Dave Schaafsma's Reviews > Steppenwolf

Steppenwolf by Hermann Hesse
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
269235
's review

really liked it
bookshelves: fiction-20th-century
Read 2 times. Last read April 11, 2018 to April 23, 2018.

for madmen only

In league with Pessoa’s Book of Disquiet and Dostoevsky’s Raskolnikov, Hermann Hesse’s Steppenwolf is about a suicidal guy who never actually commits suicide, a tortured soul who struggles with the dualism of his nature, from the human to the wolf, from the classical to the romantic, to the spiritual to the sinful, from the life of the mind to the life of the body. I read this three times when I was 18-20, trying to understand it, trying to find elements that would help shape my personality, my image as budding/wannabe Artiste, in all my adolescent angst. “You were such a happy baby; what happened?” my mother said to me once during this brooding period, when I was reading everything from Dostoevsky to Rimbaud to Malcolm Lowry’s Under The Volcano and Camus and Sartre, and yes, every Hesse book I could get my hands on.

Steppenwolf was written by Hesse at middle age, looking back on his struggle between the coolly distant Germanic aesthetic and the more sensual Buddhism. In my late teens all the Christians I knew including me were reading Zen Buddhism, and Hesse helped us bridge the strict Calvinism we wanted to be free from and the East we found more attractive, less restrictive.

Harry Haller, writer and reader of many books, an intellectual, is contemplating suicide on his 50th birthday. Melancholy, dumped by his wife, he sees himself as a “wolf of the steppes,” half human, half wolf. He hates modern society. He’d rather read Goethe and listen to Mozart than go to a party and listen to modern jazz or make small talk. His nephew sees him as "a genius of suffering," which seems about right. He’s born to be wild, separate from society:

Steppenwolf’s “Born to be Wild”:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=egMWl...

A peddler gives Steppenwolf a pamphlet entitled, "Treatise on the Steppenwolf." He meets a woman, Hermione, in a bar; she mocks him for his self-obsession, and introduces the aging intellectual—through other women—to the life of the body, to dancing, to cocaine, to wine, to sex. The sensual. Meaning: women, basically. Men: Rational, the life of the mind. Women: Sensual, physical. There’s almost no dialogue in this book, but for certain, women mostly play a central role; they don’t talk much, the me do most of the talking, but they are a central shaping force.

Steppenwolf’s “Magic Carpet Ride”:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HPE9a...

Steppenwolf visits a Magic Theater, which in the sixties might have been seen as a place for psychedelic experimentation because it is there that Harry experiences dreams and nightmares. Emerging out of this with Rosa, Harry ultimately finds he needs to lighten up! He needs to laugh, and enjoy life, and society. So that’s the heart of the book, Step embracing Mozart’s The Magic Flute and love of life, rejecting the suicidal isolation of Goethe’s The Sorrows of Young Werther. Plato, Spinoza, and Nietzsche get referenced along the way, too. I guess it can be seen as a novelistic reflection on the divided self.

There’s not much of an actual story here. It’s an internal, philosophical/spiritual novel, which feels more like allegory (and perhaps autobiography), to tell you how to stop brooding and embrace life. I can see in reading this why a man—in particular a man, because it was written by a man with men as his primary audience, I think—in his late teens or middle-age might embrace this. I liked it less than I did when I was in my teens, but it surely has a kind of intense appeal. Oh, and my mom came to see I also got out of that brooding phase and lightened up, too.
142 likes · flag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Steppenwolf.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

Finished Reading
August 26, 2012 – Shelved
September 18, 2012 – Shelved as: fiction-20th-century
April 11, 2018 – Started Reading
April 11, 2018 –
0.0% "Read this book three times when I was 18 and 19. Listening to it now. "For madmen only.""
April 23, 2018 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-37 of 37 (37 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

Ilse "You were such a happy baby; what happened?” my mother said exactly like yours when walking a quite similar reading path :). Great review David, and interesting point on your impression this being written by a man for men, last year I read a compilation of Hesse quotations (partly brought together himself, as a present for his admirers after the Nobel, to spare time in answering letters) and maybe it was this not so original dichotomy he makes between the masculine and feminine which irked me in many of the excerpts (from letters, novels, diaries).


david David. Excellent. But I was unaware that you finished Pessoa's book. So I read your review of Disquiet also. Really Great.


message 3: by Rituraj (new) - added it

Rituraj Kashyap Just came across your insightful review. Hadn't heard of it before but I can relate to it so much. I even checked out some of the quotes and it feels like this is the book I've been looking for all this time.


