Angela M is taking a break.'s Reviews > Hamnet

Hamnet by Maggie O'Farrell
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
4685500
's review

it was amazing
bookshelves: edelweiss-reviews, 2020-favorites

I have to admit that I was a little nervous going into this one for two reasons. I sometimes have a hard time with fictionalized accounts of real people. I’m always questioning how realistic they are and at the same time having to keep reminding myself that they’re fiction. Perhaps because not much is known about Shakespeare’s wife Anne or Agnes, her birth name, as she is called in the novel, that I found the imagining to be so captivating. Even though I still wondered how much might be true, O’Farrell’s beautiful rendition stands as brilliant story telling. The other thing that worried me is that this novel just seemed so different from the other novels by Maggie O’Farrell. She’s one of my favorite writers and I didn’t want to be disappointed. I wasn’t in the least and after thinking about this for a bit, I had to up my original four stars to five. While it’s a different kind of story than what she has written before, I found the same beautiful writing and stunning depiction of emotion that I loved in all her other novels.

The bard himself is not the main character on this stage. His name is not mentioned once . He is the son of John and Mary, the husband of Agnes, the father of Susanna and twins Hamnet and Judith, but never called by name. The focus is not on his plays, except for one, titled after his son Hamnet, who in the book dies at eleven of the plague. How we see the play in the end through Agnes’s eyes and heart was one of the most moving scenes of the novel. This felt from the beginning for me like Agnes’s story. Her story begins in an is almost fairy tale like way, as a girl belonging to a forest, remembering her mother, learning the power of plants and the meaning of her premonitions . She meets the Latin tutor, son of the glove maker and when they marry, she moves to Henley Street in Stratford with him.

The narrative alternatives from 1596 just before Hamnet dies and with Agnes’s early life, the time of their marriage and the years in between. Life in these times and in this place feels historically accurate, even if we really never will know the details of their family life, the death of their son. The most realistic thing of all was the stunning portrayal of a family’s grief, especially a mother’s grief. As Agnes prepares for Hamnet’s burial, when she goes to his grave or can’t bear to part with his clothes, I felt the depth of her grief.

I loved reading about Stratford, the family house and Agnes’s birthplace. Although I don’t remember details, I was there on Henley Street around thirty years ago at Shakespeare’s birthplace house and Anne (Agnes) Hathway’s house which is on the property there as well. I felt a warm connection knowing that I had been there once . I recommend this to lovers of historical fiction and most definitely to fans of Maggie O’Farrell.

I received an advanced copy of this book from Knopf (Random House) through Edelweiss.
441 likes · flag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Hamnet.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

November 22, 2019 – Shelved
November 22, 2019 – Shelved as: to-read
June 25, 2020 – Started Reading
June 30, 2020 – Shelved as: edelweiss-reviews
June 30, 2020 – Finished Reading
July 1, 2020 – Shelved as: 2020-favorites

Comments Showing 1-50 of 120 (120 new)


Bookish Ally Did you see the recent movie on Shakespeare? Was it based on this novel I wonder? It had Judi Dench (who I adore) All Is True was the name of the film.


Angela M is taking a break. Ally, I didn’t see the movie , but this book is not being published until next year.


Annette I so want to read this book.


Sara Oh, this sounds so like something I will love!!! Your review makes me long to get the book in hand. Thank you, Angela. It is going on my 2021 challenge list (that I am insanely already preparing).


Canadian Jen Fab review, Angela. I do have a few others I need to check out of hers so will do that before adding :)


Cathrine ☯️ Lovely A, & I can't wait for it to become available to me.


Diane Barnes I'm reading it now, Angela. I love the atmospheric quality of descriptions of the time and place. I have not read Maggie O'Farrell before this, but I think I'm a fan. The little known about Shakespeare's family life probably gave her a lot of freedom in this tale.


message 8: by Bianca (new)

Bianca Another extraordinary review, Angela. I've seen mixed reviews for this one and since I'm not that drawn to the subject matter, I'll try to read the other O'Farrell novels I'm yet to read.


