TBV (on hiatus)'s Reviews > Jude the Obscure

Jude the Obscure by Thomas Hardy
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
98589549
's review

it was amazing
bookshelves: fiction, uk-ireland, classic-literary, reread, 2020, reviewed-2020
Read 2 times. Last read May 14, 2020 to May 25, 2020.

This was the second time that I read this novel, and this time around it impressed me a great deal more. The first time I was certainly devastated by the story, and the story remains devastating, but this time I read it for the superb writing and what a rewarding exercise this was.

Jude sets out with such lofty ideals, but he makes bad decisions and is ultimately his own worst enemy. The result is that he never achieves what he wants, but is always on the outside looking in. One mistake in particular spirals into a lifetime of misery and tragedy. This novel is as bleak as it gets and there is no silver lining to be seen.

Although his novel writing was at its peak it was the last novel that Hardy wrote; the novel was so badly received that he devoted the rest of his writing career to poetry. It’s not difficult to see why he got so much flack over this novel. It is very well written, but Victorians might have felt uncomfortable reading about the burning of religious writings, men and women cohabitating without being married, bigamy, adultery, separation and divorce, suicide, a woman with a greater intellect than her husband... Hardy tackles the institutions of religion and marriage, criticising religion and essentially asking whether an unhappy couple should remain married, or indeed whether a couple could live together decently without marriage. Nope, the Victorians didn't like that at all!
52 likes · flag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Jude the Obscure.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

Started Reading (Paperback Edition)
1975 – Finished Reading (Paperback Edition)
April 18, 2020 – Shelved
April 18, 2020 – Shelved (Paperback Edition)
May 14, 2020 – Started Reading
May 15, 2020 –
28.0% "A mournful wind blew through the trees, and sounded in the chimney like the pedal notes of an organ. Each ivy leaf overgrowing the wall of the churchless churchyard hard by, now abandoned, pecked its neighbour smartly, and the vane on the new German-Gothic church in the new spot had already begun to creak."
May 17, 2020 –
35.0% "He would have preferred a more congenial spot, but, as usually happens, in place of a romantic field or solemn aisle for his tale, it was told while they walked up and down over a floor littered with rotten cabbage-leaves, and amid all the usual squalors of decayed vegetable matter and unsaleable refuse."
May 19, 2020 –
58.0% "‘A love-philter, such as was used by the Ancients with great effect. I found it out by study of their writings, and have never known it to fail.’
'What is it made of?’ asked Arabella curiously.
'Well – a distillation of the juices of doves’ hearts 7 – otherwise pigeons’ – is one of the ingredients. It took nearly a hundred hearts to produce that small bottle full.’"
May 25, 2020 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-16 of 16 (16 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

Candi Wonderful review, TBV! I need to re-read this one some day as well. I'm certain there is much more that I could take away from it by a second look.


message 2: by Jola (new)

Jola Another coincidence, dear TBV: I'm just planning to embark on Hardy! I was advised by Sandy to start with his short stories and I'll stick to that. After that I'll endavour his novels and "Jude the Obscure" is on my priority list. I read "Tess D'Ubervilles" many years ago but wish to revisit it also.

I'm in awe of your ability to express so many interesting thoughts in such a concise form. I find your review excellent although the book itself worries me a bit, as I think I'm not ready to face such a cumulation of sadness at the moment.

It's upsetting to imagine how Hardy must have felt facing such a negative response to his novel. I imagine him as a very sensitive person so it must have been a blow.


message 3: by Dan (new) - rated it 5 stars

Dan Great review TBV! And an underrated book for sure.


Ilse It sounds a great idea to reread this, TBV, as indeed this is such a devastating book I recall I simply didn't pay attention to the language (while I tought the language of 'Far from the madding crowd' beauteous). This must be the bleakest book I have ever read, I couldn't read for a week after closing it. Very interesting what you write here on the reception of it by the contemporaries and Hardy's turning to poetry after. One can only imagine what other novels he would have written if this had been better received (or maybe there are drafts from novels-in-the-making which remained?)


TBV (on hiatus) Candi wrote: "Wonderful review, TBV! I need to re-read this one some day as well. I'm certain there is much more that I could take away from it by a second look."

Thanks, Candi. It’s worth a reread, because the first time you tend to focus on the tragedies that unfold, but the second time you know more or less what’s coming and that means that you can focus on the writing.


TBV (on hiatus) Jola wrote: "Another coincidence, dear TBV: I'm just planning to embark on Hardy! I was advised by Sandy to start with his short stories and I'll stick to that. After that I'll endavour his novels and "Jude the..."

Jola, you and I are synchronised this year. So far this year I’ve read The Trumpet-Major and The Woodlanders and of course Jude the Obscure, but I hope to read a couple more. I’m on a British authors binge. I would not recommend Jude as an introduction to Hardy. If you wish to read a biography, Thomas Hardy: The Time Torn Man might be useful.

Thanks for your lovely compliments. :-)


TBV (on hiatus) Dan wrote: "Great review TBV! And an underrated book for sure."

Thanks, Dan! I think one gets whacked by the story, and the writing is overlooked.


TBV (on hiatus) Ilse wrote: "It sounds a great idea to reread this, TBV, as indeed this is such a devastating book I recall I simply didn't pay attention to the language (while I tought the language of 'Far from the madding cr..."

Ilse, thanks for reminding me of the writing in Far From the Madding Crowd; that is the first Hardy that I read years ago. I want to re-read that as well, but I think that I’ll leave that until I have read some of his other works.


message 9: by withdrawn (new)

withdrawn A book I have not read but, yesterday I came into possession of a copy. Your review makes it clear that I shall have to read it.

I was out on the street with my grandchildren (4 and 9 years) when a neighbour offered the kids a box of children’s books. My 9 year old granddaughter quickly came up with Jude the Obscure.


TBV (on hiatus) Most definitely not a children's book! D, I look forward to reading your thoughts on this novel. I hope that your grandchildren will enjoy reading the other books.


Laysee I can imagine how good it must have been to re-read this classic just to enjoy the superb prose. You're absolutely spot on that Hardy's last novel must have grated on Victorian sensibilities. It's a pity that the negative reception stopped him writing fiction. Thank you, TBV, for this marvelous review.


TBV (on hiatus) Thank you, Laysee! :-)


message 13: by Jola (new)

Jola Thanks for your recommendation, TBV. I've just added Claire Tomalin's book to my TBR.


TBV (on hiatus) Great! Jola, I look forward to reading your updates.


message 15: by BookMonkey (new)

BookMonkey Ah, poor Jude! I can't think of another author as brutal to his characters as Hardy, but I love him all the same. Terrific review.


TBV (on hiatus) Thanks, BM! It's not a good idea to read Hardy when one needs something cheerful, but as you say, "I love him all the same".


back to top