiler)
I'm going to be starting finnikin soon and I'm excited, although I've been seeing all these updates from people being like OH GOD! THIS BOOK! IT HURTS! Now I'm scared I get really emotional over books what If I don't survive????
Unliking in order to like again!
Beautiful review Rey. *sobs*
Beautiful review Rey. *sobs*
Amazing review, Reynje, truly. Can you believe I've had this book since March but have been holding it off because I don't want it to be over?
And OMG that passage! Already my heart is beating...how does she do that?
And OMG that passage! Already my heart is beating...how does she do that?
Yesyesyesyesyes.
I am picturing you, Quintana and I running through forests howling at things in the near future.
I am picturing you, Quintana and I running through forests howling at things in the near future.
Amazing review, Rey. I there was a passage that I thought you pulled from mine for a second, but alas! I have not yet posted it (it's so long, I'm still trying to trim). Your review captured my sentiments exactly, and what I find readers ought to know. Brilliant! Only about two more weeks for Quintana. YAY!
Thanks ladies! It was a long time coming but oh so worth it :)
K, you really need to read this, I'd love to hear what you think!
@Jo! Yes! Howling frolicks!
K, you really need to read this, I'd love to hear what you think!
@Jo! Yes! Howling frolicks!
Catie wrote: "Love your review, Reynje. :)
I'm looking forward to all the Quintana reviews!"
Thank you!
(view spoiler)
I'm looking forward to all the Quintana reviews!"
Thank you!
(view spoiler)
I blame Maggie for most things.
(view spoiler)
Now, I'm not even kidding... this is a FULL FRONTAL SPOILER: (view spoiler)
(view spoiler)
Now, I'm not even kidding... this is a FULL FRONTAL SPOILER: (view spoiler)