Moira Macfarlane A very nice review. I remember finding it a very interesting book to read and it felt like stepping in a man's mind at the time indeed.


Dave Schaafsma Thanks. I suppose anyone can be depressed, suicidal, and isolated from others. But this man-wolf aspect seems particularly male. Though I guess a simplified version of his solution would work for anyone: Find love, which he does with Rosa.


Dave Schaafsma david wrote: "David. Excellent. But I was unaware that you finished Pessoa's book. So I read your review of Disquiet also. Really Great." Thanks, yeah, I sort of finished Pessoa's book. I mean, I read most of the book, skimmed through some of the appendix. . . and it is a great work.


Dave Schaafsma Rituraj wrote: "Just came across your insightful review. Hadn't heard of it before but I can relate to it so much. I even checked out some of the quotes and it feels like this is the book I've been looking for all..." Read it and let me know what you think!


Dave Schaafsma Ilse wrote: ""You were such a happy baby; what happened?” my mother said exactly like yours when walking a quite similar reading path :). Great review David, and interesting point on your impression this being ..."

Well, it is a very familiar separation/distinction/binary, and in 1969 when I probably first read it I wouldn't have been disturbed by it. This is probably how I saw girls, as mysterious, sensual, unavailable. Now it seems really oversimplified, of course. And I probably didn't even like it most of the way through, really, but it ends with a kind of affirmation of life.. .. though a skeptic might also say he just found a girl and now he is happy again. Now I notice: He never talks to most of these women; he dances with them, he admires them for their "beauty" and he has sex with them. This feels like the history of literature with respect to men and women, in a way! A woman in my climate change literature class this spring has been writing about all the women in the books we have been reading are just objectified as sexual objects, in The Drowned World by J.G. Ballard, Do Androids Dream of Electric Sheep by Philip K. Dick, in the film Water World, Though I do think things are changing in the past quarter century of course with more women and men authors focusing on strong girls and women.


message 9: by Rituraj (new) - added it

Rituraj Kashyap David wrote: "Rituraj wrote: "Just came across your insightful review. Hadn't heard of it before but I can relate to it so much. I even checked out some of the quotes and it feels like this is the book I've been..."

Sure!


message 10: by Greta G (new) - added it

Greta G Great review, David. But now I’m wondering what you didn’t understand when you read this (3 times!) in your teens?


message 11: by Dave (new) - rated it 4 stars

Dave Schaafsma 1) Well, one aspect that was a bit over my head then was that I didn't have much experience with all these German cultural references he assumes you know: Goethe, Nietzsche, Novalis, Mozart, Wagner.. . .

2) Some of it feels like a dream, nightmare, drug trip. Everyone thought this was a cool book and all my friends were talking about it, and it has all this dark laughter in it. . . it was interesting but I didn't know what it was all about. It felt "deep" and mysterious and sexy and I was a virgin, no experience with drugs, but intrigued by all of it. I was a working class kid wanting to be that "cultured" to get that kind of hip book. . .. and know all those references.


david Wow, David. Exactly how you just expressed the first time you read it, is the same way I felt when I first read it. It was uber-rad to like Hesse, and Steppenwolf was the coolest book in the library, except of course for "the electric cool-aid acid test.' Now that one was for really bad boys and girls.


message 13: by Dave (new) - rated it 4 stars

Dave Schaafsma True, it was. This was a hipness test, and I lacked so much cultural background to read it and wanted to know why Mozart and Goethe laughed the way they did. Like gallows humor, some insight into dark mysterious laughter. And here, I'll embed the one sentence review I wanted to write but didn't have the courage to:

If you are suicidally depressed, get laid and this will make you quite a bit happier. I really think that is the point of this book, and I said it above less directly. . .. :)


message 14: by Greta G (last edited Apr 23, 2018 04:26PM) (new) - added it

Greta G Haha, I only meant, which part of the man’s mind don’t you understand? :)