Angela M is taking a break. Sara wrote: "Oh, this sounds so like something I will love!!! Your review makes me long to get the book in hand. Thank you, Angela. It is going on my 2021 challenge list (that I am insanely already preparing)."

Sara, you sound much more organized than I am ! It’s an interesting story, and I think because not very much is known about Shakespeare’s personal life, as I said it was easy for me to enjoy O’Farrell’s imagining. I hope you love it.


Angela M is taking a break. Thanks so much, Jen , Elyse and C.

C, I hope you love it, too.


Angela M is taking a break. Diane wrote: "I'm reading it now, Angela. I love the atmospheric quality of descriptions of the time and place. I have not read Maggie O'Farrell before this, but I think I'm a fan. The little known about Shakesp..."

Diane, glad you are enjoying it , too. I definitely agree, the scarce information gave her a lot of freedom. I been a fan of her writing for a while now. I’ve read all of her books. Since you haven’t read her before, I would recommend My two favorites The Hand That First Held Mine and The Vanishing Act of Esme Lennox. Looking forward to your final thoughts.


Angela M is taking a break. Bianca wrote: "Another extraordinary review, Angela. I've seen mixed reviews for this one and since I'm not that drawn to the subject matter, I'll try to read the other O'Farrell novels I'm yet to read."

Thanks very much , Bianca. I get that it won’t be of interest to everyone.


Angela M is taking a break. Annette wrote: "I so want to read this book."

Hope you enjoy it, Annette when you get to it.


Antoinette Love your review, Angela! Will definitely be reading this one.


Angela M is taking a break. Antoinette, thank you! Enjoy!


Candi A beautiful review, Angela. This really sounds quite wonderful. A must-read :)


message 17: by Kaceey (new)

Kaceey Fabulous review Angela!


Kathleen Love your beautiful review, Angela! Have added this book. Thank you! 🌹


message 19: by Deanna (new)

Deanna Excellent review!!!!


message 20: by Tzipora (new) - added it

Tzipora You deeefinitely don’t want to read Rodham! I agree about fictional accounts of real people although I tend to find it works better if they’re far removed historical figures like this. I think there’s the added benefit of the world around them being different enough from the present to pull you away from constantly asking “Wait, could this have been true? Would they have thought this way?”

I’m actually more interested in this book now reading your review and I think I like the idea that William isn’t even named and isn’t the focus at all. Sometimes that’s the other downfall of books, especially those the take on women from history because the narrative can be overshadowed by the famous men they’re connected to.


message 21: by Dem (new) - rated it 4 stars

Dem Terrific review Angela, I must admit was reluctant to read this one but your review has certainly convinced me.


Angela M is taking a break. Tzipora, I hope that if you read this, you enjoy it. Had no desire to read Rodham and if I had, I would have skipped it after your review!


Angela M is taking a break. Dem, thanks very much. Hope you do get to it.


Karen Awesome review Angela!


Angela M is taking a break. Karen, thanks, friend !


☮Karen Angela, before reading your very enthusiastic and heartfelt review, I had no desire at all to read this, but you changed my mind. Thanks!


Angela M is taking a break. Greta, thanks very much!


Angela M is taking a break. Karen, I hope you enjoy it then !


Melissa Crytzer Fry Oh, gosh.. I have to read this! I love Shakespeare -- and his plays -- and visited Stratford Upon Avon and was so enthralled I did not want to leave (my British friends could not quite understand the compulsion). This sounds lovely; I have a few Maggie O'Farrell books on my shelf, but have not yet read them. This may trump the others! Thanks for the great review, which was a heads-up for me, Angela.


Angela M is taking a break. Melissa wrote: "Oh, gosh.. I have to read this! I love Shakespeare -- and his plays -- and visited Stratford Upon Avon and was so enthralled I did not want to leave (my British friends could not quite understand t..."

