C. E.'s Reviews > The Fourth Closet

** spoiler alert ** I was so distraught when Charlie died in the second book. But when she died in the third I was okay with it. It gave it a resolute ending that didn't fail to disappoint. It was sad (to me anyway) that she was an animatronic the whole time but it reminded me of a post-apocalyptic book I read a while back. I smiled when John walked away with the woman in the end. I will always assume that it was Charlie he walked away with. Whether that puts the point that Charlie is still "alive", she's an allusion of John's mind, or John died. All in all, it was a great book and I enjoyed reading the series.