I think that sometimes, in our strive to understand the meaning of life through reading, or, in your case, to be hip :), or because we idolize an author, we may be giving a book more deep and spiritual significance than it really deserves.
I’m pretty skeptical about these kind of ‘deep’ books. If an author doesn’t succeed to get his message across, it’s just not written well (unless I know nothing about the subject of course) or he just doesn’t understand what he is talking about himself.
Also referencing authors, composers, philosophers, works of art and literature ... can be done in a way that is meaningful even when a reader doesn’t know them, otherwise it’s just name-dropping and showing off.

Anyway, I only speed-read this book to help my daughter out with a book review for school, and to be honest, I wasn’t very thrilled with it. I plan to read it again though, more attentively, because I really loved his book Gertrude which I read about 25 years ago (not surprisingly, you didn’t like that one :)


message 15: by Dave (last edited Apr 23, 2018 05:36PM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

Dave Schaafsma I can't recall exactly all these books, but I think Hesse's books such as Demian and Gertrude, more actual narratives than philosophical musings, are ones I prefer. I think now that I know the references that he is not merely showing off, though He wrote this book later in his life and it reflects some of his own experience, his need to just be happy with others and live. I did idolize him, as a young man, and if you read as I did the top rated ten reviews, all by men, we all revered Hesse growing up, he was a god to us, both darkly spiritual and sensual (i.e., made it clear that drugs and sex was were good things, sources of ecstasy; Germanic and Dutch and maybe all western religion being restrictive, stern, logical, subdued, and here Hesse said you could be happy and achieve a kind of ecstatic purity. Without renouncing the body! A romantic vision, sort of like Wordsworth and Coleridge and Lizst, embracing passion).

For much of this book I was bored with Harry Haller and his pretentious self-absorption, I winced at the idea of his thinking of himself as a Steppenwolf, ugh, but in the end I was won over by his recognizing that he had been self-absorbed and narcissistic. The women are just sexual objects (like the love children in the "sexual revolution were supposed to be, I suppose; "free" love!!) but even that part of it was way better than all his early whining.


Czarny Pies Great review. You very clearly describe a very complex book. Your students should consider themselves lucky.


message 17: by Ken (new) - added it

Ken I'm afraid to reread Hesse for the exact reason you state in your final line. Great to reminisce with your review!


message 18: by Cristóbal (new)

Cristóbal Cuenca Read a long time ago The teenager that I was, was very impressed.


message 19: by Dave (new) - rated it 4 stars

Dave Schaafsma Czarny wrote: "Great review. You very clearly describe a very complex book. Your students should consider themselves lucky."

Thanks. I read your review about the point of the book being that sex and drugs seem to be the solution. I think that would be one way to look at what the book says! I didn't read this with my students, but I would recommend it to some of them, I think. It feels like a threshold or identity crisis book, perfect for teens or mid-life crisis.


message 20: by Dave (new) - rated it 4 stars

Dave Schaafsma Ken wrote: "I'm afraid to reread Hesse for the exact reason you state in your final line. Great to reminisce with your review!" This is the great fear, that the darlings of your youth now suck. You thought they were deep, and now they appear shallow. On the Road, Catcher in the Rye. .. .but those still hold up for me. This one I still liked quite a bit, finally, but the more I talk about it, those 4 stars are losing their twinkle. Maybe I just have to admit I still like the scenes of stoned debauchery, the "courtesans," the cocaine scenes, the dialogues with Goethe and Mozart.


message 21: by Dave (last edited Apr 24, 2018 07:42AM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

Dave Schaafsma Cristóbal wrote: "Read a long time ago The teenager that I was, was very impressed." Someone here said that the literary establishment always thought Thomas Mann was the real deal, and Hesse was a more shallow, popular version of the Searching Soul. But for me at that time Mann was boring and Hesse was exciting: Narcissus and Goldmund, Demian, Siddhartha, I loved them then. I did come to like Mann but Hesse represented a kind of ecstasy I never encountered in, say, my Dutch Christian Reformed (Calvinist) church. :)


message 22: by Greta G (new) - added it

Greta G “I did come to like Mann but Hesse represented a kind of ecstasy I never encountered in, say, my Dutch Christian Reformed (Calvinist) church. :)”
Hesse himself grew up in a Pietist home, David. He had a troubled youth, showed signs of depression, attempted suicide, was in a mental institution for a while, had severe conflicts with his parents, searched for spiritual/theological inspiration a great deal of his life. I doubt he ever lived a life of free love and drugs himself. Probably that was only a fantasy. Based on your review and comments, I’m not sure I would recommend the book to people who struggle with an identity crisis ; on the contrary! :)