Melissa, I felt the same as you ! Just being there was such a wonderful experience. When I went I was on a business trip to the headquarters of a British company that had just bought the company I worked for . I had taken a few extra days to go to London which was fabulous, but all I wanted to do was go to Stratford. I was alone so I took a bus tour through the Cotswolds which was lovely and it took us to Stratford .
While I really loved this , and even though I gave it 5 stars , my favorite of hers is The Hand That First Held Mine. I hope you read her some day. She’s been one of my favorites for a while now.


*TUDOR^QUEEN* Terrific review! Glad you had a five star read! I never had an affinity for Shakespeare, but I love England. How wonderful that you got to visit 👸💓📖


Angela M is taking a break. TQ, thanks so much. I was fortunate to have gone there a number of times . I’m sure you would love it !


*TUDOR^QUEEN* Angela M wrote: "TQ, thanks so much. I was fortunate to have gone there a number of times . I’m sure you would love it !"

I did! Went there 20 years ago. Best trip of my life! 🙋✈


Carmel Hanes I've preordered this one and have been waiting for the kindle version to be out. So glad to hear your eloquent thoughts and that you found it worth reading, as I've also had my hesitations.


Angela M is taking a break. Carmel, thanks so much. Can’t wait to see what you think!


Diane Barnes Loved it Angela. 5 stars!


Angela M is taking a break. Diane, so glad to hear!


Sharon Metcalf Angela, I'm so glad you found this to be a five star book. As long as I can remember I've added each of your 5 star books. This one makes me nervous because (I don't like to admit this) I haven't read much Shakespeare. How do you think it would stand up without knowing anything about Hamlet? Either way, great review.


Angela M is taking a break. Sharon, the book doesn’t mention any of Shakespeare’s plays except Hamlet , which is meaningful in some ways to the story. It’s really not about his writing and plays, but more an imagined story about his family life and more on my view about his wife Agnes. I don’t think it’s necessary to read Hamlet , but if you are interested in this, you could probably find a synopsis of it online, I’m sure. If you are interested in reading O’Farrell, she has written a number of other novels. Her writing is superb. Hope this helps. Thanks so much.


Betsy Robinson I'm so glad to read your good review of this. Makes me even more eager to read the book. Thanks, Angela.


Angela M is taking a break. Thanks, Betsy . Hope you enjoy it if you do read it!


Brenda ~The Book Witch at Witch Words Great review, Angela!


Karen Lovely review Angela:) So thrilled for you that you enjoyed this. I think I might like to read this and also, "The Hand that Once Held Mine." Always you have impeccable good taste and I always love your 4 and 5 star reads. Thank you! xo


message 44: by JanB (new)

JanB Angela, you know we feel the same about fictionalized accounts of real people and for the same reasons, so knowing you loved it anyway, is high praise indeed. I have enjoyed the author's writing as well so will give this serious consideration. Thanks for a great review!


Angela M is taking a break. Brenda, thanks so much !


Angela M is taking a break. Thanks very much, Karen! Hope you enjoy it!


Angela M is taking a break. Jan, I think I felt different about this one because so little is known about Shakespeare and his family that it was easier to accept the imagined story . It didn’t hurt that O’Farrell is a favorite writer . Thanks so much !


Cheri Angela, I'm so glad you read this and loved it, since I've loved O'Farrell since I first read her - which is not as long as you have. But I was also hesitant, since I wasn't sure if this one would work as well for me, although I requested a copy. Wonderful review!


Jennifer ~ TarHeelReader Love this review, Angela! This one is so high up on my want-to-read list I have plans to treat myself to the UK edition because I love that royal blue cover. I definitely can’t wait to read it!


Angela M is taking a break. Cheri , thanks so much , I do hope you enjoy it !


« previous 1 3
back to top