Czarny Pies David wrote: "Czarny wrote: "Great review. You very clearly describe a very complex book. Your students should consider themselves lucky."

Thanks. I read your review about the point of the book being that sex a..."


This time I must concede that you understood the book better than me.


message 24: by Dave (new) - rated it 4 stars

Dave Schaafsma Czarny wrote: "David wrote: "Czarny wrote: "Great review. You very clearly describe a very complex book. Your students should consider themselves lucky."

Thanks. I read your review about the point of the book be..."


I appreciate the compliment, Czarny, but there are still things I don't understand about it, and those who know philosophy and music and German literature better than I do will lend more insight into it.


Czarny Pies David wrote: "Czarny wrote: "David wrote: "Czarny wrote: "Great review. You very clearly describe a very complex book. Your students should consider themselves lucky."

Thanks. I read your review about the point..."


There are some topics that I know very well. The problem or the charm of GR is that you review books in areas that you do not know very well and it in areas that you know much better.


message 26: by [deleted user] (new)

Valis by PKD


Fergus, Quondam Happy Face Wonderful memories, David. And mine are much the same! Thanks for a beautiful review.


message 28: by Ned (new) - rated it 5 stars

Ned This is on my top five all time GR reviews, so enlightening for a book I read so long ago. I remember a quote from Hesse that he was amused that it resonated for so many young men.


message 29: by Dave (new) - rated it 4 stars

Dave Schaafsma Fergus wrote: "Wonderful memories, David. And mine are much the same! Thanks for a beautiful review."

Ah, thanks, Fergus, I think if we got together we would have a lot to talk about.


message 30: by Dave (new) - rated it 4 stars

Dave Schaafsma Ned wrote: "This is on my top five all time GR reviews, so enlightening for a book I read so long ago. I remember a quote from Hesse that he was amused that it resonated for so many young men." I am floored by your response, Ned, thanks, made my day. But that book did resonate for me. But I think I understand why better now than when I was a teen.


message 31: by Jay (new) - rated it 5 stars

Jay Excellent review, David, of what - IMHO - was Hesse’s finest novel or at last a tie with Siddhartha. The interlude in the “Magic Theatre” is worth the price of admission alone. Always thought if I ever owned two cats I would name them Pablo and Mozart (“Mo” for short).


message 32: by Dave (last edited Mar 26, 2020 05:04AM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

Dave Schaafsma I once owned two cats, a gray one I named Asher (for My Name is always Asher Lev by Chaim Poto)k, and Raskolnikov (Rascal, for short) from Dostoevsky's Crime and Punishment.

Best Hesse book? Well, that's (of course) a matter of taste. Books like Demian and Siddhartha and are simple and simple straightforward and emotional and usually the most popular. The more intellectual ones, the more complex and philosophical ones that are seen as great include Steppenwolf and The Glass Bead Game, and the lit crowd usually picks that latter one, but that's one I haven't re-read in decades, though I have on old dusty copy of it here. I guess Siddhartha is the most direct and clear and emotional one, I like that, but I kind of prefer the darker Demian. . . it kind of occurs to me it's like a junior Steppenwolf. I need to re-read some of them, like Narcissus and Goldmund, too.


David Very good review, David. I was also in my 20s when I read Steppenwolf after having read Crime and Punishment. Now, you've tempted me back into reading both of them again.


message 34: by Dave (new) - rated it 4 stars

Dave Schaafsma Yes, to read them together!


David That's one of my bad habits. I read too many books that I like at one time like a child.


message 36: by Dave (new) - rated it 4 stars

Dave Schaafsma Me, too


Sensei Rosenthal Ahem, spoiler alert?


back to top